Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Brianna C.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin truly went above and beyond for us! After having some less-than-great experiences before finding her, we couldnt be more grateful that we found her when we did. She helped us find and secure our dream home, and we couldnt have asked for a better experience. Throughout the entire process, Caitlin was honest, knowledgeable, responsive, and incredibly kind. She took the time to answer our questions, keep us informed, and guide us through every step, making what can be an overwhelming process feel so much easier. We put our trust in Caitlin and her team, and we are so thankful we did. We couldnt recommend her enough!
Gabriella R.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDMy husband and I are first time home buyers, and we discovered Caitlin months before closing on our home; all I can say is what a blessing! Caitlin is extremely experienced, diligent, attentive, communicative, and so kind. This process was a lot for us as it was our first time, but having Caitlin as our agent made the process much smoother! Thank you so much Caitlin! We are beyond grateful for you!
Peter C.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDFirst time buyer here. Caitlin was the third agent we came across after the first two didn't seem like the best fit. Glad we chose our agent carefully and landed with Caitlin. Caitlin went above and beyond through out the entire process. She explained all the complicated things that can be confusing for a first time buyer, and fought for us relentlessly when it came to negotiations. With that being said, if it's your first time buying a house and you want the best agent you can get for such an important move/life event, choosing Caitlin to be your agent will be the first smart move in the process.
Abbey R.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin was our agent in selling our home and purchasing a new one, all within a few months. She did an absolutely incredible job from the time we met her to the closing. When she first arrived to talk with us about selling the house, she came very prepared with comps, a booklet for us to look through and understand and she was very professional, and most importantly kind. She worked with us on pricing, she was honest and did an amazing job with selling our home, 50k over asking! In the purchase of our new home, we were also able to get it 40k under asking, which is an incredible deal in Lake Mohawk. Throughout the process she was always available, explained everything thoroughly and was very assertive when she needed to be. Shes the epitome of professionalism and Id recommend her to anyone and everyone I know. Selling and buying is so stressful, but Caitlin took care of absolutely everything and took such a burden off our shoulders. We love her!!
Abbeythomas29
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin was our agent in selling our home and purchasing a new one, all within a few months. She did an absolutely incredible job from the time we met her to the closing. When she first arrived to talk with us about selling the house, she came very prepared with comps, a booklet for us to look through and understand and she was very professional, and most importantly kind. She worked with us on pricing, she was honest and did an amazing job with selling our home, 50k over asking! In the purchase of our new home, we were also able to get it 40k under asking, which is an incredible deal in Lake Mohawk. Throughout the process she was always available, explained everything thoroughly and was very assertive when she needed to be. Shes the epitome of professionalism and Id recommend her to anyone and everyone I know. Selling and buying is so stressful, but Caitlin took care of absolutely everything and took such a burden off our shoulders. We love her!!
Melissaandallan
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDIt took us over 3 years to find our new home and Caitlin stuck by us through the whole process. Once we were under contract, she helped us through the entire process right up until the papers were signed. We never felt pressured through the process and Caitlin was incredibly patient with us through every step. We highly recommend her. You wont regret it.
Higginsj1121
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDFrom start to finish, Caitlin was an expert, on top of every little detail to ensure a smooth, speedy listing and close, all while attracting a HUGE amount of buyers. Not only is she a true stand out in her field, she fits right in, like Ive known her for 20+ years!! I would HIGHLY recommend Caitlin to anyone looking to buy or sell!! (Thank you, Caitlin, for all of your help and guidance!)
User1665161
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDYou know when you meet someone and you can just tell that they dont just show up to work for the paycheck, but are actually passionate about their work? Thats Caitlin- dedicated, knowledgeable, organized and caring. We sold and purchased a home with Caitlin and her support throughout a unusually stressful process was unmatched. If you are looking for a realtor who will get the job done, while also gaining a lifelong friend, look no further than Caitlin!
Agslavin
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin was a incredible and invaluable asset in our home selling and buying experience. Our sale was hampered by numerous road blocks, an emergent birth and countless other obstacles along with dealing with a difficult purchase of our new forever home. Caitlin was supportive, informative and worked tirelessly to ensure my family got the best possible deal on our sale and put us in our dream home! Don't walk, RUN to hire Caitlin for your real estate experience.
Shannon M.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDTHE BEST! Caitlin was beyond phenomenal to work with. From the start, she proved how dedicated she was to ensuring the process was smooth and helping us make educated decisions that made sense for our family. She very clearly takes the time to remain current in her field, which was reassuring. She helped us sell our home in NJ for 50k over asking which was a huge plus. When our home purchase out of state had some bumps in the road, she advocated for us and continued to keep us informed in options. As a family with two children and a busy lifestyle, we also needed someone with compassion and patience, which she provided ten fold. Thank you for helping us with this process so we can live out our dreams! We can't thank you enough. - The Mahoney Family
Conner C.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDChoosing Caitlin to be our realtor was the BEST decision we could have made. Caitlin represented us with both selling and purchasing our new home at the same time. Not only did she get us top dollar for our house, but also got our offer accepted while being home sale contingent on a home that was already in attorney review. When choosing Caitlin, you dont just get her, you get a whole team and a portfolio of resources and knowledge with everything you need to streamline the home sale and home purchase. Buying and selling a home is a roller coaster ride. After working with other real estate professionals in the past I truly cannot imagine being on that roller coaster with anyone else other than Caitlin! 5 stars in every category!!!
Corey P.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDMy experience was 10/10 to be honest. What could and should have been a traumatizing experience dealing with loss of family and an estate process. I'm here to tell you that while we had hiccups, it was honestly smoother than I could have anticipated. We had to navigate a few different deals, repair work, inspections, showings, demands/requests, snow, etc. Caitlin handled EVERYTHING for me since I'm an out of state resident. She was communicative, compassionate, patient which is hard when working with me. She was competent, respectful to me and those involved. Just an all around grade A experience full of transparency and optimism. I would gladly recommend Caitlin to any of my friends or family. My only regret is that my next home purchase she wont be able to help since its out of state. Seriously folks you can not go wrong if you choose Caitlin to help you!!
Omaira S.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDI had been talking to Caitlin for sometime about selling my house. We finally did it. I picked Caitlin bc she has incredible personality and I knew that her swag would attract the right people. Her drive, professionalism, and communication were definitely an asset to her style. She is an excellent realtor and she is always taking those extra steps in order to make things happen. I'm so happy we worked together and were able to have a successful sale! I couldnt be more happier for her expertise, assistance and patience. Thank you so much -Caitlin ??
Derek H.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin is incredible. Easily one of the hardest working, kindest, and most personable professionals in the industry. I've bought a few houses across the country, and with how nuts buying in NJ is, Caitlin made the journey enjoyable. I cannot express enough how amazing this woman is. She isn't just your realtor, she's a lifelong friend.
Allison G.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin by FAR exceeded our expectations of a realtor. She made this process as easy as it could possibly be, and was our #1 advocate throughout absolutely everything. In speaking with other people buying homes and using a different realtor, we realized that Caitlin really goes above and beyond for her clients. She made phone calls for us, was in constant contact with people regarding our best interest, and stayed on top of EVERYTHING before we could even think about it. Home buying can certainly be a grueling process... but thankfully with Caitlin and her expertise, we were able to get our first offer accepted. I cannot say enough great things... if you are buying a home, USE CAITLIN. You will not have a single regret!
Alli F.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin by FAR exceeded our expectations of a realtor. She made this process as easy as it could possibly be, and was our #1 advocate throughout absolutely everything. In speaking with other people buying homes and using a different realtor, we realized that Caitlin really goes above and beyond for her clients. She made phone calls for us, was in constant contact with people regarding our best interest, and stayed on top of EVERYTHING before we could even think about it. Home buying can certainly be a grueling process... but thankfully with Caitlin and her expertise, we were able to get our first offer accepted. I cannot say enough great things... if you are buying a home, USE CAITLIN. You will not have a single regret!
Virginiethibeault
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDI loved working with Caitlin, she not only was our real estate agent but she also became a friend. The process of buying in New Jersey was very different from buying in other states so we would often turn to her for help as far as who we needed to contact for certain details and she was always more than happy to help. She made sure she was always available, quick with responses and advised us ahead of time if she would not be available. I would definitely recommend Caitlin to friends and family.
User8221418
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin is simply the best! She helped us purchase our first home and exceeded all expectations. From the beginning, she made us feel comfortable and supported. Caitlin patiently answered all of our questions and explained the home-buying process in a way that was easy to understand. She was always available and kept us informed throughout the entire process. Even after the sale, she continued to offer support and checked in on us. Caitlin's recommendations for other professionals were top-notch, saving us time and hassle. Thanks to her exceptional service, we are now proud homeowners. I highly recommend Caitlin!
Nmoresi
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDI asked Caitlin to be my realtor because we were long time friends from high-school. What I got was an absolute top notch professional. Caitlin was punctual, reliable, and informative. ANY question I asked, I received a knowledgeable, highly detailed, and informed answer. Caitlin made our home buying process a breeze. I had my FIRST offer accepted because Caitlin assisted me in making a strong offer. She recommended a few people in her network from inspector to lender and lawyer. I followed her recommendations and I was beyond pleased with my team. I was walked through each step of the process with thorough information, I was relieved of all anxiety and worry. I will endlessly recommend Caitlin to anyone I know in the future as Caitlin is a gold star realtor and true pleasure to work with. It is so important to choose a realtor that makes the home buying process fun, exciting, educational, and rewarding and Caitlin provided all of those things.
Zuser20170609151013591
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin iCaitlins a super star. She has been extremely pleasant to work with and helpful. The first house we looked at was in December. Caitlin consistently forwarded houses that she thought would be of interest. She had selected not only to our budget needs but our house favorites. We put an offer on two houses and one was accepted. She was really smart in helping me with my offer so it was competitive, in this seller's market. We didn't have to over bid financially but offered up other options that were appealing to the seller. Caitlin has an incredible network of resources, and always had recommendations. Lawyers, mortgage agents, contractors, inspectors, all who were respectful and very good at their jobs. She took her time to set up meetings to help everything go smoothly. Caitlin was super responsive through the whole process. Can text, email or pick up the phone when things were time sensitive. She was so compassionate and intuitive to our needs. She broke things down in explanation when needed with candid advice. She also was not pushy in any way. We closed on our house on May 5th, and it couldn't have benn easier.
Mrstorres0818
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDI hope I have enough space for this review! Because there aren't enough words to describe Caitlin! I wish there was more than 5 stars because she truly truly deserves it! Caitlin was honestly my Rock throughout the entire process! She was literally always available. No matter what time or place, she answered the phone call or text. If she didn't know an answer she got one! She stayed on top of everyone at every moment to make sure things stayed on track and were done correctly. Her words of encouragement and kindness were exactly what I needed when I thought I was going to loose it. She absolutely went ABOVE and BEYOND what any realtor is expected to do. She literally saved my house (haha) that's a story! If it wasn't for Caitlin I truly wouldn't have made it through the process. Not only is she an INCREDIBLE Realtor but she's an AMAZING person! Caitlin thank you will never be enough to say to you. I hope life gives you all that you hope and desire because you TRULY deserve pure happiness! The same happiness you bless the peoples lives you have POSITIVELY affected, like my family and I!
Zuser20171003141002534
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCan not begin to say how Choosing Caitlin to be our realator was the best decision we made when buying our first home. After not being happy with a previous agent Caitlin took the time to understand what we were looking for and most importantly our budget. She walked us through and explained every step of the process to us. She was available to answer any and all questions that we had and was very diligent about following up with attorneys, sellers and lenders. It never felt like we were just another client to her and felt like she was a friend having fun helping us buy a home.
Kelly Y.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDMy fiance and I used Caitlin as our realtor to purchase a house and she went above and beyond helping us navigate the process of being first time homeowners. She was always responsive no matter what time of day. Always worked around our schedule to get everything done. I would highly recommended her to anyone. She is fun and very knowledgeable and passionate in this profession. 5 stars ??
JustinBullaro
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin was amazing from day one, very responsive, always sent me listings 36 hours before they hit the market, making sure we were first to see a home on the showings list. After having multiple rejected offers and a fall out with another realtor, a failed close on another home I backed out of , and lots of time put out there looking on days off. Caitlin found us the perfect home here in Wantage and worked closely with me to choose terms to get my offer accepted. With all of her help and suggestions we WON big time by not only getting our offer accepted but finding the best home I could possibly imagine in our County. If you want the best experience for your real estate needs I highly reccomend you get on the phone with Caitlin.
Estevez231
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDVery Polite and respectful really easy to work with. She is very knowledgeable and helps every step of the way and provided me with really useful information for the home searh and getting a deal offer accepted. Thanks to her my family and I will be enjoying our firts home. Thank you Caitlin!
Nicole D.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin is the absolute best! Helped me through the whole process of selling my house and buying my dream home! She worked around my crazy schedule which was a huge help. She was readily available to answer any and all of my questions and concerns. I would recommend her over and over again!
Jamie C.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin was absolutely the best to work with! She helped me through the whole process by scheduling and managing our appointments and most importantly negotiating and getting me exactly what I want. She made it happen for me and I would recommend her with no worries!
Christine A.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin was an absolute gem to work with. She was on it everytime! She works around your schedule which is a blessing. I would go to her over and over again!
Nwnapolitano
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin helped me sell my late mothers house after she passed away, and she couldnt have been more pleasant to work with. She made a very stressful process so much easier, and was readily available to answer any questions or concerns I may have had. Her attention to detail and ability to follow through were fantastic, and I cannot recommend her enough.
Bloomintoestate
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDBought my first property here in NJ with the amazing help of CaitlinaEUR| she has been nothing short of amazing with every little step to closing. If anyone is looking for a home to buy or sell I recommend Caitlin!!! If I could give 10 stars she would get them!
Euchar1611
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin is an amazing realtor but more an amazing person who went above and beyond for myself and family in helping us purchase our first home. Thanks Caitlin!!!
Amanda G.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDWe were very fortunate to have Caitlin be a part of our home buying experience! Being that this was our first time buying a home, she was very helpful every step of the way keeping us on track of the next step. Caitlin was very knowledgeable in making our offer strong on a house we immediately fell in love with. We will definitely be using Caitlin again if the time comes and recommend her to anyone in the future!
Tomdoyleguitars
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin Sweeney was the most attentive and honest agents we had dealt with. No matter how long it took she was always willing to guide us through all of difficult twists and turns of buying a home in today's market. We recommend her with the highest 5 star ratings.
Rachael G.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin helped us purchase our first home and she made the experience a breeze. She would answer any of our questions or concerns as soon as possible. She would set up appointments for us in minutes. She went the extra mile to make this process as easy for us as she could. With the market being as competitive as it is, Caitlin had the knowledge and skills needed to get our offer to be as appealing as possible, which made our offer shine against 10 other offers and landed us our amazing first home. I will definitely be working with Caitlin again in the future and will be recommending her to anyone who is looking for a realtor.
Cindy
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDFrom start to finish Caitlin Sweeney was professional, easy to work with and very knowledgeable. She was able to assist me with purchasing a condo while living in another state. I had complete trust in that Caitlin led me the the place I can now call my home??
JordanP72
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin is professional in every way, yet still made it feel like I teamed up with a best friend to sell the house together. I think that counts for a lot when working with an agent means they're stopping by your house, looking at every room, helping stage it, and talking with you about money and living situations. It's good to be working with someone that doesn't make it painfully boring, awkward, or something worse. Listing my house with Caitlin resulted in a strong number of offers to pick from. I ultimately went with an offer that was 110% of the list price. I was very happy with that, as well as Caitlin's choice for a photographer and her recommendation for an attorney. There were all sorts of little things Caitlin was very understanding of as well. She never seemed annoyed with any of my quirks, worries, questions, or concerns. If you want the process of selling a home to be easy, go with Caitlin.
Anna I.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDI can not say enough good things about working with Caitlin. I'm so thankful we were able to work with someone so attentive, informative and thoughtful who made the entire process as easy and smooth as possible- from house hunting-to making an offer- to everything that follows. Also fantastic response time. I never once had to worry about when I was going to hear back from her. We took her advice throughout the entire process and got an accepted offer on the first house we made an offer on. We also used everyone she recommended throughout the process as far as inspections, loan officer, attorney etc. which all were amazing as well. I Highly recommend, shes fantastic.
7kthfh2ghr
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin is an amazing choice when picking a realtor! She was always well prepared, patient with answering questions, quick to follow up and thorough with every detail. For me, those phenomenal qualities were secondary to the kindness and support she provided my mom. My mom is ill so we needed a home we could live in together and one that could be made accessible for her needs. Caitlin was very understanding of this. She was a true advocate for my mom and demonstrated tremendous compassion during this very difficult transition for my family. Caitlin coordinated selling my moms home and getting us a new home while managing a complicated timeline for everyone involved. She made the process seamless. If you are wondering who to choose to help you during your next life transition, choose Caitlin. You will not be disappointed.
Kahrk
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin went above and beyond for us, answered questions at all hours, and pushed to make our transaction go as smoothly as possible. She put in the extra hours, and always had our best interest in mind. We saw dozens of houses, and we were very picky. Caitlin was always patient and positive even when we werent. I highly recommend her!
Jordan B.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin made it easy! My wife and I used Caitlin to sell our home and she helped us get more than double what we paid for it. Her communication and attention to detail was spot on throughout our entire experience. I would absolutely recommend her!
Rebecca P.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin was absolutely amazing. She found me what I wanted in record time, and her communication, professionalism, and enthusiasm are unmatched! She kept me informed at every turn, so I always knew what to expect, and she was genuinely invested in making sure I was happy. She gave me a beautiful personalized housewarming gift to make sure that my late husbands presence was felt right away in my new home. Thank you for everything!
Rebeccalucille81
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin was absolutely amazing. She found me what I wanted in record time, and her communication, professionalism, and enthusiasm are unmatched! She kept me informed at every turn, so I always knew what to expect, and she was genuinely invested in making sure I was happy. She gave me a beautiful personalized housewarming gift to make sure that my late husbands presence was felt right away in my new home. Thank you for everything!
Mickimo84
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDDedicated, hard working and knowledgeable! Caitlin found the perfect buyer right away and got me a great offer on the sale of my home. She worked diligently on my behalf to overcome the last minute challenges and got it done! If youre looking for an agent who is industrious, committed to the end and experienced, hire Caitlin!
Ashley Y.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDMy parents outgrew their home and were ready to find a bigger house. Caitlin was able to find them a beautiful townhouse that fit their needs and my mom finally got her dream kitchen. Caitlin also sold their home for well above list price which helped them get the townhouse they wanted. She was so helpful and knowledgeable throughout the whole process. She is truly the best and we wouldn't have been able to do this without her! I highly recommend Caitlin to anyone who is looking to buy!
Caramrose
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDCaitlin was such an amazing realtor and being a first time home buyer she helped me tremendously!! Especially for someone like me who knew absolutely nothing she was so helpful and knowledgeable every step of the way. Not sure if buying a house is always this easy-going or I just have the best realtor out there! I highly recommend using Caitlin as your realtor in all future homebuying! She definitely knows her stuff! Thank you again Caitlin! I couldnt have done this without you!
Susana H.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDMy parents had been looking for a property that they can call home for a while now. Ever since we met Caitlin, she was nothing but amazing, a pleasure to deal with. So knowledgeable, smart and reliable. It has been our great honor to work with her. She has made my parents transaction more manageable since coming form out of state can be difficult. Thank you Caitlin for your support and for walking us through this process. We are really thankful from the bottom of our hearts. I hope we can work together again in the near future.
Jennifer C.
Review for Member: Caitlin Schlaffer
ZillowVERIFIEDWe were doing a move to another state, selling our house, had a timeline for starting new jobs and the end of schoolaEUR|Not to mention, THIS MARKET! Caitlin did late calls virtual showings, everything and everything we needed to get us in a great rental in a great area. Cant wait to work with Caitlin to find our forever home!