Home›Advice›Buying›Is 1 offer out of 4 showings actually normal right now?
Go Back

Is 1 offer out of 4 showings actually normal right now?

We listed our house for $300k a few days ago and already had 4 showings plus one offer, they found $7k of wiggle room after we pushed back and we're about $5k apart now. The other showings liked it but passed. Is 1 offer this early actually a good sign, or should we hold out for more?

Asked by Devon R. | Toledo, OH| 11-19-2026| 12 views|Buying|Updated 1 day ago

While AI use is allowed, don't copy & paste generic answers. Add your own insights and real experience to make your answer personal and helpful.

Sort by:

Expert answers are from licensed real estate professionals with a verified FastExpert profile.

Zoltan PeresztegiReal Estate Agent8 hours ago

Devon, one offer after four showings in the first few days is a healthy start, and the number to negotiate is your net, not the last $5,000. Two offers at the same price can leave you thousands apart once seller paid closing costs, buyer agent compensation and repair requests are counted. Jonathan and Alla covered the timing and the terms well. Before you decide on that gap, I would check three things: - Ask your agent for a net sheet on this offer. If the buyer is asking you to cover closing costs or their agent's compensation, that matters as much as the price gap, and it is often an easier thing to trade. - Have your agent call the buyer's lender. A short conversation confirms the pre approval is real and that the buyer can close on the timeline in the offer. - Think about the appraisal, which Jonathan touched on. If the buyer is financing and the price is already at the top of the recent sales, a low appraisal can reopen the negotiation anyway, so a few thousand dollars above the comps may never reach your pocket. If those check out, a counter near the middle with a short response deadline keeps the momentum. Since the other buyers passed, holding out mostly means waiting for a buyer who has not seen the house yet. I am Zoltan Peresztegi and I work in Palos Verdes and the South Bay of Los Angeles, so lean on your Toledo agent for the local comps, and I am happy to point you toward another strong Toledo agent if you ever want a second opinion. Zoltan

Find Agent CTA

Are you ready to find a top agent near you?

Browse profiles of the highest ranked agents in your area and find one that meets your specific needs.

Jonathan ClaudioReal Estate Agent1 day ago

Yes! Honestly, I would consider one offer after just four showings in the first few days a positive sign. It means someone has seen enough value in the property to put an offer together, and you're already negotiating. I wouldn't automatically assume you need to accept it, but I also wouldn't dismiss it thinking something better is guaranteed to come along. The fact that the buyer came up $7,000 after you pushed back shows they're willing to negotiate, which is encouraging. One thing I would look at is how your $300K asking price compares to recently closed sales, how much competition you have nearby, and whether those other showings are likely to turn into second showings. The November market is showing slower buyer activity nationally, so having an interested buyer this early is encouraging. National Association of REALTORS®+1 My advice would be to counter that remaining $5K if the numbers make sense, but keep the conversation moving. Don't negotiate yourself out of a good deal chasing a hypothetical better one. At the same time, if you're comfortable waiting and your home is priced competitively, you can give the other interested buyers a little more time. Remember, the highest offer isn't always the best offer either. Financing, contingencies, appraisal, and closing timeline matter just as much. I'd rather see you negotiate a strong, clean offer than lose a qualified buyer over $5K.

Alla NovytskaReal Estate Agent1 day ago

One offer out of four showings in your first few days is a good sign, Devon, not a weak one. A buyer who already came up $7k wants this house. My license is in California rather than Ohio, so lean on your Toledo agent for the local comps, but here's how I'd weigh the last $5k. Put it next to what one more month of owning the place costs you, and remember a new listing usually gets its strongest traffic early. Waiting has a price too. Then look past the number. A buyer with solid financing and a timeline that works for you can be worth more than one who pays a bit more and falls apart before closing. If the gap is all that's left, meeting near the middle or trading the last bit of price for terms you care about is usually how these get done. Alla Novytska, Realtor®, JohnHart Real Estate, DRE #02254775

Jessica ArledgeReal Estate Agent1 day ago
Novice1 Answer

That is a great sign and honestly people often shoot themselves in the foot holding out for more when your first offers are often your best! I don't know your specific market and can only speak to what is happening here in Georgia, but if the offer is in the range you originally wanted to be in and in line with the comps I would take it and focus on your next steps!

Related Questions

Is getting my house key from a lockbox code after closing normal?

Asked by Anonymous | Allentown, PA | 7 views | Buying | 11-20-2026 | Updated 14 hours ago

I'm scared to buy my first home

Asked by Hailey | Everett, WA | 12 views | Buying | 11-18-2026 | Updated 1 day ago

Is my buyer's agreement still valid if my agent switched brokerages?

Asked by Anonymous | Reno, NV | 5 views | Buying | 11-19-2026 | Updated 1 day ago

How do I verify that a property isn't a scam?

Asked by Amber | Lexington, KY | 11 views | Buying | 11-18-2026 | Updated 2 days ago

Is Prime Lending a solid choice as a builder's preferred lender?

Asked by Anonymous | Spokane, WA | 15 views | Buying | 11-17-2026 | Updated 3 days ago