Company Thumbnail Image
    Send Message

    Benchmark Realty

    1712 KY HWY 121 N. Suite A
    Murray, KY 42071

    Send Message
      Sue Ann Stevens

      Sue Ann Stevens

      Murray, KY

      (12)
      Tracy Mayhew

      Tracy Mayhew

      Paducah, KY

      (31)
      37 REVIEWS(5.0/5)
      Kali W.
      February 11, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      We had a great experience with Tracy. She kept in contact with us from the first time we reached out until we were able to start looking for a home. When the time came she explained the process and helped us along the way. She responds quickly, very open and detailed. The process was very smooth. We are really glad we have her for a realtor.
      Adam H.
      March 27, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Tracy truly goes above and beyond. Shes helped me seamlessly navigate both buying and selling property, and her dedication is unmatched every step of the way. If youre looking for someone who will work tirelessly in your best interest, I highly recommend Tracy, you will not find a more committed realtor in the area.
      Humphrey F.
      July 31, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      I worked with Tracy on buying a home in Paducah, and she was fantastic from start to finish. I was moving from another state, and she really made the whole process feel manageable instead of overwhelming. Tracy was patient and very detailed, always keeping me on track with deadlines and explaining what needed to happen next. She handled inspections, helped negotiate repairs, and took care of so many things behind the scenes that I never had to worry about them. Her communication was greataEUR"she kept in touch with updates the whole way, so I always knew what was completed and where we were in the process. On top of that, she even had a thoughtful welcome gift waiting, which meant a lot to me as someone relocating. Overall, Tracy is professional, kind, and truly client-focused. Id happily work with her again and highly recommend her, especially for anyone buying from out of state or looking for an agent who will really stay on top of the details.
      Greg B.
      March 26, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      I recently purchased a home through Zillow mortgage program. If I used their affiliate agent I would forego the appraisal fee. I said, aEURoeyes,aEUR? with a little skepticism. What I got was an agent named Tracy Mayhew, Benchmark Realtor in Paducah, KY, my home purchase destination. Tracy is thorough and absolutely flawless. She made every effort to help me choose the right house for my needs. Most of our interactions were over the phone and FaceTime but we got the chance to meet personally at out last house inspection in Paducah and she was just as warm and attentive in person. Tracy tells the truth and points out features many would overlook to make a sale. She treats you the way she would want to be treated. Put all of those attributes together and it spells an exceptional agent and buyers experience. Kudos to Tracy Mayhew.
      Megan S.
      May 25, 2026
      Zillow
      VERIFIED
      Tracy is without a doubt the realtor you want in your corner! My family relocated across the state, and Tracy bent over backwards to accommodate us, doing virtual tours and offering her professional insight. She is an excellent communicator, educating us on the process and kept us in the loop the whole time. Tracy truly made the home buying process as smooth as can be and she was an absolute joy to work with! I can't say enough good things!!
      Location:
      Loading map