Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Steve M.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
ReviewI had a great experience working with Peter and Linda on the purchase of a condo in the Indianapolis area. Peter is extremely knowledgeable about the entire Indy market and provided excellent advice throughout the process, especially when it came to where and what to buy. Linda was also fantastic to work with during the closing process. She stayed on top of everything, handled several issues quickly, and helped keep the transaction moving toward a successful closing. Great communication, excellent local knowledge, and a very professional team. I highly recommend Peter and Linda!
Kristopher R.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter was fantastic to work with on our investment property purchase in the Butler-Tarkington area of Indianapolis. As out-of-state investors, we relied heavily on his guidance, and he walked us through the entire process for our first investment property in Indianapolis. He's extremely responsive, knows the local market inside and out, and was incredibly generous with his time throughout. It's clear Peter has his clients' best interests in mind, and we're looking forward to working with him on more deals going forward.
User27773851
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review This was our third property transaction using the Peter Stewart Realty Group, and they knocked it out of the park as usual! Peter is always thorough and patient throughout the buying and selling process. His knowledge as an active real estate investor has also been highly valuable! Also his Transaction Coordinator, Linda is the BEST!! She goes above and beyond for anything you need throughout the process.
James T.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review This was our third property transaction using the Peter Stewart Realty Group, and they knocked it out of the park as usual! Peter is always thorough and patient throughout the buying and selling process. His knowledge as an active real estate investor has also been highly valuable! Also his Transaction Coordinator, Linda is the BEST!! She goes above and beyond for anything you need throughout the process.
Athena C.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review It was my second time working with Peter and Linda. They made the selling process as simple and as easy as possible despite a few issues with the property management company and the uncooperative tenants. I really appreciate their knowledge in the local market, helpful recommendations on negotiations and business vendors to use to get the property ready for market, and professionalism! I'd highly recommend them to anyone!
User54989577
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review I cannot recommend Peter enough. He did a great job on the sale of one of my investment properties, and he got me the price I was looking for with no hassles at all. Don't bother with any other agent; once you use Peter, you won't want to go anywhere else. 5 Stars!
Daniel D.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review This review could be condensed to this paragraph alone. If youre an investor in Indianapolis looking for a real estate agent who knows the market exceptionally well, thinks like an investor, is extremely responsive, negotiates effectively, and is genuinely committed to long-term relationships, Peter Stewart and his assistant Linda Schotter are the team you want. If you want to understand why, read on. I found Peter through BiggerPockets after speaking with many agents in Indianapolis. He immediately stood out. He has a deep, granular understanding of the market and thinks like an investor because he is one. Working with Peter meant buying my first investment property, my first out-of-state purchase, and my first home ever. Trust did not come easily. Time and time again, over more than a year of searching, Peter consistently proved he had my best interests in mind. Each moment built trust. I needed that. He was always responsive, thorough, and thoughtful. I was never rushed and never pushed into a deal. When concerns came up, Peter didnt dismiss them or try to sell me. He laid out the facts and let me make informed decisions. In hindsight, that approach helped me grow as an investor and truly understand the Indianapolis market. Peter also personally visits properties. If something interests you, he has likely already walked it and often has video. Watching him evaluate homes is impressive. He understands construction, age, condition, and risk far beyond what most investors would catch. When the right deal came along, I needed specific terms to make it work financially. Peter negotiated excellent terms and made the deal happen, even when it wasnt the easiest path. What truly sets Peter apart is what happened after closing. He stayed involved, ensured repair credits and security deposits were handled properly, and personally delivered warranty and appliance documentation to my property manager. Weeks after closing, when many agents disappear, Peter was still there. That level of follow-through says everything. I'm incredibly grateful for Peter and Linda and excited for many future deals together.
DanDeGroff
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review This review could be condensed to this paragraph alone. If youre an investor in Indianapolis looking for a real estate agent who knows the market exceptionally well, thinks like an investor, is extremely responsive, negotiates effectively, and is genuinely committed to long-term relationships, Peter Stewart and his assistant Linda Schotter are the team you want. If you want to understand why, read on. I found Peter through BiggerPockets after speaking with many agents in Indianapolis. He immediately stood out. He has a deep, granular understanding of the market and thinks like an investor because he is one. Working with Peter meant buying my first investment property, my first out-of-state purchase, and my first home ever. Trust did not come easily. Time and time again, over more than a year of searching, Peter consistently proved he had my best interests in mind. Each moment built trust. I needed that. He was always responsive, thorough, and thoughtful. I was never rushed and never pushed into a deal. When concerns came up, Peter didnt dismiss them or try to sell me. He laid out the facts and let me make informed decisions. In hindsight, that approach helped me grow as an investor and truly understand the Indianapolis market. Peter also personally visits properties. If something interests you, he has likely already walked it and often has video. Watching him evaluate homes is impressive. He understands construction, age, condition, and risk far beyond what most investors would catch. When the right deal came along, I needed specific terms to make it work financially. Peter negotiated excellent terms and made the deal happen, even when it wasnt the easiest path. What truly sets Peter apart is what happened after closing. He stayed involved, ensured repair credits and security deposits were handled properly, and personally delivered warranty and appliance documentation to my property manager. Weeks after closing, when many agents disappear, Peter was still there. That level of follow-through says everything. I'm incredibly grateful for Peter and Linda and excited for many future deals together.
Patrick P.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review We worked with Peter for one year and half as we were looking to relocate, he was extremely patient with us and we never felt pressure on any of the houses we were looking to purchase. We found the perfect house with the perfect location and Peter guided us thru the process to purchase the home in this highly competitive market. Linda was also a great resource for the close and both members of the team are great communicators. He also makes video walk thru videos very comprehensive for remote folks looking to buy a home.
A C.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review I really enjoyed working with Peter - from our first conversation where he presented me with a full picture of the market verbally and with many resources (I am an out of state investor), getting numerous recommendations of vendors, to actually seeing the properties, negotiating on an offer and ultimately closing on one. Peter's team was able to smoothly guide me through the process, answer all the questions and make it a very positive experience. I highly recommend working with Peter Stewart.
Justin L.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter was fantastic to work with aEUR" clear communication, fast responses, and a solid understanding of the Indianapolis market. He approaches everything with an investor mindset and gave practical, no-fluff advice throughout negotiations and beyond. Even after closing, hes been a great resource for reliable local vendors. Highly recommend Peter to any investor looking in the Indy area
Loo J.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter was fantastic to work with aEUR" clear communication, fast responses, and a solid understanding of the Indianapolis market. He approaches everything with an investor mindset and gave practical, no-fluff advice throughout negotiations and beyond. Even after closing, hes been a great resource for reliable local vendors. Highly recommend Peter to any investor looking in the Indy area
Yanncrennsof
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review I just bought a duplex in Indy, and Peter was awesome from start to finish. Hes calm, practical, and actually listens. He walked me through the Section 8 pieces (HQS, HAP vs tenant share, change of ownership) in plain English, kept title and the seller on track. What I liked most: he was always a step ahead and never pushy. Quick updates, honest advice, and real numbers instead of sales talk. If youre buying from out of state or want someone who treats your deal like their own, work with Peter. He made a stressful process feel manageable, and Id happily use him again.
Qtrvista
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review As a real estate investor, working with the right agent can make or break your dealsaEUR"and Peter is absolutely the right agent. From our first conversation, it was clear that he not only understands the Indianapolis market inside and out, but he also truly understands what investors are looking for: cash flow, value-add opportunities, strong ROI, and speed. Peter is professional, responsive, and always comes prepared with comps, rental estimates, and renovation insights. Hes helped me analyze multiple deals with a sharp eye and isnt afraid to tell you when something doesnt make senseaEUR"which I respect deeply. Hes not just trying to close a sale; hes helping build long-term investment success. What really sets Peter apart is his local network. From property managers to contractors and inspectors, he connected me with reliable professionals whove helped streamline the entire process. Whether youre just getting started in Indy or scaling your portfolio, Peter is the kind of partner you want on your team. Highly recommended to any serious investor looking for a knowledgeable, honest, and investor-savvy real estate agent in Indianapolis
Jonathan S.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review I could not have had a better experience with this team - I completed my first 1031 exchange this summer and purchased four investment properties in Indianapolis with Peter's help. Peter provided expert advice in assessing different locations with abundant resources for an out-of-state investor to gain familiarity with the area; he provided excellent referrals to help me build my local network, and most importantly gave trusted, transparent advice on what he felt were each properties' assets and potential issues. His ability to navigate complex negotiations with sellers and find mutually beneficial solutions was second to none, and I will absolutely be working with him on more deals in the future. Linda managed the crucial administration and kept all four closings on track with clear, concise communication and timely help whenever needed. Thank you both for everything, you've been amazing to work with!
Sarah T.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review This is the second home that Peter has helped us purchase. We previously lived out of state and Peter was kind enough to do virtual tours and help us throughout the process. He was patient in answering all of our questions and helped us feel confident during the highs and lows of the escrow period. Linda was also incredibly helpful during this time. We appreciate Peter and Linda and look forward to working with them again in the future.
Kamen P.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Working with Peter to purchase my property was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. As a first-time buyer, I had a lot of questions and concerns, but Peter was patient, knowledgeable, and always available to guide me through every step of the process. What stood out the most was his deep understanding of the local market and his commitment to finding the right property for my needsaEUR"not just making a quick sale. He was honest, transparent, and never pushed me into anything I wasn't 100% comfortable with. I highly recommend Peter.
Terrywheeler1
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter was great to work with. He knows the market really well. I recommend him for anyone looking to buy and/or sell. He helped us sell our home and it was sold on the first day it hit the market.
Ivanfloresm
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter and Linda were an absolute dream team to work with! Peter's deep experience and knowledge of the market were immediately apparent and gave me such confidence as an investor. His communication was top-notch aEUR" always clear, proactive, and timely. And when it came to negotiation, Peter truly shone; he navigated everything with skill and finesse, undoubtedly proving to be a significant asset. Linda was equally fantastic. She was always so helpful and incredibly responsive whenever I had a question, making the entire process smooth and stress-free. I wholeheartedly recommend their services to any investor looking for knowledgeable, communicative, and effective partners!
Diana T.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review My husband and I bought our first investment property with Peter and his team . As first timers, we purged him with many questions and he was always able to answer patiently and quickly . I was working with other agents in other areas and I can say that Peter and Linda are very quick in replying and getting things done, which is something I was looking for in an agent. Highly suggest them and would work with them again !
RituMahajan
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter and his team were extremely helpful and professional. They answered all our queries very promptly and went way above and beyond to work on this deal. Peters knowledge in the field of real estate is very thorough and extensive. I would highly recommend them.
ThomasLoyola
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter helped us purchase our first investment property out of state. He was extremely professional and knowledgable about the entire process and we felt confident having him on our side. His assistant Linda was also fantastic and aEUR~on it. Both were excellent communicators. 10/10 would recommend.
Gino R.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter and his assistant Linda were very responsive and answered all my questions regarding the property. He was able to negotiate a lower price after inspection. He was very knowledgable about the area and also gave me recommendations for contractors and property managers which was extremely helpful.
Plreed2022
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review I recently purchased an investment property in Indianapolis while living in a different state, and Peter Stewart made the entire process incredibly smooth. His market expertise and negotiation skills were invaluable, ensuring I got a great deal. Peter and his transaction coordinator Linda, were always responsive and on top of every detail, making this purchase effortless. I truly appreciate their professionalism and support, and Ill definitely be interested in working with them again in the future! Highly recommend!
Dustinmail
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter is extremely knowledgeable in the Indianapolis and surrounding markets. Professional, and great customer service! We have used Peter and team to purchase 4 homes now. Being an out of state investor and not being able to see the properties he makes it very easy with personalized videos and honest feedback!
Marc S.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter was my agent for my first ever investment property transaction. I very much appreciate the outstanding customer service that he provided to me during the entire process. Peter did many walk-throughs of properties, took videos and photos, and provided very helpful recommendations on where to invest and where not to invest. I closed on my property last month and I could not be happier. I will definitely work with Peter again in the future!
Marc
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter was my agent for my first ever investment property transaction. I very much appreciate the outstanding customer service that he provided to me during the entire process. Peter did many walk-throughs of properties, took videos and photos, and provided very helpful recommendations on where to invest and where not to invest. I closed on my property last month and I could not be happier. I will definitely work with Peter again in the future!
Chaggerty74
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter did an amazing job helping and guiding me through the process. I am an out of state investor so I needed someone who knows investment properties, and Peter was the perfect choice!
Rpeck5441
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter did a great job guiding us through the selling process. He is very responsive to questions after the listing and especially as offer and counter offer phase began. I highly recommend him.
Jourdanw42
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter helped me purchase my first rental property this month. He?s extremely professional, knowledgeable, honest, and patient! He always made sure that any and all questions I had were answered. He?s also very resourceful! His assistant Linda was also very kind and professional and helped navigate sealing the deal at the end. I highly recommend using Peter and his team!
Jayedspa
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Working with Pete was an absolute pleasure! From the very beginning, Pete demonstrated exceptional professionalism, deep market knowledge, and a genuine commitment to helping me find the perfect home. He was always available to answer questions, provide valuable insights, and guide me through every step of the buying process. His attention to detail and proactive approach made the entire experience stress-free and enjoyable. I couldn?t be happier with the outcome, and I highly recommend Pete to anyone looking to buy or sell a property. Thank you, Pete, for your outstanding service!?
Brian D.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Working with Peter was a fantastic experience! His expertise in the real estate market is unmatched, providing invaluable insights that guided me through every step of selling my home. Communication was always prompt and clear, making the process stress-free. Peter truly had my best interests at heart, negotiating an excellent deal and ensuring all my needs were met without any pressure. His professionalism, dedication, and genuine care made the entire experience enjoyable. I highly recommend Peter for anyone looking for a top-tier real estate agent!
Forhim2911
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review What a wonderful experience it was working with Peter and Linda securing our first investment property. Peter was extremely knowledgeable about the Indianapolis area and his expertise was instrumental in the deal. He was extremely patient with us and always took our phone calls. We appreciated that we never felt he was rushing us off the phone and made us feel comfortable and valuable as clients throughout the process. Linda was also very helpful once we were in escrow and was easy to get a hold of. We are so excited to now own our first investment property and look forward to future acquisitions working with Peter!
Sarah T.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review What a wonderful experience it was working with Peter and Linda securing our first investment property. Peter was extremely knowledgeable about the Indianapolis area and his expertise was instrumental in the deal. He was extremely patient with us and always took our phone calls. We appreciated that we never felt he was rushing us off the phone and made us feel comfortable and valuable as clients throughout the process. Linda was also very helpful once we were in escrow and was easy to get a hold of. We are so excited to now own our first investment property and look forward to future acquisitions working with Peter!
Justin T.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter and Linda are an amazing team. Im an out-of-state investor, and Peter, without hesitation hopped on a Zoom with me to deep dive into neighborhoods and discuss local nuances. Even though we were in different time zones, Linda always replied to my emails within five minutes, no matter how late it was for them. Peter is everything you want in a real estate agent, and then some! I highly recommend them.
Mitchellkunkler
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review I worked with Peter to purchase my first investment property in Indianapolis in Jan 2024. Peter has invaluable experience that gave me confidence through the process. I was also able to meet Peter in person at my closing and his passion for real estate is contagious. I intend to work with Peter for all of my future real estate investments.
User255079
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter and Linda were both very attentive and communicated very quickly. The whole process was handled very professionally and timely. Listed both of our homes with Peter Stewart Realty and both processes went very smoothly. The listings were well photographed and videos had a very professional quality to them. Their staging recommendations were so helpful in displaying our home well. Would absolutely use them again.
Danielrosen2012
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter and his team made me feel extremely informed, comfortable and in control throughout the entire sale process of my property in Indy. They really go above and beyond for their clients and provide a personal touch that is hard to come by.
Chelsea S.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review I cant say enough about how phenomenal Peter and his assistant Linda are! We were looking to purchase our 1st investment property out of state and found Peter on Bigger Pockets. We were nervous purchasing out of state. However, he made the process seamless, was incredibly knowledgeable, provided great communication the entire time, hes detailed, and went above and beyond to help make this easy for us. In fact, after our 1st purchase with him, we felt confident having him in our network that we ended up purchasing 3 more properties! If youre looking for an agent, Peter is the one to go with!
Lizzy T.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review I purchased my very first investment property with Peter, and I cant recommend him enough. As someone who purchased out of state, and for the first time, it was crucial for me to find someone hands on and trustworthy. Peter made the entire process from start to finish so easy and stress-free. I knew absolutely nothing about the areas I was looking in, and Peter always gave me thoughtful and detailed descriptions of neighborhoods and great advice when I was first searching for a property. He always got back to me in a timely manner as well. Truly 10/10!
Kellerwith2es
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter is a fantastic resource for both selling and buying! He prepared an awesome video campaign which helped to sell our home in hours. He helped us through multiple bids, the first buyer changing their mind, and securing the final sale to close the same day we closed in the new house. When it was time to find our new home, Peter went to bat for us on the comps, value, and negotiation. Linda, from his office, was also great with coordination of all the final details. We had outstanding selling and buying experiences!
Keith4546
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter has been outstanding to work with! Most recently he help us sell a property on the east side of Indianapolis. His expertise and knowledge of the market allowed us to price the property correctly, and get an offer within a few days! Peter is great with communication as well. He responded to any questions or concerns right away. He also went above and beyond with explaining the market analysis and how to navigate it. I woul;d recommed Peter to anyone who is looking to buy or sell in the area.
Rio G.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter, has sold two homes for me. I wouldnt use anyone in IN other than Peter, because I am certain that he will always provide the utmost knowledgeable advice. His responsiveness and that of his executive assistant were so reliable that I never had any concerns for any part of the selling process. As the buyer became evident, Peter and his EA teamed to complete a seamless experience. I could fill this space with superlatives to describe Peters professionalism and good natured manner and never broach being excessive, nor exaggerated. I highly recommend working with Peter Stewart. Buying and selling a home can be stressful for a variety of known reasons, dont introduce the unknowns selecting just any realtor, when working with Peter Stewart Realty will take out the stressful variables. Peter Stewart is a sure thing of Integrity and Competency.
Jen
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review I had an exceptional experience working with Peter?s team while purchasing my first investment property. From the outset, their extensive knowledge of the local market and investment opportunities impressed me. They patiently guided me through various options, providing valuable insights on each propertys potential ROI. Throughout the process, Peter was responsive, proactive, and an excellent negotiator, ensuring I got the best deal possible. I wholeheartedly recommend Peter to anyone seeking a dedicated and knowledgeable real estate agent.
Frasierholdings
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter is amazing to work with. He is very knowledgeable and professional. He helped us understand the market and know what to expect during the sales process. I always felt like I knew what was going on with our house and he kept in touch throughout the entire process.
Kewlaunt12
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter did a great job. My home sold and closed quickly. Peter answered all my questions and guided me through the whole process. It was a pleasure selling my home with Peter?s help.
Pat W.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter helped me buy my second house and provided the same solid expertise, once again. I actually went under contract while he was briefly out of town with the aid of Linda Schotter, a member of his team, and she was just as helpful, knowledgeable, and friendly. Between the two of them, I had every question answered and felt more than prepared to tackle every step of the search with the confidence that every buyer should have. I would not hesitate at all to recommend them or enlist their help a third time.
Keifer T.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter helped us buy our first out-of-state investment property in Indy and we could not be happier with him and his team. He was vital in helping us find deals and giving us knowledge of the area to help us feel comfortable moving forward with the deal. I look forward to hopefully many more deals with Peter in the future!
Anna M.
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Just closed on my 3rd property this year with Peter. I am an out of state investor and Peter and His team (Linda) have been vital in finding me deals and giving me first hand knowledge of the area. I?ve never been to Indianapolis so investing in a market you never been is only possible with the help of someone very knowledgeable. This is what I have found in Peter and Linda. This is just the beginning of many more investments to come. I couldn?t be more happy having them on my team.
User3331465
Review for Member: Peter Stewart
Zillow
Review Peter did a great job helping me to find my next home. His local insights on the neighborhood helped to guide me to a place that fit my needs and would be good location in popular area of the city. Peter makes the process towards closing easy by providing a checklist once offer is accepted of the immediate next steps and follows up to make sure that you stay on task and answer any questions in the meantime.
View All Listings