Company Thumbnail Image
    Send Message

    Coldwell Banker American Homes

    28 East Main Street
    Smithtown, NY 11787

    Send Message
      Nicole Chimento

      Nicole Chimento

      Smithtown, NY

      (24)
      Sherri Cosentino

      Sherri Cosentino

      Smithtown, NY

      Portia Gelormino

      Portia Gelormino

      Smithtown, NY

      24 REVIEWS(5.0/5)
      Jennifer C.
      January 17, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      I cant recommend Nicole highly enoughaEUR"she truly helped us find our dream home in the exact neighborhood we wanted! She listened carefully to our must-haves and preferences, and her deep knowledge of the local market was impressive. From day one, Nicole was genuinely motivated to make our dream happen. We told her our top priority was to find and close on a house before getting married so we could cross the threshold as husband and wife. She took that to heart and got us under contract and closed in less than 4 months. That fast, successful closing turned our wedding into the perfect new beginning in our forever home. Nicole was always prepared to be hands on- whether that meant inspecting properties thoroughly and pointing out potential issues to check things out herself. What stood out most was how proactive she was in ruling out homes that wouldnt be a good long-term fit for us, even if they looked appealing on paper. She educated us every step of the way about what to look for in a home, neighborhood trends, and the buying process, which made us feel confident and informed as first-time buyers. Thanks to her expertise and dedication, we ended up with a house that checks every box and feels like home. Were so grateful and are fortunate enough to not only have gained a trusted real estate agent on our team, but also gained a neighbor and a friend. If youre looking for an agent whos knowledgeable, hands-on, honest, and truly puts your needs first, Nicole is the one.
      User19701698
      September 22, 2025
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Nicole did an outstanding job working with me to assist in the process of selling my home. Come to think of it, aEURoeassistaEUR? is the incorrect word. Nicole took the reins and ensured that I walked away with the highest possible value for my home. She is responsive, empathetic, and most of all trustworthy. I wouldnt want to do any of this process without Nicole and her expertise!
      Yanks71025
      March 20, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      We had an amazing experience working with Nicole Chimento! She helped us sell our home and find the perfect new one, and we couldnt be happier with the entire process. As a mortgage loan officer, I have worked with many realtors over the years, when it was time for my own new purchase and existing sale, there was never a doubt on who I was choosing! Nicole is incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and truly family-oriented. She was always flexible and willing to show us homes whenever we asked, which made a stressful process feel so much easier. We never felt rushed or pressuredaEUR"she really took the time to understand what was best for our family. On the selling side, Nicole went above and beyond and was able to get us top dollar for our home. Her expertise and dedication really showed every step of the way. Overall, it was a smooth and positive experience from start to finish. We highly recommend Nicole to anyone looking to buy or sell a home!
      Andrew And Amanda B.
      January 5, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      We were introduced to Nicole through our mortgage team at Four Leaf, and it was easily the best recommendation we received. As first-time homebuyers, we were completely new to the process, but Nicole made us feel confident from day one. I jokingly told her during our first call that I wanted a "Father of the Bride" house, thinking it was a pipe dream, but Nicole actually made it happen! Even during the busy holiday season, she was incredibly patient, answering our millions of questions and providing tailored listings. We found our dream home after only a few outings, and Nicole's expertise ensured we landed the deal. If you're looking for a dedicated, responsive, and effective realtor on Long Island, we cannot recommend Nicole enough!
      Matthew D.
      November 24, 2025
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Nicole is a amazing person and reltor. From signing the contract to close it was a super easy process. She answered all of our questions, very knowledgeable. Will definitely recommend her to family and friends.Thank you Nicole!!! The best in the business.
      Location:
      Loading map