Home›Advice›Buying›Seller Never Satisfied The Repairs?
Go Back

Seller Never Satisfied The Repairs?

I fell in love with a house in April 2024 and never imagined I'd be in a position where I still haven't closed by June 21, 2024. My agreement of sale (AOS) was signed on April 9. My original close date was May 10, 2024. A few days before closing I was notified there were 3 outstanding permits with our city's L&I department and the property was in violation. We added an addendum to the agreement of sale stating the seller would address all repairs required by the city before closing and we rescheduled the closing date. All parties signed. Since that time, I have had closings set for May 30, June 6, June 13, and June 20 - Change in Terms agreements (CTAs) were in place for each of these new closing dates and the Seller has yet to complete the repairs according to the city's satisfaction. The city has re-inspected the property twice. I decided to pursue an escrow agreement with the Seller so we could close with funds set aside for the repairs. They promised to review it but took 1 full week to do so. I had additional redlines to their response and my attorney and I sent a new escrow proposal on June 19. My agent told me on 6/20/24 that the Seller was reaching out to the city to get more clarification on the date of final inspection for the repairs. That was over 24 hours ago and I've had no update from anyone (despite following up). The CTA for the AOS expired on June 20 at 11:59pm with all of the above in limbo. Since I haven't heard from anyone, what are my next steps? I hope to speak with my attorney this afternoon. Does anyone have experience with a transaction like this? I have been ready to move forward since May 10. I feel blindsided by these repairs and further blindsided by the fact that the seller is not making them in a timely fashion. It scares me that they are doing work and yet not passing inspections. Also, I've had to extend my rental agreement to have a place to live while all of these repairs occur. I've scheduled and rescheduled movers, cleaning crews, and handymen. I've changed insurance companies in preparation for the move (for a good home/auto rate vs. what I was paying as a renter). And I've been scheduling time off from work for the closing and the move, which ultimately has not yet happened. I am so frustrated and I am going into my 4th month of dealing with this. Now that the agreement of sale has expired, what are my options (if any)? Do I walk away and leave my earnest money deposit on the table? Or, do I decide to pursue a lawsuit for the Seller's negligence/breach of contract? This has cost me so much, not to mention several interest rate extensions to maintain my current interest rate with my lender. Those extensions also come at a cost. Thanks in advance for the insight.

Asked by Morgan Wade | Philadelphia, FL| 06-21-2024| 561 views|Buying|Updated 2 years ago

While AI use is allowed, don't copy & paste generic answers. Add your own insights and real experience to make your answer personal and helpful.

Sort by:

Expert answers are from licensed real estate professionals with a verified FastExpert profile.

Zoltan PeresztegiReal Estate Agent3 months ago

Morgan, the tool that unsticks a deal like yours is an escrow holdback, and I would put it on the table in the next conversation rather than agreeing to a fifth closing date. Here is how it works. Instead of waiting for the seller to complete the repairs before closing, you close now, and the title company holds back a sum of the seller's proceeds, typically one and a half to two times the estimated cost of the work, in escrow. The seller gets that money only when the work is done and the permits are closed out. If they never do it, the money is released to you and you hire the contractor yourself. It flips the incentive completely. Right now the seller has no reason to hurry, because you keep granting extensions and they keep getting paid eventually. A holdback makes delay expensive for them instead of for you. Two things to check before you propose it. Your lender has to approve a holdback, and some will not allow one where the issue affects habitability or the certificate of occupancy. And the title company has to be willing to administer it. Ask both this week. The rest of what I would do, in order. Understand what you are actually dealing with, because open L&I permits and violations are not a repair problem, they are a title and compliance problem. They attach to the property, and if you close with them open, they become yours. In Philadelphia those can affect the certificate of occupancy, they can block future permits, and they can create a lien exposure. Ask your title company directly whether they will insure over them, and get the answer in writing. That answer may decide everything. Read your agreement of sale for two specific things, with an attorney. Is time of the essence, and what does the default section entitle you to? Those two clauses determine whether you currently have a right to declare the seller in default, and what happens to your deposit if you do. Know your remedy menu, because you have more than two options. Terminate and get your earnest money back is the obvious one and it is the one everybody mentions. But if you still want this house, ask your attorney about specific performance, meaning asking a court to compel the seller to complete the sale. Real estate gets this remedy where most contracts do not, because land is treated as unique. Even the credible threat of it changes the conversation with a stalling seller. Stop signing open-ended extensions. If you sign another change in terms agreement, put teeth in it. Ask for a per diem credit for every day past the new date, a hard outside date after which the deal terminates automatically with your deposit returned, and the holdback provision. A seller who will not agree to any consequence for further delay is telling you something important about whether they intend to perform. Document your damages. Rate lock extension fees, temporary housing, storage, moving costs you have already incurred. If this ends up in a dispute, that list is the case. And ask the honest question: is the seller stalling, or can they not afford the repairs? Those look identical from your side and they lead to different strategies. If it is money, a price reduction that lets you do the work yourself may close this faster than any deadline. Your agent can often find that out with one direct conversation with the listing agent. I am a real estate professional, not an attorney, and this one genuinely needs a Pennsylvania real estate attorney rather than a forum. Four missed closings with open code violations is past the point where advice is sufficient. You need someone who can read the actual agreement of sale and the addendum and tell you what your rights are today. One acknowledgment: you asked this in June 2024 and it is now 2026, so I expect this resolved one way or another long ago. I am answering it fully anyway because people land on this question in the same situation, and the holdback is the piece almost nobody knows to ask for. Philadelphia is not my market, I am Zoltan Peresztegi, and I work Los Angeles and the South Bay. If you are still in it or ever in a similar spot, that is my honest read. Zoltan

Find Agent CTA

Are you ready to find a top agent near you?

Browse profiles of the highest ranked agents in your area and find one that meets your specific needs.

Loodmy JacquesReal Estate Agent6 months ago

This is beyond normal real estate frustration. If the seller agreed in writing to satisfy city-required repairs before closing and still hasn’t done it, your attorney needs to review whether they’re in breach and whether the contract is still alive after the latest extension expired. I would not assume you lose your earnest money just because you’re fed up. If the seller failed to meet signed repair obligations, you may have grounds to terminate and demand your deposit back, or push for another written extension with very specific deadlines, escrow terms, and consequences. I’d also be very cautious about closing until the city issues approval or the escrow agreement is airtight. The fact that repairs are being done but still not passing inspection is a red flag. Don’t threaten lawsuits through the agents. Let your attorney handle it now. Ask them directly: “Can I terminate and recover my deposit, can we force performance, or should we extend only with strict written terms?”

Keith Jean PierreReal Estate Agent6 months ago

Highly suggest speaking to a real estate attorney regarding this matter as there are way too many factors at play here for a simple answer. Best of luck! Keith Jean-Pierre Managing Principal The Dapper Agents Operations In: NY, NJ, FL & CA

Kevin NeelyReal Estate Agent7 months ago

If a seller agreed in writing to complete specific repairs as a condition of the contract and those repairs were not completed before closing, the buyer has several options depending on the contract language and how close you are to the closing date. Most Florida Realtors contracts include provisions that address seller failure to perform agreed repairs, and the resolution depends on whether you have already closed or are still in the pre-closing window. In Floral City, Citrus County, Florida, older homes and rural properties often have inspection lists that include septic systems, well water quality, roof conditions, and aging electrical panels, and repair agreements on these items are common. If the agreed repairs were not completed and you closed anyway without reserving rights, your recourse becomes significantly more complicated after the fact. If you are still pre-closing, you may have the right to terminate the contract, extend the closing date to allow repairs to be completed, or negotiate a price reduction or credit in lieu of repairs. If you have already closed, consult a Florida real estate attorney to evaluate whether the seller failure constitutes a breach of contract. Keep all written repair agreements, inspection reports, and communications as evidence. A real estate attorney is the right professional to consult when a seller fails to perform agreed contractual obligations. Kevin Neely & Kaitlynd Robbins | K2 Sells

Amanda CourtneyReal Estate Agent1 year ago

If the seller didn’t complete agreed-upon repairs, review your contract first. You may have rights to request proof, negotiate credit at closing, or delay the closing until work is done. Your Realtor can help ensure proper documentation and coordinate inspections to verify completion.

Lisa And Greg HarrisReal Estate Agent2 years ago

THIS IS AN ATTORNEY QUESTION! I highly recommend you consult a reliable Real estate attorney, outside of the closing attorney you have used to this point!

Related Questions

Is Prime Lending a solid choice as a builder's preferred lender?

Asked by Anonymous | Spokane, WA | 9 views | Buying | 11-17-2026 | Updated 18 hours ago

Is there a way to verify when work was done as a buyer?

Asked by Trent H | Iowa City, IA | 19 views | Buying | 11-16-2026 | Updated 1 day ago

How long should title take to clear when the seller is in bankruptcy?

Asked by Anonymous | Columbia, SC | 15 views | Buying | 11-16-2026 | Updated 1 day ago

How do I make an offer on a FSBO house with a Section 8 tenant and no asking price?

Asked by Anonymous | Calumet City, IL | 24 views | Buying | 11-13-2026 | Updated 4 days ago

Will a lender approve a HELOC on a house I'm planning to list soon?

Asked by Anonymous | Norfolk, VA | 23 views | Buying | 11-13-2026 | Updated 4 days ago