Simone, start with the $400 a month you keep after the mortgage and the property manager. The $12k you've already spent equals about 30 months of that, and an 1880s house rarely goes 30 months without another surprise. So I'd judge the refi on the next ten years, not the last two. A cash-out refi only makes sense if the rehab fixes what keeps breaking or lets you raise the rent enough to cover the bigger payment. Have a contractor bid the big-ticket items first, especially anything involving the plumbing or the roof, and see if the numbers still work. Then compare that with selling. Ask a Milwaukee agent for an as-is value, subtract your payoff and selling costs, and look at what you'd actually walk away with. Loop in a CPA too, since selling a rental can come with a tax bill. Managing an old building from Oakland wears on people, and that counts even if it's not on the spreadsheet. Alla Novytska, Realtor®, JohnHart Real Estate, DRE #02254775


