Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Noele W.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIEDReid did an outstanding job marketing our condo for sale in a very difficult city with an even more difficult sales climate. He was the 4th realtor we hired for the job and by far and away did the best job. He does all the showings himself and does not rely on associates that dont know the details of the propertyaEUR"the ones that made our home in the Sky so special. He was also masterful with his negotiating skills- gentle but firm and was able to get the job done to everyones satisfaction- both buyer and seller.. Reid knows his market insude and out and I can enthusiastically and whole heartedly recommend him if you are thinking of selling your home. He is simply the best!!
Valentina G.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Kevin was great in handling house tours and communication with the sellers. He has a lot of knowledge and he closely helped us through the whole process. We highly recommend him
Nature S.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED JoAnn did an amazing job helping me sell my home. I lived out of state from where the property was being sold and helped with repairs, showing, and required inspections. She is also very quickly to respond to your questions/inquiries. Highly recommend!
Gadeutsch
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid did a great job helping us sell our home. He helped us price it appropriately and marketed it well. We ended up selling in one day, getting offers above asking price. He and his team helped with the process after contract, working through any issues and getting us through closing quickly and smoothly. I highly recommend Reid!
Rachel G.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED This was my third time working with Reid and he makes the process easier each time. His team has grown in size since our first transaction over 10 years ago, but the experience was just as personalized and supportive. He and/or his team reached out promptly, explained everything simply and were an overall pleasure to work with. Highly recommend!
Mrmayer1030
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid helped us prepare our home to sell and advised us on how to price it to receive the best price. The process was incredibly smooth and Reid and his team were very responsive to any questions that arose. We definitely would use Reid again.
Jillian M.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid and Joann were an incredible asset in buying our home on the Main Line. They know the area inside and out and helped us navigate competitive market dynamics very well. We are thrilled with our purchase and credit their expertise and work ethic in landing our forever home.
Parker B.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid was a pleasure to work with. He is professional, knowledgeable, and very easy to communicate with. He was always responsive to calls, texts, and emails, and provided excellent guidance throughout the process. His market insight, negotiation skills, and support with marketing and showings were invaluable. I was extremely happy with the results and would highly recommend Reid to anyone looking for a real estate professional.
Daniela R.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED The best realtor we could have asked for! Working with Reid was the best decision we made when starting the journey of buying our first home. We had countless questions, and Reid made everything feel manageable and stress-free. He is incredibly knowledgeable, responsive, and always had our best interests in mind. He went above and beyond to secure the best deal possible for us. We couldn't be happier and can't thank Reid enough for all of his help throughout this process. We would not have been able to do it without him!
Richardcohen30
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED I can't say enough about Reid and his team. Always responsive, always helpful and very knowledgeable about the Philadelphia area. I thought it would take me a long time to find what I was looking for. I bought the first place I looked at, all because Reid listened to what was important to me. I've never had such a positive experience buying real estate. Thank you Reid and the Rosenthal Group!
Drgb73
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid was very responsive, informative and helpful through the whole process. He suggested staging the home and listing, helped with identifying contractors, movers, etc. I felt like I got the 5-star service/team that I was looking for.
Rebecca P.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid is the best. He is super responsive, patient, and great at answering questions. He definitely has your back, and I felt comfortable and confident during the whole process.
Zuser20170330190212687
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid was great to work with again. He was familiar with the "comps" in the area and made a good recommendation on price point. He was able to advocate and negotiate on our behalf. We definitely had lots of little and not so little questions for him throughout the process which were answered immediately. We have now purchased two homes and sold one home with Reid and his team. Thank you!
Matthew B.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED We worked with Reid for about two and a half years all in as we had no idea where we wanted to move to necessarily. Through numerous conversations, home showings and leaning into his network of contacts, he helped us focus our search and eventually find the area we wanted to be a part of. Unfortunately inventories were very low, rates were climbing and we didn't see much that interested us in the school districts we were considering. In the end, we opted for new construction, to which Reid was able to negotiate a full finished basement at roughly the same asking price, rent stipend in case it went longer than expected, a 5-figure landscaping credit and additional warranty package. When it came time to sell our new home, Reid found us a very thorough photographer and after having the house listed for about 24-hours, we received an offer about 4.5% over asking with small concessions requested and a 30 day close, which we immediately accepted and cancelled all future showings. That was just the icing on the cake for a long and extremely fruitful relationship. I would highly recommend Reid and his team to anyone looking to buy or sell in the Philadelphia area.
Chris M.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid and team were fantastic! They really helped get the word out about our home, and we were under contract within a week of listing. Highly recommend!
Tim H.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
Reid and the entire Rosenthal Group made selling my Bryn Mawr home on the Main Line easy. His market knowledge and guidance proved to me why he's referred to as the best real estate agent in Philadelphia. Thanks again!
Kimberly S.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Cannot say enough good things about Reid and his team. I have used them for multiple sales, rentals and as a buyer. They are professional, responsive, and go above and beyond for their clients. Reid gets my condos rented and sold in record time. His team is also top notch. You will not regret using Reid and his group. Hands down my best real estate decision!
Daniel M.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid helped us find the perfect home! He always made himself available to answer our many questions and he went above and beyond to ensure all of our needs were met. We really appreciated his expertise and responsiveness throughout the process.
Zuser20140804113523531
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED He was great all around. He was able to sell our home for a good price during a tough market. The experience was smooth and he was professional.
Ryan D.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid did an incredible job on a unique listing within a tough market environment. He was thoughtful in his communication and advice, providing market feedback and data to back up his views. He went above and beyond with the listing as the seller was largely out of town throughout the 6-month listing period. Moreover, Reid masterfully dealt with an unfriendly HOA Board to navigate some thorny issues as they popped up later in negotiations. He brings great experience and the perfect temperament for a tough job!
Barrylkatz7
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid was amazing to work with. From advising on price, to getting the best price, to negotiations with buyer before sale and after inspection, to making sure it all closed on time. Very very highly recommended. And I am in the real estate business, and have bought and sold over 15 properties in the last 15 years. Reid knows his stuff and this is the 3d time I have had the pleasure to work with him.
Gadeutsch
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid did an excellent job for us. I was the executor for the estate of the owner of the property, and Reid was helpful and patient with the probate process that we needed to get through to sell the property. Reid also provided us with great advice regarding the marketing of the property and negotiating the purchase agreement. Reid's knowledge of the Center City real estate market was also very helpful. Reid was accommodating and personable, and he and his team made a somewhat complicated situation much easier. I highly recommend him.
Johanna V.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid is extremely responsive and knows the real estate market well. He is very helpful in smoothing out any concerns you have or if you start overthinking things. His photographer is outstanding and the photos really presented well.
Danielle S.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Samantha was/is a pleasure to work with. She is knowledgeable on the Philadelphia area, and she gives valuable feedback and opinions when asked. Samantha made what is normally a tiring and overwhelming process easy and painless. Samantha is very responsive to both email and text. She is available at all hours to answer a quick question. 100/10, I would work with Samantha (and the Reid Rosenthal group) again in a heartbeat!
Beatricelazaroff
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid was amazing. He is professional and on top of everything. He sent a great photographer to help stage our house and the pictures were fabulous! He sold our house in 3 days. He kept us informed every step of the way and even handled a last- minute crisis before settlement. Reid is personable and funny and we would recommend him highly without reservation.
Mstaccount
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid is a real professional with great attention to details and prompt service always . This is the second time I have used his services and was extremely pleased both times with his level of service, honesty and results
Rhokahn
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid is knowledgeable about the area and was able to match me with the right apartment, respecting my price range and desired aesthetic. He is extremely competent responsive and personable.
Furnari N.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid was the fourth realtor I chose to sell our home in Philadelphia and he should've been the first. At least we eventually got it right! He did what four others could not do--get us to the finish line (I'll add, seamlessly!)--along with the help of his wonderful Marketing Assistant, Joelle Lanvin. Reid was always available, professional, and willing to go the extra mile to sell our home in this extremely difficult market. His team's marketing abilities, even down to the pictures and description of our home, were all top notch. I couldn't recommend Reid and the Rosenthal Group highly enough. Thank you for everything!
Zuser20170330190212687
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid did it again! He made our house search and buying experience seamless and pleasant! It took months of searching and eventually he had a feeling this particular home could work for us...and at a lower price! He was very responsive and always got an answer for anything we needed. Thank you!
4ynk4kdzsc
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid, Brooke and the entire Rosenthal team are exceptional to work with. We first had the pleasure of working with Reid back in 2020 when we were searching for our dream home on the Main Line. They made the buying process easy and seamless during a competitive COVID market. We knew that when we went to sell our Philly townhome this summer that we had to work with them again. Reid had two offers lined up for us, both over ask, within 7 days of being on the market. Reid and his team continued to work with us closely and had great communication right up through closing. If youre looking for a professional, trustworthy and knowledgable realtor, Reid and his team are the perfect fit!
John W.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid was very helpful and great to work with. He was on top of all the different changes throughout the whole selling process and great at communicating with us. In addition, Reid and his team moved quickly and professionally throughout our selling process and I would highly recommend him and the rest of the team.
Inv252
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED We just had Reid Rosenthal selling close on our second home. He is the absolute best at marketing and giving advice in order to make the transition smoothly. We got more for house than we ever wouldve dreamed of. I highly recommend Reid in the Rosenthal group for selling or purchasing a home. They are very professional and make the whole process very easyl
Jostroff
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid Rosenthal stands alone as the most knowledgeable, involved, responsive and authentic realtor I have ever worked with. He has sold 4 properties for us over the past year, ranging in value from $400k to $1.5m. Ive bought and sold at least two dozen properties over the past 30 years. Some to occupy, some for investment. Over this time, I worked with at least 10 different realtors. Ive never been particularly impressed with any of them. I would not have given any the 5 star ratings Ive given to Reid. His organization is well run, proactive and also responsive. It is clear that Reid has integrated his values into his agency.
Alexa L.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid did an amazing job at assisting us during our home search. My husband and I were first time home buyers and therefore very nervous about the entire process, especially in todays environment. Reid was so responsive, thorough, and helpful through the entire journey. He truly exceeded all of our expectations. We are so thrilled to have found the perfect home (and so quickly!) and we couldnt have done it with him! If you are in need of a realtor, he is the man for the job.
Carolynmchan
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid guided me through the process of purchasing an investment property via a 1031 exchange. As an out-of-state investor, I made limited trips to view the units. Reid made sure that he showed me only units that met my criteria, which was very helpful and efficient. He also arranged for my virtual closing and provided great recommendations.
Af102
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Outstanding,responsive and always clarifying step by step the buying process. He showed us the place more than once so we could have a clear idea of the place both during the day and at night accommodating our schedule including weekends and at night. If I buy steel or rent anything in the area I will contact him.
Nora
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED We worked with Reid to sell our home in Philadelphia. Reid and his team were able to help us sell our home within a month, even in a tumultuous market. Cant recommend him enough!
Zuser20170727132434532
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED I had a great experience working with Reid to sell my house. Before meeting with me to discuss whether to move forward with selling, Reid did his research and shared a report with me showing market conditions, similar houses, and an initial pricing recommendation. After meeting with me to hear my goals, he suggested a pricing strategy to get me to my target. Throughout the process Reid supported the sale of my property by hosting open houses, sharing my property with his network, and supporting the negotiation process. He made suggestions and provided advice along the way, and listened to my goals and responded to my needs. Working with Reid was great. He was knowledgable, an advocate for me, and got the job done. I highly recommend him!
Marklove24
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid Rosenthal and Joelle was a great team to work with while selling my condo. Everything was quick, seamless, and stress-free. They were professional and responsive. I highly recommend and would utilize their services whenever I am ready to purchase again.
Zuser20150830152254373
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid was extremely thorough, knowledgeable, and responsive throughout the process of selling my condo in Graduate Hospital! I highly recommend him and his team for any home purchases or sales - he is honest, straightforward, and excellent to work with.
Nancyburrows813
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid puts the aEURoerealaEUR? in realtor. His expertise and professionalism make him an exceptional realtor, but his warmth, sense of humor and lack of pretense make him an absolute pleasure to work with! We always had fun on our search - and Reid found us the perfect house - So thrilled with him and his entire team!
Emilymrush
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid and his team were wonderful! They answered all our questions, gave us good suggestions for how to improve the look of the house and worked well with us to get our house sold quickly. The team also communicated clearly throughout the process and arranged everything for an easy and relatively low-stress experience. From decisions about pricing the house to the photography to the marketing campaign, Reids team was phenomenal. Thanks to their guidance, the house sold in 5 days for more than $50,000 over asking. We are very pleased we chose to work with them over other realtors and highly recommend them.
Melissa E.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED We had a great experience selling our condo with Reid. Reid answered all concerns quickly; managed unexpected problems effectively and was on top of the transaction throughout. Reid is knowledgeable about the market and pricing. This was the 3rd time we tried to sell with different agents and Reid got it done. I would highly recommend Reid for all your real estate needs.
Guest0987
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED She provided a fantastic experience for a first time buyer. She made the search process low stress and the closing process very smooth. Some repairs were needed post-closing and she stayed in control of the punch list with a wide network of repair specialists. Without her, the process would have been overwhelming.
Matthew S.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid's team, including Samantha Milner, were incredibly responsive, transparent, and helpful throughout my first home buying process. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a home.
Kbrenns
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED This review is of Sam Milner, who works with Reid. Sam was referred to me by a friend who tends to be highly critical, yet she referred to Sam as aEURoethe best broker ever!aEUR? Having now used Sam both for the sale of one home and the purchase of another, I can say without any hesitation that my friends assessment was 100% correct - Sam is the best! In short, Sam is super friendly, knowledgeable, incredibly responsive, and, perhaps most importantly, she is completely honest and trustworthy. If you ask her a question and she doesnt know the answer, she will tell you that and then quickly confer with her highly experienced team and come back to you with an answer. Shes patient and understanding with questions and concerns, she explains things calmly, and she makes the process fun and exciting, and minimizes unnecessary stress. Real estate transactions can be stressful, so its important to work with someone who is responsible, communicative, smart, friendly, patient, and honest. Sam is all of that, and more. So I'm beyond grateful to my friend for recommending Sam, and in writing this review I hope to pay it forward.
Kadbkny
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED I worked with Brian from Reid Rosenthal on the purchase of a condo. He was very professional and helpful. He answered any questions that I had and would get back to me promptly with any information that I requested. It was a pleasure working with him.
Daniel G.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED We recently worked with Reid on the purchase of a townhouse in Northern Liberties. As first-time homebuyers, we are glad we connected with Reid! He explained each step of the process, was responsive, and proved to be very skillful at the negotiating table. When we had a hiccup with our title, Reid stepped up to the plate to get the issue resolved, assuaged our concerns, and kept us on track to close. Reid is knowledgable with regard to the Philadelphia market and we felt confident with him on our team. If you are looking to buy or sell a property, Reid is someone who you want in your corner. We look forward to using him again down the road! Dan & Julie
Adam Z.
Review for Member: Reid Rosenthal
ZillowVERIFIED Reid (and team) were all so helpful in getting our house sold. We met with a lot of agents in the selection of our selling agent and were impressed with his knowledge of the market, honesty in what to expect, and his attentiveness to getting our house sold. We wanted to move quickly and he scheduled a photographer, got our house on the market, and got open houses scheduled within a very short amount of time. We were very happy with our experience selling our home and would recommend Reid for any and all real estate needs!
View All Listings