Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Sassyshar6264
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIEDTibitha was just wonderful helping us find the home for us here in Ohio. She never gave up and always made time for any questions we had, even if they seemed silly. Always with a smile, makes you feel at ease. Will recommend her to everyone I know and will certainly work with her again in the future if the need arises.
Gabriel271931
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was very kind and thoughtful all throughout the whole process. She was always responsive to my questions and would always give me feedback. She definitely cares about her clients and very dedicated to her work.10/10 would recommend for anybody whos trying to purchase their first home!
Cheryl M.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED As first-time homebuyers, we had absolutely no clue what we were doing, but Tibi made the entire process feel so much less overwhelming. From the beginning, she was patient, kind, knowledgeable, and always took the time to explain things and guide us every step of the way. When we finally found the house we loved, Tibi was just as excited as we were and wrapped me in the biggest, most heartfelt mom hug. Then she moved mountains to help make sure we got our home! That moment meant so much to us and truly showed how personally invested Tibi was in helping make our dream of becoming homeowners a reality. We are beyond grateful for everything she did for us and could not have asked for a better realtor to guide us through our first home-buying experience. We would recommend her to anyone, especially first-time homebuyers!
Malbertini325
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED What i expected was a huge complicated experience. What i got was peace of mind andconfidence in Tibithas knowledge. I have not bought or sold a house in over 30 yrs so we had alot to learn about selling in current times. Tibitha always had the answers!
Lkiddon4
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED This was our first experience selling a house. We couldn't have asked for a better realtor than Tibitha Matheney! Tibi was with us every step of the way. From the moment we met her, we felt comfortable with her. She walked through our house and help us decide which things were important to address and which were not. We were clueless; thank goodness for Tibi! She helped us choose an asking price and explained her thought process. She answered all of our questions in a concise way (and we had a lot of questions). She even had an open house the day after the house was listed! We live hours away from where we were selling. Tibi even helped by letting workers into the house. Pretty much everything for the sale was handled online. Tibi worked hard to get the asking price for our house. And she went through the closing documents line by line with us so we fully understood everything. We highly encourage anyone who is looking for an honest, hardworking realtor to consider Tibitha Matheney. You'll be happy you did.
User4546836
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha made the process very easy! She was very responsive and walked us through the process every step of the way. I would use her again if I was selling/buying!
Zuser20220329193123327
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was great to work with! She devoted a lot of time with us and her experience was very helpful during our home buying process. As out of state buyers, she was able to help us with many different quotes and recommendations. She also was very accommodating with our schedule and remote closing needs.
Reynok7
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha is fantastic! So glad we chose to work with her to get our dream home! What really stood out was how much she went above and beyond. She not only helped us navigate the buying process, but also connected us with a fantastic home inspector and reliable contractors for quotes and repairs. She?s a great communicator and we felt well informed through the entire process!
Mikeconnolly1968
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha went the extra mile for me. I had a property that had some technical issues and she was able to market it and get it sold to the right person. She is very good at bouncing ideas and coming up with a resolution. She?s definitely a deal maker.She is a classy lady and a true master of her craft. You cannot go wrong with her as your representative! Only one issue, she needs to use more four letter words.
Amanda H.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was an excellent realtor who we were able to trust and was by our side for every question and decision. We had no idea what the process of selling a house was, how to prepare, or how to start. She was with us every step of the way and always got back to us right away. She is personable but still knows how to put the job at hand first. We were fully confident in all our decisions with her by our side and I would recommend her for anyone looking to buy or sell.
Jpo825
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha and her assistant did an outstanding job helping us sell our house. We purchased the house through Tibitha back in 2012 and knew it was in our best interest to stay with her due to her many years of experience in real estate in our area.
Cherry2205
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha Matheney is an excellent realtor! She goes above and beyond to help you every step of the way! She is very knowledgeable and works hard to help you through the whole process! With her many years of experience we highly recommend her for all of your real estate needs!!
Ryan H.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was referred to us from a friend and did not disappoint! She was clear and concise with us and made selling our father?s home a breeze. Would recommend to anyone in the Youngstown area who is looking to buy or sell their home! She was extremely knowledgeable and great at communicating on all aspects of the process.
Jeanettefolliett
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha Matheney did her research and suggested a price that would sell quickly. The home sold within three days with a full price offer. She responded quickly to all my messages and answered all my questions thoroughly. I would hire her again.
Mamalizia
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED It was a delight to work with Tibitha. She is very knowledgeable about the industry, she is honest when she does an assestment of your house and tells you what to expect. She did a detailed market analysis of other properties around mine and gave me an honest opinion on the value of my house. She was very responsive to any inquiries and alway kept me up to date on anything that was happening with the property. I highly recommend her.
Brian G.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha has been an exceptional realtor to work with. Their communication is always clear, timely, and professional, making every step of the process feel smooth and manageable. They are consistently friendly, approachable, and genuinely invested in helping clients succeed. Their dedication and hard-working attitude truly set them apart. I highly recommend Tibitha to anyone looking for a reliable and supportive real estate professional.
Mmtoth0
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha did a amazing job helping us get our house. She made sure we could view the house multiple times and got all of the information we needed/requested.
Beverly L.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha is very knowledgeable, professional, and very easy to work with. She listens to her clients to determine their likes and dislikes and then narrows the search to find the perfect house for them. Thank you Tibitha for doing such a great job!
SLaraway
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha is an amazing realtor. I have bought and sold four different homes, over the past twenty years, using Tibitha. She is extremely knowledgeable and responsive to any and all requests. She is patient and has complete understanding in the wants and needs of her clients. She is a tremendous negotiator and works hard to get her clients fair deals. I recommend her to everyone I know that is in the market to buy or sell a home. Tibitha will go above and beyond to make sure her clients are happy.
Jack
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha helped me to sell my property, her experience, knowledge and flexibility made everything even easier I am so glad Tibitha was working for me, she remained professional but helped me feel less worried about the selling process
Reblynn629
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was such a pleasure to work with. I appreciated the time she took with me explaining what options I had in the process of selling this house by explaining commission and closing costs. She was always readily accessible to answer any questions when an offer was presented. I highly recommend working with Tibitha.
Amiller0917
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was great! She listened to our wants and needs to help find us the house of our dreams! She fought for us during negotiations and even helped us to find good contractors to fix things in the house. I was a first time home buyer and had no idea what I was doing, but I felt supported and she guided me through the entire process. I highly recommend her!
Rachelbendel2001
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Working with Tibitha was an absolute pleasure, and I cant recommend her enough. From the very beginning, it was clear she always had our best interest at heart, and made the entire process feel smooth and stress-free by truly taking the time to understand our needs and preferences. What impressed us the most was her proactive approach, as she was always one step ahead and was very quick to get us quotes and recommendations for everything we needed, even before we had the time to think about some of these things ourselves. She knew exactly when things needed to be done and kept everything moving forward. We never had to chase anyone down because she handled everything with such precision and speed. If youre looking for an agent who is organized, energetic, and dedicated to fighting for you, Tib is the perfect choice and I cannot recommend her enough!
Mario B.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED I am so glad we decided to work with Tibitha. She is one of the best realtors ive ever worked with. Extremely responsive, very diligent, communicates well, and gets the job done quickly. She was able to sell 3 properties of ours within 2 months all the way to closing which is a direct result of her hard work. Thank you Tibitha!
Jrothra11
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha is awesome. Buying a house can be an incredibly stressful experience and she goes out of her way to make sure her clients are happy and comfortable throughout the process.
Chloe D.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED As first-time home buyers, my husband and I couldnt have asked for a better experience than working with Tibitha. She was patient, thorough, and made sure we understood every part of the process. What truly set her apart was the way she went the extra mile to help us?she informed us about a home-buying grant that we hadn?t even known existed, and it turned out to be a lifesaver for us financially! Tibitha?s knowledge and expertise, combined with her dedication to our needs, made the entire journey smooth and stress-free. She was always available to answer questions, provided expert advice, and guided us through each step, ensuring we felt confident in our decisions. Her negotiation skills helped us secure a great deal, and she truly cared about finding the perfect home for us. We highly recommend Tibitha to anyone, especially first-time buyers. She?s not just a realtor, but a true partner in the home-buying process!
Cristobalvruiz
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was very helpful throughout our entire selling/buying process. She provided necessary recommendations and was always available. She had an answer to all of our questions.
Rasha A.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha is an excellent agent! As I was a first time home buyer, she was very helpful and always answered my many questions on how things work until I finally find my house. She is very knowledgeable and trustworthy. I would recommend her to anyone who?s looking for a trustworthy, knowledgable, patient, and kind agent. She is so great!
Kennethcullar
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was very professional in the process from start to finish. It felt like she represented us fairly and in a responsive manner. Communication was timely and clear. She also took extra effort to work with subcontractors to get prices and arrange servicing where little thing?s needed to be addressed. I would recommend her to represent anyone needing realtor needs. She also has a very competent assistant, Nicole that was working hard behind the scenes. This was my first connection with Tibi?s team and I would definitely return to them for future realtor needs. The process of selling our house from start to finish was about 2 weeks. This was very acceptable for my wife and I.
Aaren L.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was very outstanding throughout the whole home buying process. She was very patient and truly cared about finding the right home for us and would definitely recommend her to anybody in the housing market!
Canbaugh12
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was recommended to us by a friend and she was an absolute pleasure to work with. Incredibly organized and detail oriented, efficient and knowledgeable she was a joy to help us sell our home. Always easy to communicate with and contact I would highly recommend her services to anyone selling their house. We had a fantastic experience with her!
Kadidas615
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha did great helping us locate, walk and purchase property. She is a wealth of knowledge and very quick to respond. It took us some time to find the right place, but she was always there and willing to help.
User31389878
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was great as always! 2nd time buying with her. She has several good contacts that were very helpful throughout the process. She always replies quickly and went out of her way so we could see the very many properties we asked to, even on some weekends.
Emcguigan
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha and Century 21 team were very professional. Their paperwork protocols were very easy to follow. Tibitha was in touch with us and accessible 24/7. She made our selling experience personable.
Turtlangel
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED I worked with Tibitha following my mothers passing in Boardman, Ohio to help sell her condominium. I live out of state in Georgia so I expected this to be quite challenging; however, with Tibithas help the sale of the condo was smooth and easy. She is extremely knowledgeable regarding local contacts you may need such as title agents and handyman services. Her knowledge of the local housing market was vast, and she researched well. Our property had an offer we approved within 24 hours of being listed! I highly recommend Tibitha for all your realtor needs.
Clinejenny81
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha did an amazing job. We were so fortunate to work with her. I would recommend her to anyone needing realty services. Her attention to detail and her care for our wants and needs was exceptional.
Duritsa1
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha did a great job for us in the selling of our home. We live across the country now, and could not have been happier with the process. Would highly recommend her in the future!
K C.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was outstanding through the whole process. There were a few setbacks due to the buyers. In usual Tibitha style, she was unwavering. She has assisted me in both buying and selling a property. I recommend her 100%.
Jeffgrenamyer
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was the best. 10 out of 10 recommend. I couldn't be happier with help I got looking for my home. Definitely made things easier for me during the whole process.
Tkobrien55
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was more than helpful , actually outstanding ! Working with someone virtually on line from Colorado moving back to Youngstown area she was knowledgeable and most of all patient . It was a pleasant experience and if the chance would gladly recommend her to anyone
User80608122
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha is a great asset to have on your team when selling your home. She is friendly, passionate, and a good communicator. She is knowledgeable and kept us informed during the entire process. We sold our home in less than 5 weeks from listing to closing. She went above and beyond to assemble and close the sale. Also, thank you to the team at C21, Nicole and Val, for their outstanding support!
Kaminskijarrod
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha was absolutely brilliant! I would recommend her to work with anyone especially someone new looking for a home! She helped me go through the entire process of buying my first home and was there every step of the way! She is person that I would recommend to anyone looking for a home.
Amrenze
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED I am very happy with the service that Tibitha provided me when I sold my condo. She was professional, courteous, and knowledgeable. She helped me with every step of the process, from staging the property, marketing it online, negotiating with buyers, and closing the deal. She always kept me informed and answered all my questions promptly. She sold my condo in less than a month and got me a great price. I would highly recommend Tibitha to anyone looking for a reliable and experienced realtor. She is the best!
Soltislindsay
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha did an amazing job helping find a home and was very informative on the different homes we looked at. As a first time homeowner, she made the process easy and we felt comfortable going to her as well as asking her questions. She answered every text/call and if she wasnt sure about a question we asked, she immediately found the answer for us. She went above and beyond for us and we are so thankful that she helped us find our first house.
Slarocca6615
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha is the agent that is top notch in every aspect! She is strategic with her approach, but is also as hands on as you need her to be with her team. She works with high energy and has amazing empathy towards her clients.
Ericam0817
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Love working with Tibitha. She's a very likable, friendly person. She makes you feel like you're the only client she's working with. Very personable, prompt, and quick to find out answers to questions. We appreciate her honesty and trustworthiness. She makes the whole process as smooth as possible. She's helped our family with several real estate transactions. Would refer her expertise to anyone!
Midwayli
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha did an outstanding job in all phases from getting our duplex to the place it could be sold, working with me from out of state, and getting me more than expected for the sale. She was knowledgeable, professional, honest, and kind. Tibitha also provided me with referrals to other agencies that were required. I would gladly use her again and recommend her to my family and friends.
Rbrooksii2005
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED I was helping an elderly friend liquidate his estate and Tibitha was very understanding and patient with us as we went thru the process of selling his home. Tibitha took the time to explain each and every step to make sure we understood what was happening which made the sale stress free. Tibitha is my realtor for life!!
Ryan B.
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Tibitha went above and beyond with the purchase of my new home, by understanding exactly what my new family and I were looking for and supplying us with homes that were of our interest, all the way to providing the step by step process before it happened so we knew exactly what was going on without any surprises.
Bryanfranczkowski
Review for Member: Tibitha Matheney
ZillowVERIFIED Coming from the banking industry for more than 31 years, where and spent most of those years in the mortgage division. During that time I worked with a lot of great professionals, both internally and externally. I found myself working with Tibitha Matheney, owner-operator of 21st Century, Lakeside Reality. A real estate pro that has a knack for getting the job done. Recently Tibitha listed a property for my wife and me. From the jumpstart, she was informative and very knowledgeable about the neighborhood. During the process she made us feel like we were part of her team. She was always available to answer calls and provide updates on a regular basis. We liked the fact that she has a team approach and that she has the resources available to get your home ready for market. We are very happy with the level of service she provided and recommend to anyone who is looking to purchase or sell their home that Tibitha is the real estate professional that you can trust and rely on.
View All Listings