Meet Nicole - Your Go-To REALTOR on Amelia Island. Local expert. Top producer. Trusted guide. Since 2015, I've helped hundreds of buyers and sellers confidently navigate the North Florida real estate market--especially in my hometown of Amelia Island, where coastal charm meets everyday luxury. I became an independent agent in 2018, and since then, I've consistently ranked as a Top Producing Agent across the region. I've been featured in Real Producers Magazine, recognized among Florida's Top 500 Agents, and even appeared on HGTV--proof that hard work (and heart) go a long way. What sets me apart? I combine deep local insight with creative problem-solving and a no-stress, no-pressure approach. Whether you're buying your first home, selling a luxury property, or relocating to this little slice of paradise, I'm here to make your journey smooth, exciting, and even fun. Off the clock, I'm a proud cheer mom, tennis mom, beach wanderer, and passionate volunteer with causes like Habitat for Humanity, Take Stock in Children, Rotary International, and Lynch Syndrome International. Real estate is more than just contracts and closings--it's about connection, community, and leaving people in a better position than when I met them. Ready to make your next move in North Florida? Let's connect and make it happen!
OTHER LANGUAGES
English, American Sign Language, Spanish
Community Involvement
I believe real estate is about more than just homes--it's about people. I stay active in the community throughout Nassa County through causes close to my heart, including FBHS (GO PIRATES!) and RCA Cheer, Amelia National Tennis, Rotary International, Take Stock in Children, Junior Women's Club, and Lynch Syndrome International. I'm also proud to support conservation efforts through Ducks Unlimited. Whether it's supporting our local athletes or mentoring future leaders, giving back is one of the most rewarding parts of what I do.
HOBBIES/INTEREST
When I'm not helping clients buy or sell in beautiful North Florida, you'll probably find me out on the boat, soaking up the sun, or enjoying anything that involves being on the water. I'm a proud Jacksonville Jaguars fan, loyal to UGA Football (Go Dawgs!), and love staying active--whether it's a good workout or a walk down Centre Street with an iced coffee in hand. I'm all about live music nights on the island, beach days with my girls, and keeping faith at the center of it all. Jesus is my compass--on and off the clock.
FAMILY
My greatest joy is are my two amazing daughters who keep life fun, busy, and full of laughter. We share our home with a sweet German Shepherd, a laid-back cat, and a turtle with a big personality. Whether we're at the beach, out on the boat, or just enjoying island life together, family is the heart of everything I do.
Read More About Nicole
Credentials
LICENSE
Real Estate - Florida - # 3357459
Specialties
Buyer's Agent
First Time Home Buyers
Investment Properties
Land & Lots
Listing Agent
Luxury Specialist
New Construction
Relocation
Vacation / Short-term Rentals
Awards
2026
TOP AGENT
Fernandina Beach, FL
2026
TOP AGENT
Yulee, FL
Other Awards
Best of Zillow, Top 500 Jacksonville, Top Producers Nassau County,
Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Professional
Outstanding
Responsive
Communicative
Available Remotely
Knowledgeable
Trustworthy
Hard working
Melissa M.
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
June 28, 2024
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nicole is the BEST real estate agent I have ever met. I flip homes and use agents to buy and sell properties I have renovated. Most agents I have used are not very thorough. They do as little as they can to get through the sale. Not Nicole... Nicole is "over the top". Her dedication to professionalism is something I have never encountered. Our latest purchase was from out of state and she covered for us in every aspect of even past closing. I cannot stress how happy we are with Nicoles professionalism, her dedication and her service. She made the transaction smooth and painless. I can see why all of her reviews have five stars! Do yourself a favor and entrust Nicole with the sale or purchase of your next property. Thank you Nicole for all that you did for us. I only wish I could give her 10 stars! She is by FAR the best!
Travis S.
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
December 29, 2023
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
I again had the pleasure of working with Nicole, this time was to sell our property in Nassau County. From the beginning, Nicole demonstrated a deep understanding of the local real estate market. Nicole was always available to answer any questions and address any concerns I had. She provided valuable advice on how to best present my home to potential buyers, which I believe played a significant role in the successful sale of our property. What impressed me the most about Nicole was her commitment to ensuring that I was comfortable and well informed at every stage of the selling process. Her negotiation skills and understanding of the selling process are top-notch. I would highly recommend Nicole to anyone looking for a realtor in Nassau County. Her expertise, patience, and genuine care for her clients truly set her apart in the real estate industry and she ESP shines when it's difficult to get the deal across the finish line.
Merry S.
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
February 8, 2022
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nicole is wonderful!!! This is the second time we have worked with Nicole, and if we need a realtor again- she will be top of the list. She always goes above and beyond, answers all our questions and makes the process smooth and easy.
Croomsallan744
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
January 18, 2022
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nicole is extremely professional friendly very helpful has a positive attitude all of the time will go above and beyond for you I felt as though we became good friends as I'm sure she makes all of her clients feel the same I'm a superintendent for one of the biggest new home builders in the nation and I meet a lot of realtors Nicole Reams is hands down the best
John S.
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
December 23, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
I cannot say enough good things about her. Professional yet friendly and approachable. Master of her trade. She will advise you to suit your needs, be honest with you and help you set realistic expectations, explain things without being condescending and fight for you when needed. You want her on your side. She holds my highest possible recommendation. She is among the top professionals I have worked with throughout all industries.
Turboturtlefab
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
November 6, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nicole was very dedicated and worked very hard to get us what we wanted in a home. Spent months helping us find our home and was able to get our previous home listed, sold, and closed on the same day as or new one. Impressive work, very professional, and patient.
Daniel S.
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
November 2, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nicole is awesome and really went above and beyond to guide me through the home buying process. She was great at communicating and kept on top of deadlines and ensuring we were on track to close. Highly recommend her!
Megysteed
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
October 30, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Wonderful to work with! She helped us find a new home while selling our old home. With the current market it took us months to find the right fit for us and Nicole stayed patient with us the entire time.
Mjpappas777
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
June 25, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Very quick response time and super effective realtor. No question is tooo dumb to be answered by this realtor. If you are on the buying side, she is the one who will get you that house!!!
Meredithshiflett
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
June 3, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
We loved working with Nicole Reams. We moved overseas and Nicole went above and beyond to get our property ready to sell and negotiate the best selling price for us. She kept in constant contact with us from afar and always had our interests in mind. We would absolutely buy and sell with Nicole Reams again and recommend others to call her soon!
Yveray
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
October 14, 2020
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
We from out of state to Florida and almost everything was coordinated through ur agent Nicole, She provided great assistance and great customer service, was very professional at all times. Nicole is a person you can trust with your real estate needs. Thank you, Nicole!!!!
Merry S.
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
August 14, 2020
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nicole was wonderful. Very knowledgeable to get us through the buying of our home. She was there whenever we needed her. It was refreshing to work with someone who really seems to understand us as a family. I feel as though I gained realtor and a friend. Would definitely recommend!
Nickgmiller04
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
May 6, 2020
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Excellent realtor. Went above and beyond to sell our house after we moved out of state. Great communication. She even fixed a few things for us after we moved out.
Rebecca A.
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
April 23, 2020
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Excellent Realtor she dedicates her time with her clients, to assure they experience top of the line Boutique service. Both my husband and I feel fortunate to have had Nicole find us our dream home in Amelia, and we plan to continue to work with her for years to come.
Joe W.
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
April 22, 2020
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nicole is the very best. She demonstrated her expertise in many ways beginning with pricing our home to sell at the right market price far above my expectations. She was tenacious and innovative by having open house times scheduled during weekdays also. I highly recommend her.
Zuser20150331164120474
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
September 25, 2019
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nicole from day one after the offer went in was very informative to my wife and I in the ends and out of the house/property we were purchasing. She was fast to get answers on questions I had about current tax bills, property/flood insurances, last years electric bills, and items specifically I wasn't familiar with. She was able to do the research and get detailed answers for me promptly. I have used several agents through the years for over 10 properties I've purchased and yet was never satisfied with the agent's performance . I will contact Nicole on my next investment house purchase because she meets the "5 star standard!"
Kgrahamdesigns2
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
February 15, 2019
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nicole was so responsive and tuned into our needs finding us the perfect property! If you are looking for a professional realtor that goes that extra mile and thinks outside the box, look no further.
Lora E.
Review for Member: Nicole Reams
February 15, 2019
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
The best there is, hands down. Nicole is incredibly helpful and always goes above and beyond for her clients. We are so grateful for her amazing services and look forward to continuing to work with her.