About Susan Oldendorp
Credentials
LICENSE
Awards
-
2026
TOP AGENT
Madison, NJ
2026
TOP AGENT
Chatham, NJ
2026
TOP AGENT
Morristown, NJ
2026
Madison, NJ
2026
Chatham, NJ
2026
Morristown, NJ
Loading recent sales...
Shelly Carey of Oldendorp Group of Compass was amazing to work with! My wife and I were first-time homebuyers and did not know how to start the process, but having Shelly made everything so comfortable and easy. Shelly was extremely responsive with any questions we had or scheduling visits for properties we saw on the compass app (which was very helpful). We felt that Shelly knew exactly what we were looking for when it came to the style of home and the town that would fit best. The home we were fortunate enough to by came way of Shelly's recommendation, and it was the perfect match. The real estate market can be very stressful and overwhelming, and Shelly was able to guide us through the process and make it enjoyable. My wife and I cannot thank Shelly enough for all the help and would 100% recommend for anyone looking for a home!
We were on the lookout for a piece of land mid last year, to purchase and came across Sasha at Oldendorp as we went through the process. Working with Sasha was one of the most positive experiences we have ever had in working with realtors. Sasha is professional, highly responsive, diligent, extremely enterprising and always working for you to ensure your best interests are always front and center at all times. He not only helped us with research about different properties we were interested in, but also used his extensive network in helping us find the right professional, be it legal support or professionals in various fields including inspections or financial institutions. Sasha went above and beyond we finalized and purchased our property and we consider him not just as our realtor but a trusted advisor. We would definitely highly recommend Sasha for anyone in the market looking for a reliable realtor to work with.
Charlie did an amazing job helping us find a new construction home and navigating the complex construction and closing process. He was always patient and responsive, and brought a lot of valuable local knowledge and connections to the table. I would heartily recommend Charlie and the Oldendorp Group.
My experience with Anthony Acosta, Oldendorp Group of Compass NJ was exceptional! I find him very knowledgeable about the local market, always available to answer my questions and address all concerns. He listened attentively to our needs and preferences, provided valuable insights into different neighborhoods, provided the list of properties on sale, helped in visiting and guided me every step of the way. From our initial consultation to closing day, Anthony demonstrated his professionalism throughout. He is pretty smart in follow-up with all partners, like attorney, sellers agent, lenders, inspector and HoA if applicable to gather all the details for everyone needs and he went above and beyond to make the buying process smooth and stress-free. I highly recommend Anthony Acosta for anyone in search of a reliable and skilled buyer's and seller agent. I am also taking his help in selling my home.
Worked with this realtor 2 years ago. Complete waste of time. I had to provide her with addresses of places to go. Never made an attempt to find properties or scope them out before seeing them. She had very limited knowledge for construction .Always had an excuse of family outings in the summer and was not available. Very inexperienced and no knowledge of area or towns in North Jersey. Absolutely would not recommend, extreme disappointment
When we reached out to Susan on a Friday night to discuss selling our family home in Madison, she answered immediately and agreed to meet with us the next morning. In that first in-person conversation, Susan?s knowledge of the Madison market as well as her thoughtful approach to valuation confirmed that working with her was the right choice for us. She knew we were ready to get the house on the market as soon as possible and within five days of that first meeting, she and her team had our home photographed, videos made, necessary staging completed, open house scheduled, and MLS listing up and running. It was incredible! And twelve days from that first meeting we had a signed contract with a buyer. Susan and the Oldendorp team were always available to answer questions or take care of tasks related to the completion of the sale. Susan is the ultimate professional; she listens carefully, focuses on her clients? needs, and is incredibly well-organized. We were extremely happy with the process and the outcome.
Susan and the Oldendorp group could not have been more helpful from guiding us through getting the property ready for sale to ensuring that we got the best possible price. This is the 3rd time we used Oldendorp (2 sales/1 purchase) and we would absolutely choose them again!
The Oldendorp Group exceeded our extremely high expectations. Susan?s reputation for excellence in the industry is well known, which is why we chose her to represent us. As we worked through the process, we learned what an exceptional human being she is on top of being a top notch realtor. If you choose the Oldendorp Group, you can be sure you will have a professional team that is honest, responsive, knowledgeable, and delivers on their promises. We recommend Susan and her team without reservation.
Susan and her team were THE BEST! Beginning way in advance of our move she and her great stager met with us, carefully did an entire walk through and provided us with a thorough ?to do? list to prepare our home for listing. They were responsive, honest, helpful and considerate from beginning to end. Their expertise and professionalism were second to none. We can?t give them a higher recommendation!
Susan did a fantastic job for us. In a challenging and fast-paced real estate market where homes are sold and closed very quickly, Susan effectively assisted us with the home selection, bidding, inspection, and closing process. We are delighted with her work and would definitely use her again.
After living in our house for 13 years, we decided to sell our house and move to a bigger one. When it came to picking agents, we had a decision to make. My wife and I always saw great reviews about Susan in our town throughout the years and decided to work with her based on these excellent reviews and recommendations. Even though everything about her sounded great, we were still worried she wouldnt take us as customers as it was a busy time and our house was on a busy road and difficult to sell. So, we called her thinking she wouldnt be interested. But to our surprise, she was very kind and she agreed to come to our house and meet us. We were amazed by Susan in our first ever meeting when she came to our home. She was extremely knowledgeable about the market and she was the sweetest person you could have as a realtor. She told us what to expect when selling and educated us about the selling process. As first-time sellers, we loved what we heard from Susan and agreed to go with her. This probably was the best decision my wife and I made in at least past 5 years. Our amazement with Susan and her real estate team continued throughout the process. They helped us prepare the house for showings, came up with great marketing materials and continued being flexible with our needs. From the first day on, everything went perfectly. The day house went on the market we received requests for 36 showings even before the first open house. As a result, we received multiple offers after only 2 days and picked the offer that made the most sense for our family. Susan never tried to sway us in our decision. She was informative but neutral. She patiently waited us while we were deciding and she was supportive whenever we had a question about the details of the offers. In the end, we signed the contract with the buyers we chose. Susan and her team continued their support throughout the closing process. Since this was the first time we were selling a house, we didnt know much about what to expect during closing. Susan continued to be on our side until the day of the closing. And after the closing, she surprised us with a great gift that we will keep with our family forever. We loved working with Susan and her team very much. We felt respected, we felt supported and we felt like we were being treated like we were celebrities. All this support from Susan for a family who owned one of the cheapest houses on a busy road. If we were selling one of those multi-million-dollar homes, maybe we could justify Susans great attention and support. But nope, Susan doesnt differentiate between her customers. This is the Susan we worked with and the Susan we loved. This was a long review. I hope we didnt bore you with details. Go with Susan and her team. You will not be disappointed.
Susan is one of a kind! She not only is your realtor but she becomes your friend and therapist. She truly cares and it shows. She takes the time to speak with you about anything and will always answer your call. Susan helped me so much and I will continue to use her in the future.
Susan and her team of professionals helped me navigate the difficulties of selling a property as part of an estate at the close of 2021. Susan reached out to me immediately and was responsive throughout the entire transaction. Only ever a phone call or text away - very supportive and provided all the necessary advice and recommendations for estate sales, clean out, and repairs. I would highly highly recommend Susan Oldendorp to anyone looking to buy or sell seamlessly in this unprecedented market. If I could give her 6 stars I would!!
Susan and her team of professionals helped me navigate the difficulties of selling a property as part of an estate at the close of 2021. Susan reached out to me immediately and was responsive throughout the entire transaction. Only ever a phone call or text away - very supportive and provided all the necessary advice and recommendations for estate sales, clean out, and repairs. I would highly highly recommend Susan Oldendorp to anyone looking to buy or sell seamlessly in this unprecedented market. If I could give her 6 stars I would!!
Susan is everything you would want in a realtor?knowledgeable, understanding, trustworthy, very careful in managing the process and driven to succeed in the sale of your home. We could not have done it without her and highly recommend Susan and her team.
Introduction with this realtor was through Zillow . A property of interest to us came up for sale & was promoted on Zillow. Touring said property with an agent recommended by Zillow was both helpful & very convenient.
Susan Olendorp is a highly competent and organized professional. She helped us sell our home for the full price, on the first day it was listed. Her honest recommendations for what we should do to get our best price were exactly what we needed to sell our home quickly for a great price. We are grateful for Susan?s guidance.
Choosing Charlie to be our real estate agent was the best decision we made in our home buying experience. He is incredibly knowledgeable, patient and really cares about his clients. He was always realistic and honest with us about the houses and put our interests first. We changed our search parameters and wish list 50 times and he was always supportive and optimistic. We found the right house several months ahead of when we thought we would and Charlie carried us through a tough negotiation. The agency is truly full-service, they take care of everything! We are now in our dream neighborhood in a house we love that is perfect for our family. We are still amazed that it happened in a market like this and all our thanks are to Charlie.
Working with the Oldendorp Group (mostly Susan) was a pleasure. They kept us informed, helped us in making decisions, and most importantly, kept their eyes on the little details that otherwise we may have missed. Susan would always go above and beyond, and delivered more than she promised. I would definitely recommend her and her team.
Choosing Susan to sell our home was the best decision we made. She is incredibly knowledgeable, warm and so responsive. We are busy parents with two little kids and we loved that she was so hands-on, guiding us through every step of the process. She was upfront, clear and always put our best interests first. Her team handled EVERYTHING?from staging, to submitting inspections to the town and even dropping off water/Gatorade for our movers. Our family was completely amazed by just how full-service the Oldendorp Group is. Our listing photos and materials were gorgeous and our house sold in 2 days for an amazing price. Her experience and skills as a negotiator were invaluable as we navigated multiple offers. We were thrilled and give her our most emphatic recommendation.
From the moment we met Beth at the first home we toured we felt immediately comfortable. Beth is a true professional, who knows the market and area. We just purchased our dream home and it could not have gone more smoothly, thanks to Beth! She was always a text or phone call away, with quick response times to address any of our questions or concerns. Beth?s enthusiasm for real estate and understanding of the buyer?s goals were evident. I would strongly recommended Beth for your real estate needs!
We absolutely LOVE Susan!!! She is one in a million! We are an analytical pair so when we decided to sell our home in Chatham, we prepared an analysis of local home sales to determine which agent we wanted to use. The data pointed conclusively to Susan. We reached out to her and within the hour, she responded. That responsiveness and professionalism continued throughout. She was always available to us and made us feel like we were her only clients! That level of customer service is hard to find! There are not words to express how grateful we are to Susan and her stellar team and how fortunate we feel to have had Susan lead us through the home selling process from start to finish and beyond. Susan brought in professional stagers and worked with us to develop a pricing and listing plan that we and she believed in. We sold our house for $130,000 over listing with 24 showings and 6 offers in 4 days!! We were thrilled! But the experience we had with Susan went beyond the data. She led with kindness and generosity that really set a new gold standard. Selling a home and moving is stressful and it was so wonderful to work with such an outstanding team. In addition to selling our home, we had to put down our 16 year old family dog right in the middle of the process. Susans compassion, respect and understanding for what we were going through was heart-warming and really helped us through that very tough time. Not only is Susan amazing but she also effectively leverages an outstanding, very skilled team to ensure that everything runs smoothly and on schedule. Debbie did an outstanding job of managing the showings schedule and helping us every single step of the way. Among other things, Neal managed the boroughs inspections for us which was a great help and stress relief and even brought our movers water and gatorade on moving day. Oldendorp is a well-oiled machine that works seamlessly!! Now that our house has sold and we have left the area, we really miss Susan! She became not only our agent, but also our friend and sage advisor. Thank you Susan and team for making a stressful time an amazing experience!
We worked with Susan to sell our home in Madison, NJ. We chose Susan and her firm based on her stellar reputation, personal knowledge of the community, and proven skills in pricing, marketing and managing the process from listing to closing. Susan exceeded our expectations. She priced our home right and was able to get an offer within days. But her work didnt stop there. She and her team fully managed the process in terms of setting up necessary inspections and facilitating the closing process. This was a wonderful experience. We couldnt have been happier with all she did for us...we highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell their home.
What a pleasure to work with Monica. She is knowledgeable, responsive and positive. She is clear and direct with a nice dose of sensitivity. Professional and always on time. I would recommend her over and over again
Charlie made the process of buying a home, in a super competitive market, about as easy and low stress as could be. He always picked up the phone, and if he didnt know the answer, he would always follow up. He stuck with me through a long process and saw it through to the end. I dont know what I would have done without him. Good realtor, and a great person.
I highly recommend Susan Oldendorp and her team. Her and her teams extensive experience in the business is reflected in how they handled our overall transaction: masterful, efficient, well connected, excellent negotiation skills, professional in all areas, very responsive to all our questions no matter how trivial. If we can give her 10 stars, I will. Amazing realtor and business team! I would avail of her services again in the future. Keep up the great work.
Charlie made what we thought would be a stressful experience anything but stressful. He and his team helped us find the home we plan to be in for years. They provide excellent service and are true problem solvers for all of the needs we had. Would recommend to anyone.
Pleasure working with Susan and her team. Very professional and knowledgeable about the market! She kept us updated and pushed through the process so that it was a smooth sale.
Susan was with me every little and big step of the way. She explained what I needed to do and always got back to me when I needed help. It was very emotional and she guided me step by step with no pressure and always very professional.
Susan and her team are hard-working, honest, and excellent negotiators. Susan came to our house one day after I called to discuss listing it. She brought all the data to support a suggested listing price. She and her stager came by later to give me steps to get the house ready to sell. We followed all the steps and had the house listed within 2 weeks. We got multiple offers above our asking price on the first day. If you want a hassle-free expert who has a pulse on the market and will work tirelessly to sell your home and get you the best price, call Susan Oldendorp and her team today! Do not wait...it will be worth your time and consideration.
Susan was fantastic. She is such a professional and it showed from our first meeting which made selecting her to sell our house easy. She was great through the entire process of getting the house on the market and helped us get top dollar for our home. She is a great directory of trade partners ready to assist with either preparation for sale or any inspection issues that may arise. The entire Oldendorp team was there to support us throughout the process. We would recommend Susan and the Oldendorp team without reservation to anybody looking to sell their house.
Susan was incredibly engaged with us during the entire sale process. From planning the house preparation process, pricing and close, she was always available, responsive and thoughtful in responding to our questions and concerns. She demonstrated an intimate knowledge of the market dynamics, and helped us achieve a terrific outcome with our sales price and closing timeframe. Susan is surrounded by an exceptional team and Neal and Deb are terrific! We?d highly recommend Susan and her team to anyone!!
This is my fourth experience with The Oldendorp Group, and my first with Charlie representing me as a buyer. Charlie helped me find the perfect home, and was incredible throughout the negotiation and closing process. We ran into a few snags which he handled with a complete sense of professionalism, determination and calm. He is an absolute pleasure to work with. I highly recommend reaching out to Charlie for your real estate needs. You will be glad you did!
It was an absolute pleasure working with Zander Oldendorp. His years of experience and knowledge truly made what could have been an extremely stressful process feel like a breeze. Id highly recommend Zander to anyone looking to buy/sell a home!
I would highly recommend Susan Oldendorp. Attentive to my needs at every stage of staging, selling, inspections and closing issues made an emotional move much easier.
We had a wonderful experience working with Zander Oldendorp and the Oldendorp/Compass Team with regard to the sale of our family home in Morristown, NJ. Having lived in our home for 20 years plus, Zander made the process understandable, efficient and painless. For every question we had, Zander had an answer and a solution. He helped set the listing price perfectly and the house sold quickly. He introduced us to a top notch home stager who did a marvelous job! His team even interfaced with town building officials to facilitate all approvals for the sale of the house and a continuing certificate of occupancy. All in all, we highly recommend Zander and his team as we could not have been more pleased with his services!
We were first-time homebuyers who came to Zander with a long list of unique must-have?s which were seemingly impossible to find under one roof. Through his impressive network and tireless commitment, we found our forever home. Zander?s local expertise and his extensive knowledge of the market were particularly impressive. He was accessible and responsive, always ensured that we were the first ones in to see new listings, and was even able to show us quite a few off-market homes. He was a trusted source of much-needed guidance during the negotiation, inspection and closing process, and calmly steered us through to a relatively stress-free transaction. On a personal note, Zander is patient, considerate and respectful, with a strong work ethic and deep rooted integrity. We are so fortunate to have worked with Zander and the Oldendorp Group, who took us under their wing and treated us like family. We highly recommend them for all of your real estate needs.
Excellent sense of the market and best approach to selling our home. Very detail oriented, which significantly simplifies the entire process. Strong supporting team handles many tasks that would otherwise fall on the buyer/seller. Honest and trustworthy, and a pleasure to work with. This was our third transaction with The Oldendorp Group and we were extremely pleased with every one of them.
We had an excellent experience working with Zander. He knows everything there is to know about the area and market and took us around several neighborhoods quoting information on endless comp properties. As a parent in the community he understands the schools and what families value. With his extensive knowledge Zander found us a property that was off market and was perfect for us and our family. He has recommended several resources for us to work with such as painters, electricians and contractors. Overall we had a wonderful experience working with him and his team, we cannot recommend The Oldendorp Group enough!
We had an outstanding experience with Susan and her entire team. It was the first time in 15 years we were selling our home. Fortunately, we had Susan to shepherd us through the entire process. Susans experience and knowledge was invaluable, particularly since we were selling into a market upended by the pandemic. She performed a detailed market analysis and helped us arrive at an appropriate price point. From there she arranged professional staging, outstanding marketing, and efficient scheduling of individual realtor visits as well as our open house. As a result, we found a high quality buyer for our home in just one week. Susan also guided us through the offer, attorney review and inspection processes. She provided invaluable guidance and insight that allowed us to negotiate inspection related issues in a manner that was fair, reasonable, and expeditious. I would be remiss in not mentioning the excellent support we received from Susans entire support team which included (but was not limited to): scheduling numerous realtor visits, referrals to helpful and trusted vendors, acting as a concierge on our behalf with the Boro to arrange fire department inspection and final utility billing, and much more. Perhaps, most importantly, she was a calming presence and a trusted confidant who provided us with moral support and reassurance throughout. In sum, I would recommend Susan without hesitation or reservation. As a matter of fact, I enthusiastically recommend her to any of my friends and acquaintances in need of an outstanding Realtor.
Zander is an outstanding agent who provided us with real time market data, advice and guidance throughout the process and access to experts and professionals for inspection and closing. I would highly recommend Zander and the Oldendorp Group!
Zander and his team at the Oldendorp group were phenomenal to work with especially in a very tight market. He helped identify houses timely and guided us through the buying process with a difficult seller. It was an absolute pleasure to work with Zander and his team.
I was selling my late father?s condo. Susan was compassionate, practical, and set reasonable goals for timing and pricing. When a couple of minor roadblocks arose, she always had a ready solution when she called. She handled this emotionally packed transaction with expertise and grace.
My wife and i have lived in 7 different homes around the U.S over the last 30 + years and have had a wide range of experiences with real estate agents. Monica Marucci was the best agent with whom we ever dealt. Her experience, market knowledge, and professionalism is unsurpassed.
The Oldendorp Group, and specifically Charlie, was extremely helpful in the purchase of our first home. Charlie was a true expert on the housing market and the town we were looking in (Chatham). He was extremely easygoing and flexible; working with us as our needs and wants in a house continually changed. He is a great listener, professional, trustworthy, and resourceful. I would highly recommend Charlie and the Oldendorp Group to anyone looking to buy a home in the Northern NJ Area!
Charlie and the whole Oldendorp group were great. We were really impressed with his professionalism and responsiveness. He walked us through the entire process of buying a home in Chatham, and we ended up finding our perfect house and getting into contract in under two weeks. We had a lot of concerns about different parts of the process and Charlie diligently followed up with everything and helped resolve all the issues. He was very knowledgeable about the area and different neighborhoods. He even dropped off drinks for our movers. Highly recommend and we will definitely use Charlie and the Oldendorp group again in the future.
Kim helped us purchase a home in Morristown as first-time buyers. She was very easy to work with and helped guide us to the areas of town that best fit our needs. Kim was great through the entire home buying process. She was responsive and available whenever we needed her, while also making sure we were stayed on top of everything on our end to ensure a smooth closing. If looking to purchase a home in the area, we highly recommend reaching out to Kim!
My wife and I were introduced to Zander through a work colleague to assist in the purchase of a new home. Zander and his team could not have been better. The first phone call provided us comfort that we had the right team bc the focus was on transparency and respect - not only for the process but the individuals we meet along the way. Zander took the necessary time to listen as we walked each home (he was never on his phone around us). His knowledge was evident and allowed him to quickly narrow our search based on OUR priorities. For the negotiation and inspection process, I would not want any other broker. The attention to detail on the inspection was well beyond expectations. I wish I knew more people moving to this area so I could recommend Zander more often.
Monica made our first home buying process as smooth as possible. She is so knowledgable and works incredibly hard to find you the best options and deals. She knows a lot of people in the industry and helps you navigate the complexities each step of the way. Were so glad we were connected with her that we even had my parents work with her for their second home purchase!
Having Zander Oldendorp as our agent was the best choice we could?ve made for the sale of our house. He was professional, knowledgeable, pleasant, hard working and honest. That pretty much sums up everything we wanted in a real estate agent.