Home›Advice›Selling›Should we sell our money-losing duplex or refi and fix it up?
Go Back

Should we sell our money-losing duplex or refi and fix it up?

We bought a Milwaukee duplex for $315k a couple years ago while living in CA, it rents for $3,300 but nets $2,900 after the PM, and our payment is $2,500. Its an 1880s place that keeps needing work, already spent $12k on repairs. Should we just sell, or does a cash-out refi to rehab it actually make more sense?

Asked by Simone T. | Oakland, CA| 11-17-2026| 14 views|Selling|Updated 1 day ago

While AI use is allowed, don't copy & paste generic answers. Add your own insights and real experience to make your answer personal and helpful.

Sort by:

Expert answers are from licensed real estate professionals with a verified FastExpert profile.

Alla NovytskaReal Estate Agent16 hours ago

Simone, start with the $400 a month you keep after the mortgage and the property manager. The $12k you've already spent equals about 30 months of that, and an 1880s house rarely goes 30 months without another surprise. So I'd judge the refi on the next ten years, not the last two. A cash-out refi only makes sense if the rehab fixes what keeps breaking or lets you raise the rent enough to cover the bigger payment. Have a contractor bid the big-ticket items first, especially anything involving the plumbing or the roof, and see if the numbers still work. Then compare that with selling. Ask a Milwaukee agent for an as-is value, subtract your payoff and selling costs, and look at what you'd actually walk away with. Loop in a CPA too, since selling a rental can come with a tax bill. Managing an old building from Oakland wears on people, and that counts even if it's not on the spreadsheet. Alla Novytska, Realtor®, JohnHart Real Estate, DRE #02254775

Find Agent CTA

Are you ready to find a top agent near you?

Browse profiles of the highest ranked agents in your area and find one that meets your specific needs.

Vicky KustovReal Estate Agent19 hours ago
Novice7 Answers

Hi Simone, This is a very important question and there are many options to consider. The best way to figure this out is to speak with a financial advisor or tax prepare and have them advise you based on your financial situation. I do recommend that you get the current market valuation for your property (which a local realtor can help you with), get your financial details for the property (income and expenses), and you may want to have your last year's tax return so they have a complete financial picture in order to provide you with the best advice. Most financial advisors offer a free consultation and should be able to help. Vicky Kustov, Realtor Elite Realty Experts, LLC Burlington, MA

Rick FullerReal Estate Agent19 hours ago
Semi-Pro31 Answers

Hi Simone, I would be careful about putting more money into this property before stepping back and looking at the bigger financial picture. The fact that it is a duplex doesn't automatically make it a good investment, and sometimes holding onto a property simply because you've already invested money in it can lead to throwing good money after bad. The first thing I'd want to understand is the property's true cash flow. You're collecting $3,300 in rent, but after property management, you're down to $2,900. With a $2,500 mortgage payment, that leaves only $400 per month before accounting for maintenance, vacancy, property taxes (if not included in the payment), insurance, capital improvements, and unexpected repairs. On an 1880s property, those expenses can add up quickly. A cash-out refinance is worth considering only if the improvements will meaningfully increase the property's rental income, reduce ongoing maintenance, and create a positive return on the additional debt. Otherwise, you're potentially borrowing more money against a property that is already struggling to perform. I'd compare three things before making the decision: 1. Sell as-is: Get a realistic market value, estimate selling expenses, calculate your remaining mortgage payoff, and determine how much cash you'd walk away with. 2. Rehab and hold: Get a detailed contractor estimate, identify which repairs are necessary versus cosmetic, and determine what the property could realistically rent for after improvements. 3. Refinance: Compare the new interest rate, monthly payment, closing costs, and total borrowing against the additional income the improvements would generate. I'd also consider the fact that you're managing this property from California. Distance, property management fees, and the age of the building all add another layer of risk. The Milwaukee market has continued to show rental demand, but that doesn't necessarily mean this particular property is a good investment. My biggest advice: Don't let the $12,000 you've already spent dictate your next decision. That money is gone. The question is whether investing another dollar into this property makes sense compared with what else you could do with that money. Sometimes the best investment decision is knowing when to exit and redeploy your equity into an asset that better fits your financial goals. There are plenty of real estate options that can still help you to reach your financial goals. I'd want to know three more things before making a recommendation: What's the property's current estimated market value, how much do you owe on the mortgage, and what would the contractor estimate be to address the major issues?

Amber JohnsonReal Estate Agent20 hours ago

I would compare three forward-looking scenarios instead of focusing on what you originally paid or have already spent. First, ask a Milwaukee agent for a current value and a seller net sheet. Second, have a contractor prepare a written scope and cost for the proposed rehabilitation. Third, get actual refinance terms showing the new payment, closing costs, required reserves, and expected value after the work. Your current $400 monthly spread is before vacancy, major repairs, and future capital items. On an 1880s duplex, that is a thin cushion. A cash-out refinance only helps if the improvements are likely to produce enough additional rent or value to support the larger loan and leave a healthy reserve. If the property remains negative after realistic vacancy, maintenance, management, and capital reserves, selling may be the cleaner choice. If the rehabilitation creates strong, documented cash flow, keeping it may be reasonable. Related Pillar article: Should You Rent Out or Sell Your House? Amber Johnson, Founder Pillar Real Estate 805.835.3425 [email protected] 1345 Park St. Paso Robles, CA 93446 DRE# 01925434

Shayla TwitReal Estate Agent20 hours ago
Semi-Pro44 Answers

FIRST find out what it's worth right now. And if it's worth cutting your losses by selling. Depending upon what you owe, would you need to bring $$ to the table to close? And is that cost worth it to you to move on or not. Do you need write offs? If so keeping it and waiting may behoove you. I need more info to truly be able to answer this in the best way possible. I'd say seek out a local agent first. Go over the numbers with him/her and decide if your market can garner a higher price, a break even or a loss. Go from there.

Joe FoxxReal Estate Agent21 hours ago
Semi-Pro59 Answers

Honestly, I'd start by running the real numbers, not just rent minus the mortgage. You're netting about $400 a month after the PM and the payment, but you've already put $12k into repairs in a couple of years. Spread that out and you're pretty much breaking even, maybe a little underwater, on a building that's almost 150 years old and will keep asking for money. A cash-out refi only makes sense if the rehab actually fixes the problem. If the money goes into the big-ticket stuff (roof, electrical, plumbing, foundation) and that cuts your repair bills way down or lets you raise rents, it can pencil out. If it just covers the next round of patches, you've turned equity into a bigger loan payment and you still have an old building eating your cash. Before you decide, I'd have a local contractor or inspector walk it and give you a rough list of what's coming in the next five years and what it'll cost. Then compare that to what you'd walk away with if you sold today, after commissions and closing costs. One more option to ask about: if you want to stay invested but you're tired of managing an old property from across the country, a 1031 exchange lets you sell an investment property and roll the proceeds into another one without paying the tax right away, as long as you follow the rules and timelines. A CPA can tell you what selling versus exchanging looks like for your taxes, including depreciation recapture. I'm in California, so for values and rents in Milwaukee you'll want a local agent there. But if you ever want to look at buying something closer to home, I'm happy to help. Joe Foxx, DRE #02047329, Rose District

Zoltan PeresztegiReal Estate Agent23 hours ago

Simone, the question to answer first is not whether the duplex cash flows, it is what return you are earning on the equity tied up in it. At $2,900 net of management against a $2,500 payment you clear about $400 a month before vacancy, repairs and capital items, and the $12k you have already spent on repairs equals roughly two and a half years of that cushion. Janice covered the valuation and rehab estimate side well. A few things change the math for California owners specifically: Selling is taxable in two states. As California residents, California taxes your gain on the Milwaukee sale, and Wisconsin also taxes it as Wisconsin source income. California generally gives you a credit for the tax paid to Wisconsin (Schedule S), so you are not simply paying twice, but you do need returns in both states. Federal depreciation recapture, taxed at up to 25 percent, applies to the depreciation taken or allowable either way. There is a third option besides sell or refi. A 1031 exchange lets you sell the duplex and defer the gain by buying a newer replacement property that does not need constant work. The deadlines are strict: 45 days to identify and 180 days to close, with a qualified intermediary holding the proceeds. Run the refi honestly. Cash out on a 2 to 4 unit investment property is capped well below what owner occupants can borrow (under Fannie Mae guidelines it is currently around 70 percent loan to value), and the rate is higher. The new payment can erase your $400 entirely, so the rehab has to raise rents enough to cover it. Budget for what an 1880s building hides. Old wiring, foundation work, the sewer lateral (get a scope), the water service line (Milwaukee has an active lead service line replacement program, so check whether yours is lead), and lead paint, which means any contractor must follow EPA lead safe renovation rules. I am a real estate professional, not a CPA, so have a tax professional model the after tax proceeds of a sale against the refi before you choose. I am Zoltan Peresztegi and I work the Palos Verdes and South Bay market in Los Angeles; if you decide to exchange that equity into something in Southern California, I would be glad to help you run those numbers, and if you stay in Milwaukee I can point you to a strong investor focused agent there. Zoltan

Keith Jean PierreReal Estate Agent23 hours ago

Simone, this is a personal decision that is based on your individual finances and lifestyle. We do not have the full scope of the situation, so it would be unwise to render an appropriate verdict on the issue. Keith Jean-Pierre Managing Principal The Dapper Agents Real Estate Operations in ALL 50 States

Janice AllenReal Estate Agent1 day ago
Rising Star11 Answers

Hi Simon, with only $400 a month in positive cash flow before accounting for repairs, vacancies, and future maintenance, I'd be cautious about a cash-out refinance. You've already spent $12,000 on repairs, and an 1880s property could have more surprises ahead. Before deciding, I'd recommend getting a current market valuation, a detailed rehab estimate, and refinance numbers. Compare what you'd walk away with if you sold versus your projected cash flow after refinancing. Sometimes selling and reinvesting your equity makes more financial sense than continuing to put money into an aging property.

Related Questions

Do agents regularly use "fake" offers to pressure buyers?

Asked by Jerry U | Boise, ID | 2 views | Selling | 11-18-2026 | Updated 29 minutes ago

Can I recover my money after learning my house sits on the neighbor's land?

Asked by Anonymous | Albany, GA | 12 views | Selling | 11-17-2026 | Updated 1 day ago

How do I know which inspection issues to push on without blowing up the deal?

Asked by Anonymous | Appleton, WI | 23 views | Selling | 11-16-2026 | Updated 2 days ago

I’m

Asked by Donald Rosenthal | 75686 | 14 views | Selling | 11-15-2026 | Updated 2 days ago