Colleen Teifer Top real estate agent in Ocean Isle Beach

Colleen Teifer

Greylock Company, Inc.
10 Years of Experience
(104)
$21M
Total Sales Last Year
10
Years of Experience
182
Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years
$385K
Average Price Point

    About Colleen Teifer

    I moved to North Carolina from New Jersey in 2014 after retiring early from a career as a high school administrator. Real estate has always been in my blood, as other family members were agents, builders and investors. I began investing in property myself many years ago, as I knew it would be a means to a planned early retirement and relocation. As such, I have the benefit of many years of experience buying, selling, renovating, and managing my own properties. This enables me to look with a critical eye at properties for my clients, and help educate them throughout their search for property. As I relocated to this area myself, it also offers my clients the additional benefit of my experience and understanding of this process. I can help clients streamline their search, and offer them the options that appear to best match their preferences. I cover the entire area from Wilmington to Myrtle Beach, so can assist clients with any communities or properties. I am licensed in both NC and SC as well. My background as a public servant gives me a perspective that other traditional salespeople do not have. I truly have my clients' best interests at heart, and will work for their benefit alone. This has served me well as I am one of the top producing brokers in this area. My sales volume for 2021, 2022 and 2023 was in excess of $20,000,000 each year, and my sales volume in 2024 was in excess of $26,000,000.
    OTHER LANGUAGES
    English
    HOBBIES/INTEREST
    Softball, golf
    Read More About Colleen

    Specialties

    • Sellers
    • Residential Property

    Awards

    • award image
    • rewards

      2025

      TOP AGENT

      Sunset Beach, NC

    • rewards

      2025

      TOP AGENT

      Ocean Isle Beach, NC

    • rewards

      2025

      TOP AGENT

      Calabash, NC

    View All Awards

    Loading recent sales...

    Colleen Teifer's Reviews & Ratings

    104 Reviews
    (5/5)
    Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
    What clients say about this agent....
    • Professional
    • Responsive
    • Knowledgeable
    • Communicative
    • Outstanding
    • Attentive
    • Trustworthy
    • Hard working
    • Sold Quickly
    • Available Remotely

    Mike O.

    Review for Member: Colleen Teifer
    January 5, 2026
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    Excellent Support! My wife and I moved from Maryland and relocated to Ocean Isle Beach NC. Colleen was referred to us as the best to work with. Colleen got to know us and our needs. She found several excellent properties for us that exceeded our expectations. We bought a wonderful new home and are so thankful to her! She took care of so many details with our move and truly made it much easier and a smooth process. I highly recommend her as your realtor!

    Andrea A.

    Review for Member: Colleen Teifer
    January 4, 2026
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    Exceptional Realtor Who Goes Above and BeyondaEUR"Truly the Best in NC Coastal Area. Working with Colleen has been the best real estate experience weve had in over 25 years. She took the time to truly understand me, my family, and what we were looking for in a home. Her goal was never just to help us buy a house aEUR" she wanted us to love where we landed and feel completely confident in our decision. Her knowledge of the North Carolina coastal area is extraordinary. Colleen gave us a thoughtful, detailed overview of the region, introduced us to neighborhoods that aligned with our lifestyle, and helped us understand the nuances of each coastal community. She knew which areas would fit our needs, which areas were up-and-coming, and how each location would feel day-to-day - helping us find the right fit for our family. Because we were six hours away, we relied heavily on her guidance, and she went above and beyond. She visited homes on our behalf, sent thorough videos, and provided honest, insightful feedback so we never felt distant from the process. Her dedication, communication, and genuine care made everything smooth and stress-free. I truly cant say enough about her. Her expertise in the NC coastal market and her commitment to her clients truly set her apart.

    Kelly R.

    Review for Member: Colleen Teifer
    January 4, 2026
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    Highly-Recommended Knowledgeable Professional . Colleen has extensive knowledge of the area and neighborhoods, which we appreciated as we planned our move from out of state. She was thorough in her preparation to review properties within our parameters, mapped out the properties for showings, and maximized our schedule. She was flexible, even giving up some of her personal time, when we needed to see a property again on short notice. When the time came to do so, she provided all the information we needed to make an informed offer to get us the best possible deal on our new home. But she didn't stop there - she was excellent in her communication from offer to to closing, helping us with getting the inspection, having work done (at the expense of the seller) to correct some things found on the inspection, and so much more. She was always quick to respond to our questions, very pleasant to work with, and so very helpful. She really made our experience a breeze - even from 500 miles away! We highly recommend Colleen for your buying or selling needs - you won't be disappointed!

    Catherine M.

    Review for Member: Colleen Teifer
    December 29, 2025
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    Colleen is the best in Brunswick County! We had the pleasure of working with Colleen when we purchased our home and then again when it was time to sell. Her professionalism and local market knowledge is unparalleled, from professional photos, online marketing and setting the right price for our home to streamlining the selling process. We were able to sell our house quickly and profitably in a slow resale market due to her guidance. She is the best in Brunswick County!

    Pmass1220

    Review for Member: Colleen Teifer
    December 28, 2025
    Local Knowledge
    Process Expertise
    Responsiveness
    Negotiation skills
    zillowZillowVERIFIED

    We met with Colleen looking to relocate from NY. We gave her our wish list. She listened!! She immediately found properties geared to our desires & Colleen met with us to show us around to what we were looking for! We found our forever home thanks to her!!!!! Colleen helped us every step of the way!!! I highly recommend her for her knowledge, professionalism & her approachable/very friendly manner!