Stacy McFadden

Signature Premier Properties

19 Years of Experience

(63)

$15M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$754.7K

Average Price Point

Service Areas

Amityville, NY Babylon, NY Deer Park, NY East Islip, NY Great River, NY Huntington Station, NY Islip Terrace, NY Islip, NY Lindenhurst, NY Massapequa, NY North Babylon, NY Oakdale, NY West Babylon, NY West Islip, NY West Sayville, NY

View All Service Areas

About Stacy McFadden

I'm Stacy McFadden, a Long Island-based Realtor and licensed associate broker with 18+ years of experience in residential and commercial real estate. I help buyers, sellers, and investors across Nassau and Suffolk Counties. From first-time buyers and downsizers to landlords and investors seeking income-producing or mixed-use properties, I offer hands-on, relationship-driven service. I also assist with retail leasing and portfolio growth. My approach blends local expertise, strong negotiation skills, and a deep commitment to client success. Let's connect if you're buying, selling, or investing--residential or commercial, I'm here to help.

OTHER LANGUAGES

English

Community Involvement

I love being involved in my community and supporting causes that make a real difference. Whether it's helping organize local fundraisers, volunteering my time, or connecting people who can help one another, I enjoy being part of something bigger than myself. Giving back and seeing others succeed is what motivates me.

HOBBIES/INTEREST

I'm happiest when I'm surrounded by good people, great food, and new experiences. I love traveling, decorating, and spending time outdoors, but I also find joy in the little things, like cooking, hosting get-togethers, or relaxing with my family after a long day.

FAMILY

My family is my heart. I'm a proud wife, mom, and "Mimi" -- and no matter how busy life gets, time with them always comes first. We love getting together for Sunday dinners, celebrating milestones, and creating new memories whenever we can.

Specialties

Sellers
Buyers
Residential Property
Commercial Property

Commercial Sales & Leasing, Buyer's Agent, Listing Agent, Foreclosure, Short-Sale, Property Management

Awards

2026
TOP AGENT
East Islip, NY
2026
TOP AGENT
North Babylon, NY
2026
TOP AGENT
Babylon, NY

View All Awards

Loading recent sales...

Stacy McFadden's Reviews & Ratings

63 Reviews

(5/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Responsive
Professional
Knowledgeable
Communicative
Attentive
Trustworthy
Outstanding
Great for new buyers
Excellent negotiator
Hard working

Prty M.

Review for Member: Stacy McFadden

March 12, 2026

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I cannot say enough amazing things about my real estate agent Stacy! She came highly recommended by my sister, and from the very beginning she exceeded every expectation I had. Selling a home can be stressful, but she made the entire process smooth, organized, and far easier than I ever imagined. What truly meant the most to me was how incredibly supportive and accommodating she was during a very difficult time for me while I was dealing with illness, she stepped in and went completely above and beyond to make sure everything was taken care of. She handled details, kept me informed, and always made sure I felt comfortable and supported throughout the process. Not only is Stacy an outstanding professional who knows exactly how to get results, but she is also a genuinely kind and caring person. The fact that she is also a friend made the experience even more special. If you are looking for someone who is dedicated, compassionate, and truly committed to getting the best outcome for you, I highly recommend Stacy. She worked tirelessly to sell my home and made what could have been a very overwhelming experience feel manageable and successful. I am beyond grateful!

Dawndamico5

Review for Member: Stacy McFadden

September 15, 2021

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Working with Stacy to sell our house was a great experience. We were nervous and did not know what to expect but Stacy put our minds at ease and made the whole process very easy. From the very first text to her, we knew she was the right person to sell our house. Stacy was very responsive and answered every text and phone call immediately. Stacy was with us every step of the way. Her vast knowledge of the area and real estate made us confident we would sell our house quickly. In our humble opinion, Stacy is the best in the business. It was an absolute pleasure to work with her.

Kari S.

Review for Member: Stacy McFadden

February 21, 2021

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I thoroughly enjoyed working with Stacy. She is very responsive and easily answered any questions I had. This was my first time buying a home in NY and the process was quite different than my previous experience and she clearly explained what to expect offer to closing. Stacy was also able to make helpful referrals for other service providers I needed during the home buying process.

Randy T.

Review for Member: Stacy McFadden

February 20, 2021

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Stacy was great to work with. She was extremely patient with us, as we werent in a rush and wanted to find the perfect home for our family. She provided great advice during negotiations to stay consistent with comps and not over pay. She was a pleasure to partner with

Randalltibbetts

Review for Member: Stacy McFadden

February 20, 2021

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Contact Information

Location

126 West Main StreetBabylon, NY, 11702

Social Media

Trusted Professionals

Trusted Pro

Stacy McFadden is a Trusted Pro with a network of verified professionals.

Megan Gardner

Real Estate Agent

Michael cymbala

Loan Officer

Teri Dedonato

Real Estate Agent