Karey Grimsley

Q: 1. What advice would you give a buyer trying to purchase a home?

Buying your first home is exciting — and having the right guidance makes all the difference. Start by connecting with a trusted REALTOR® and lender who can walk you through the process and help you understand your true buying power. Before you start shopping, get pre-approved so you know exactly what you can afford and can act quickly when the right home comes along. Be mindful of your full budget, including closing costs, inspections, and future maintenance, and never skip a home inspection — it’s your best protection against surprises. Keep your finances steady once you’ve applied for a loan by avoiding new credit or big purchases. Most importantly, think long-term about what fits your lifestyle and goals - the best home is one that truly works for you today and in the years ahead

Q: 2. What advice would you give a seller trying to sell their home?

When selling your home, preparation and presentation make all the difference. Start by working with a knowledgeable REALTOR® who understands your local market and can help you price strategically to attract qualified buyers. Take time to declutter, make small repairs, and enhance curb appeal — first impressions matter. Have inspections completed early to set clear expectations about the property’s condition and identify any repairs that may need attention before listing.

Q: 3. What types of clients have you worked with?

Throughout my real estate career, I’ve had the privilege of working with a wide range of clients — from first-time homebuyers and seasoned investors to sellers, developers, and business owners. My experience spans new construction, 1031 exchanges, bank-owned properties (REO), land development, and business sales, allowing me to provide expert guidance across every type of real estate transaction

Q: 4. Describe a recent transaction you are fond of. How did it go?

I recently had the pleasure of helping a seller whose property — which included acreage and two mobile homes — had been listed twice before without success. Many lenders initially said the property couldn’t be financed due to its unique setup, but I didn’t stop there. Through persistence and research, I found a lender who understood the guidelines that allowed us to secure traditional financing and close the sale successfully. In the end, both the seller and buyer were thrilled — a true win-win that proved how the right knowledge, persistence, and teamwork can make all the difference.

Q: 5. How did you get started in Real Estate?

I started my real estate career a few years after high school as an administrative assistant in a successful real estate office. Having moved many times growing up as my father’s job relocated our family, I developed a love for touring homes and the excitement of finding a new place to call home. That experience sparked my passion for real estate and the joy of helping people find a home where they can create lasting memories with family and friends. Over the years, this career has brought me incredible friendships, fulfillment, and purpose — it truly is my passion.

Q: 6. Do you have any special education or training that will benefit your clients?

Education has always been a driving force in my career. The real estate market is constantly evolving, and I believe that knowledge is power when it comes to providing exceptional service. I’ve earned multiple professional designations, including the Certified Residential Specialist (CRS) — the highest credential awarded to residential real estate agents — as well as Accredited Buyer’s Representative (ABR), Short Sale Negotiator, and Marketing and Luxury Designations. Ongoing education allows me to stay ahead of market trends and serve my clients with the utmost expertise, professionalism, and care.

Intero Real Estate Services

35 Years of Experience

(28)

$12M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$870K

Average Price Point

Trusted Pro Network

Service Areas

Aromas, CA Freedom, CA Gilroy, CA Hollister, CA Morgan Hill, CA Moss Landing, CA San Juan Bautista, CA San Martin, CA Tres Pinos, CA Watsonville, CA

View All Service Areas

About Karey Grimsley

Karey Grimsley is a highly accomplished Real Estate Broker and Certified Residential Specialist (CRS) with over 30 years of experience helping clients navigate the San Benito County and Central Coast markets. Guided by her philosophy -- Real Trust. Real Care. Real Estate. -- Karey is known for her integrity, professionalism, and commitment to delivering exceptional results. A consistent top producer with Intero Real Estate, Karey is proud to be part of the Intero Executive Circle, ranking among the Top 10% companywide. She has been voted Best Realtor in San Benito County (Hollister Freelance, 2022), received the President's Award from the San Benito Association of REALTORSA(R) (2021), and was voted a Neighborhood Favorite on Nextdoor (2023 & 2024) -- reflecting her trusted reputation and dedication to her clients and community. Beyond her professional success, Karey is deeply committed to giving back. She has served in multiple leadership roles with the San Benito Association of REALTORSA(R) as Past Director, Secretary, and Treasurer; currently serves on the Hollister Downtown Association Board of Directors; is an Emeritus Former Director and Treasurer of Emmaus House; and has also served as a Past Ambassador for the Intero Foundation, supporting charitable causes throughout the community. Her clients know they can count on her for expert market insight, strong negotiations, responsive communication, and genuine care for their goals. Whether buying or selling, Karey ensures every client feels confident, informed, and valued throughout one of life's most meaningful investments.

OTHER LANGUAGES

English

HOBBIES/INTEREST

Hiking, yoga, traveling

Credentials

LICENSE

Real Estate - California - # 01116747

Designation

ePro

CDPE (Certified Distressed PropertyExpert)

CRS (Certified Residential Specialist)

SFR (Short Sales & Foreclosure Resource)

ABR (Accredited Buyers Representative)

REALTOR

Broker / Associate Broker

Specialties

Buyers
Sellers
Residential Property

Awards

2026
TOP AGENT
Hollister, CA
2026
TOP AGENT
San Juan Bautista, CA
2026
TOP AGENT
Morgan Hill, CA

Loading recent sales...

Karey Grimsley's Reviews & Ratings

28 Reviews

(5/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Professional
Knowledgeable
Responsive
Communicative
Attentive
Available Remotely
Excellent negotiator
Great for new buyers
Hard working
Outstanding

Sgtbratt64

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

November 10, 2021

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey not only sold us our home , she helped us sell it . We relocated out of State . But through the process her knowledge ,her time she makes for you. Just a very great person to know as well as she knows her job. She listens to you and makes your dream home come true . Thank you Karey Grimsley .. Randy & Gloria Ragsac

Paul P.

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

October 14, 2021

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

In this wild market, Karey was our rock throughout our entire buying process. She was extremely responsive, patient, caring, personable and professional. At the end of the day, we ended up with a home that we absolutely love. I couldn't imagine buying our home with any other realtor. It's been a pleasure to work with Karey and I can't recommend her enough!

Dominic M.

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

November 4, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

We have nothing but good things to say about Karey. Karey was professional, diligent and her responsiveness throughout the process was brilliant. As first time home buyers, Karey coached us through the process from start to finish, and was an invaluable resource to us. Kareys knowledge of the area was very reassuring and helped us to identify the perfect home for our needs. Karey also went the extra mile in helping to put us in contact with local services and generally helping out with any questions we had related to our new home. Thank you so much Karey!

Jenny M.

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

November 3, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey was great and very professional! We are first time home buyers and she made the process so easy and exciting. We ended up finding and buying our dream home with the help of Karey and her team. Very grateful and thrilled at the experience. She comes highly recommended from us. Thank you for all your help Karey!!!

Scott41105

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

October 24, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey was recommended to us by our son, who she sold a home. Karey knows Hollister, knows the market, and knows how to treat clients correctly.I always appreciated that whenever I had a question or a concern, at any point in the sale process, I could call Karey and she was always right there to respond. Awesome service.And she got us a great price.Scott and Linda DuBois

Tmaheu1261

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

August 31, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I had the pleasure of working with Karey in 2019. She is very attentive to her clients and listens to what it is they are wanting and needing. She was instrumental in helping me achieve my dream of home ownership. She is very knowledgeable about the local community and neighborhoods. She answered my countless questions with ease and understanding. If I had to use her services again I would and highly recommend her for your real estate needs.

Shirleycunha

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

June 23, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey Grimsley is an amazing professional person. Always available to help with any question I had. She is very knowledge about the purchasing area. Karey is a very caring person. I"m very thankful I had Karey as my Real Estate Professional. I recommend her 100%

Maneeshkhare

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

June 21, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey is an absolute expert when it comes to Hollister. We are seriously considering moving to Hollister and decided to seek her help in looking at new construction properties. She patiently helped us over the course of half a day, showing us multiple sites and giving a locals insights into the neighborhoods. She was patient, knowledgeable and understanding of our timeline. If we decide to buy in Hollister, we wont go ahead without her help.

Ezcordia

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

June 11, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey guided me through the process of finding a home to purchase in Hollister 24 years ago. My personal needs in a home were somewhat restrictive, but she kept working with me until the right fit was found. It took several months, but she didn't give up. Everything turned out fabulous for me. She helped me get everything I wanted and needed in a home for a price I could afford. She did much the same nine years ago to get me a different home here in Hollister. It took awhile once again because I was looking for just the right fit for my needs. She stuck with me until just the right place popped up. She still helps me to this day with after-sale service, such as getting a modification to the title recently. Outstanding realator!!

Gmtmpt0

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

February 2, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey Grimsley is an Amazing realtor! It is such a roller coaster ride to sell and buy a house and she made it feel like it was no stress at all... she was prompt, knowledgeable, efficient, calming, happy, confident, and reassuring at stressful situations in deciding what to do. If you want an excellent professional choose Karey! We cant say enough how wonderful she is.

Bkshep17

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

April 9, 2019

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey has been our go to agent for many years. After several transactions, both buying and selling, we can not say enough about what a pleasure it is to do business with her. She is knowledgeable, responsive, and most important acts with a great deal of integrity. Real estate can be overwelming at times but she takes the stress out of it. We are happy to recommend Karey over and over again.

Adrian A.

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

November 8, 2018

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey Helped us buy our first home! She was always there when We needed her! Always picked up her phone no matter what day or time it was. She was always following up with me and the lender made it quick and easy! Closed on time and am going to keep her in my contacts for Friends and family looking to buy in the near future.

Patricia1124

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

October 17, 2018

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey Grimsley was always professional and respectful throughout the listing and sale of our home. Her experience, knowledge and expertise facilitated the closure of our real estate transaction. She listened to us and guided us successfully through the escrow process. She communicated with us regularly to ensure that we were informed. We were impressed with Karey's honesty, integrity and trustworthiness. We highly recommend Karey Grimsley!

Watsonam2

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

October 11, 2018

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey really listened to what we wanted in our new home, made sure that we saw only the ones that fit our needs and within 3 weeks we had found the perfect home. She was very knowledgeable when it came to selling our previous home. Her recommendations regarding what to repair, replace, refresh and what to leave alone were spot on. The purchase and sale both went through without a hitch. Thank you Karey!

User9524786

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

May 21, 2018

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

We recently sold our Hollister house with the expert help Karey Grimsley who was amazing in every way, and it could not have gone any better. We were very impressive with her ability and professionalism. She helped us prepare our house with all her connections with painting, flooring, cleaning, handyman, whatever we needed, so the house were able to be on the market with a fresh new look within a short time, and received satisfactory offers. She is very personable, knowledgeable, and organized. Her knowledge about the Bay Area housing market and about real estate practices in general is very strong. We feel we received her full attention and excellent professional services, and we recommend Karey to you with our highest recommendation.

Handley2004

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

April 17, 2018

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

The one word that describes Karey is: exceptional! Karey assisted in purchasing and selling both of my last 2 homes. In each instance, I was thoroughly satisfied with the outcome as both a buyer and seller. She takes personal care to understand her clients' needs, provides a balanced assessment and guidance on market value, and helps to find that perfect fit. Anyone will instantly recognize her experience, professionalism, and efficiency is second to none. If want an personable agent with high integrity that gets results, then you need to look no further than Karey Grimsley.

Frculler

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

March 29, 2018

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey acted as our agent with early notice of a potential property on the market. She had been searching for a similar property for us. She promptly worked with us to submit what turned out to be the successful offer. Her personal attention to our needs and coordination with the listing agent and seller made for the success of the purchase. I strongly recommend Karey and will continue to ask her to represent us with future real estate transactions. Ron Culler

Shelley S.

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

October 1, 2017

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey was very professional and knowledgeable in helping us list our home and getting it ready to sell. Once the contract was in, with her help, the transaction went very smooth and easy! We would highly recommend using Karey's expertise and skills in any real estate transaction!

Daddyramos

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

June 3, 2016

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

this is the second time that we used karey for purchasing a home. there were some unexpected hiccups, but karey stuck with us from beginning to end. its been an awesome experience to work with her.

Robynbankz

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

June 1, 2016

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey is wonderful to work with! She was my realtor in 2011 & again in 2016. She's professional, personable & extremely knowledgeable in her field of expertise. She also has a very flexible schedule & responds in a timely manner. Plus she's a great negotiator & will try her hardest for the best price. I highly recommend working with Karey Grimsley!!

Drjanmeyer

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

May 6, 2016

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey was very responsive to every situation and issue, be it small or large (and there were a lot of both due to the nature of the sale!) Because we are not local, she handled virtually everything in a professional, efficient, and friendly manner. I wish she could be cloned at any point we might need a realtor!

Ramanlazary

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

April 16, 2016

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey was very transparent and gave me peace of mind. She made sure we didn't miss anything, and worked very fast. She is very knowledgable, and knows the Hollister market in and out. She was very responsive with emails, calls and texts.

User2946902

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

February 4, 2016

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey was awesome every step of the way. Our process was extended over several months and Karey treated us as if we were negotiating a multi million dollar deal. She is very professional, and highly knowledgable. We have used her service several timed over the last 15 years and each time is as positive as the last. We highly recommend Karey!

Wrothwel

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

February 20, 2015

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey was our agent when we bought our Hollister home in 2009. She was wonderful! This was our first home purchase and she made it go very smoothly. She was very knowledgable about the Hollister area and the real estate market here. She helped us find and purchase the perfect home. Since the purchase she has continued to be helpful in recommending good local people for things like termite inspections. We will always be grateful for her excellent help and her lovely friendship and highly recommend her to anyone interested in buying property in Hollister.

User17313417

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

January 22, 2015

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey has been a tremendous partner in our home sales and purchases. She is a consummate professional, very detail-oriented, extremely patient, thorough in her research and preparation. Over the course of five real estate transactions in 10 years, her demonstrated work ethic and other qualities Karey has earned our highest level of trust.

Zozayacindy

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

January 12, 2015

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I highly recommend Karey Grimsley for any real estate needs in San Benito County. She handled the listing and sale of my elderly mother's home and was truly sensitive to my mother's needs, always being available when an agent wanted to to show the home or when inspections were necessary. Her honesty, creativity in challenging situations and caring approach sets Karey high above the standard I've experienced with other realtors in the past. If you are looking for a truly professional real estate broker/associate, Karey Grimsley should be your choice!

User0041484

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

January 10, 2015

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey is our go to person for our real estate needs. I trust her to give us up to date information and have our best interests at heart. She has been our agent as a seller and as a buyer. We have used her for the past 5 plus years. We are currently thinking of another purchase and wouldn't consider anyone else. If you choose her you won't be sorry.

Bcolman77

Review for Member: Karey Grimsley

January 10, 2015

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Karey was very professional, knowledgeable, and easy to work with while taking our next step in home ownership. We felt very confident and at ease with our decisions while working with Karey.. We will continue to use Karey in the future as well as recommend her to others.

FAQ

1. What advice would you give a buyer trying to purchase a home?

2. What advice would you give a seller trying to sell their home?

3. What types of clients have you worked with?

4. Describe a recent transaction you are fond of. How did it go?

5. How did you get started in Real Estate?

6. Do you have any special education or training that will benefit your clients?

Answered Questions

What should I know about buying a mobile home?

Check the rules and requirements if the mobile home is in a park. Some parks are 55 + communities. You will also want to know the space rent and how much it can increase yearly. If you need financing, you will also want to check on the requirements with a knowledgeable lender specializing in mobile home financing, older models may be difficult to finance. The age of the mobile home will typically determine its value and appreciation.

Answered by Karey Grimsley | Sunnyvale, CA, USA | 1589 Views | Working With an Agent | 3 years ago

Should I order a home inspection?

I always recommend getting a home inspection !! It helps uncover hidden issues, protects your investment, and gives you peace of mind before you buy. A small step now can save you big surprises later.

Answered by Karey Grimsley | | 1668 Views | Working With an Agent | 7 months ago

I'm trying to find who built my house?

When researching the build of your home, the local Building Department should have the original permits and construction records on file.

Answered by Karey Grimsley | Wilmington, DE, USA | 1460 Views | Working With an Agent | 7 months ago

Can I make an offer on a pending house?

Absolutely, yes. Submitting a back-up offer is highly recommended. It gives you the opportunity to move into first position if the current contract falls through. I've successfully sold many properties where the buyer originally came in as a back-up offer.

Answered by Karey Grimsley | San Marcos, CA, USA | 2511 Views | Working With an Agent | 7 months ago