Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
ChristineDevane
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIEDI needed to sell a home in the short term. Kristi helped me pull everything together and complete the sale (over asking price) in one month, even while she was out of the country. I'd highly recommend Kristi!
Vladimir E.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED My wife and I asked Kristi to be our realtor based on a recommendation from a friend who had successfully sold her home in our neighborhood in just two weeks. We never once regretted our choice! With her wealth of experience, Kristi offers invaluable advice on pricing and how best to prepare a home for sale, backing it up with an analysis of comparable sales. Her suggestions proved highly effective; some of the steps she recommended would never have even crossed our minds. She and her colleagues handle the listing process skillfully, and communication with her is always prompt. At the same time, Kristi never pushes her own opinion; she listens to your wishes with understanding, takes your specific circumstances into account, and accommodates them as much as possible. Thanks to her efforts, the house was listed on April 21, 2026, and by May 3, 2026, we had received an offer that satisfied both of us. Throughout this, Kristi worked patiently and thoughtfully with us on two previous offers that we had decided to reject. The entire process, from listing to closing, was perfectly organized. I would also add that Kristi is a charming and exceptionally friendly person who is a pleasure to work with.
Kcrites12
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Having previously purchased a home with Kristi nearly a decade ago, teaming up with her for our next move was a no-brainer. We were a bit worried about the daunting task of searching for the perfect home for our family, but once again, Kristi made everything so impressively smooth and easy from the beginning of the process through closing date. She is incredibly market savvy, highly communicative, sharp, and somehow on top of all of those qualities, is just an absolute delight to work with. I will always recommend Kristi to anyone looking for an exceptional real estate agent.
Ccook642
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED From the initial contact through closing, Kristi was great! She never pressured us to make a quick decision and didn't get flustered when we completely changed our minds and went in a different direction after the first few months of house hunting. We will definately use Kristi when we do another real estate transaction in the area. We will also refer her to our family and friends!
Jerrwilliams
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi was excellent in every way. Because I didn't live in the state, I needed someone who would act in my best interests. Kristi took on the task of not only marketing and selling my property, but also overseeing cleaning and repairs that were needed. I can't imagine having a better agent than her. I consider myself very fortunate to have worked with Kristi.
Sginther90
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi was a joy to work with during the home search and buying process! She was professional, friendly, and knowledgeable. She guided us through the sale of our current home and helped us find a great fit for our family.
Zuser20190630073921094
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED We worked with Kristi to sell our home last spring. She proved to be a seasoned professional agent who is very approachable. She first gave us a detailed explanation of the current market conditions in our area and different strategies for dealing with competition from other homes that were on the market in our neighborhood. Kristi also provided very detailed suggestions on how to prepare our home for showings. At the offer stage, Kristi provided alternative strategies for us to consider to get the price we felt was appropriate for our home, and ultimately, we got a fair price that we were happy with. It seemed clear that Kristi is well-regarded by other agents in the area, which no doubt aided in the marketing and selling our home. Overall, we feel she is a top agent in the Bloomington area.
Sundbergca
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi is such a positive person to work with! She has a wealth of knowledge and resources to help you through the process. She sold our home in record time! I highly recommend her services.
Kilah G.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi Gibbs went above and beyond to help us find exactly what we were looking for and made the whole process so smooth. Shes professional, kind, and truly cares about her clients. I couldnt recommend her enough!
Michelle F.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED "Kristi was friendly, competent, and efficient. Setting up the sale was swift and thankfully devoid of overcommunication or delay. She even found a wonderful home for my beloved piano! And, at the end, when I called in a panic on a Sunday, she cheerfully responded and reassured IMMEDIATELY! A delightful experience from start to finish!"
Umakeithkyle
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi is an experienced and professional agent who is very easy to work with. She advocates strongly for her clients, and helps clients understand the market realities at the time they are responding to offers. Kristi also seems to be well known by the other agents in the area which helps with marketing and closing sales. Overall, a top agent in the Bloomington area.
Sara F.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Before selling our house, we knew Kristi to be a thorough, fair, considerate, honest, helpful, and kind person. She seemed like the perfect representative for the human-to-human exchange we hoped for our home transaction. We had no idea how far she could exceed our expectations. Kristi's professional knowledge was tantamount. She knew the market of not only our area but how it interplayed with other similar areas in the region. She put our requests as top priority and then assembled a top-notch presentation of our home tailored beautifully to just the right buyers. Would happily work with Kristi again!
Rscrouch7
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED My wife and I lived in our previous home for 40 years, and weve never had any reason to work with a realtoraEUR"until recently. When the time came, Kristi was everything we could have hoped for. She walked us through the whole process, step by step, with patience and understanding. She really knows her stuff and made what couldve been a stressful situation feel smooth and easy. We couldnt be more grateful for her hard work, and Id recommend her to anyone who needs a good, honest realtor.
Thaddeus W.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED We cant say enough how pleased we have been with Kristi Gibbs and all the work she has done for us as our realtor! Kristis knowledge of the local market was incredibly valuable to get us the house we wanted and to sell our previous property. She was also readily available to us whenever we had questions, clearly communicating answers, problem solving, and cheerfully helping us with every step along the way. We cant imagine having a better person navigating us through such a huge life change than Kristi!
Bowman R.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED We enjoyed working with Kristi to find a new home. She is very knowledgeable about the local market and helped us buy a home we love. She was friendly and very responsive to all of our questions throughout the process.
Strykerrl8
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi and her crew are just unbelievable! Even when working with difficult parties they made it a breeze and less stressful! Ive used her multiple times and will always turn to her! No one better!
Zuser20171129101510216
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi Gibbs went above and beyond for us throughout the home selling process. She was incredibly knowledgeable, provided great support, advice, and was always quick to respond to our needs and questions. We had complete trust in her throughout the entire process and would without a doubt recommend Kristi to anyone looking to buy or sell a property. She was fantastic!
Lissi J.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi was fantastic to work with on what we knew would be a competitive home purchase. She made time for us to see homes as soon as they came on the market and was knowledgeable in negotiations when we were ready to buy. She was accessible, communicative, and did so much for us behind the scenes that it made the process a breeze. We would absolutely work with her again.
Mparker997tt
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi Gibbs had excellent knowledge of our neighborhood and our builder's work and was very collaborative in assessing listing price for our home. She has good experience with the local real estate market and homes at our price point, and was proactive throughout the process. She worked effectively with the buyer's agent to address questions and facilitate the sale."
Natalie F.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi was kind, patient, helpful, and always quick to respond. A great experience all around. Kristi's knowledge was critical in guiding us on how to submit a competitive offer in today's market.
Howelljg
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi did an outstanding job helping us sell, beginning with a walk through prior to listing. This gave us the opportunity to meet her and she gave us some valuable input on how to best prepare the house for sale. Kristi was very knowledgeable and personable. We completed the recommended work and listed a couple weeks later. In less than two weeks we had two offers with escalating clauses up to $17K over asking price. In a short time we closed at $17K over asking price. A way better experience and result than we dreamed possible. Thank you, Kristi.
Trask S.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi was a dream to work with. She had a lot of insight and really got to know us so she could direct us to houses we would be interested in. She also was very accommodating of our schedules, including many last minute showings that we asked for and being understanding of having to plan around a newborn. I also really love that after we closed, we were given a list of local charities to pick from where Kristi would make a donation on our behalf. She really goes above and beyond, and I will be sending her information to anyone moving to the area in the future.
Denniseltatman
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED We especially loved how no question or task was too big or too small for Kristi. We felt that we were in great hands throughout the process, and our property had a unique piece to it, and Kristi was super confident regardless. Nothing seemed to shake her and we never felt we were a bother. Super responsive, no matter the time or question at hand.
RobertLudwig0
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi is super personable and very chill while still being incredibly professional and on top of things. Working with her was an awesome experience for us as first time buyers who had no idea what we were doing and were very indecisive :) Kristi really helped us hone in on what we wanted and was very patient. She totally got us. It was a great experience.
Jillian H.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED I cannot say enough good things about Kristi. She impressed us right from the start. She went above and beyond and I truly do not think we could have sold our house as quickly as we did without her connections and expertise. If you need to sell your house, use Kristi!
Rstremm
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED "Awesome Agent!!!! Highly recommend Kristi to anyone in search of new home!!! If I was teacher passing out grades Kristi would get an A" . Kristi was amazing and helped us with all our needs as we were from out of town. Will definitely use Kristi again !!!!!! A ++++
Madisonschuckman
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED We had a great experience working with Kristi to purchase our home. Shes the best! She was very professional and responsive to all of our questions and emails. Her extensive knowledge of the area was essential when it came to deciding which neighborhood would be the best fit for us. We cannot recommend Kristi enough, if you choose her as your realtor you will be in great hands!
MiriamNorthcutt B.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi and her team are outstanding! She has crafted the perfect buying and selling experience. She provides expert advice of the local market, the buying/selling processes, and delivers great selling and purchase agreements. You will not be disappointed. Throughout the process she was quick to respond to our inquiries AND also anticipated our needs and helped us stay on track with weekly newsletters. She was always on site, ready with contractors to help us with both information and practical support. I really just can't say enough positive things about her and the team she's assembled. She clearly brings A+ expertise but also has a personal touch that makes you feel like you're her only client.
Beth W.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi Gibbs is professional, knowledgeable, and provides wise counsel. She has helped me with two buys and one sell. I felt well-informed throughout each of those. Working with her is akin to working with a friend. She listens and applies what she hears to make buying/selling a positive experience.
JoyousWilliams
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Working with Kristi was excellent. She is professional but also empathetic to the sellers experience. She was always updating us on marketing strategies and leads. We enjoyed working with her and would recommend her with confidence to anyone. Kristi provided great service from day one- all the way through closing day. She was always touching base and letting us know how our house was being marketed. We selected the broker Century 21 Sheetz because we wanted to work with Kristi. We knew she is the best and would work hard for us, which she did. We were very pleased with her services.
Doctor B.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi helped us buy a beautiful lot a year ago. We in the end decided to buy a home already built and renovate rather than complete a new build. We listed the lot again with Kristi. It sold to a lovely couple. Kristi has been helpful, patient and creative when needed. She is a great agent and a lovely person.
Amartin4059
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi is the consummate professional who also genuinely cares about her clients. I've known her for years and would never use anyone else or reccomend anyone else. Specific to selling, one thing Kristi does is that she prices your home appropriately. She does her homework, knows the activity in the area, and will not tell you an inflated price just to get your listing. She priced our home, and we had multiple offers the day after we listed. Thanks Kristi!
Diana M.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED In both buying and selling a home, Kristi and her team proved invaluable in their knowledge of the process and connection to the community. She and her team are incredibly supportive and experienced. While I hope to stay put for awhile, I would definitely use her again!
Kimberly P.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi and her team were very helpful in our search for a home in Bloomington. We had very specific criteria and a short window to do our search and make a decision. Each of the team members (Kristi, Kimberly, Kelly and Angela) all made our experience easy. We would definitely recommend the team and will use them if needed in our future.
Michael J.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED This is the third time I have used Kristi, and she was fantastic as usual! This was a very tough market with multiple competitive offers over asking price. Many of my friends have found it nearly impossible to buy. In my case, Kristi got me into a newly listed house firstaEUR"she was very strategic about the offer timing, and I got the house at asking price before others could pounce. She also handled the post-inspection negotiations perfectly. I am thrilled with the house and with the process!
Merrill C.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED We had a great experience working with Kristi Gibbs during the process of finding and purchasing a home. Kristi is knowledgeable, a good listener, responsive and inclusive. Kristi demonstrated a wealth of knowledge regarding the local area and spent time helping us narrow down our search by listening to our needs. Kristi was responsive to our many questions and communicated effectively. She made the entire process run smoothly, which made things easy for our family. When you work with Kristi you can tell that she has spent time working with and getting to know individuals of all different backgrounds. She makes you feel important and valued in the process.
Brouhard K.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi was amazing to work with and made our first time buying a home great even in this crazy sellers market. She was always a text away as we were trying to get in to see houses as soon as they were listed!
Kristin C.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED "Kristi always worked hard and listened to our concerns. We had a tough sale and inspection process and Kristi was always patient and understanding even when we were venting our frustrations of the situation to her! She made sure we got the best sale we could and walked us through the process with grace. I appreciated her ability to stay level headed and listen to us throughout the process!"
Aame J.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi has an incredible wealth of local knowledge and is quick to point out planned developments throughout the community to help you better understand how your neighborhood may change in the future. She recognizes and notices aspects about the homes you are viewing that may become challenges and never tries to force a sale. She was patient, informative and kind throughout the entire buying process and was eager to connect me with local services to support the process. In addition to all of these fantastic qualities you would want in a realtor, Kristi's greatest asset is her ability to listen to her clients and understand their needs. She knew exactly what I wanted and never tried to convince me to change my goals or wish list, and she found me a house with EVERY single item on my needs AND wish list! I couldn't be happier with my decision to work with Kristi, as I'm now settled in my new home that is a true reflection of the goals I set at the beginning of the homebuying process. If you want a realtor willing to work with any budget who is patient, knowledgable, and a great listener...choose Kristi!
Krystal C.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED In an extremely competitive market, you need a realtor that will get the job done. Kristi helped us to get our house dream house in Bloomington. Kristi responds quickly to all communications and also shows you places right away. I also appreciated her professionalism and kindness and humor too.
Tscottherring
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi is simply a phenomenal realtor: professional, responsive, & super-knowledgeable. She made the selling process so, so much easier with her expertise--from start to finish. She responded immediately to all of our questions and walked us through all the steps of selling our home with patience and empathy. She and her team came highly recommended to us, and I am happy to highly recommend them in return. A truly fantastic person to work with!
User102198287
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi has been an immensely helpful relator. She is knowledgeable of market conditions, kept our best interests in focus, and provided us with valuable negotiating advice. We have bought/sold multiple properties with Kristi through the years. She provides exceptional service and supports her clients throughout the entire process.
Ggennis
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi Gibbs was recommended to us through a friend and after reading her bio and sales record we felt she was the agent for us. She was very professional and always had our best interest at heart. All questions and concerns were handled efficiently and timely and always kept us up-to-date as to the progression of our sale. Kristi impressed us with how comfortable she made us feel around her. She never made us feel like our questions and concerns were a bother and was extremely timely in responding to them. Without a doubt we would definitely recommend Kristi to our family and friends and use her again as our sales agent if the occasion arose. We are grateful and appreciative of all she did to sell and close our home in a timely manner. G. Ennis, Nashville IN
Benckart
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED "Kristi came highly recommended as a realtor with working relationships with other service providers who could advise us on updating our home and staging it in ways that attracted buyers. As it turned out, within a month not only did it attract buyers, but we found the right buyer! Kristi is fabulous! She has been a realtor long enough to be knowledgeable about real estate in Monroe County, yet not so long that she has lost her aEURoehungeraEUR? for the sale!"
Traciorr2
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED We were moving to Indiana from out of state. Kristi Gibbs was a valuable asset to our planning and home shopping! We were only able to make one house shopping trip and she was available for all showings, and answering all of our questions. Long distance closings are a hassle and Kristi was very helpful and kept us informed during the process. We would definitely recommend Kristi Gibbs and Century21."
Bethie1785
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi was a great choice for my first home purchase. From our first meeting, she thoroughly explained what to expect and laid out a timeline. She also showed great interest in what needs and wants were important to me. Throughout the homebuying process, she continued to be both proactive with communication and responsive to any questions I had. In our fast paced market, I can't imagine having to wait on a realtor response. Kristi always replied promptly and I never had anything less than a professional, friendly interaction with her. She showed me several properties before finding the right one. I never felt any pressure to make an offer or look above my budget. When I did go under contact, she handled the flood of details and was very organized, making sure that nothing slipped through the cracks. Overall, Kristi was an excellent guide through the process, breaking down stressful stages into manageable tasks. I found a home that was exactly what I pictured when I originally described what I was looking for to Kristi and had a great first time experience.
Stogdill62
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi let me know up front that my house may be a little difficult to sell because of the location but she was always very encouraging and gave me tons of feedback on everything we did. I would refer her in a heartbeat. She is a go getter and for sure gets the job done timely, professionally and efficiently. Now on to buying a house with her and because of her professionalism feeling totally at peace with it."
Georylk
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED Kristi is an excellent realtor and stands out in many ways. If I had to choose her top 3 characteristics, I'd choose: professional, trustworthy, accessible, friendly, and knowledgeable. (Yes, I know that's 5 - I couldn't only choose 3!) I contacted multiple agents before choosing Kristi and she stood out to me because she listened to my needs and was positive about my timeline. She didn't think my short timeline was unrealistic for finding a home (even though I did). Not only did she think it was possible (even though others did not), but it turned out to be! I saw a house with her for the first time on March 1st then closed and started moving into the house on March 20th! Kristi made me feel comfortable and was patient with me as a first time home buyer. She answered all my questions and helped me to focus on priorities throughout the process. She provided detailed and reliable responses to all my questions and even provided insight that I would have asked about, had it not been the first time I purchased a home. I would recommend Kristi to any friend or family member.
Loren552
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED As a home builders, I've worked with many realtors in Bloomington and Kristi stands out. She is honest, caring, communicative and, above all, she is emotionally invested in helping you sell your home. I recommend her whole-heartedly and feel lucky to have her help on my sales and purchases.
Keith U.
Review for Member: Kristi Gibbs
ZillowVERIFIED I previously used Kristi Gibbs when we bought our home 2204 W Karney and the experience was outstanding. She was the agent that I wanted to use with the sale of the property. She has the traits of professionalism and put both my wife and I at ease. Her understanding of the staging of the property and what we need to do for curb appeal increased the number of showing we had for our home. I plan on using Kristi Gibbs in the future when I purchase my next home within the next 12 months and highly recommend her to all my friends and co-workers. I would say that Century 21 Scheetz should be honor to have Kristi Gibbs as an agent.
View All Listings