Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
J B.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was phenomenal throughout our house hunting and home-buying process. We bought a home in La Grange Park and he knows the area and surrounding towns incredibly well. He was professional, responsive, and proactive throughout the process (which took us a while, we were picky!). When we submitted an offer, he helped us strategize the offer terms to make our offer competitive. When looking at houses, he had a lot of great knowledge about things to check and watch out for--he wasn't only pointing out the positive aspects, and we appreciated his honest opinion. We highly recommend Robby!
Dizzida123
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was very patient with us...walking with us through homes in the cold and even odd homes with a bathroom for an entrance...he showed up at times that worked best for our schedules and sometimes to take pictures when we couldn't be there, never making us feel rushed or pressured. He listened to what we were looking for and helped navigate each step of the process. In an extremely competitive market, Robby guided us strategically to help us secure a home in our preferred neighborhood, where properties are often sold in what seems like an instant. He is super friendly and professional, making our home search more of a fun experience than stressful. Robby was attentive from our very first showing all the way through closing and still checks in with us to this day to make sure we are doing well in our new home. We appreciate Robby's expertise and highly recommend him to anyone looking for a dedicated realtor!
Meredith H.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby did an excellent job as our seller agent. With his advice and guidance, we were able to sell quickly well over our anticipated asking price. He has excellent knowledge of the area and the market in general.
Erick P.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was the best! My wife and I were first-time home buyers and Robby was able to walk us through every step of the process and take the time to fully explain everything we needed to know. He was always available whenever we had questions and his knowledge of the real estate business is phenomenal. We highly recommend him, especially if you are a first-time home buyer!
Mtrench09
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was fabulous identifying what was being looked for, and matching to great property options. No wasted time in the search, and great representation all the way through closing.
Chris
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby is fantastic! I worked with him back in 2020 to buy my home, and when it was time to sell in 2025, I knew exactly who to call. He is professional, responsive, and truly cares about his clients. He made the selling process just as smooth as the buying process. I highly recommend him!
Stephen F.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDI was fortunate to have Robby represent me in my home buying experience. Robby has a commanding knowledge of the market conditions, availability in the neighborhoods, and negotiating tactics to lead to a successful closing. I am grateful to him pointing out details, whether good or problematic, in each of the houses I was able to tour, and given my price range and limited time, I was better able to make an informed logical decision instead of a emotional one. I am thankful Robby had helped me find the house, in the neighborhood and in my budget, and I would recommend him for any future transactions.
Kellina L.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDAs first-time home buyers, we couldnt have asked for a better real estate agent! From day one, Robby was knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely invested in helping us find the right place. Thanks to his expertise, we were able to move quickly and secure a great condo aEUR" and even got our offer accepted against higher bids, which we didnt think was possible in this market. Throughout the process, Robby was professional, responsive, and always on top of the details. He helped us quickly narrow down on the type of property we wanted to buy, and proactively got to the bottom of some odd property information for us. We're so happy with how everything turned out and would absolutely recommend Robby to anyone looking to buy in the greater Chicago area!
Amkidaguian
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDWe worked with Robby to purchase our condo 4 years ago so when we decided it was time to move into a house we had no doubts we wanted to work with him again. He helped us all the way trough the process of selling and buying and made it as easy and smooth as it could be. He was great at listening and taking notes of our needs and desires and helped us find a great house in the area we love. He was very informative trough the whole process, always answering all our questions both in person and over the phone if needed, he was always available for us.
Chocolatier2
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDWe decided to work with Robby as he had sold the unit next door to ours, he lives in the area and is very familiar with the great attributes of living in La Grange, IL. Robby knew how to price our unit and was instrumental in getting our property prepared to get the results we wanted. We would highly recommend Robby for your next property purchase or sale.
Dbdudley1998
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDWe had the pleasure of working with Robby and can confidently say that his expertise, insight, and intuition make him an exceptional agent. He had a deep understanding of the market and his deliverables were proof of this. His experience is evident in every conversation, and his guidance through the selling process was invaluable. What sets Robby apart is his intuitive grasp of both the emotional and practical aspects of real estate transactions. His ability to balance market trends with personal needs led to an outcome that exceeded our expectations. Moreover, his communication is second to noneaEUR"always timely, transparent, and thorough. If youre looking for an agent who combines professionalism with a genuine care for his clients, look no further than Robby. We wholeheartedly recommend him to anyone seeking not just a transaction, but a trusted advisor who will work tirelessly to ensure your success.
Bibiana P.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDMy husband and I were struggling to find our perfect home for our little family for a while. Robby then came along and immediately showed us EXACTLY what we were looking for ! And by immediately I mean, the first home he showed us ended up being the home we purchased. We are so grateful for his kindness and dedication. We would absolutely recommend him to anyone starting this process !
Rpsdms
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDI had a positive experience with Robby. He was very professional and helpful. He sold my home in LaGrange Park. He made it simple after living in thee house 46 years I needed help. It is something I had not done in many years.
Jcrogers5894
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby did an amazing job helping us sell our home. From the moment we contacted Robby about our plans thru the closing date, he has been nothing but professional & patient. He gave excellent guidance in pricing and staging our home. Once our home was ready, Robby was extremely thorough and kept us in the loop with communications and timeline. We really appreciated the aEURoecalmaEUR? that Robby brought to the whole experience. We would highly recommend Robby for your real estate needs!
Tiago P.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby is the best! Went above and beyond to make sure everything was smooth and took care of the entire process while we were across the country. Very knowledgeable in the area and was able to accommodate our timing and provide great advice.
Martina W.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDIt was an absolute pleasure working with Robby! As a first-time homebuyer, I could not have asked for a more patient and knowledgeable realtor. His attention to detail is unmatched and his hands-on approach throughout the entire process was invaluable. I could not have asked for a smoother experience.
Ckipping310
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDMy experience with Robby at @properties was nothing short of fantastic. From our initial meeting to receiving the keys to our new home, Robby demonstrated unmatched professionalism, deep market knowledge, and a genuine commitment to our needs. He and his wonderful team expertly staged our house, enhancing its appeal and helping us visualize our future home. Robbys guidance through each step of the home buying process was invaluable, particularly in how he eased our minds during what could have been a stressful time. His responsiveness and attention to detail ensured that we felt confident and informed at all times. I highly recommend Robby to anyone looking to make their home buying experience as smooth and successful as ours.
Pnrh7tsn44
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobbys spot on expertise on the real estate market helped my family find out forever home quickly. His attention to all the details and informative nature let me to know my family was in good hands. He was very attentive to our family needs in a home, as well as gave us great recommendations for an attorney & insurance company. He helped us with all our financial issues we were encountering. He is very insightful, attentive, friendly, and keeps you in the loop every step of the way! We are so happy with his expertise we will have Robby sell our previous home & recommend to our family members looking to buy a home.
Vwfrank84
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was great at communicating and made sure we understood all the steps of both our sale and purchases. Great with details and simplifying the processes.
Flo S.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby Bartholomai did an excellent job of assisting me with the purchase of my condo. His expertise in the markets geographical area and providing comps helped me in determining my offer price to the seller. Robby kept me informed and on track throughout the entire process. He recommended a very nice home inspector, lender, and insurance company. All of which I used, and I was very happy with their kindness and services too. He was friendly, extremely knowledgeable, involved with all aspects of the purchase, very responsive, and answered all of my questions. And I had a bunch. I'm very happy with my home and I would definitely recommend Robby. Hes very trustworthy, kind and will help you through every step of purchasing or selling real estate.
Tgripp77
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby approached us with the full package of a competent, personable, highly intelligent realtor that had a strong visual scope of today's drastically changing market. I was attracted mostly to the way he was family oriented and always answered the phone. His strong abilities shown mostly during the intense negotiations between the selling and purchasing part. He was always on the Ball! Thanks again Buddy!!!!
Mat W.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDWe connected with Robby through Zillow and right from the start we knew that we were in good hands with him when looking to buy our very first home. Robby was always responsive, punctual and professional --- he also has a great attitude and personality. He handled EVERYTHING for us, from the home search, to the offer(s), to the inspections, to the closing. When Robby organized our home tours, he came ready with useful knowledge about the homes and neighborhoods, and he was honest with his advice, feedback and answers to our many questions. Robby connected us with an amazing financing team that handled our rather difficult situation of having just moved from abroad. He also recommended a team of inspectors that did a great job. Importantly, Robby respected our health concerns and had no problem wearing a good mask around us. Overall, we couldn't be happier about Robby's service and we recommend him wholeheartedly.
Snash581
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDThis was the second time our family used Robby's services in selling our homes. He has always been the consummate professional. His knowledge and insights into the local markets has always been spot on. His preparation of marketing materials, photo for the listing service, and suggestions for the property have both times increased the sales price over the listing price, and both homes sold quickly. Robby's calm demeanor and quiet assurance always helped remove some of the anxiety that comes with the process. We could not recommend him enough.
Pennymc390
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDWe have relied on Robby's expertise in the real estate industry for the past few years for both buying and selling residences. We have recommended him to friends when they were looking for a realtor because we are confident in his professional, results- oriented approach. He is well-informed of the real estate market, responsive to questions and concerns, and easy to work with. We highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.
Mmagough
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDCannot say enough about our experience working with Robby. From our initial introductory meeting, Robby was incredibly professional and helpful. He provided us with ample information and was very attentive to our wishes for finding the perfect home for us. Throughout our house search, Robby ensured that we were in the loop on all potential houses on the market (as well as those coming soon to the market) he thought would interest us. Robby also provided great recommendations for our attorney, electricians, plumbers, really whatever we needed. When we eventually found the house for us, Robbys expertise helped us make a competitive offer that was quickly accepted. He remained engaged with us throughout the closing process and help facilitate a smooth and eventless closing. If youre looking for an agent in the Chicagoland area, especially the near western suburbs we would highly recommend contacting Robby.
CynthiaHall47
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDWe highly recommend Realtor Robby Bartholomai! Casually browsing an online real estate website, we found our aEURoeforeveraEUR? home during the early days of pandemic restrictions. Robby came to us through Zillow. Knowledgeable, responsive, helpful, patient and conscientiousaEUR|these are professional and personal qualities that he brought to the process. Cindy & Tom Crissey
Vgeraci
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDIt was a pleasure working with Robby. He was very thorough from day one, walking us through each step of the process until closing. Robby is meticulous in getting the best out of your home. Thank you!
Jimcapraro
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDMy wife and I are in the stage of our lives where purchasing a home in close proximity to our son's family (our three granddaughters) is of the utmost importance. We are both retired and no longer need to be close to work. Last February, my wife contacted Robby Bartholomai to assist with our search. We are so thankful that she found him. He worked very closely with us during an intensive three month search. During that search, Robby spent a lot of time getting to know us and developed an understanding of our unique needs. This was no easy task as we had several requirements such as: proximity to our son's family, accessibility concerns for our physically disabled daughter who spends lots of extended visits with us, finding the right size home that would not be a maintenance burden (while also not being too small); and then, the normal host of concerns regarding style and aesthetics of our future living environment. Hidden within Robby's soft and gentle manner is a real estate professional driven to serve his clients. Experiencing his method to get to know us and our needs and deliver suitable options was fun at first, exciting as we honed in on the perfect option and much appreciated throughout. We closed on our home purchase a few days ago and afterward Robby met us to hand us the keys accompanied by a warm smile and hearty congratulations. Choose Robby Bartholomai as you agent, you will be so glad you did.
Katie O.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was absolutely wonderful to work with. We had been searching for a home for over a year with another realtor who wasnt much help. After switching to Robby, we were in our dream home by our goal date. Robby was incredibly knowledgeable about the market as well as the home buying process which helped make us feel more comfortable while buying our first home. I would recommend Robby to anyone and I will go to him again for any home buying/selling needs.
Esiemins
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDWe were passively looking at homes and thinking about moving when we met Robby at an open house. I tried explaining that we were likely a lost cause, because we were looking for a "purple squirrel" of a house that met our long list of criteria. Undaunted by the comment, Robby rose to the challenge and, at our request, began sending us home listings he felt came close to everything we were looking for. He exhibited endless patience during our search, and genuinely sought to understand and help us clarify what was truly important. He remained highly responsive throughout our search. When we finally found our "almost-purple squirrel" of a house, that met much of our criteria, Robby walked us through the offer and inspection process and kept on top of everything to help ensure we would close on the agreed-upon date. We are genuinely happy with our new house and excited to begin making it our own!
Chris
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was great. He was always available and on top of the process. He is patient, fast , friendly, good negotiator and very thoughtful. We couldnt get out dream house without him .
Kim G.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was fantastic! We were first time homebuyers and he walked us through every step. He was knowledgeable, understanding and personable. We didnt feel like we were working with an agent, we felt like we were working with a friend who wanted nothing but the best for us. Highly recommend Robby for any real estate transaction.
Kim S.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was fantastic! We were first time homebuyers and he walked us through every step. He was knowledgeable, understanding and personable. We didnt feel like we were working with an agent, we felt like we were working with a friend who wanted nothing but the best for us. Highly recommend Robby for any real estate transaction.
Penny M.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby clearly outlined the process for us to sell our home. He was responsive, attentive, and professional. We recommend him to anyone buying or selling their home.
Laura B.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDMy husband and I initially met Robby when we were exploring a few open houses in La Grange. We were immediately impressed by his knowledge of the area and his proactive approach to identifying homes we may be interested in viewing based on "must-haves" list. Robby was by our side through every step of the process to make sure that our experience as first time homebuyers was simple and successful. We really enjoyed our time working with Robby and would recommend him to anyone looking for a home in Chicagoland!
Mmaron2
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDMy wife and I had the pleasure of working with Robby while looking for a home in the western suburbs of Chicago, IL. Robby was very attentive to our needs by recommending houses to us that met our search criteria. He was very communicative and reachable. As first time home buyers, Robby was very patient with us, which made it easy for us to work with him. Robbys knowledge of the local area was very valuable as he informed us of some local nuances and provided insight on to how think about them (ex: distances to services, taxes, schools, etc.). We would highly recommend Robby's real estate services to anyone looking for a home.
Ed C.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was always professional and highly responsive. On very short notice, he was able to set up several showings as requested and made us aware of listings unknown to us. Even upon last minute notice, he was able to accommodate our schedule. Highly recommended for LaGrange and surrounding areas.
Nicole S.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby is an Amazing Realtor I would definitely recommend him and use him again in the future. We met Robby at an open house and he remembered from our split second interaction our likes and dislikes and tailored our home search accordingly. This made the house search quick and painless. He did not try to show us properties out of our price range or out of our preferred neighborhood.
KRehor7
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDThis was our first time buying a home and we were very new to the process. Robby went above and beyond to answer our questions. He talked us through each house that we were considering and was very patient. He gave us opinions when we wanted him to weigh in. When we eventually settled on a home he answered all our questions. He was responsive through the entire process. We are so appreciative of him!!! We would recommend him to anyone buying.
Katyrose77
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDI am so incredibly grateful to have worked with Robby. He is a true expert in his field. I cannot imagine anyone else who would have been as honest, thorough and patient, helping me put my situation in perspective. A true blessing to have worked with him.
Zuser20160125082026102
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was fantastic to work with from start to finish! Robby is an excellent realtor with great knowledge of the suburbs surrounding La Grange. Robby listened to us over the months and knew what our "wish list" was. When the perfect home was listed we jumped on it quickly and could not be happier! We just closed on our perfect home thanks to Robby. He found the house, walked us through the process, and was a true professional at all times. Highly recommended!!!
OSchneewind
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDLooking for a home in La Grange or Hinsdale, we relied on Robby Bartholomai to identify houses that would fit our needs (school district, traffic patterns, yard, house size and age) and that would emotionally resonate with us. Mr Bartholomai made important contributions in evaluating homes, identifying weaknesses and strengths and assessing whether we could be happy in our new hope. While this was certainly a lengthy as well as time and effort consuming process, Mr Bartholomai was never intrusive or impatient. We are very glad that he helped find the home we were looking for!
Hdswimtack
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was very helpful in providing an analysis on our home. We had bought our house off market and wasn't sure if we had paid a fair price. We reached out to Robby after meeting him at an open house and he said he would be willing to give us an idea on what he thought our house was worth. He was responsive in setting up a time to meet and came prepared with questions. He took care in noticing details of the property and provided insight into how others would view our house if we ever decided to sell. He also helped give us a value on the updates we had put into the house after purchasing it. Robbie came for a follow-up appointment and shared market comps with us showing us how our house stacked up to others that had sold in the previous year. His knowledge of what buyers were looking for in regards to layouts, location, and updates and how that impacts pricing, went beyond what we could find ourselves through online tools. I would highly recommend working with Robbie from a professional and personal standpoint.
Laura L.
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby is extremely knowledgeable in the western suburbs. He is a great negotiator, and works to get the best deal for buyers. It is so nice to work with a realtor who looks out for his buyers!
Williamcaplice
Review for Member: Robby Bartholomai
ZillowVERIFIEDRobby was very conscientious in sending us weekly information about houses / properties which matched the criteria we discussed. I would recommend him for your rel estate search.