Company Thumbnail Image
    Send Message

    RE/MAX New Beginnings Realty

    509 Main St
    Toms River, NJ 08753

    Send Message
      Michael Tumminelli

      Michael Tumminelli

      Toms River, NJ

      (95)
      Patrick Meehan

      Patrick Meehan

      Toms River, NJ

      Michael Harbord

      Michael Harbord

      Toms River, NJ

      (94)
      298 REVIEWS(5.0/5)
      Kbridges15
      April 21, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      I'm not one for reviews, but we have recommended Nicole to several friends because we felt she did such an amazing job helping us navigate the buying process and securing our home! She was patient, knowledgeable, responsive, and honest - everything youd hope for with your realtor! Highly recommend Nicole!
      Maggie S.
      April 21, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      I cannot recommend Nicole Pagnoni highly enough. Selling a family home is never easy, but Nicole handled the sale of my grandmothers house with incredible professionalism and genuine empathy. She took care of every detail, kept me informed at every step, and made what could have been a very stressful process feel seamless. If you want a realtor who is both highly skilled and truly compassionate, look no further.
      Deborah H.
      November 19, 2025
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Mike's 30 years of experience and knowledge in the field, made our negotiations and sale profitable for everyone involved. Mike always kept us updated , and was responsive in a timely fashion .
      Kayjay21
      April 21, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Nicole went above and beyond to help me buy my house. She is the best. If I ever sell she will be the agent I will call. I lived an hour away and she would check out the units before I could. She also knows the area really well.
      Bolie7203
      April 22, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Working with Nicole was an amazing experience! As a first-time homebuyer, I had so many questions, and she guided me every step of the way. She was incredibly responsive, always answering my texts so quickly, and made me feel supported throughout the entire process. We ran into some issues with the crawlspace, and at one point I honestly thought we were going to back out of the deal because of the seller. On top of that, the sellers agent was lacking and not keeping things moving. But Nicole went above and beyond, she stepped in, took on extra work, and worked closely with myself and my attorney to stay on top of everything. They gave me options and helped navigate a path forward so we could still make the deal happen. I truly felt like Nicole had my best interests at heart the entire time. I couldnt have asked for a better realtor. I strongly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!
      Location:
      Loading map