Home›Advice›Buying›What should I not negotiate when buying a home?
Go Back

What should I not negotiate when buying a home?

What should I not negotiate when buying a home? Are there things that are offensive or would end negotiations?

Asked by Rodrigo | San Diego, CA| 10-17-2023| 541 views|Buying|Updated 3 years ago

While AI use is allowed, don't copy & paste generic answers. Add your own insights and real experience to make your answer personal and helpful.

Sort by:

Expert answers are from licensed real estate professionals with a verified FastExpert profile.

Angela TadevosyanReal Estate Agent2 months ago
Semi-Pro84 Answers

Negotiation is a normal part of buying a home, but how you negotiate matters just as much as what you negotiate. In my experience as a California Realtor, here are a few things buyers should avoid: Making unrealistic low offers without market support. A very low offer can offend a seller and may cause them to reject your offer without making a counteroffer. Requesting repairs for minor cosmetic issues. It's usually better to focus on significant health, safety, or structural concerns identified during the inspection. Asking for everything at once. Requesting a large price reduction, extensive repairs, seller credits, and personal property can make the offer seem unreasonable. Ignoring the seller's priorities. Sometimes a flexible closing date or rent-back agreement is more valuable to the seller than a slightly higher purchase price. Making demands outside the contract. Your Realtor should communicate professionally through the terms of the purchase agreement rather than informal requests that can create confusion. Negotiations should never be based on a person's race, religion, national origin, disability, family status, or any other protected characteristic. The goal isn't to "win" every negotiation—it's to reach an agreement that works for both parties. A respectful, well-supported negotiation often leads to a smoother transaction and a better chance of getting your offer accepted.

Find Agent CTA

Are you ready to find a top agent near you?

Browse profiles of the highest ranked agents in your area and find one that meets your specific needs.

Zoltan PeresztegiReal Estate Agent3 months ago

Hi Rodrigo, do not nickel and dime is the right instinct, and here is the specific list behind it. These are the moves that sour sellers or kill deals outright: - Cosmetic items discovered at the inspection. Scuffed paint, worn carpet, an older but working water heater. The inspection is for surprises about condition and safety, not a second bite at the price for things you could see at the showing. Sellers read cosmetic repair requests as bad faith, and it poisons the rest of the escrow. - Small-dollar items in general. Fighting over a few hundred dollars on a transaction this size costs you goodwill you may badly need later when you ask for something that matters. - The seller's personal property as a demand. Asking nicely whether the patio set is available is fine. Making the washer and dryer a sticking point in a competitive situation is not. - Re-opening agreed terms late in escrow without a new reason. Nothing erodes trust faster. If nothing changed, your ask should not change. - Lowballing and then improving in tiny increments. Some sellers will simply stop responding and take the next offer. If you want the house, open respectably. Now, where you SHOULD spend your negotiating capital: genuine health and safety findings, roof, foundation, plumbing, electrical, sewer line, and anything expensive you could not have known before inspection. On those, ask confidently, and credits are often cleaner than repairs because you control the work afterward. One more: do not negotiate away protections to look tough on price. Keeping your inspection and appraisal contingencies is usually worth more than the last few thousand dollars. I am a real estate professional working Los Angeles and the South Bay. For San Diego I am glad to connect you with an excellent local agent from my network who negotiates this way every week. Zoltan

Keith Jean PierreReal Estate Agent5 months ago

In this competitive market, only negotiate the major and habitable items. Nickle and diming the seller will almost certainly terminate a deal. Keith Jean-Pierre Managing Principal The Dapper Agents Real Estate Operations in ALL 50 States

Amanda CourtneyReal Estate Agent8 months ago

Don't sweat the small stuff—it kills deals. Never negotiate cosmetic flaws (like ugly paint or carpet) or personal property (furniture and curtains). You saw those when you made the offer, and nitpicking them makes you look difficult. Most importantly, if you are buying "As-Is," do not ask for credits on systems that are simply old. The inspection is for finding broken things (like a leak), not for getting a free upgrade on a working 15-year-old AC unit.

GIOVANNA ROSEReal Estate Agent2 years ago
Novice2 Answers

Hi Carlos! Everything is negotiable when buying a house. Some sellers state "as is" however it never hurts to ask.

Nicole ParkerReal Estate Agent3 years ago
Rising Star17 Answers

Your Realtor should be able to advise you on the current market conditions, and whether a lower offer is acceptable or not. That being said, some things to consider when putting in an offer are whether or not the items that you would need to pass a 4pt inspection are in good working order. Those items are the roof, plumbing, electrical and HVAC. If these items are older and would potentially prevent you from obtaining homeowners insurance, due to the age and/or condition of them I would consider putting an offer to offset those costs.

Related Questions

What should I check for liens and title problems before buying my first rental?

Asked by Anonymous | Lakeland, FL | 12 views | Buying | 10-23-2026 | Updated 3 days ago

Can I buy tow house

Asked by James Stewart | Los Angeles, CA | 12 views | Buying | 10-22-2026 | Updated 3 days ago

Does a verbal agreement with a buyer actually mean anything once it's time to sign?

Asked by Anonymous | Providence, RI | 18 views | Buying | 10-22-2026 | Updated 3 days ago

Will a lender even approve us for a 15 year mortgage at our age?

Asked by Anonymous | Peoria, IL | 18 views | Buying | 10-22-2026 | Updated 3 days ago