Do I have to make all the repairs and staging updates my agent recommends?
We are getting ready to sell our older home and our agent gave us a massive checklist of things to update, including painting cabinets and replacing carpets. We are on a tight timeline and a strict budget before we move out of state. How do I work with my agent to prioritize which fixes are actually necessary to sell the home versus what is just nice to have?
Asked by Juan | Iowa City, IA| 05-05-2026| 7 views|Selling|Updated 11 hours ago
Juan, you do not "need" to do all the repairs suggested, but the more move in condition and "HGTV" style the home is, the quicker it will sell. Alternatives to what you mentioned in your question would be painting the problem areas, steaming the carpets if they aren't too bad and virtual staging. Please note that these are not the ideal solutions if the agent has recommended with validity to do the previously requested. Put yourself in the buyers shoes, how would you feel walking into your house in its current state?
Keith Jean-Pierre
Managing Principal
The Dapper Agents
Operations In: NY, NJ, FL & CA
Ask your agent one question for every item on that list: will this affect my sale price or my ability to close, or is it just cosmetic?
Anything that could fail an inspection or trigger a lender requirement is non-negotiable. Structural issues, roof problems, electrical, plumbing — those get addressed. Buyers can request repairs, and lenders can require them depending on the loan type.
Everything else is a judgment call based on your market. Carpet and cabinet paint are cosmetic. In some markets they move the needle. In others, a buyer is going to update them anyway and doesn't care. Your agent should know which category your market falls into, and if they can't tell you the expected return on a specific update, that's worth pushing back on. Frankly, I've had a buyer state that they were going to change 3-week-old carpet on a house where we were putting in an offer!
A price reduction is also a legitimate alternative to spending money on updates. Sometimes it's cleaner to price accordingly and let the buyer decide what they want to change.
Go back to your agent with your budget and timeline clearly stated. A good agent will help you spend where it matters and skip what doesn't.
Great question Juan. Regarding the full list of items recommended to repair, I would consider only the most important items from the list that prevent buyers in your area from writing an offer. For example, many times upgrades in the kitchens and bathrooms fair better vs updating something that is outdated, or has deferred maintenance in a bonus room or hallway. I would also work with your agent regarding your strict budget, and timeline and come up with a plan based on those restrictions to bring the highest ROI for the given factors. From there, I would verify what items most common items that are causing homes nearby not to sell, or that cause nearby homes to sell at a massive discount to prioritize those items first. Items that commonly pay off the best is servicing systems in the home, roof cleaning, painting and floors in the case that their is damaged carpet or hardwoods.