Yes, that's a completely reasonable ask — pet damage beyond normal wear and tear is fair game in a repair request or credit negotiation, and cat urine in carpet padding is one of those things that's expensive enough (often full carpet + pad replacement, sometimes subfloor treatment if it's soaked through) that sellers usually understand why you're asking. A few tips on how to actually get this handled well: - Get a specific, itemized estimate from a flooring contractor rather than asking for a vague dollar amount — 'replace carpet in bedrooms 2 and 3, treat subfloor, $X' gets taken more seriously than 'give us money for the damage.' - Decide whether you want a credit at closing or an actual repair before close — credits are usually cleaner since you control the contractor and timeline, but ask your agent what's more common with this particular seller/agent based on how the rest of the negotiation has gone. - Don't bundle this into a huge laundry list with every minor inspection item — isolate the pet damage as its own clear ask so it doesn't get lost or used as a bargaining chip against smaller things. - If the smell is bad enough that it might indicate subfloor saturation, get that checked specifically — sometimes what looks like 'just carpet' turns into subfloor replacement, and that's worth knowing before you finalize the number. Bottom line: this isn't an unreasonable request at all, just make sure the number you're asking for is backed by an actual quote, not a guess.


