Totally get it — not every lender truly works with first-time buyer programs. The best way is to start with official sources and filter for lenders who are approved for the programs you want. In California, I can point you to CalHFA-approved loan officers, plus I’ll verify they regularly fund FHA, HomeReady/Home Possible, and local down-payment assistance. I’ll also connect you with a HUD-approved housing counselor for unbiased guidance. If you share your price range and city/ZIP, I’ll shortlist a few lenders and make warm introductions
Your quick playbook (California-focused but adaptable anywhere)
Start with your state HFA’s approved list (in CA: CalHFA).
Use CalHFA’s “Find a Loan Officer” and “Approved Lenders” tools. Shortlist loan officers who are active on MyHome/CalPLUS (signals real experience).
CalHFA
+1
Cross-check affordable conventional options (for pricing and income limits).
Fannie Mae HomeReady: verify property income eligibility via the AMI lookup.
Fannie Mae Single-Family
Freddie Mac Home Possible: confirm 80% AMI limit using their eligibility map.
Freddie Mac
+1
Layer in down-payment assistance (DPA) lookups.
Use Down Payment Resource (also embedded in Fannie Mae’s DPA tool) to see city/county programs you can pair with your first mortgage.
Down Payment Resource
+1
If shopping rural or edge-of-town areas, check USDA lenders.
USDA publishes active lenders and even a current “top lenders” PDF by volume (handy proxy for who actually closes these).
Rural Development
+1
Need unbiased guidance first? Add a HUD-approved housing counselor.
Find one via HUD or CFPB’s official locator; they can help compare programs and prep you for lender calls.
HUD Exchange
+1
What to ask a lender (script)
Use this verbatim if you like:
“How many CalHFA / MyHome / CalPLUS loans did your team close in the past 12 months?” (I’m looking for recent, local success.)
CalHFA
+1
“Do you regularly originate HomeReady and Home Possible? Please confirm my income fits the AMI rules for the property area.”
Fannie Mae Single-Family
+1
“Which down-payment or closing-cost assistance programs do you pair most often in [CITY/COUNTY], and what are the typical timelines?”
Down Payment Resource
+1
“If the home is in a USDA-eligible area, are you an active USDA lender?”
Rural Development
Green flags vs. red flags
Green flags
Can name specific local DPA programs and CalHFA options off the top of their head.
CalHFA
+1
Screens your address through AMI/DPA tools during the call.
Fannie Mae Single-Family
+2
Freddie Mac
+2
Explains education certificate steps (often required) and realistic timelines.
Red flags
“We don’t really do those, but we can maybe figure it out.” (Translation: you’ll be their test case.)
Won’t quote program-specific fees/MI or can’t state an exact DPA pairing process.
Tries to steer you away from programs without checking income/location eligibility first.
Common program requirements (set expectations)
Income limits & AMI caps (varies by address/program).
Fannie Mae Single-Family
+1
Homebuyer education certificate for many DPA/HFA loans. (HUD/CFPB counselors can help.)
HUD Exchange
+1
Owner-occupancy and CLTV/LTV caps when stacking assistance (typical with HFA + DPA).
CalHFA
Want me to do the legwork?
Shoot me the target city/ZIP, price range, and household income (roughly), and I’ll:
Pull CalHFA-approved loan officers who actively close these loans,
Verify HomeReady/Home Possible eligibility for the area,
Map available local DPA options, and
Draft a warm intro email from you to the top 2–3 lenders.