Company Thumbnail Image
    Send Message

    Kistle Realty

    394 Route 206 North
    Branchville, NJ 07826

    Send Message
      Kelsey Kistle

      Kelsey Kistle

      Branchville, NJ

      (61)
      Karina Matthews

      Karina Matthews

      Branchville, NJ

      (3)
      Debra Kistle

      Debra Kistle

      Branchville, NJ

      64 REVIEWS(5.0/5)
      Jessica F.
      September 20, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Kelsey is the best!! She is so knowledgeable, responsive, great attitude, and overall a pleasure to spend our home buying experience with! Were already recommending her to our friends and family, and would love to work with her again in the future!
      Lauren M.
      August 9, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      I cant recommend Kelsey and Kistle Realty enough! Although my property hunt definitely took a minute, it was SO worth the wait. We were looking for a true unicorn, a property that could meet both my personal and business needs, with the right mix of residential and commercial possibilities, and due to diligence and persistence, we found it. It checked every box and then some. What really stood out was Kelseys willingness to think outside the box throughout the entire process. Finding the right property took creativity, patience, and persistence, and she was there through all of it. Kistle Realty is also a family-owned business, and you genuinely feel that difference. They care about their clients, treat you like family, and the relationship doesnt end at closing. Kelsey continues to check in and recommend trusted local contractors, services, and homeowner resources whenever I need them. Highly recommend Kelsey and the entire Kistle Realty team!
      Umit A.
      March 8, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Working with Kelsey was a great experience from start to finish. She was responsive, organized, and stayed on top of every detail, which made the whole process much smoother and less stressful. A big thank you as well to attorney Marleen, inspector Ryan, and Stephanie at the title company aEUR" everyone was professional, helpful, and great to work with. Highly recommend Kelsey and her team!
      Baverogary
      February 12, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      I was very happy with having Kelsey as my agent. She was extremely helpful and a pleasure to work with. Kelsey always got back to me ASAP with answers to all my questions (and I had a lot)! Her knowledge and level of expertise is top notch and resulted in the purchase of my dream home. I also used Kelsey to sell my prior home and we closed in less than a month!
      User8633333
      August 9, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Kelsey is filled with energy and motivated. She had a few offers right away when selling my house, when other realtors did not. We changed nothing other than realtors. So it was clear that she put more effort in to selling it. Kelsey promoted my house negotiated like an expert. She was able to get $28,000 more than the ask. Then we found a new house to purchase and the purchase went smoothly too. Kelsey is professional, understands the business very well, always got back to me in a timely manner, calmed my nerves when needed, was flexible and always ready to look at houses. She went over and above all while expecting a new baby. She is the best realtor I have ever used. I highly recommend her. You wont be disappointed.
      Location:
      Loading map