Devon, one offer after four showings in the first few days is a healthy start, and the number to negotiate is your net, not the last $5,000. Two offers at the same price can leave you thousands apart once seller paid closing costs, buyer agent compensation and repair requests are counted. Jonathan and Alla covered the timing and the terms well. Before you decide on that gap, I would check three things: - Ask your agent for a net sheet on this offer. If the buyer is asking you to cover closing costs or their agent's compensation, that matters as much as the price gap, and it is often an easier thing to trade. - Have your agent call the buyer's lender. A short conversation confirms the pre approval is real and that the buyer can close on the timeline in the offer. - Think about the appraisal, which Jonathan touched on. If the buyer is financing and the price is already at the top of the recent sales, a low appraisal can reopen the negotiation anyway, so a few thousand dollars above the comps may never reach your pocket. If those check out, a counter near the middle with a short response deadline keeps the momentum. Since the other buyers passed, holding out mostly means waiting for a buyer who has not seen the house yet. I am Zoltan Peresztegi and I work in Palos Verdes and the South Bay of Los Angeles, so lean on your Toledo agent for the local comps, and I am happy to point you toward another strong Toledo agent if you ever want a second opinion. Zoltan


