desktop img
mobile img

Top Real Estate Agents In Shelbyville, IN

Learn More

Looking for a top real estate agent in Shelbyville? You’ve come to the right place. Our realtors profiles include:

  • Recent Sales
  • Ratings & Reviews
  • Average Price Point
  • Years of Experience
  • Service Areas
  • Neighborhood Expertise
shelbyville, in area badge
shelbyville, in
32 Results
Filters filter icon

Filters

Jennifer Andrews Top real estate agent in Shelbyville
6 Yrs of Experience
16 sales in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
2 Available Listings
$1M
Total Sales Last Year
34
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$198.7K
Average Price Point
Chris Price Top real estate agent in Avon
23 Yrs of Experience
8 sales in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
3 Available Listings
$34M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$187.9K
Average Price Point
Derrin Phoenix Top real estate agent in Greenwood
17 Yrs of Experience
4 sales in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
4 Available Listings
$10M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$281.9K
Average Price Point
Karen Neligh Top real estate agent in Indianapolis
11 Yrs of Experience
3 sales in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
$7.1M
Total Sales Last Year
38
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$258.4K
Average Price Point
Amy Hobbs Top real estate agent in Batesville
8 Yrs of Experience
2 sales in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
$3.5M
Total Sales Last Year
70
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$227.4K
Average Price Point
Jake Hemrick Top real estate agent in Franklin
12 Yrs of Experience
2 sales in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
4 Available Listings
$12M
Total Sales Last Year
59
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$377.7K
Average Price Point
Michael Price Top real estate agent in Plainfield
19 Yrs of Experience
1 sale in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
$1.9M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$294.1K
Average Price Point
Scott Babb Top real estate agent in Columbus
3 Yrs of Experience
1 sale in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
2 Available Listings
$16.5M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$279.9K
Average Price Point
Sarah Noel Top real estate agent in Plainfield
7 Yrs of Experience
1 sale in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
$4.5M
Total Sales Last Year
89
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$290.6K
Average Price Point
Shelli Anderson Top real estate agent in Bargersville
8 Yrs of Experience
1 sale in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
$8M
Total Sales Last Year
77
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$273.4K
Average Price Point
Jill Dixon Top real estate agent in Greenfield
14 Yrs of Experience
1 sale in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
4 Available Listings
$67M
Total Sales Last Year
60
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$278K
Average Price Point
Kathy Vandrtbur Top real estate agent in Greensburg
6 Yrs of Experience
1 sale in shelbyville, in in the last 3 years
$40K
Total Sales Last Year
41
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$213.4K
Average Price Point
Cindy Stockhaus Top real estate agent in Greenwood
$24M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$203.8K
Average Price Point
Darrin Galyean Top real estate agent in Greenwood
$80M
Total Sales Last Year
122
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$197K
Average Price Point
Sarah Flynn Top real estate agent in Carmel
$2.2M
Total Sales Last Year
65
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$329.9K
Average Price Point
Michelle Kelly Top real estate agent in Fishers
Real Broker, LLC
19 Yrs of Experience
$6.6M
Total Sales Last Year
98
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$245.4K
Average Price Point
Jonathan Hopson Top real estate agent in Greenwood
$4.9M
Total Sales Last Year
102
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$266.7K
Average Price Point
Sarah ODonnell Top real estate agent in Indianapolis
$6M
Total Sales Last Year
71
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$378K
Average Price Point
Ray Podesta Top real estate agent in Greenwood
$7.5M
Total Sales Last Year
65
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$353.1K
Average Price Point
Chris Harmon Top real estate agent in Plainfield
$3.8M
Total Sales Last Year
32
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$317K
Average Price Point
Alexis Lucas Top real estate agent in Martinsville
$0
Total Sales Last Year
6
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$0
Average Price Point
Connie Lindsay Top real estate agent in Shelbyville
$0
Total Sales Last Year
$0
Average Price Point
Brian Quinlan Top real estate agent in Indianapolis
$4.9M
Total Sales Last Year
57
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$334.6K
Average Price Point
Holly Newland Top real estate agent in Columbus
$1.4M
Total Sales Last Year
15
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$288.8K
Average Price Point
Nicole Gosser Top real estate agent in McCordsville
$3.2M
Total Sales Last Year
$0
Average Price Point
City Divider

Resources to pick the best agent in Shelbyville, IN

Shelbyville, IN Real Estate Agents

There are 26 real estate agents in the city of Shelbyville to choose from. We’ve analyzed and ranked over 32 top real estate agent profiles in our network to help you find the best agents in Shelbyville for 2026.

Our team evaluates the number of recent sales, confirmed customer reviews, and agent track record to determine the top agents in each location.

Hiring an agent who is experienced and trusted by past clients gives you confidence throughout the home buying or selling process. You can be sure you have the best partner to get you the best price for your home.

Shelbyville has many real estate agents who claim to be the best and get you the best deal. How do you know who to trust and who will work the hardest for you?

We’ve crunched the numbers and gone through thousands of real estate agent profiles to bring you only the best as you begin your journey. Search, compare, and hire easily from this list of top Shelbyville real estate agents of 2026.

Cities near Shelbyville, IN

    View all cities near Shelbyville, IN
    Banner

    Get matched by an expert!

    Still having trouble choosing an agent? Let our team of dedicated experts pick one for you! We'll email you our recommendations after you answer a few questions.

    Our team will find the best agent in your area for you.

    Still have questions? We’d love to help!

    support_call

    Call our support team toll free at 1 (800) 319-0511

    call center

    Frequently Asked Questions

    The Bottom Line

    Choosing a real estate agent in Shelbyville can seem overwhelming, especially with so many agents in Shelbyville who would love to work with you. At FastExpert, we help make the decision easy.

    We provide all the details and information you need about Realtors in Shelbyville so that you can find a trusted real estate agent who understands you.

    With the world’s largest database of real estate agents, you have access to each agent’s profile so you can compare and hire. Check out Shelbyville real estate agent listings, read verified client reviews and easily message your perfect Realtor.

    Or let us do the work for you! Let us know your priorities, and FastExpert will match you with several of the best Shelbyville real estate agents for you to choose from.

    When your money and your memories are involved, you need an advocate by your side. With a FastExpert real estate agent, you can have confidence that you’ll get the best service in all of Shelbyville.

    Have questions? We’re here to help! Message us at [email protected] or call (800) 319-0511.