Company Thumbnail Image
    Send Message

    Catanese Real Estate

    405 Carpenter Street
    Evansville, IN 47708

    Send Message
      Jeremy Outlaw

      Jeremy Outlaw

      Evansville, IN

      (3)
      Natalie Wilhelm

      Natalie Wilhelm

      Evansville, IN

      (2)
      69 REVIEWS(5.0/5)
      Kayla P.
      November 23, 2025
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Jeremy was amazing to work with! Great communication. Made me feel so much better when he would give me regular updates when trying to sell my home. I will definitely use his services again if we decide to buy or sell another home.
      Chelseyhedrick889
      September 10, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      My husband and I had the privilege of working with Natalie to both purchase our new home and sell our current one, and we could not be more grateful for the experience. From the very beginning, Natalie demonstrated an incredible level of dedication, professionalism, and responsiveness that exceeded every expectation we had. Natalie took us on what felt like countless home tours, never making us feel rushed or pressured. She was patient, attentive, and genuinely committed to helping us find the right home for our family. No matter how many questions we had or how many properties we wanted to see, she always showed up with a positive attitude and a wealth of knowledge. What truly sets Natalie apart is her responsiveness and sense of urgency. Any time we had a request, wanted to schedule a showing, needed information, or had a concern, she acted on it immediately, often within hours. Throughout both the buying and selling process, she was always one step ahead, keeping us informed, prepared, and confident in every decision we made. Selling a home and buying another at the same time can be incredibly stressful, but Natalie made the process feel manageable. She provided expert guidance, offered thoughtful advice, and was always available when we needed support. Her communication was exceptional, and she consistently went above and beyond to ensure everything moved forward smoothly. It's rare to find someone who cares as much about their clients as Natalie does. We never felt like just another transaction; we felt like a priority every step of the way. Her work ethic, attention to detail, and genuine commitment to her clients are truly remarkable. If you're looking for a realtor who is knowledgeable, hardworking, responsive, and completely invested in helping you succeed, Natalie is the one. We would recommend her without hesitation to anyone buying or selling a home. Thank you, Natalie, for making such a significant life transition a positive and successful experience! 5 stars isn't enough.
      Ebbarnes26
      November 10, 2025
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Jeremy helped make the home buying process easy for us as first time buyers. He assisted with communication between the bank which was a huge help. He worked around our schedules and was always available for questions. Highly recommend Jeremy for all your home buying needs!
      Bradley E.
      March 26, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Jeremy did a great job helping me purchase a home. He was very helpful with quick responses throughout the entire process. I would definitely do business with him again.
      W363157
      December 11, 2025
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Natalie opened my very new eyes to All things Process, approachability and level-headedness as it relates to sales. I was delighted with her uninterrupted patience and kindnesses she exuded in a manner most professional and humane. Thank you Natalie bc I was ready to walk away and you changed that.
      Location:
      Loading map