Service Areas
About Susan Connelly
Credentials
LICENSE
Specialties
- Buyer's Agent
- Listing Agent
Awards
-
2026
TOP AGENT
Riverhead, NY
2026
TOP AGENT
Hampton Bays, NY
2026
TOP AGENT
Greenvale, NY
Available Listings View All



View All Listings2026
Riverhead, NY
2026
Hampton Bays, NY
2026
Greenvale, NY



View All ListingsSusan and Richard are consummate real estate professionals. Their straightforward, authentic, and honest style makes seller and buyer comfortable and confident. Integrity and earned trust are high on their goals. My wife and I recently sold our primary residence of 41 years in Malverne NY, a special home where our family thrived. The Connelly team was sensitive to the concerns of seller and buyer, provided great guidance to all parties, and facilitated the transfer of a very special property to another caring family. You can place your trust and confidence in the Connelly team. We did so with no regrets. Jim Jacobs
Susan worked extremely hard selling my home. She is amazing I cant thank her enough for all the hours she worked in order to get it accomplished. Her experience and hard work was the best combination to get my house sold. She always goes way beyond to sell my homes. I worked with her and Richard for years.
Working with Susan was an absolute pleasure from start to finish. As first-time homebuyers, we really relied on her guidance, and she went above and beyond to make the process smooth and stress-free. She was always quick to respond, patient with all our questions, and incredibly knowledgeable about every step. Susan also connected us with a wonderful attorney and lender, which made everything even easier. With her help, we were able to close on our first home aEUR" and we couldnt be happier! We truly appreciate everything she did for us and cant recommend her highly enough.
We had the pleasure of working with Susan as our real estate agent, and we couldnt be more grateful for her expertise and professionalism. She was incredibly prompt and responsive throughout the entire process, always available to answer questions or provide guidance when needed. Susan has a true talent for managing complex situations with calm and confidence, and her strong communication skills made everything feel smooth and clear. Most importantly, she has a sharp instinct for negotiation, helping us secure the best possible outcome. We highly recommend Susan to anyone looking for a knowledgeable, reliable, and dedicated real estate partner.
I have been working with Susan and the Connelly team for a few years now across multiple properties. I continue to go back because she is easy to work with, extremely professional, committed, and overall a nice person. She was committed to selling our home, hosting multiple open houses, being flexible for private showings, and leveraging various outlets to get the word out, including local magazines. She took the time to really know our home, ensuring that potential buyers would have all of their questions answered. I would continue to recommend her and her team.
Susan was super knowledge and responsive throughout this process! We appreciated her help and care in helping us find our home. She got back to us right away with any questions
Susan was super knowledge and responsive throughout this process! We appreciated her help and care in helping us find our home. She got back to us right away with any questions
Susan was phenomenal! Patient, explained everything. Moved the process along. Glad she was my agent. Very knowledgeable . Brought alot of prospective buyers to my condo
I am very pleased with the way Susan and her team managed sale of my house. It was efficient and quick. I praise Susan for great local knowledge, process expertise, and also for her responsiveness and negotiation skills.
By using Susan you can feel 100% confident that your home is in the best hands. She knows her job and keeps you always up to date with the latest news. I strongly recommend her for selling your house.
Susan has been amazing since the first call. She is very knowledgeable and determined. She always responds in a timely manner and is on time. We brought our first house with her and we couldnt be more satisfied with how quick and painless she has made the process. I would recommend her over and over again! Thank you Susan for being you!
Wonderful job! From beginning of the process through the closing. Susan was thorough, always available and very persistent with following up with potential buyers. Helping lead to our eventual sale to wonderful buyers. Thank You.
Wonderful job! From beginning of the process through the closing. Susan was thorough, always available and very persistent with following up with potential buyers. Helping lead to our eventual sale to wonderful buyers. Thank You.
Susan is an amazing professional. She has extensive knowledge of the market out east on Long Island. She has a full compliment of professionals that can assist in every aspect of a real estate transaction. I give her my highest recommendation.
Susan is amazing! So intelligent, warm personality and professional. Susan is providing me with expert advice on my North Fork home. Specifically she helped set a realistic selling price for my unit. So glad she is my agent!
great job assisting finding a good rental property, good location, and helping us managing the whole process. Glad to deal with Susan, amazing professional, great knowledge of the area and understanding of family needs. Kids liked her a lot as well. only good words to describe her help. looking forward to deal with Susan again in the future
Susan is the best! We were picky and always seemed to be behind the market but Susan never gave up and kept scouring the market until we found the perfect house for us. Thanks Susan!!
Susan is an outstanding real estate professional. She is experienced, determined, and energetic. It is very easy and pleasant to work with her. She is goal oriented, and delivers results. Total success!
I've been looking to get out of the city and away from its density. Susan was recommended to me by a friend who lives on the island. She's been extremely pleasant to work with thus far. I've seen a handful of properties and feel like I'll be a Long Island resident soon! She answers all of my questions and phone calls anytime I reach out to her on her cell. As an added bonus to her knowledge and attentiveness, she has a vast number of professionals who she works with and has provided me with multiple contacts as referrals to bring my vision to life when I close on one of the two properties I've made offers on. I'd recommend Susan to anyone in the market for a home, whether it's going to be their primary residence or an investment property.
Susan was instrumental in the purchase of my home, as she had a wealth of resources for me to use at every step of the process, including recommendations on mortgage providers, real-estate attorneys and contractors, for my future renovation work. She was pro-active, communicative and hands-on, and I would highly recommend Susan and The Connelly Team to anyone needing assistance in the purchase of a home or the sale of their own home. You will be greatly pleased!
Susan was incredible and so instrumental in helping me find the perfect home. She was very professional and told me exactly what to do along the way. Her connections from mortgage broker to insurance lender to finding a mason made this process seamless
Susan worked with us through a number of showings and several offers. She knows the area and gave us great advice. Susan is easy to work with and makes a process that can be stressful a pleasant experience.
Susan is the best! She has great relationships with other brokers in the area and an intimate knowledge of market conditions. Her advice was invaluable in buying my first home, I could not have done it without her. When choosing an agent you want someone who knows the market and will advocate for you at every turn, and Susan is the best fit for that. Highly recommend Susan for your home purchasing needs.
She worked so hard to help us all the way along. A wonderful person and great to help guide us through the process. She helped us figure out our offer, showed us a number of houses. Helped us get to closing. Met us at the house multiple times when she didnt need to. Was friendly and knowledgeable and connected us to a great mortgage broker.
Susan helped me navigate a very competitive and unusual buyers RE landscape - eventually getting me into a nice condo in Moriches. She was always willing to meet me at the properties I selected, always on time, and she always brought her positive outlook and smile.
Susan came recommended to us by our neighbor and she exceeded our every expectation. She was professional, punctual, knowledgable and a real class act. She is one of the smartest and hardest working people I've had the pleasure of dealing with. Susan knows the ins-and-outs of the real estate business and how to get things done. We would recommend Susan and the Connelly Team to anyone and will call them again should we ever be looking to buy or sell property on Long Island. Thank you Susan.
Susan is top notch. Her experience, knowledge and advice were invaluable in helping us purchase our home. We also very much appreciated how quickly she responded to our questions and her recommendations of service providers.
Susan has been an absolute pleasure to work with! She is honest, knowledgeable, available, and an incredible resource. We always felt that she had our back and was looking out for our interests. She was always responsive and available - it was so easy for us to arrange meetings and to ask questions. She is helpful on so many levels and has a great network to help you. She goes above and beyond to truly help her clients. Highly recommend!
Susan was amazing! She was extremely patient with us. She organized several roadshows for us, always taking in consideration our preferences. She has strong knowledge of the region and very good negotiations skills. On top of all she is very pleasant person to be with.
Susan was extremely helpful, very professional. She always returned our calls in a timely manner and she was always on top of things. She offered my wife and I many good suggestions and she managed to get us throughout the buying process till we closed on the property we purchased with self-confidence and assurance. We highly recommend Susan and will definitely use her services again
Susan was absolutely wonderful to work with. She always got right back to me when I had questions about anything. She was very knowledgeable. Above all, she had a sense of humor, and was extremely patient and kind. My husband and myself couldnt have been happier with the experience. I would highly recommend her to anyone.
They always made time to help us and they were so knowledgeable about the whole house buying process and what to look for in a house. We were blown away with how personable and how invested they were in our home buying process. We definitely recommend the Connelly team!!
Loading recent sales...