Service Areas
About Bethany Wager-Mckee
Credentials
LICENSE
Designation
CPRES
Top Producer
Real Estate Broker
Broker / Associate Broker
REALTOR
Awards
-
2026
TOP AGENT
Poughkeepsie, NY
2026
TOP AGENT
Marlboro, NY
2026
TOP AGENT
Hyde Park, NY
CPRES
Top Producer
Real Estate Broker
Broker / Associate Broker
REALTOR
2026
Poughkeepsie, NY
2026
Marlboro, NY
2026
Hyde Park, NY
Loading recent sales...
Zillow connected me to her through their automated system. She answered the phone and she said she'd send me a MLS for the property I was interested in and she didn't. She first said she send it the next day, because she was traveling. This was understandable, but then, she said she'd send it to me later that evening. I wasn't expecting it that evening. However, she didn't send it that evening or the next day.
Beth is very patient and took us to any properties before we found "the one". She is very knowledgeable and knows her business well. And if she doesn't know, she finds out PDQ! She helped us through the whole process and I would highly recommend her to anyone looking in the Hudson Valley!
She was very unprofessional and disorganized. It was impossible to get return calls and she seemed to struggle with simple questions. It?s hard to believe she?s been in the business as long as she claims. I would not recommend her to my friends.
This real estate agent disappeared without any communication, after I tried to schedule visit to visit the property. Multiple text messages were ignored. Not recommended.
This real estate agent disappeared without any communication, after I tried to schedule visit to visit the property. Multiple text messages were ignored. Not recommended.
She was a pleasure to work with. Responsive and knowledgable. Although I wasnt ready to purchase a home, she gave me useful advice that made the home buying process seem more feasible.
My husband and I recently bought our first house and Bethany was our realtor. She was really great to work with and regularly went above and beyond on our behalf. She was available for any questions regardless of the time, advocated for us and problem solved when needed. She advocated for us as her clients, and we would highly recommend her.
Bethany was a great agent for me. She helped me buy my current home a few weeks ago. She was very pro-active in finding what I wanted and also arranging showings for homes I found myself. She was very good at getting multiple showings near each other which made it easy to see more homes without driving around to much. Always professional. Very friendly and great personality. She made the whole process of finding a new home easy! I would highly recommend her for any real estate needs.
Bethany was an unbelievable advocate for us with an uncanny ability to comfort nervous first time home buyers and also expedite certain processes that we were unfamiliar with. Not enough nice things can be said for the time and thoughtfulness Bethany showed us during this process.
We first met Bethany at a house she had listed. We very much appreciated her forthrightness in describing the challenges we we were going to face in renovation. She subsequently showed us a house another agent was showing. Closing was delayed due to deficiencies revealed during inspection and testing. During this time, Bethany invested substantially more time than one would expect in arranging for appropriate corrective services. Her efforts were exceptional. And, it should be noted, we have dealt with many agents as this is our sixth substantial real estate transaction.
Bethany assisted me in finding me and my wife a perfect home during the times of covid. Bethany showed me multiple listings until I found exactly what I wanted. Very easy to communicate with and a person of her word.Went above and beyond after the purchase was done to help me with other things things that she didnt have to do. If you are looking for a skillful real estate professional that will help you find the home of your dreams Bethany is the person for you.
Bethany was awesome from beginning until the end. She DID NOT show me properties there were outside of my vision. Bethany was always available and answered all of my questions. She also went above and beyond in every phase of my home buying experience. I learned a lot from Bethany and she kept me apprised of what to expect from my mortgae lender, the home inspector, the buyer and governmental agencies involved. Great personality and I will be working with Bethany in the future for my second home purchase.... I neverwrite reviews that is what she means to me!!!
Bethany was fantastic to work with! She was incredibly helpful and responsive throughout our buying process and really pushed to get things over the line as quickly as possible, have already recommended her to friends.
Beth was incredibly helpful in preparing our home for sale, pricing appropriately, and steering us through the entire sale process! We had multiple offers at the. Open House, and got more than we were asking. She made numerous phone calls and emails on our behalf to facilitate closing, and was communicative and forthright every step of the way. I highly recommend her!
Bethany was an awesome real estate agent. I was a first time home buyer and she helped me to understand all the steps in the process. She was super flexible with her hours to accommodate our schedule even showing us homes on holidays. I would definitely look for her help if I decide to purchase again in the future.
Buying a house is a stressful process, regardless of whether you?re a first time buyer or a seasoned veteran.Bethany went above and beyond to make sure that my purchase was a seamless and stress-free process from start to finish. This was the smoothest and easiest home buying experience that I have ever been through! You can always reach Bethany very quickly?she responded to my e-mails, phone calls and texts in a timely manner and took the time to explain everything to me. I really appreciated her continuous updates and progress throughout the whole process of buying my home.She is very knowledgeable. Thank you, Bethany for being so AWESOME at what you do!!! I really enjoyed working with you! I will definitely be referring everyone I know who is looking to buy or sell a home in orange and ulster counties.
Bethany was the PERFECT broker for us first time buyers. She was accessible, communicative, patient, and great at explaining things to us. I cannot recommend her more highly. Thanks to Bethany, the process was so smooth I?m afraid I have unrealistic expectations for how buying a home should work!
It was a pleasure working with her, she knew exactly what I wanted. She is an excellent negotiator, with an amazing drive for her work. She was on top of the deal from the start to the finish, reminding me of things I forgot to do. She is responsible, professional and very self organized. I would recommend her to anyone!
Bethany was amazingly helpful throughout the whole process, especially in such a crazy market. She continually sent us houses that met our criteria and was available around our schedule to show us places. We ended up finding a wonderful home and would recommend Bethany to anyone looking for a home in the Hudson valley!!
This is my first time buying a home and I must say the process is very stressful during the Covid pandemic. But Bethany was so helpful and patient with me. She is so responsive and knew exactly what I was looking for. I must?ve drove ioher crazy with all my questions but she was always so happy to quell my anxiousness. . In such a short time she made appointment after appointment to viewings. And now I?ll be closing on my first home in February! Thanks to her! I?ve already recommended my friends to her. Oh
Bethany helped my husband & I get into our first home. She was always available to us even on nights & weekends and we weren?t easy to please. She showed us so many homes in such a small amount of time. She remembers details & is extremely knowledgeable of the entire process. She answered all the multitude of questions we had & helped us navigate through this very tedious & stressful process. She went above & beyond what was expected & we are forever grateful. We couldn?t have hoped for a better realtor, I highly recommend her!
It was an absolute pleasure working with Bethany and I ended up with the condo of my dreams! She remembered every little detail of what I wanted and curated the best tours and then negotiated a price that could not be met. I could not recommend her more to excited first home buyers.
She was fast in her response and was involved in every step of buying the house. It was great working with her as her expertise for the process is excellent too
My partner and I have been very lucky to work with Ms. Wager. We will be soon closing on our first property for our growing family! Ms. Wager walked us through the home buying process she was constantly available to us. She responded to our questions late night weekends and checked in on us to make sure we weren?t getting lost in the process. My only hope is that when it?s time for us to buy our second home she will be available to us.
Beth was very accomodating, as my schedule changed daily, and managed to make appointments for me on the fly. Beth paid great attention to what I was looking for, and what I wasnt. Beth did not waste my time looking at houses I would not be interested in. She found me the perfect home for the wife and I. I would call her again immediately if and when my housing needs change.