Service Areas
Credentials
LICENSE
Specialties
- Buyer's Agent
- Landlord
- Listing Agent
- Property Management
- Real Estate Consulting
- Short sale specialist
Awards
-
2026
TOP AGENT
Pennington, NJ
Available Listings View All


View All Listings2026
Pennington, NJ


View All ListingsStefanie and her team ensured such a successful sale on my home. She helped me renovate the home prior to selling for a maximum value. She took the time to provide a strong consultation on what to do. She followed up on feedback, and hosted many open houses which helped my home sell above asking.
Stefanie and her team ensured such a successful sale on my home. She helped me renovate the home prior to selling for a maximum value. She took the time to provide a strong consultation on what to do. She followed up on feedback, and hosted many open houses which helped my home sell above asking.
Stefanie is an outstanding competent agent. She knew how to market our rental property and the turnout for the open house was huge. We sold for over asking in one week. She is extremely knowledgeable in all areas of real estate.
Stefanie was a great real estates agent! She helped me by my house. She was knowledgeable, prompt, responsive, honest, and very smart! I had a great experience with her, and I recommended her to my son. She also helped him and his wife but their house. I would strongly recommend her to anyone.
Stefanie did an amazing job not only showing us homes and working with us when we found the home we desired but each step of the way through closing and she has been here several times since our purchase as we remodeled etc. She has great contacts, knows the ins and outs of the local market and when we do sell we cannot imagine contracting with a more diligent team.
I recently had the pleasure of working with Stefanie Prettyman as my realtor and I can confidently say she is one of the best in the business. From the moment we met, I knew she was incredibly knowledgeable about the housing market and the area we were looking to buy in. Stefanie helped us find our dream home for our family of four and made the entire process as seamless as possible. She was always available to answer any questions we had and provided valuable insight and advice throughout the entire process. Stefanie truly cares about her clients and it shows in the way she works. She was always professional, friendly, and attentive, making sure we felt comfortable and well-informed every step of the way. We are so grateful to have had Stefanie as our realtor and would recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. She truly exceeded our expectations and we will definitely be working with her again in the future. 5-star rating for Stefanie Prettyman!
Over the period of 3 months working with various realtors, I found Stefanie literally the best realtor anyone can ask for she made sure everything was going smoothly, took care of a lot, was very patient, and sensitive to my property needs, and helped me throughout the complete process of buying a new place and also helping in putting my old place on rent, hence all 5 out of 5 to her.
Stefanie is the best realtor I have ever encountered. I was very impressed with her expertise in realty right away, she is truly an expert in this field. You can tell Realty is her life's passion and she's not in it for the money, she truly cares about finding the right home for people. As you do house visits she is almost like a house inspector in a way, as she has a keen eye for issues to look out for and will be completely honest and up front with you about issues she sees, unlike many other realtors who would rather just get an easy sale. If it wasn't for Stefanie, we would have never got our dream home. After a year of looking a home finally came on the market that we loved. If it wasn't for Stefanie connections in Realty and her savvy plan to put forth the best offer we could possibly put forth, we would not have had a chance getting the home, especially in the crazy sellers market of today. I have nothing but great things to say about Stefanie and really appreciated her hard work and knowledge/connections to make this happen. She's an extremely hard working individual and deserves all the recognition possible. I highly recommend her to anyone looking to purchase or sell a home especially in this market. She will do anything possible to get you a house that's right for you and your family!
Stefanie is a knowledgeable, experienced, and proactive real estate agent who understands the entire process and requirements of home sales. She is capable to empathize with sellers and buyers, identify all necessary action items, and execute them in a timely manner. I interacted with Stefanie only remotely during the pandemic (also because I was about 50 miles away from the home to sell). We were able to quickly build a trustful relationship, and she turned my home selling experience into a pleasure. As a result, I was able to sell my home for higher than the initial target price. Repair, negotiation, legal reviews, CO acquirement, and more of those which we recognize as pain points have been well-mitigated. I'm absolutely grateful and delighted to find Stefanie and her team.
My experience working with Stefanie was absolutely wonderful. As a first time home buyer, I was still trying to understand all the ins and outs of buying a home and all that came with it. Stefanie thoroughly explained every step of the way to me and never made me feel like my questions were silly. She responded in a timely manner and was quick to help us schedule home tours. Stefanie went above and beyond for us and took a lot of the stress off my shoulders. She was very well informed of the area and each house we looked at and I loved that she helped create a vision for each of them, without being pushy! Her negotiation skills are fantastic and she really went to bat for us. We have been in our house for almost a month now and I couldnt be more happy. I highly recommend Stefanie for any realtor needs.
I cant say enough good things about Stefanie. She helped us navigate the waters as first time homeowners 3 years ago at the most difficult time of my life while pregnant with my son. I was experiencing two really big events and Stefanie knew that and helped me feel good about my purchase. Shes knowledgeable and made me feel comfortable because she didnt just hand hold through the process but she was honest in sharing her opinion about whether it would be a good fit. Which is why we didnt hesitate to call her for our second home purchase. There are plenty of realtors out there but none like Stefanie. She goes above and beyond in advocating for for her clients. Who better to share such an important milestone with?
My husband and I got really lucky getting randomly paired with Stefanie through Zillow. What we appreciated about her most during the entire process was her honesty about each house we visited. As first time home buyers, we had no idea what we were getting into and she recommended so many quality people to work including our mortgage lender, inspector, and attorney. After we put in the offer on our house, she went above and beyond to make sure it was accepted. Shes a master negotiator and continues to go above and beyond even well after closing. If anyone is meant to be a realtor, it's her. Highly recommend! ????
Stefanie checks all the boxes you need with a realtor. She made buying a 1st house much easier. Her strengths are in her knowledge, connections, communication and followup. I would highly recommend her to anyone especially 1st time homebuyers!
We have been working with Stefanie on buying a home in Hamilton. She knows the real market inside out and amazes us with all her expertise and skills. She is very patient, resourceful and always responsive to our questions. We are very pleased to have her as our agent and would highly recommend her to anyone looking for an outstanding real estate agent.
If you're looking for a dedicated and resourceful real estate agent, I highly recommend Stefanie. She sold our house in a relatively short time in a sluggish market while other properties in our area languished on the market (in some cases bigger houses at the same price point). She is extremely knowledgeable about the entire selling process and works with a lot of different contractors to take care of any issues that might come up during inspection. Thank you Stefanie, we are grateful for all of your hard work!
Stefanie was a real pro who worked tirelessly to sell our home. She was always available and responsive and she was very helpful throughout the entire process. If you want results, use Stefanie's services!
One of the most knowledgeable agents Ive ever met. She will keep you in the loop at every turn of the selling or buying process. Just an all around excellent real estate agent!
Stefanie is amazing. She tells you what you need to know whether or not you're going to like the news. She kept our whole process streamlined and was very straightforward. Her wealth of knowledge and understanding nature helped make buying our first home wonderful. I absolutely loved working with Stefanie and will be sure to use her in the future looking for our forever home. I would recommend her to anyone and everyone.
I would highly recommend Stefanie to anyone looking for a home. She is extremely professional and very knowledgeable. She amazes me with the knowledge she has off the top of your head. She is very trustworthy and treats you as if you were family. We are very happy to be working with her to buy our next home!
Stefanie goes above and beyond. She is the most knowledable agent in her field. You would be making a grave mistake not to have her in your corner especially if youre a first time homeowner like my fiancA(C) and myself! She listens to what your needs are in a home and will find you 3 that match! Shes personable and comes with a checklist and contacts of area professionals if needed. I cant say enough about her and the level of professionalism and red carpet customer service every time! I could go on and on!
Lets just say that Stef is real estate genius. Shes got the patience of a monk and the knowledge of a seasoned contractor. My wife and I are first time home buyer and shes gone above and beyond to put us at ease through the buying process.
Loading recent sales...