Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Jessica F.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIEDKelsey is the best!! She is so knowledgeable, responsive, great attitude, and overall a pleasure to spend our home buying experience with! Were already recommending her to our friends and family, and would love to work with her again in the future!
Lauren M.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED I cant recommend Kelsey and Kistle Realty enough! Although my property hunt definitely took a minute, it was SO worth the wait. We were looking for a true unicorn, a property that could meet both my personal and business needs, with the right mix of residential and commercial possibilities, and due to diligence and persistence, we found it. It checked every box and then some. What really stood out was Kelseys willingness to think outside the box throughout the entire process. Finding the right property took creativity, patience, and persistence, and she was there through all of it. Kistle Realty is also a family-owned business, and you genuinely feel that difference. They care about their clients, treat you like family, and the relationship doesnt end at closing. Kelsey continues to check in and recommend trusted local contractors, services, and homeowner resources whenever I need them. Highly recommend Kelsey and the entire Kistle Realty team!
User8633333
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey is filled with energy and motivated. She had a few offers right away when selling my house, when other realtors did not. We changed nothing other than realtors. So it was clear that she put more effort in to selling it. Kelsey promoted my house negotiated like an expert. She was able to get $28,000 more than the ask. Then we found a new house to purchase and the purchase went smoothly too. Kelsey is professional, understands the business very well, always got back to me in a timely manner, calmed my nerves when needed, was flexible and always ready to look at houses. She went over and above all while expecting a new baby. She is the best realtor I have ever used. I highly recommend her. You wont be disappointed.
Umit A.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Working with Kelsey was a great experience from start to finish. She was responsive, organized, and stayed on top of every detail, which made the whole process much smoother and less stressful. A big thank you as well to attorney Marleen, inspector Ryan, and Stephanie at the title company aEUR" everyone was professional, helpful, and great to work with. Highly recommend Kelsey and her team!
Baverogary
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED I was very happy with having Kelsey as my agent. She was extremely helpful and a pleasure to work with. Kelsey always got back to me ASAP with answers to all my questions (and I had a lot)! Her knowledge and level of expertise is top notch and resulted in the purchase of my dream home. I also used Kelsey to sell my prior home and we closed in less than a month!
Tina Y.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was fantastic. Her knowledge about each property we visited was incredible and she pointed out the smallest details for us to pay attention to when we visited each home. She knew exactly the right questions to ask and how to set us up in the best position possible to find our house! 100% recommend her to anyone looking to purchase a new home!
Jen R.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey is absolutely amazing. Honest, educated, personable and willing to go to bat for any of her clients. We had the pleasure of using her for multiple occasions, over a course of 2 years. We recommend Kelsey to everyone; whether it be renting, buying or selling!! She is your girl!!
Jenpink567
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey is absolutely amazing. Honest, educated, personable and willing to go to bat for any of her clients. We had the pleasure of using her for multiple occasions, over a course of 2 years. We recommend Kelsey to everyone; whether it be renting, buying or selling!! She is your girl!!
Denise S.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey Kistle is a true professional. Her knowledge, guidance, and positive support in assisting us with our search for our home made for a smooth process. Were happy to be back in Jersey and if youre searching for a home here, call Kelsey!
Sj O.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey Kistle was truly wonderful to work with while selling my home. She was extremely knowledgeable, genuinely caring, and consistently on top of every detail, which made the entire process smooth and stress-free. I couldnt have asked for a better experience and wouldnt recommend anyone else.
Babyblues163
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was and is a pleasure to work with. She took charge in helping us navigate through this whole buying and selling process. She is very knowledgeable, and we are very happy that she was able to help us through this important part of our lives.
Nicole K.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was absolutely phenomenal to work with!!!! She was responsive, professional, and friendly throughout the entire experience. Her go-getter attitude and dedication made a huge difference, and we highly recommend her!!!
Alfonso D.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED You know when youre buying a house and everyone says, aEURoeMake sure you have aces on your teamaEUR?aEUR"and you think, aEURoeYeah, but where am I really going to find someone that good?aEUR? Well, look no further. Kelsey is that good. Shes on top of every detail, resourceful, smart, and incredibly knowledgeable. Shes available day and night, and she goes above and beyond to make sure you find the right house for you. She never pushes you toward a property just to make a sale: in fact, shell tell you flat out if a house isnt right. Kelsey is truly on your team, not just trying to close a deal. Shes one in a million.
Jesse B.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey Kistle was amazing! She, and the entire kistle realty team, are the best in Sussex County for a reason! She goes above and beyond for you and remains completely transparent and accessible throughout the entire process! Would always recommend Kelsey and the Kistle Realty team for your buying and selling needs! Thank you, Kelsey!
Bman5225
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was awesome to work with! Her knowledge, advice, and guidance all helped us tremendously throughout the entire process. She is, hands down, the best realtor in the area!!
Zuser20180121062403584
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED I recently had the pleasure of working with Kelsey Kistle at Kistle Realty to sell my house, and I cannot recommend her highly enough! From the very beginning, Kelsey demonstrated exceptional communication skills, keeping me informed every step of the way. She was always available to answer my questions and provide valuable insights that helped ease the selling process. What impressed me the most was her tenacity as a negotiator. Kelsey fought hard to secure the best possible deal for my property, always with my best interests in mind. It was clear that she genuinely cared about achieving a positive outcome for me, and her dedication made all the difference. If youre looking for a real estate agent who will go above and beyond, look no further than Kelsey Kissel. Her professionalism, knowledge, and personal touch truly set her apart. Thank you, Kelsey, for making this experience so smooth and successful!
Pedersendana0
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was there for us every step of the way! Responsive almost immediately and she made sure everyone did their part and got things done and answers right away. I highly recommend her she has knowledge of the area, the process, and all the mechanics worling parts your house needs. I love my home and the stress free process she made for us!
Christina R.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Working with Kelsey was an outstanding experience! She expertly guided us in finding our perfect home, showcasing her deep knowledge and professionalism every step of the way. Kelsey was always honest, friendly, and responsive, addressing all our questions and concerns with valuable insights. Her commitment to going above and beyond made the entire process enjoyable. We wholeheartedly recommend Kelsey and appreciate everything she has done for us!
Hannahvanwoudenberg
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was outstanding!! Not only is she easy to communicate with but she also went above and beyond every step through our process! We really appreciate how hard she worked for us as we searched through homes, and when we finally were in the process of buying ours, she was always on top of everything! Also, sweet bonus, she gave us a very personalized welcome basket for our new home with toys for our son, and a little something for baby on the way. Kelsey is so personable and lovely and were so thankful she was able to help us purchase our dream home!
User4195937
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey and her team were extremely thorough and informative throughout the process! She was extremely responsive and kept us informed of expectations at every step. She took what I expected to be a stressful situation and turned it into a very easy going experience. I highly recommend Kelsey and her team at Kistle Realty!!
Scottschwemmer
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey Kistle was a pleasure to work with. Not only is she professional and knowledgeable, she's a great person. Very trustworthy. For months she helped my family search for a waterfront property in New Jersey. However, the lean market forced us to consider other states and we bought a house outside of New Jersey. Kelsey was always on point and somehow maintained her sweet disposition despite encountering some stressful situations. I highly recommend her.
Jennifer W.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey has truly been an amazing rockstar throughout our home buying process! She was very responsive with any questions and was flexible when trying to choose times for house showings. Whenever we went to see a place, she could immediately tell you everything about the home/space and town. With her phenomenal knowledge, she has a great eye for what to look for whether good or bad. From flooring/cabinetry, HOA relations, water heaters/pumps, ventilations in attics, etc. You name it and she knows the answer, including the difference between a cheap home reno or something of good quality that will last. This was super helpful to us with it being our first time purchasing a home. Also, if a place didn't seem right for us, she never made it feel like we were wasting her time. We are very grateful with the entire process and are so thrilled about our new townhome!!
Sofia V.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED We had a fantastic experience working with Kelsey and Franny on finding our 1st own home. Found them by chance, and it was definitely the luckiest chance ever. Could not have done it without this crew by our side. They are simply MILES above and beyond any average seller agent: knowledgable, responsive, incredibly energetic and able to find a solution for any challenge. We had a few bumps in the road, and Kelsey always resolved them expertly. She is also well connected in the area and can recommend the best contracts, etc. The negotiation strategy we developed together was also excellent and allowed us to secure a dream property on great terms. 10 out of 10 - would highly recommend this team to anyone buying or selling in NJ.
Sshubilla66
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was absolutely amazing through the home sale process & when the time comes I will definitely call on her to help me with my home buying process! My sale was a divorce sale situation. Divorce can be a devastating & difficult time & her patience, empathy & compassion went above & beyond. Kelsey Kistle is a boss lady & I am so proud of her! She steps up to the plate & does what needs to be done to get it done! I highly recommend her!!
Keith R.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey did an excellent job from the house hunting stage all the way through to us closing on the house of our choice. She was probably the only part of the home buying process that wasnt frustrating. I will recommend her to anyone who asks about a realtor!
Shpaperclip
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey helped us in both selling and buying and we couldnt have been more impressed or happy with both outcomes. Her knowledge in both areas was super helpful and it helped make both processes so much smoother. Any questions we had she answered no problem and anything she wasnt sure about she found out. Thank you so much for helping us out and we will definitely be recommending you to anyone we know who may be looking to buy and/or sell!
Kyle99f
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was super helpful and was amazing to work with. Any questions we had Kelsey either knew the answer or found out the answer and got back to us very quickly. Thank you so much Kelsey.
Alexis S.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED First and foremost - Kelsey amazing to work with! My family was moving from out of state and needed someone who was willing to work hard to place us in the right spot. Kelsey was a workhorse and went above and beyond throughout the entire process of purchasing a home. She took notes throughout each showing, helped us narrow down our search areas based on family needs, and sent endless listings that met our criteria and weeded through the listings that didn't. Kelsey was clearly passionate about helping us find the right home - she was candid about her impressions and openly discussed likes/dislikes & pros/cons of each property based on her understanding of our needs and desires. Throughout the process I felt like we were truly a team and Kelsey had our best interests in mind. We bought during the 'crazy market' but Kelsey remained positive and we ended up exactly where we needed to be. Kelsey is who you want to walk you through this process, she is invested in her clients and the person you want on your team.
Barbknowles130
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey helped to make a nerve-wracking process understandable and less stressful. She made herself available at all times. Kelsey worked hard representing our needs and interests. We will recommend Kelsey to people we know who are looking to purchase or sell their homes and property.
M C.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was a pleasure to work with and worked a swift by for me. Kelsey helped through the entire process of buying and was very helpful looking at houses before she found me the one I liked
Kacey S.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED HIGHLY recommend Kelsey to anyone that is looking to buy or sell. She is open and honest with you. She has a good feel of what her clients want and will keep them on the right direction. She won't let you settle for less which is great. Made our first home buying experience a breeze! Always there for us when we had questions or wanted to see multiple homes in one day. When it came to negotiation, she was right there for us especially when we were unsure if our terms were unreasonable. Overall the experience of working with kelsey is amazing.
Pgallagher1457
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey is the best! She's very personable and friendly! She doesn't make this process feel like a nightmare at all! She would help out with stuff that I have never heard of or ever seen a realtor do to make sure her clients are happy and taken care of! I will recommend her to anyone I know looking for a house!! Best realtor I have ever delt with!! Doesn't try to hide anything from you and is straight forward with laying everything out and actually looks for what your looking for and won't let you just settle on a house which really speaks volumes to me!! She helped find the perfect house for us! Anyone ever looking for a friendly, very knowledgeable person call Kelsey!!
S6v7h82mhc
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey Kistle made our home buying and selling experience a flawless event. She is outstanding at what she does and all of the other people that she suggested to us (Mortgage Company, Home Inspector, Surveyor and Real Estate Lawyer) were also exceptional. We highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home.
Stephanie C.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was an amazing agent - she made the process of selling our house much less stressful. She was very knowledgeable and super responsive to all of our questions, and I am confident that she is the reason we sold our home for as much as we did. We also decided to use Kelsey to help us purchase our next home as we had such a great experience - Would highly recommend Kelsey to anyone buying or selling their home!
Ecasson3
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kistle reality a true one stop shop! We met Kelsey through zillow and it was a perfect fit from day one! The whole Kistle team is amazing. Highly suggest using Kistle for your next sale or purchase!
Robert L.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED I am extremely impressed with the knowledge, work ethic and overall skills that Kelsey has demonstrated from our initial meeting to when we closed on the sale of our home. Kelsey was true to her word as she keep me informed and up to date from the start of marketing our home (always taking the initiative in addressing any issue or concern quickly and professionally. Over the last 25 years I have worked with a few realtors and know one displayed the confidence, knowledge and focus as did Kelsey.I would highly recommend anyone who is considering buying or selling a home to reach out to Kelsey. I assure you that it would be the best decision you made.Bob O.Hamburg NJ
Zuser20150103102904518
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey Kistle was like having "Alexa" for my Real Estate questions and concerns. I received real time responses including phone calls. I have been a business owner for many years. I was impressed by her knowledge and her presentation. Her cheerful upbeat personality makes her a superstar. I would recommend her to everyone I can.
J F.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey is a very knowledgeable and very responsive to inquiries. Our first offer backed out of the sale and within an hour we had a second offer, and that sale was finalized and the closing went off as originally scheduled without a hitch. Kelsey is a top knock Real Estate Agent and with her bubbling personality she is a pleasure to deal with.
Gelyf
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kistles were amazing through the whole process. They have sold multiple homes FOR our family and sold multiple homes TO our family. Knowledgeable, honest, and hard working.
Jlatawiec11
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED She will be in your corner and fight for you. Very trustworthy and a hard worker. If there is any concerns or worries she is very approachable and will go the extra mile to help you out.
Zuser20190915092554578
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED It was our pleasure to work with Kelsey through process of purchasing our new home.She was very much helpful and was always there for us.We consider ourselves lucky to had such a good and honest person working with us.Highly recommended.Thank you, Kelsey.
Stephanie Y.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was very professional and helped us with all our questions during the rental process. She provided us with certain contacts to be able to get the best services in order to get our rental property up and running. I highly recommend her!
Bobbyboats1234
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was a pleasure to deal with. Responsive and attentive. Always knew where we stood in the process... She knows the aEURoetricks of the tradeaEUR? to get the deal done..... Kistle Realty Rules!
Pcwang22
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED It was a pleasure working with Kelsey on the purchase of a lakefront home. She has an intimate knowledge of the towns in Sussex County and her attention to detail made the process run that much smoother. I would be happy to work with her in the future and recommend her without reservation.
Eetay4
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED We love Kelsey! She is attentive, knowledgeable, and always available. She helped us find what we were looking for and will definitely use her service in the future. We recommend her to all home buyers.
Rosest1009
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey was very knowledgeable, patient, organized, personable and dedicated. She was able to limit down what we wanted even when we didnt know what we wanted. She went above and beyond with sending searches and when were about to give up she found the house we currently purchased. Thanks Kelsey ! Stacy & Anthony & Debbie
Daeberli68
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED She was incredible! She new what I was looking for and did not stop til we found something! Listing after listing and hours back and forth. Kelsey was friendly, courteous but most of all honest!! Best 1st time experience with a realtor or shall I say now friend! Would recommend to everyone!!!!Thanks Kelsey youre the best!!!!
Alisondmadden
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey is the BEST! She is very professional, friendly, honest, knowledgeable and hard working. I honestly believe we would not have been able to purchase the house of our dreams without her help and expertise. Our lender required certain work to be done to the home prior to closing, which was a logistical hassle for everyone involved (especially in the middle of a pandemic!), and Kelsey made it all run so smoothly. She truly went above and beyond for us every step of the way! We would highly recommend her for either selling or purchasing a home!!
Potential T.
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey has been knowledgeable, resourceful and overall extremely helpful in the process of finding my house, from start to finish. As a first-time homebuyer, I needed guidance and reassurance. She provided that in spades, and alleviated a lot of the stress associated with the entire process.
Hogmire
Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle
ZillowVERIFIED Kelsey Kistle is very professional and friendly. She made sure to stay on top of every step of our home buying process and to answer all of our questions. She was very accommodating and flexible with our needs. She went above and beyond in terms of making this experience as easy as possible.
View All Listings