Company Thumbnail Image
    Send Message

    Thomas J McCarthy Real Estate Inc

    46520 County Rd 48
    Southold, NY 11971

    Send Message
      Thomas McCarthy

      Thomas McCarthy

      Southold, NY

      (110)
      62 REVIEWS(4.9/5)
      Andrew L.
      April 21, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Tom was great to work with when purchasing our home. He was extremely responsive, knowledgeable about the local market, and proactive throughout the process. He helped us identify potential issues early and provided clear, effective advice on negotiation strategy. We would highly recommend working with Tom.
      Vknotoff
      February 18, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Matty went above and beyond to assist in the sale of my parents home. He was knowledgeable, courteous, and very kind in understanding how difficult it was for the family to put their childhood home up for sale. I would use him again as my real estate agent.
      Teresa M.
      August 4, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Thomas did a great job in helping us with the purchase of our townhouse. Thomas, Matt, Colin and all of his staff couldnt have been any more helpful. They answered all our questions promptly and their advise was spot on. I highly recommend them if you are looking to purchase a new home!!
      Teerose7
      February 18, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Matt did such an amazing job with the sale of our dads house. He was professional and courteous and so very helpful!! Selling my family home was a very emotional time for us, and Matts kind and thoughtful manner made the transition much easier. I would highly recommend Matt as an agent. I promise you wont be disappointed!
      Banglebeads
      February 17, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Working with Matthew McCarthy as our agent was an outstanding experience from start to finish. From our very first conversation regarding the sale of our home, Matthew was professional, responsive, and genuinely considerate of our needs and concerns. He took the time to understand exactly what our needs were and guided us through every step of the process with patience and clarity. What truly set him apart was his negotiation skills. He advocated for us with confidence and strategy, ensuring we received the best possible outcome. We always felt that our interests were being protected and prioritized. His knowledge of the market and attention to detail gave us complete confidence in every decision. Beyond this, Matthew consistently went above and beyondaEUR"whether it was accommodating our schedule, proactively addressing potential issues before they became problems, or simply checking in to make sure we felt comfortable with next steps. His dedication and work ethic made what could have been a stressful process feel smooth and manageable. I would highly recommend Matthew to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, trustworthy, and hardworking real estate professional. We are incredibly grateful for his support and wouldnt hesitate to work with him again!
      Location:
      Loading map