
Send Message
FC Tucker Company
28 Yorkshire Boulevard
Indianapolis, IN 46229
Send Message
25 REVIEWS(4.9/5)
Linda M.
September 25, 2026
VERIFIED
I entered criteria into an AI Agent seeking the "most successful" real estate agent in the New Palestine, IN, citing fewest days on the market and highest sales price. 5 agents came up and I reviewed each one reading bios and websites. I selected Sarah O'Donnell with F.C. Tucker Company because her information was the most complete, really showcased her success in our area and the reputation of F.C. Tucker. Upon talking with her, she outlined her approach and also emphasized her market differentiators resulting in a higher closing rate. We loved the photographer/videographer she selected and the final product. We also loved her use of AI to virtually furnish our otherwise empty home. We provided Sarah with an inventory of all upgrades to the home and the cost of each which she turned into a "Features Page" in our sales packet. We believe that this page and her emphasis of this data is what sold our house. Buyers loved the Turn-Key aspects of the home. Additionally, there were multiple 1-story ranch homes For Sale in ours and the adjacent neighborhood. On our closing day, all but 1 of those competing properties were still on the market. We really enjoyed working with Sarah, her responsiveness to our inquiries and overall pleasant experience.
Janna
January 29, 2026
VERIFIED
Working with Sarah from Talk to Tucker was a fantastic experience! She was knowledgeable, professional, and truly listened to our families needs. Sarah guided us through every step of the buying/selling process and made everything smooth and stress-free. Her market expertise and attention to detail helped us find the perfect home at a great price. I highly recommend Sarah from Talk to Tucker, for anyone looking for a dedicated and trustworthy real estate professional!"
Destinyspath24
August 23, 2024
VERIFIED
Sarah was a calming presence when trying to sell. It can be nerve wracking with many ups and downs! She was confident, did a lot of research to help us, and worked hard to make it happen. She was responsive when I needed questions answered and was proactive in her dealings. She helped us secure offers on multiple properties and also guided us to the place we call home now. Sarah is awesome!
Drieman77
September 6, 2024
VERIFIED
Sarah was a tremendous help with the sell of my house. She was put in many difficult situations dealing with my situation. She managed and help me through the hole process. She was alway punctual with answering any questions. When looking for a house. Sarah was always ready to show a house. Sending me listing's, setting up showings, meeting me there. Giving me feed back and comps. In the area. She has great negotiation skills with the offers and counter offers. I would use Sarah as my realtor again. and recommend Sarah for your next sell or purchase.
User9053924
September 28, 2026
VERIFIED
Sarah was amazing through the entire process of buying and selling. She was always available for questions even when on vacation! I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell.
Location:
Loading map