desktop img
mobile img

Top Real Estate Agents In Chautauqua County, NY

Learn More

Looking for a top real estate agent in Chautauqua County? You’ve come to the right place. Our realtors profiles include:

  • Recent Sales
  • Ratings & Reviews
  • Average Price Point
  • Years of Experience
  • Service Areas
  • Neighborhood Expertise
chautauqua County badge
chautauqua County
36 Results
Filters filter icon

Filters

Rick And Julia McMahon Top real estate agent in Jamestown
34 Yrs of Experience
221 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
2 Available Listings
$21.2M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$327K
Average Price Point
Cynthia Rosenbloom Top real estate agent in Mayville
14 Yrs of Experience
41 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$11.7M
Total Sales Last Year
58
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$423.1K
Average Price Point
Tiffany Borst Top real estate agent in Jamestown
10 Yrs of Experience
202 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$10M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$240.5K
Average Price Point
Marcello Miceli Top real estate agent in Fredonia
6 Yrs of Experience
60 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$3.1M
Total Sales Last Year
82
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$127K
Average Price Point
Richard Benedetto Top real estate agent in Jamestown
41 Yrs of Experience
144 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
4 Available Listings
$12M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$237.8K
Average Price Point
Wayne Weaver Top real estate agent in Jamestown
17 Yrs of Experience
14 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
1 Available Listings
$0
Total Sales Last Year
24
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$273K
Average Price Point
Tammy Hess-Schmitt Top real estate agent in Mayville
22 Yrs of Experience
78 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$5.6M
Total Sales Last Year
118
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$122.3K
Average Price Point
Amy Garris Top real estate agent in Jamestown
6 Yrs of Experience
69 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
1 Available Listings
$2M
Total Sales Last Year
89
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$149.1K
Average Price Point
Heidi Brooks Top real estate agent in Jamestown
10 Yrs of Experience
62 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$5.6M
Total Sales Last Year
103
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$167.8K
Average Price Point
Lora Reed Top real estate agent in Mayville
5 Yrs of Experience
47 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$2M
Total Sales Last Year
63
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$183.9K
Average Price Point
Michelle Hawkins Top real estate agent in Lakewood
5 Yrs of Experience
46 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$2.2M
Total Sales Last Year
65
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$130.7K
Average Price Point
Jacob Benedetto Top real estate agent in Jamestown
1 Yrs of Experience
46 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$1.9M
Total Sales Last Year
51
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$124.5K
Average Price Point
Mark Jaquith Top real estate agent in Mayville
10 Yrs of Experience
44 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$2.3M
Total Sales Last Year
59
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$145.6K
Average Price Point
Rachel Willow Top real estate agent in Mayville
8 Yrs of Experience
35 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$6.6M
Total Sales Last Year
35
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$317.5K
Average Price Point
Susan Muscarella Top real estate agent in Jamestown
13 Yrs of Experience
32 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$4M
Total Sales Last Year
54
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$184.7K
Average Price Point
Tonya Studley Top real estate agent in Randolph
15 Yrs of Experience
11 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$3.3M
Total Sales Last Year
96
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$162.6K
Average Price Point
Ryan Sander Top real estate agent in corry
9 Yrs of Experience
5 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
2 Available Listings
$0
Total Sales Last Year
121
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$196.2K
Average Price Point
Matthew Froehlich Top real estate agent in Erie
18 Yrs of Experience
3 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$4M
Total Sales Last Year
62
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$350.7K
Average Price Point
Victor Flores Top real estate agent in Falconer
8 Yrs of Experience
2 sales in chautauqua, ny in the last 3 years
$250K
Total Sales Last Year
7
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$179.4K
Average Price Point
Mary Huffman Top real estate agent in Erie
$11.4M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$293.6K
Average Price Point
Shane Wills Top real estate agent in Edinboro
$5M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$244.6K
Average Price Point
Leslie Jaglowski Top real estate agent in Erie
$8.3M
Total Sales Last Year
127
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$268.8K
Average Price Point
Renee Brown-Wagner Top real estate agent in Erie
$10.8K
Total Sales Last Year
8
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$218.8K
Average Price Point
Behar Hoxha Top real estate agent in Erie
$1.7M
Total Sales Last Year
104
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$156.7K
Average Price Point
Samantha Clabbatz Top real estate agent in ERIE
$8.1M
Total Sales Last Year
3
RecentTransactionsTotal Transactions from the last 3 years
$0
Average Price Point

The Best Realtors in Chautauqua County by Top Cities

The State of New York has 1608 Cities, and 62 Counties. Chautauqua County houses 36 cities within its borders. Often agents will service and specialize in multiple zipcodes and cities, especially in larger counties. According to the National Association of Realtors, the state of New York has 20 licensed real estate agents as of August 2021.

No matter what Chautauqua County city you live in, there's a top realtor who will get you the best deal when it comes to buying or selling a home. As you start on your real estate journey be sure to pick a great agent to ensure your real estate experience is the best it can be. Here we show the best Chautauqua County real estate agents in each city.

Chautauqua County, NY Real Estate Agents

Chautauqua County is located in the state of New York and has 36 cities located within its borders. The state of New York has a total of 62 counties with Chautauqua County ranking number 3 for number of housing units.

There are 20 real estate agents in Chautauqua County to choose from. At FastExpert, we analyzed and ranked over 36 top real estate agent profiles within our network to help you locate the best agents to work with in Chautauqua County for 2026.

Our team reviews and evaluates recent sales history, real customer reviews, agent location, years active, and more to determine the top agents in each county.

When you hire a realtor you want to feel confident in your decision. Having all of the right information can help you feel sure that you found the best partner for your real estate needs.

With 66,260 homes in Chautauqua County, there are many real estate agents that are trying to earn your business and will tell you they will work the hardest for you.

We’ve crunched the numbers and have gone through thousands of real estate agent profiles to bring you only the true top agents. Search, compare, and hire simply knowing that we have done the work for you. Check out our list of top Chautauqua County real estate agents of 2026.

Frequently Asked Questions

The Bottom Line

Don’t make choosing a real estate agent in Chautauqua County difficult. We know it can seem overwhelming, especially with so many agents in Chautauqua County ready to work with you.

FastExpert makes it simple.

We have the world’s largest database of real estate agents in Chautauqua County. You can browse and view agent profiles with all the information you need to make the best decision. Check out each Chautauqua County agent’s home listings, read verified client reviews, and easily message your perfect Realtor.

When your money and your memories are involved, you need a trusted partner by your side. With a FastExpert real estate agent, you can be confident you’ll get the best service in all of Chautauqua County.

Have questions? We’re here to help! Message us at [email protected] or call (800) 319-0511.