Kellie Rutherford

Keller Williams Arizona Realty-Prescott

22 Years of Experience

(4)

$17M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$608.3K

Average Price Point

Service Areas

Chino Valley, AZ Dewey, AZ Humboldt, AZ Prescott Valley, AZ Prescott, AZ

View All Service Areas

Credentials

LICENSE

Real Estate - Arizona - # BR552205000

Designation

Seller Representative Specialist

Broker / Associate Broker

Specialties

Buyer's Agent
Listing Agent
Real Estate Consulting
Relocation

Awards

2026
TOP AGENT
Prescott, AZ
2026
TOP AGENT
Chino Valley, AZ

Loading recent sales...

Kellie Rutherford's Reviews & Ratings

4 Reviews

(3.5/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Knowledgeable
Outstanding
Professional
Responsive

Amy H.

Review for Member: Kellie Rutherford

July 8, 2026

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I'm sorry to report a very bad experience with Kellie. I have had years of experience in real estate. I have never had such a bad experience. Starting with inaccurate information about the market. She incorrectly wrote a description of the home. I gave her pictures because car were in her photo. As I decided to take off the market she became very belligerent and said she would no longer text me email only. She would not remove my home from mls until I paid her for her pictures. In 30 days there was one showing.

Rthayer1

Review for Member: Kellie Rutherford

January 2, 2019

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

We lived in Southern California when we decided we wanted to check out Prescott, AZ because my husband needed a VA Hospital nearby. Kellie took a whole day back in April to show us around the town so we could narrow in on the areas we were most interested in. When we were finally able to get our home into escrow back in SoCal in August, Kellie took the time to show us several Prescott properties. We made an offer that day, which the seller did not accept. Kellie did her very best to make the deal happen. When another one came on the market the next day, she was there immediately to help us view the home and then make an offer. I am thankful the first offer fell through because we now have a home in the pines that we love. Kellie was by our side when some glitches happened the first week in our new home. Kellie has become a dear friend because she is a woman of integrity. I am so thankful for Kellie. I HIGHLY recommend her!

Marie S.

Review for Member: Kellie Rutherford

May 22, 2018

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

In Dec 2017, I contracted with Kellie to sell my home. I was going through a difficult time & she seemed to understand. Kellie seemed to be supportive of my situation to sell at the time. Escrow on my house closed April 2018, 40 days ago. During the signing of my closing docs at the title co, it was brought to my attention that I would be paying for the buyers home warranty. I had missed this on the offer and when I brought it to Kellie's attention, she immediately said she would reimburse it to me, because she had also overlooked it. I declined since I knew it came down to me. Several times Kellie said she would issue a check for the Home Warranty and it was left with her insisting she wanted to pay for it, which she did on 05/23/18. I have waited until now to write this review to give her that opportunity. Thank you, Kellie, for taking care of the sale of my house and your follow through even after.

Gilbert13

Review for Member: Kellie Rutherford

September 7, 2014

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Kellie Rutherford is by far the most knowledgable, personable and professional real estate agent we have ever worked with. Having Kellie as our agent proved to be an excellent experience and we greatly appreciate her skill, integrity and in-depth knowledge of the real estate market. She always goes above and beyond and we highly recommend her to handle any real estate needs!