YOUR NEIGHBORHOOD GUIDE · SHELTER ISLAND, NY
Get to know
Hay Beach.
Explore Hay Beach in Shelter Island, NY: nearby homes, schools and everyday places.
LIFE IN HAY BEACH
Get a feel for Hay Beach.
Hay Beach is a neighborhood in Shelter Island, NY. This guide brings together a housing snapshot and places to explore in and around the community.
LOCAL KNOWLEDGE MAKES A DIFFERENCE
Work with Top Real Estate Agents in Hay Beach
Explore top real estate agents in Shelter Island who serve the Hay Beach neighborhood. Compare their experience, verified reviews, and profiles. A neighborhood-specific rating for Hay Beach is not currently available.
Richard Susan Connelly
Douglas Elliman Real Estate, Nassau, Suffolk
Hampton Bays, NY
10 Years of Experience
Joshua Maziarz
Property Professionals Realty
Hicksville, NY
11 Years of Experience
Carolina LaFurno
Carolina LaFurno
Hampton Bays, NY
1 Years of Experience
A LOOK AT THE MARKET
Hay Beach Housing Market
Asking prices come from active listings. Recorded sales cover to . A dash means that figure was not available.
What kinds of homes are here?
37 residential property records give a broader picture of Hay Beach, including homes that aren’t for sale.
Updated 2026-10-04. 3 land or other records are excluded from this housing mix. These are property classifications, not a census of individual homes.
How does Hay Beach compare?
Compare median asking prices across Shelter Island neighborhoods.
| Neighborhood | Median asking price | Compared with Hay Beach | Sale price / sq ft | Recorded sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hay Beach This neighborhood | $62,500 | — | — | 0 |
| Shelter Island Heights Historical District | $60,000 | 4% lower | — | 0 |
| Little Ram Island | — | — | — | 1 |
Median asking price and price per square foot come from the same listing sample as the neighborhood cards. Recorded sales cover 2025-10-04 to 2026-10-04. A dash means that figure was not available.
Explore nearby neighborhoods in Shelter Island
Shelter Island Heights Historical District ↗
- Median asking price
- $60,000
- / sq ft
- —
- Active listings
- Not available
- properties in discovery sample
- 50
CNearby schools · estimated
4/10 · 1 schools
Little Ram Island ↗
- Median asking price
- —
- / sq ft
- —
- Active listings
- Not available
- properties in discovery sample
- 10
CNearby schools · estimated
4/10 · 1 schools
Median asking price is the midpoint of listing prices in the discovery sample. A dash means that figure was not available. Photos show community or nearby landmarks.
See all featured Shelter Island neighborhoods →THE CITY AROUND YOU
Shelter Island demographics & households
Citywide context for a move to Hay Beach. These figures describe Shelter Island as a whole.
Explore Shelter Island’s age distribution
From FastExpert’s existing Shelter Island city-data source, retrieved 2026-10-04; source year was not supplied. Explore all Shelter Island city data →
FIND YOUR PLACE HERE
Homes for sale in Hay Beach
No properties are currently available in Hay Beach. Explore homes for sale in nearby neighborhoods.
For sale3 beds · 2 baths · 1,352 sq ft
775 Ridge Dr
Glendale, CA
For sale4 beds · 2.5 baths · 1,839 sq ft
10320 Nassau Avenue
Sunland, CA
For sale5 beds · 4 baths · 3,223 sq ft
2600 Legend Ln
Rowland Heights, CA
For sale0 beds · 0 baths · 3,443 sq ft
3425 West 15th Street
Los Angeles, CA
For sale3 beds · 2 baths · 1,348 sq ft
537 N Cummings St
Los Angeles, CA
For sale3 beds · 2 baths · 1,100 sq ft
3643 1st Avenue
Glendale, CA
For sale5 beds · 4 baths · 3,378 sq ft
1920 Flint Rock Road
Diamond Bar, CA
For sale2 beds · 2 baths · 1,095 sq ft
4900 North Grand Avenue
Covina, CA
For sale2 beds · 2 baths · 1,186 sq ft
10604 Valley Spring Lane
Toluca Lake, CA
For sale4 beds · 2 baths · 2,048 sq ft
7544 Owens Street, Tujunga
Los Angeles, CA
For sale0 beds · 0 baths · 3,026 sq ft
2200 West Burbank Boulevard
Burbank, CA
For sale0 beds · 0 baths · 14,102 sq ft
2501 South Santa Fe Avenue
Vernon, CA
KEEP EXPLORING
Get to know Shelter Island.
Explore the broader area’s housing and demographic context.
Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions About Hay Beach
Common questions about homes, the housing market, and daily life in Hay Beach, Shelter Island.
What types of homes are in Hay Beach?
Answer here
How Competitive Is the Hay Beach Housing Market?
Answer here
Is Hay Beach, Shelter Island a good neighborhood to live in?
Answer here
Pros and cons of living in Hay Beach, Shelter Island?
Answer here
Cost of living in Hay Beach, Shelter Island?
Answer here
How can I find a real estate agent serving Hay Beach?
Answer here
When is the best time to sell real estate in Hay Beach?
Answer here
When is the best time to buy real estate in Hay Beach?
Answer here
Sources, dates & how we calculate estimates
Nearby places and photos come from an approved snapshot. Viewing this page does not call Google Places. A controlled refresh can still search within 5 km of the center. Recreation combines park, lake, trail and club searches, removes duplicates and keeps results within 5 miles. Restaurant ranking balances star ratings with review counts; fast-food, convenience stores and places marked as not offering dine-in are excluded.
Housing mix uses residential property records, including homes that are not for sale. Market prices use the most recent recorded qualifying sale per property within 2025-10-04 to 2026-10-04. Transfers identified as non-market transactions and records without a positive sale amount are excluded. Medians appear with at least 10 sales; price per square foot also requires a recorded home size. Property classifications and neighborhood definitions may differ from local usage. These are dated snapshots, not a complete transaction history or live inventory feed.
School grades are FastExpert estimates based on the mean available ratings for unique public schools found across 4 Hay Beach property samples: A = 8–10, B = 6–under 8, C = 4–under 6, D = 2–under 4, F = 1–under 2. Unrated schools are excluded. Grades do not confirm attendance eligibility.
Shelter Island demographics come from the existing FastExpert city-data source. The city’s source year was not supplied. Top agents use FastExpert’s existing Shelter Island ranking; a Hay Beach-specific ranking is not available yet.