fastexpert logofastexpert icon
Searchsrch icon
Join Our Network

INDIANA · 2026 RANKINGS

Top Real Estate Agents in Indiana (2026)

Compare top-rated local experts, backed by verified sales performance and client reviews.

  • Data-driven
  • No Obligation
  • Direct Messaging
FastExpert 2026 Top 25 Agent in Indiana

Ranked Real Estate Agents in Indiana

Showing 25 of 500 results

500 agents in Indiana directory.

Ranked list of real estate agents in Indiana
Rank / AgentBrokerageExperienceSales (3 yr)Reviews
Headshot of Heather Schaller, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14038556
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

26. Heather Schaller

  • Recommended

eXp Realty, LLC

Years of Experience
22 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Service Areas: Advance, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 3 hours

Price range: $10K-$1.8M

Experience
22 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
261
Reviews
1
Headshot of Mary Finkle, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14026176
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

27. Mary Finkle

  • Recommended

Mainstreet Realtors

Years of Experience
37 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$15M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Borden, IN · 

Price range: $19K-$1.4M

Experience
37 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
258
Reviews
13
Headshot of Cathy Russell, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14004908
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

28. Cathy Russell

Top Agent Video Red
  • Recommended

Russell company

Years of Experience
52 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$44M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Attica, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 3 days+

Price range: $29K-$1M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
52 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
150
Reviews
40
Headshot of Manny & Laura Hernandez, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14046635
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

29. Manny & Laura Hernandez

  • Recommended

Team Hernandez at Simplify Your Move! Realty

Years of Experience
20 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Service Areas: Crown Point, IN · 

Price range: $11K-$885K

Specialties: Move-Up Buyers · 
View Profile
Experience
20 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
247
Reviews
93
Headshot of Laura Heigl, Team Lead, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14044556
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

30. Laura Heigl, Team Lead

  • Recommended

Heigl Real Estate Group at Century 21 Scheetz

Years of Experience
22 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$47M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Advance, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 20 hours

Price range: $140K-$4.9M

Experience
22 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
243
Reviews
59
Headshot of Nicole Milford, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14052457
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

31. Nicole Milford

  • Recommended

Compass Indiana

Years of Experience
12 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$30.9M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Cedar Lake, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 3 days+

Price range: $13.2K-$0.9M

Experience
12 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
233
Reviews
69
Headshot of James Embry, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14037418
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

32. James Embry

Keller Williams

Years of Experience
24 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$30.2M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Arcadia, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 1 day

Price range: $21K-$3.9M

Experience
24 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
321
Reviews
84
Headshot of David Brenton, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14028349
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

33. David Brenton

DAVID BRENTON'S TEAM

Years of Experience
34 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$58M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Bargersville, IN · 

Price range: $10K-$2.9M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
34 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
315
Reviews
11
Headshot of Jennifer McBride, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14035004
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

34. Jennifer McBride

Top Agent Video Red
  • Recommended

Keller Williams

Years of Experience
25 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$3.8M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Boonville, IN · 

Price range: $100-$1M

Specialties: Multi-Family Properties · 
3 Available Listings
Experience
25 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
215
Reviews
7
Headshot of Amy Kopp, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14038750
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

35. Amy Kopp

  • Recommended

RE/MAX Acclaimed Properties

Years of Experience
19 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$19.5M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Bloomington, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 3 days+

Price range: $102.5K-$1.4M

Experience
19 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
113
Reviews
32
Headshot of Stephanie Cook, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14039206
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

36. Stephanie Cook

Real Broker

Years of Experience
13 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Service Areas: Carmel, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 15 hours

Price range: $12.5K-$2.1M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
9 Available Listings
View Profile
Brokerage
Real Broker
Experience
13 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
305
Reviews
45
Headshot of Steve Clark, real estate agent

37. Steve Clark

Compass

Years of Experience
20 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$62.5M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Advance, IN · 

Price range: $134K-$3.9M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
4 Available Listings
Brokerage
Compass
Experience
20 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
302
Reviews
79
Headshot of Peter Stewart, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB15000083
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

38. Peter Stewart

Peter Stewart Realty

Years of Experience
17 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$26.7M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Carmel, IN · 

Price range: $10K-$2.5M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
10 Available Listings
Experience
17 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
297
Reviews
128
Headshot of Christina Mckim, real estate agent

39. Christina Mckim

  • Recommended

Green Tree Real Estate Services

Years of Experience
11 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$100M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Austin, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 3 days+

Price range: $29.5K-$1.1M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
2 Available Listings
View Profile
Experience
11 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
89
Reviews
48
Headshot of Chris Koerner, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14051669
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

40. Chris Koerner

  • Recommended

Property Advancement Realty

Years of Experience
19 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$118.5M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Clarksville, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 3 days+

Price range: $10K-$769.5K

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
19 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
188
Reviews
20
Headshot of Jeffrey Cummings, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14035686
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

41. Jeffrey Cummings

Top Agent Video Red

REMAX Complete

Years of Experience
19 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$41M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Anderson, IN · 

Price range: $4K-$1.5M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
4 Available Listings
Experience
19 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
282
Reviews
42
Headshot of Warren Barnes, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB19000578
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

42. Warren Barnes

North Eastern Group Realty

Years of Experience
7 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$16M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Arcola, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 2 days

Price range: $2K-$15.1M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
1 Available Listings
Experience
7 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
277
Reviews
31
Headshot of Mandy Baesler, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB15001108
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

43. Mandy Baesler

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices, Newlin-Miller REALTORS

Years of Experience
11 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$9.8M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Brazil, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 3 days+

Price range: $35K-$1.2M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
11 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
276
Reviews
93
Headshot of Meighan Wise, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14047813
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

44. Meighan Wise

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Indiana Realty

Years of Experience
18 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$75M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Carmel, IN · 

Price range: $55K-$2.7M

Experience
18 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
275
Reviews
53
Headshot of Steve Silver, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14010813
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

45. Steve Silver

RE/MAX Professionals

Years of Experience
47 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$16M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Brownstown, IN · 

Price range: $22K-$1.2M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
47 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
274
Reviews
22
Headshot of Justin Bennett, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB15001044
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

46. Justin Bennett

  • Trusted Pro

Bennett Realty

Years of Experience
11 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$35.5M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Amo, IN · 

Price range: $3K-$1.6M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
6 Available Listings
Experience
11 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
272
Reviews
74
Headshot of Dani Robinson, real estate agent

47. Dani Robinson

Top Agent Video Red
  • Recommended

FC Tucker

Years of Experience
13 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$17.5M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Alexandria, IN · 

Price range: $49K-$1.8M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Brokerage
FC Tucker
Experience
13 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
171
Reviews
5
Headshot of Jennifer Walker, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB18001905
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 19, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

48. Jennifer Walker

  • Recommended

Real Broker LLC

Years of Experience
8 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$9.6M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Cedar Lake, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 2 days

Price range: $5K-$2.3M

5 Available Listings
Experience
8 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
166
Reviews
12
Headshot of Amy Cavender, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14030154
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 19, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

49. Amy Cavender

  • Recommended

Northern Lakes Realty

Years of Experience
24 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$110K
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Albion, IN · 

Typical Response Time: 1 hours

Price range: $5K-$1.5M

Experience
24 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
166
Reviews
19
Headshot of Corina Jones, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14035921
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Sep 15, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

50. Corina Jones

Your Home Team

Years of Experience
20 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales in
last 3 YearsRecent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$330M
Sales Volume in
Last YearSales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Boggstown, IN · 

Price range: $25K-$1.3M

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
20 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
254
Reviews
7
Find a Top Real Estate Agent Today