Service Areas
About Karen Neligh
Credentials
LICENSE
Awards
-
2026
TOP AGENT
Greenfield, IN
2026
TOP AGENT
Shelbyville, IN
2026
TOP AGENT
Knightstown, IN
2026
Greenfield, IN
2026
Shelbyville, IN
2026
Knightstown, IN
Were first time home buyers and Karen was so helpful and explained everything to us. I would definitely recommend her, she works to get you what youre wanting and makes the process as easy as it can be.
Karen has endless patience with questions from new homeowners...and answers then in the same kind and knowledgeable way. Karen has a quick grasp on recognizing your tastes and shifting her focus on those choices. She was VERY accommodating to, honest with, and protective of us as her clients. She's not loud and boisterous in being her client's voice, but quietly determined...which is MUCH more effective. Choosing her as your agent would be the first step into making sure that you get what fits your checklist!
Karen was the perfect agent! She helped us through finding a house, getting pre-approved, helped us sell our current home and did it all in a timely well thought out plan that executed exactly as she said it would. We closed on our new home and our current home within days of each other. Very communicative and responds quickly via text. HIGHLY RECOMMEND.
Karen was exceptional! She was fast in responding to our inquiries about new properties, knowing the good ones won't last. Showing them to us within a few hours. We didnt buy an expensive home, I know she didn't earn a lot from our sale, but she gave us of herself, a lot of her time and expertise. She was always kind, never rushed us, and never made us feel like our questions weren't valid. I would recommend her to anyone!! And I have been telling friends about her. She made a stressful process tolerable.
Karen was a great help in my search for a home. She worked with me for months and we were able to find something I love. Before I met her, I was working with an agent from another company that wrote me off as not being serious due to my young age. I did not want to deal with that agents poor service any longer, so I found Karen on Zillow. She was very helpful, noticed things in homes that I did not, provided me with recommendations for inspectors and future improvements, and did everything she could to make sure I was happy.
Our Realtor Karen Neligh was Great!!! Karen was very professional very helpful and always eager to show us houses and help with our home search. She went above and beyond to help us get our home and make sure we were happy. We would definitely recommend her for anyone looking to purchase a home. Karen Neligh is a go getter!!!!!
Thank you so much Karen for helping us find our first home. You knew exactly what we were looking for even before we did and were always available when we needed you. I absolutely would recommend Karen to anyone looking to buy. She is very dependable and a pleasure to work with. We are loving our new home!
Karen was great throughout the whole process. She made me feel as tho I was her only client and she was always available when I had a question or when I found a new house to add to our list. I will definitely be using her service in the future when I buy another home
Karen was great throughout the whole process. She made me feel as tho I was her only client and she was always available when I had a question or when I found a new house to add to our list. I will definitely be using her service in the future when I buy another home
Karen made the whole process of selling and buying a house a breeze. She provided advice on how to sell our house quickly; which we followed and received an offer for more than our asking price within 48 hours of listing our home. She also made sure to explain everything thoroughly and answered all of our questions. Even our mortgage lender raved about how working with Karen was a pleasure as she was very proactive and responded very quickly. Overall Karen was the absolute best person to work with in a process that can seem ovyerwhelming at times. We are currently living in our dream home thanks to Karen and would highly recommend her to anyone buying or selling a home.
It was a pleasure to work with Karen! She was patient with us as new home buyers and understood our wants and needs very well. She was willing to negotiate on our behalf and did a great job of communicating with us throughout the entire home-buying process. I will definitely be recommending Karen to any of our friends and family who are looking for a new home. Thanks Karen!
Karen was great to work with and helped us through the entire process. We were able to find the right house at the right price. Her evaluations of the properties we looked at helped us make the right decision. We felt she was more like a trusted member of our family than an agent. It was a great experience.
Karen was very helpful in finding us our new home,she also helped us with the sale of our old home.She is very attentive to detail and made our sale and buying as painless as she could.
It was an absolute joy to work with Karen and the Front Porch Reality team. Karen was readily available to answer all questions and address any concerns that developed along the way. She was accommodating to our needs and hectic schedules and managed to find us the perfect home that has everything we want and more. I appreciate all of the hard-work, time, and effort she gave to my family and would recommend her to any future home-buyers.
Karen made our first home buying experience fantastic! She really helped us get the home we wanted for the price we wanted. She tackled all the problems we encounter swiftly and kept in close contact with our mortgager so everything was always up to date.
Karen was motivated and courteous through the entire process, even though it took months to find the right house. Would definitely work with her again.
She is very reasonable, understanding and caring. She works fast and finds exactly what you want. I highly recommend. She was very fast and efficient at finding a home, she worked with my crazy schedule and lack of knowledge. She helped me understand fully and always looked out for my better interest.
She is very reasonable, understanding and caring. She works fast and finds exactly what you want. I highly recommend. She was very fast and efficient at finding a home, she worked with my crazy schedule and lack of knowledge. She helped me understand fully and always looked out for my better interest.
I would recommend Karen to eny one she is vary delightful to be around she helped me in every way possibly she went out of her way to make it easy for me i would use her again eny time i thank her she helped me buy the house I wanted never got in no hurry never made me wait for always prompt loved having her on my side thanks Karen its been a pleasure FLOSSIE RAYN5
Karen did a great job and was a pleasure to work with. She was very patient and responsive with all of our questions. I would highly recommend her to help you buy a new house.
Karen is amazing, and I would certainly recommend working with her. I am a first-time home-buyer and I was connected with Karen through my mortgage company, Quicken. She was a fantastic realtor to work with! I was buying a house in Indianapolis while still living in Colorado, and Karen made this process easy. She took me through houses over the phone and was honest with me about whether or not she felt I would like them/or should buy them, and she found me my perfect home in the Irvington neighborhood which I had fallen in love with. Karen is warm, friendly, and effective. She advocated for me throughout the process and was wonderful at answering my questions and making sure all of the details were managed quickly and efficiently. Thanks, Karen!
Karen is amazing! She goes above and beyond for her customers. We were first time home buyers and she re assured us through the long process. She made sure to explain everything we signed during the process step by step, which I really liked since we had no clue what we were doing at first. Karen is very caring and compassionate, and makes sure to answer any question you have for her right away! Karen stands by her customers 100%. Me and my boyfriend were so glad to be able to experience this first time experience with Karen! I would highly recommend her to anybody!
We were SO impressed with Karen Neligh on our recent property purchase. She had our backs all the way, answering questions immediately, meeting us to see the property (multiple times!) and triple checking our contracts saving us extra money at signing! She was so sweet, caring and personable. We will be recommending her to all our nearest and dearest in the future. If I could give her 10 stars here, I would in a heartbeat!
Karen is awesome! I'm in California and found her through Zillow. She did tours via video chat and is amazingly responsive. She has many clients but makes you feel like her top priority. She secured everything I asked for in negotiations and did great! Bought the house without coming to Indiana. Highly recommend her!
Karen was referred to me by my lender to purchase my first home. I had no experience in the home buying/searching process. Karen was very patient and kind, she returned all of my texts, calls, and emails very promptly and answered my many questions about searching for and buying a home. When I finally made my choice, Karen advocated for me and looked out for my best interest. She is a very kind and caring person. I will recommend her to family and friends in the future, and if I ever decide to buy or sell, she will be my first choice.
Karen was extremely helpful in showing me my future home. She showed the utmost respect and was very knowledgeable about the process. I felt that I was in good hands.
Karen is an experienced agent with strong knowledge of the Indianapolis area. She works hard to find excellent value and quality at their price point. Her strengths as a negotiator helped me find the home that I wanted and afford the improvements I needed at closing. Throughout the process of looking for and buying a home I felt that Karen was an engaged partner with the advice I needed as a first-time buyer. Overall, I would highly recommend Karen to a friend or colleague aEUR" it has been a pleasure to work with her and I love my new home!
She is so helpful and patience we are so glad to met her. this our first time as a buyers and with her we are getting a great experience. She advice us on every step we do
Karen was incredibly helpful during our home search. She was very knowledgeable of the area and found several beautiful homes for us to look through that fit our specifications. Karen is professional, kind, and thorough. She went above and beyond to make sure our needs were met--including spending extra time with us explaining every detail of the mortgage application and home buying processes. She has a wealth of resources available, which proved to be indispensable to us as first-time homebuyers. Karen was easy to reach and quick to communicate. We are so happy we worked with Karen and would highly recommend her!
Karen said a few things on listed house needed addressed, and I took care of them, and looks like house got a buyer, so her intuition and knowledge paid off for me
Karen was very helpful and understanding, during my home buying process. There was a point I gave her an address of a property I thought was for sale and she went and knocked on the door to find out for. She was very patient with me and my family, I would highly recommend her to anyone.
Karen was very helpful and understanding, during my home buying process. There was a point I gave her an address of a property I thought was for sale and she went and knocked on the door to find out for. She was very patient with me and my family, I would highly recommend her to anyone.
We haven't finished the close yet, but I have to say Karen has been a wonderful agent. She's been extremely quick to respond to messages but you probably won't have the opportunity to leave one because Karen seems to be always available when it comes to work. She does her research well, and is knowledgeable about her trade. I had some very specific features in mind when it came to my home search, and Karen has been adept at locating homes that fit my requirements.To be sure, I believe this will be my last house search. However, if I ever do have the need to locate another property, I'll be happy to contact Karen again.
Karen was a great Realtor, she took her time explaining things to me since I was a first time home buyer, she got me a great deal and a great home. She was an excellent choice for me, and above all she got me the financing when no one else would. 10/10 no question.
Karen was a great Realtor, she took her time explaining things to me since I was a first time home buyer, she got me a great deal and a great home.She was an excellent choice for me, and above all she got me the financing when no one else would. 10/10 no question.
Loading recent sales...