Abigail Swihart

Q: 1. What advice would you give a buyer trying to purchase a home?

get clear before you start. your dream home isn’t just square footage! it’s school drop-offs, saturday mornings, and long-term lifestyle alignment. the more clarity we have up front (budget, timeline, non-negotiables), the smoother the entire process becomes. and in a fast market, preparation wins.

Q: 2. What advice would you give a seller trying to sell their home?

don’t list until you’re ready to impress. selling isn’t just about putting a sign in the yard.... it’s about positioning your home to feel like the one. i help sellers prep intentionally so we launch with confidence, not chaos. clean, calm, and clear is the vibe we’re going for. my clients have received over a million views through my social media showcasing their properties to hyper local buyers as well as those relocating to columbus.

Q: 3. What types of clients have you worked with?

i specialize in helping busy, successful families in columbus make seamless double moves—selling their current home and buying their next with clarity and strategy. i’ve worked with first-time sellers, second-time buyers, and professionals relocating for schools, space, or lifestyle shifts. my sweet spot? high-achieving families who want more ease in the process.

Q: 4. Describe a recent transaction you are fond of. How did it go?

a favorite was helping a family sell their starter home while pregnant with their second baby. we built a timeline around their due date, used my vendor list to knock out prep quickly, and went under contract in 4 days. they were in their forever home by month 7.... with a nursery ready in time. smooth, intentional, and stress-free—that’s the goal!

Q: 5. How did you get started in Real Estate?

i got into real estate because i saw how chaotic the process could be for families... and knew it didn’t have to be that way. with a background in strategy and a heart for helping people move forward, real estate became the perfect way to blend both. now i help families make moves that feel aligned with their next chapter.

Q: 6. Do you have any special education or training that will benefit your clients?

i’m trained in real estate strategy, market psychology, and digital marketing—but what truly benefits my clients is how i bring it all together. i was lucky enough to have started my career under Donald R. Kenney. being under his mentorhsip was such an important experience to have gotten me where i am today. i’ve built systems that simplify complex moves, plus a marketing approach that makes every listing feel premium, i stay current on what actually converts.

Red 1 Realty

8 Years of Experience

(13)

$18.2M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

220

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$349.8K

Average Price Point

Service Areas

Columbus, OH Dublin, OH Galena, OH Lewis Center, OH Powell, OH Sunbury, OH

View All Service Areas

About Abigail Swihart

Meet Abigail Swihart Valentine, a true real estate professional born and raised from Worthington, Ohio. Abigail's journey through the dynamic world of real estate has been nothing short of remarkable. With a commitment to unwavering expertise and a steadfast moral compass, Abigail has consistently delivered outstanding results for her clients, be they consumers, investors, developers, or fellow real estate professionals. Abigail's foundation in real estate was laid at Ohio State University, where she honed her skills and gained invaluable experience working alongside Donald R. Kenney, a renowned figure in Columbus, OH's real estate development scene. Here, she absorbed top-tier business practices, cultivated strategic management acumen, and mastered the art of negotiation. Since earning her real estate license in 2018, Abigail has amassed a portfolio of 35 (and counting) rental properties. In 2021 alone, she facilitated the sale of a total of 145 homes, a feat she exceeded in 2022, with over 165 homes sold. Beyond her own career, Abigail is driven by a genuine passion for assisting others in their real estate endeavors. She takes immense pleasure in sharing her knowledge and expertise with those navigating the complex landscape of buying, selling, or renting properties. Abigail's dedication to helping others achieve their real estate goals is evident in her participation as a speaker on esteemed panels throughout Columbus, including Impactful Women in Columbus Real Estate, Elevate Real Estate, and LINK Real Estate. Recently, Abigail graced the cover of Top Agent Ohio's magazine, a testament to her standing as a true industry leader. Outside of the real estate world, Abigail cherishes moments spent with her family and friends. She maintains an active lifestyle and eagerly explores national parks during her free time, as well as taking care of her 2 german shepherds, Zara and Nova. Her unwavering drive and determination are the driving forces behind her continuous pursuit of excellence and success in her career. When it comes to real estate, Abigail Swihart Valentine is your trusted partner for all your property needs.

OTHER LANGUAGES

English

Community Involvement

I love being involved in the community where I live and work. I help organize neighborhood block parties and fun seasonal events that get people together, and I am always sharing my favorite local spots to support the small businesses that make our area special. I stay plugged into what is happening with development and zoning to help protect the character of our neighborhoods. I also put time into the Worthington Hills Gardening Club and other projects that make our streets feel even more welcoming. Real estate is about more than houses to me. It is about helping people feel at home in a community they are excited to be part of.

HOBBIES/INTEREST

I am happiest when I am outside in my garden with dirt on my hands, tending to my hydrangeas and planning what I want to plant next. I love exploring new restaurants and coffee spots around Columbus, especially places with great patios. When I am not working, you can usually find me with my family at the pool or a park, traveling when we can, or checking out fun local events. I am a big fan of design, home projects, and anything that lets me be creative. And yes, I am that person who will always stop to pet a cute dog or cat.

FAMILY

Family is everything to me. My husband Mike and I are raising our son James along with our very loved pets, and we soak up every adventure we can together. We spend a lot of time outside, hosting friends, and enjoying our neighborhood. Becoming a mom has made me even more passionate about helping families find the right home and community to grow into. The way a home supports real memories, real milestones, and real connection is why I love what I do.

Credentials

LICENSE

Real Estate - Ohio - # 2018002817

Specialties

Buyer's Agent
Investment Properties
Listing Agent
Relocation
Rentals

Awards

Other Awards

Top 1% Club, Most Influential Women In Real Estate (Columbus)

Loading recent sales...

Abigail Swihart's Reviews & Ratings

13 Reviews

(5/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Communicative
Knowledgeable
Responsive
Professional
Outstanding
Available Remotely
Attentive
Great for new buyers
Hard working
Trustworthy

Jacobyount0

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

May 8, 2026

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

He did an outstanding selling our rental property. He Helped with getting the house ready for sale, helped to stage the house and was great in prolonged negotiations.

Dani D.

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

March 3, 2025

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Had a great experience was able to find dream home in the area we wanted before listing current home and was able to sell our house on a short time line for the amount we wanted

User2994749

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

February 18, 2025

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Outstanding agent. Advised us during purchase, renovation and marketing of an upscale property. Excellent staging, managed multiple brokers and offers., Would highly recommend.

LisaWilson86

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

December 3, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Abigail is a great person. She cares about everything that you're trying to accomplish as a family. She even cares after the sale and that's important because when we needed her, she stepped up. I would recommend her to anyone she knowledgeable she with you every step on your journey! Call her you will not regret it!

Bmnkb69kvx

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

October 23, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

My spouse and I moved to Columbus from a different state, and we believed it was time to move out of our apartment into a true home. We wanted a real estate professional that was an expert in their field and would put our interest first. We got more than what we bargained for with Abigail. We found her to be so knowledgeable and answered all of our questions. She responded to our questions and concerns with lightening speed. Most importantly Abigail put us first in the buying process. She also found and placed us into our dream home. I would tell anyone that they need Abigail on their side if youre searching for a home. She isnt just our agent, now we can call her our friend.

Zuser20170819171742441

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

October 18, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Abigail is the best she honestly cares about your end result! We never gave and found favorable results for our new life. She has contact that are the best people I ever met! Ask a lot of questions because there is always those what ifs!

Michelle B.

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

June 7, 2024

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

My introduction to Abigail "Abbey" Swihart Valentine was via divine intervention. To make a long story short, we were connected while I searched on Zillow. Abbey is not overbearing, but but she is assertive in the best way possible. She thinks "out of the box," and always acts in the best interest of her clients. Abbey is both my selling and buying agent and I would have it no other way! She is very responsive to questions and she truly listens to her customers. If you are looking for a dedicated, astute, consummate professional realtor, look no further than Abigail Swihart Valentine.

Vodopichm

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

August 28, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Abigail is an absolute rockstar! She helped me quickly get my first home on the market after putting an offer on my dream home. She provided a wealth of knowledge on preparing my home to sell to get the best possible offer. She navigated me through multiple offers to help select what best fit my needs for closing quickly on both homes. She was also instrumental in negotiations to get our offer accepted on our new home. Abigail is well connected in the industry and helped us get quotes from multiple contractors to support our negotiations after inspection. She was available any time- often after business hours- when we needed her to answer a question or talk with the selling agent on the house we were purchasing. She is meticulous, knowledgeable, passionate, and an all-around great person to work with.

Njcarnesi

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

August 28, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Abigail was absolutely the right agent for us. She took the time to understand what we truly wanted and heard us as our opinions changed throughout our search. When it came to offer/negotiation time she pushed when she needed to push and carried us to the end. We couldnt be happier with our experience with her.

Molly S.

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

August 24, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Abigail helped my parents sell my childhood home, closed QUICK, no inspection and all cash! Not only that, she helped them find their forever home. She is an absolute dream to work with. Abigail also works frequently with my law firm and handles all of our real estate referrals. We cannot speak more highly of her and we certainly recommend her to anyone who needs help buying or selling their homes!

Kittensyes

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

August 24, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Abigail was incredible!! She took the time to really get to know and understand exactly what we were looking for and stopped at nothing to make our dreams comes true. We were first time home buyers and she took the time to walk us through every step of the process and built immense trust. I could not be happier with the experience I had with her and highly recommend her.

Olivia P.

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

August 24, 2023

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Abigail did a fantastic job helping us being first time buyers and finding exactly what we needed! She had great negotiating skills and taught us stuff every step of the way! Cannot recommend her enough for anyone looking to buy or sell a house

Brittani O.

Review for Member: Abigail Swihart

July 14, 2020

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Getting a house in the Columbus real estate market seemed like an extremely daunting task when my husband and I started the process of shopping around. We immediately fell in love with a house and I believe Abigail was the only one who could have gotten it for us in this competitive climate. Our offer was accepted on the very first house due completely to her knowledge and skill set tailored to the needs of the sellers and her extensive communication with the agent. If you are wanting to not take any risks in getting your dream home, Abigail is the clear choice in this competitive buyers market!!