Home›Advice›Buying›agent didn’t have me sign an agreement prior to showing ?
Go Back

agent didn’t have me sign an agreement prior to showing ?

My agent did not have us sign an agreement prior to showing us houses. We found a house and verbally made an offer. When he wrote up the offer he didn’t tell us that the selling agent had agreed to a 4% commission. He sent us the contract electronically with 1% of closing over the price we verbally agreed on and told us we would get the money back at closing. Not true. Are we stuck paying his fee now ?

Asked by Robert Nichols | Pass Christian, MS| 05-28-2025| 2,199 views|Buying|Updated 1 year ago

While AI use is allowed, don't copy & paste generic answers. Add your own insights and real experience to make your answer personal and helpful.

Sort by:

Expert answers are from licensed real estate professionals with a verified FastExpert profile.

Zoltan PeresztegiReal Estate Agent3 months ago

Hi Robert, the thread has covered the missing paperwork, but I think you are actually dealing with two separate problems and they are getting blended together. Pull them apart and the answer gets a lot clearer. Here is the claim I will commit to: an agent's fiduciary duty means every material term, especially anything that changes what you pay or what the seller nets, has to be explained to you before you are asked to sign, not delivered by being buried in a document that shows up in your inbox. Disclosure by document is not the same thing as disclosure by conversation, and the second one is the duty. Problem one is the missing buyer agreement. Since August 17, 2024, under the NAR practice changes that bind MLS Participants, an agent working with a buyer is supposed to enter into a written buyer agreement before touring a home, and that agreement has to include a specific and conspicuous disclosure of the compensation the agent will receive or how it will be determined. Touring you through houses with nothing signed is not a small clerical slip. It skipped the exact document that was designed to tell you the number you are now discovering the hard way. Problem two is the bigger one, and it is the part I would focus on. Since that same date, offers of compensation are no longer published on the MLS. Compensation is negotiated between you and your own agent in your buyer agreement, and separately it can be requested from the seller as a concession written into your offer. Those are two different conversations, and both of them belonged to you. NAR's own consumer guidance says plainly that compensation is not set by law and is fully negotiable. So the moment your agent learned what the listing side was prepared to do, that was a phone call to you, not a line item. I am deliberately not going to tell you whether 4 percent is reasonable or what the 1 percent figure means, because your question is cut off mid-sentence and I cannot see what that number attaches to. Anyone in this thread telling you it is fine or telling you it is outrageous is guessing. What I would actually do, in order. Do not sign anything else until it is explained. Send your agent a written request, email so it is dated, asking for a plain-English breakdown of every dollar that moves in this transaction and who pays it. Ask for copies of every form you have signed and every form he has signed on your behalf. Say clearly that the amounts are negotiable and that you want to renegotiate before you sign. If the answer is vague, go to his brokerage's managing broker, who supervises him and can fix it. If that goes nowhere and you believe there was a license law violation, your state real estate licensing commission takes consumer complaints. If he is a REALTOR member, his local REALTOR association handles ethics complaints separately. One note for anyone reading this later: you asked in May 2025, and compensation practice has kept moving since then, so verify the current forms with your own agent. I am a real estate professional, not an attorney, so if real money is on the line here, an hour with a real estate attorney in your state is worth it. I am Zoltan Peresztegi, a Los Angeles and South Bay real estate professional serving the Palos Verdes Peninsula and the surrounding beach cities. Your location is not listed, so if you are outside my area and want a second agent to review the paperwork with you, I am glad to refer you to someone solid in your market. Zoltan

Find Agent CTA

Are you ready to find a top agent near you?

Browse profiles of the highest ranked agents in your area and find one that meets your specific needs.

Juan PicosReal Estate Agent5 months ago

Probably **not**, but it depends on what you signed. * If you **never signed a buyer representation agreement** or any document agreeing to pay your agent compensation, it may be difficult for the agent to require you to pay an additional fee. * Review the purchase offer and any disclosures carefully. There may be language regarding buyer-agent compensation. * If the agent increased the purchase price by 1% and represented that you would "get it back at closing," that should have been clearly explained in writing before you signed. * Ask for a complete accounting of how the compensation was structured and where the money is going. If you have not closed yet, speak with your closing attorney, title company, or your agent's managing broker immediately and ask them to explain: 1. What compensation the seller is paying. 2. What compensation, if any, you agreed to pay. 3. Which documents create that obligation. A buyer should never be surprised by an agent's compensation at the contract stage. If the fee arrangement was not properly disclosed, raise the issue with the broker as soon as possible.

Loodmy JacquesReal Estate Agent6 months ago

No, you’re not automatically stuck, but it depends on what you signed. If you never signed a buyer agreement or any written compensation agreement, your agent may have a hard time forcing you to pay a fee. But if the purchase contract or another document you signed says you agreed to pay that extra 1%, then that can become enforceable. The bigger issue here is disclosure. If the numbers were changed or presented in a way you didn’t clearly understand, that’s a red flag. My move? Stop signing anything else, get copies of every document, and call the agent’s broker today. The paperwork will tell you whether you owe anything, not the agent’s opinion.

Keith Jean PierreReal Estate Agent7 months ago

If an agreement was not signed, typically it cannot be enforced. Now if you signed an agreement with that contract, these you are in murky waters and it can get tricky. Consult an attorney to see your options as none of us in here can give legal advice. Keith Jean-Pierre Managing Principal The Dapper Agents Operations In: NY, NJ, FL & CA

Kevin NeelyReal Estate Agent7 months ago

This is a common question among Florida buyers and sellers, and the answer depends on your specific situation and local market conditions. Understanding the fundamentals before making any decisions protects your investment and your timeline. In Lecanto, Citrus County, Florida, the real estate landscape has its own characteristics that affect how this plays out in practice. The Citrus County market attracts a diverse buyer pool including relocators from higher-cost states, retirees, and local move-up buyers, which creates consistent demand across most price points and property types. The strategic approach is to work with a local agent who can pull current comparable sales data and walk you through the specific factors that apply to your situation in Florida. Every market is different at the neighborhood level, and decisions based on general advice or national headlines often miss the local nuances that matter most to your outcome. Making informed decisions based on local data is always the strongest position. Kevin Neely & Kaitlynd Robbins | K2 Sells, Keller Williams Elite Partners

Jason CraigReal Estate Agent1 year ago

I'm not a lawyer, but here's how commissions usually work. Buyer's agents are typically paid out of the commission that the seller offers through the listing broker. You only become personally responsible for paying an agent if you sign a **buyer‑broker agreement** that spells out a retainer or success fee. In fact, many buyer agency contracts are exclusive and last for a set term (often around 90 days), and they specify exactly how the agent will be compensated. In your case it sounds like you never signed a buyer‑agent agreement before touring homes. If you don't have a written contract obligating you to pay, then you're generally **not required to pay your agent's commission out of pocket**. That fee should come from the commission offered by the listing broker, and it should have been disclosed to you before the offer was written. If the agent inserted a 1% fee into the contract without your consent, you have every right to push back. Reach out to the agent's **broker in charge** and explain what happened. Brokers oversee their agents and can remove or reduce a commission clause that wasn't agreed to. If you did sign an offer or buyer‑broker agreement with a commission clause, the broker may be able to release you from it. Under the new rules rolled out in 2024‑2025, buyer‑agent compensation must be negotiated and put in writing before any showings, so there should be no surprises. If the broker will not resolve the issue, consult a real‑estate attorney or file a complaint with your state real estate commission. Going forward, insist on reviewing and signing a written buyer‑representation agreement that clearly states how your agent will be paid before you look at homes, so there are no misunderstandings.

Amanda CourtneyReal Estate Agent1 year ago

That is okay. In Florida, some agents show homes first to build rapport. Before making offers, your agent should present a buyer’s broker agreement outlining representation and compensation terms.

Julianne ClarkReal Estate Agent1 year ago

Before you get involved with a real estate lawyer and their expense -- contact "your agents" broker in charge and explain the situation. A resolution may be easier than it appears. The broker in charge is responsible for the agent and will help resolve your concerns.

Irina RileyReal Estate Agent1 year ago
Novice1 Answer

Hi, I am sorry that you are in this situation right now. I strongly suggest to consult with a real estate lawyer. He/she will guide you through the process and answer your questions. Good luck!

Related Questions

Is getting my house key from a lockbox code after closing normal?

Asked by Anonymous | Allentown, PA | 9 views | Buying | 11-20-2026 | Updated 1 day ago

I'm scared to buy my first home

Asked by Hailey | Everett, WA | 16 views | Buying | 11-18-2026 | Updated 2 days ago

Is 1 offer out of 4 showings actually normal right now?

Asked by Anonymous | Toledo, OH | 14 views | Buying | 11-19-2026 | Updated 2 days ago

Is my buyer's agreement still valid if my agent switched brokerages?

Asked by Anonymous | Reno, NV | 6 views | Buying | 11-19-2026 | Updated 2 days ago

How do I verify that a property isn't a scam?

Asked by Amber | Lexington, KY | 14 views | Buying | 11-18-2026 | Updated 3 days ago