INDIANAPOLIS · 2026 RANKINGS

Top Real Estate Agents in Indianapolis, IN (2026)

Compare top-rated local experts, backed by verified sales performance and client reviews.

  • Data-driven
  • No Obligation
  • Direct Messaging
FastExpert 2026 Top Agent in Indianapolis, INIndianapolis, IN

Ranked Real Estate Agents in Indianapolis, IN

Showing 25 of 289 results

289 agents in Indianapolis, IN directory.

Ranked list of real estate agents in Indianapolis, IN
Rank / AgentBrokerageExperienceSales (3 yr)Reviews
Headshot of Mindy Byard, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB18002015
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
9 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$7M
Sales Volume
in Last Year

Price range: $185K-$205K

Specialties: Staging & Home Preparation
Experience
9 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
4
Reviews
30
Headshot of Makayla Henderson, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB24001777
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 19, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
2 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$3.9M
Sales Volume
in Last Year
Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
2 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
4
Reviews
9
Headshot of Joe Vigliano, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB20000312
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 19, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
6 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$1.2M
Sales Volume
in Last Year

Price range: $144.5K-$575K

Specialties: Foreclosure specialist · 
Experience
6 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
4
Reviews
0
Headshot of Nicole Morales, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14045954
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
23 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$6M
Sales Volume
in Last Year

Price range: $220K-$249.9K

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
23 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
2
Reviews
34
Headshot of Karen Neligh, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB15001301
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
11 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$7.1M
Sales Volume
in Last Year

Price range: $155K-$172K

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
11 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
2
Reviews
35
Headshot of Tyson Bontrager, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB16000180
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
10 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$2.7M
Sales Volume
in Last Year

Price range: $135.5K-$220K

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
10 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
2
Reviews
17
Headshot of Noah Barrow, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14046012
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
12 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years

Price range: $200K-$258K

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
12 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
2
Reviews
19
Experience
4 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
2
Reviews
5
Headshot of Stacey Brown, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB21000092
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 18, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
5 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$3M
Sales Volume
in Last Year

Price range: $238K-$420K

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
5 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
2
Reviews
4
Headshot of Caleb Low, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB19001496
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Oct 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
7 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$5M
Sales Volume
in Last Year

Price range: $125K-$600K

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
7 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
2
Reviews
0
Headshot of Tonya Burton, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB21001672
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 19, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
5 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$3.3M
Sales Volume
in Last Year
Service Areas: Indianapolis, IN · 

Price range: $137K-$142K

Specialties: Listing Agent · 
Brokerage
EXP Realty
Experience
5 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
2
Reviews
0
Headshot of Karen Long, real estate agent
Years of Experience
22 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$3.5M
Sales Volume
in Last Year

Price range: $365K

Specialties: First Time Home Buyers · 
Experience
22 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
1
Reviews
1
Headshot of Caolan Hoff, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB17002120
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
9 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years
Sales volume in last year
$569.4K
Sales Volume
in Last Year

Price range: $355K

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
9 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
1
Reviews
3
Experience
6 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
1
Reviews
0
Headshot of Breone Dupree, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14050736
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Oct 17, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
13 yrs
Years of
Experience
Recent sales in last 3 years
Recent Sales
in last 3 Years

Price range: $245K

Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
13 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
1
Reviews
0
Brokerage
Fathom Realty
Experience
22 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
3
Brokerage
Real Broker, LLC
Experience
15 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
40
Headshot of Collin Aber, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB22001431
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 19, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
4 yrs
Years of
Experience
Sales volume in last year
$2.3M
Sales Volume
in Last Year
Specialties: First Time Home Buyers · 
Experience
4 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
4
Headshot of Craig Bartels, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14037801
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
26 yrs
Years of
Experience
Sales volume in last year
$19M
Sales Volume
in Last Year
Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
26 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
11
Experience
14 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
9
Headshot of Rita Fish, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14020620
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
34 yrs
Years of
Experience
Sales volume in last year
$10M
Sales Volume
in Last Year
Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
34 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
4
Headshot of Sarah Riggen, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB14040735
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 19, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
16 yrs
Years of
Experience
Sales volume in last year
$500K
Sales Volume
in Last Year
Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
16 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
38
Brokerage
FC Tucker
Experience
11 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
11
Headshot of Rachel Bradbury, real estate agent
FastExpert VerifiedActive and in good standing
License #
RB18000553
License Type
Broker Individual
Status
Active
Issued
N/A
Expires
06/30/2029

No discipline or board actions on file for this license.

Verified Aug 20, 2026 · Source: IN PLA

Years of Experience
8 yrs
Years of
Experience
Sales volume in last year
$4M
Sales Volume
in Last Year
Specialties: Buyer's Agent · 
Experience
8 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
7
Experience
9 Yrs of Experience
Sales (3 yr)
0
Reviews
20