About Susan Oldendorp
Specialties
- Sellers
- Buyers
- Residential Property
Awards
-
2025
TOP AGENT
Madison, NJ
2025
TOP AGENT
Morristown, NJ
2025
TOP AGENT
Chatham, NJ
Recent Sales
We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:
- 1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
- 2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.
Susan Oldendorp's Reviews & Ratings
- Responsive
- Professional
- Communicative
- Knowledgeable
- Trustworthy
- Outstanding
- Attentive
- Hard working
- Great for new buyers
- Available Remotely
Pat C
We had the pleasure of working with Terry during our home search. From the very beginning, Terry was incredibly friendly and approachable, making us feel comfortable every step of the way. She took the time to truly understand our needs and preferences, never pushing us into decisions, but always providing thoughtful and informed guidance. What stood out the most was how considerate she was of our timeaEUR"scheduling viewings and meetings that fit our busy schedules without any pressure. Terrys professionalism and personal touch made the entire process smooth and enjoyable. We highly recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor who genuinely cares about their clients needs and makes the home-buying experience a positive one!
David King
Shelly Carey of Oldendorp Group of Compass was amazing to work with! My wife and I were first-time homebuyers and did not know how to start the process, but having Shelly made everything so comfortable and easy. Shelly was extremely responsive with any questions we had or scheduling visits for properties we saw on the compass app (which was very helpful). We felt that Shelly knew exactly what we were looking for when it came to the style of home and the town that would fit best. The home we were fortunate enough to by came way of Shelly's recommendation, and it was the perfect match. The real estate market can be very stressful and overwhelming, and Shelly was able to guide us through the process and make it enjoyable. My wife and I cannot thank Shelly enough for all the help and would 100% recommend for anyone looking for a home!
Kapil Sharma
I couldn't have asked for a better realtor than Tina! I got connected to her through Zillow and gave her a tall order with a tight 3.5 months deadline to buy a house and a strict criteria in terms of what I wanted. In the end, Tina proved to be proactive, incredibly responsive, and deeply knowledgeable. She expertly guided me through a competitive market, never losing momentum despite multiple offers not working out. Her persistence and positive attitude were invaluable, and I'm thrilled with the townhome I eventually found. Highly recommend Tina!
Roppenheimer88
Sarah was an absolute rockstar, first and foremost she was never pushy or just wanted to make a sale, she wanted what was best for my family, we spent countless weekends and months looking for the right home and there were many times that most of the houses were a flop but no matter what Sarah had a positive attitude and made sure we were happy and always had our best interest. I seriously cant recommend Sarah enough. She is an amazing agent to work with. Warm, welcoming and really felt like she was part of our family at the end of our time together.
Swarup Shetty
We were on the lookout for a piece of land mid last year, to purchase and came across Sasha at Oldendorp as we went through the process. Working with Sasha was one of the most positive experiences we have ever had in working with realtors. Sasha is professional, highly responsive, diligent, extremely enterprising and always working for you to ensure your best interests are always front and center at all times. He not only helped us with research about different properties we were interested in, but also used his extensive network in helping us find the right professional, be it legal support or professionals in various fields including inspections or financial institutions. Sasha went above and beyond we finalized and purchased our property and we consider him not just as our realtor but a trusted advisor. We would definitely highly recommend Sasha for anyone in the market looking for a reliable realtor to work with.