Bringing results that move my clients has been my number one priority since the start of my real estate career. For more than three decades, I've had the privilege of serving as a trusted advisor to hundreds of buyers, sellers, and investors across Connecticut, guiding them through residential, commercial, and investment transactions of every size and scope. As the Team Leader of the Regional Properties Team at Coldwell Banker Realty, I'm proud to lead a top-producing group of professionals recognized as the #1 Medium Team in Connecticut for closed transactions. In 2024, I was honored to be named the Top Agent in Connecticut with Coldwell Banker, a reflection of the trust my clients place in me and my commitment to delivering exceptional results. What sets me apart is a client-first approach built on service, strategy, and trust. My clients benefit from: - Unmatched marketing expertise that maximizes exposure and drives powerful results. - Expert negotiation skills that protect their best interests. - Clear, consistent communication that creates confidence at every stage of the process. This dedication has earned me the Five Star Professional Award for seven consecutive years--a recognition of the level of service I bring to every client relationship. Whether you're buying your first home, relocating, downsizing, or exploring investment opportunities, my role as a trusted advisor is to provide the guidance, market knowledge, and results that move you forward with confidence. Beyond real estate, I remain deeply connected to my community. Raised in Orange, where my wife and I chose to raise our family, I've served on the board of the Orange Chamber of Commerce, as a member of the Water Pollution Control Authority (WPCA), and I actively support various charities throughout the year.
OTHER LANGUAGES
English
Community Involvement
Member of Orange Chamber of Commerce, Water Pollution Control Authority and support various charities each year.
HOBBIES/INTEREST
Time with my family and traveling.
Read More About Nick
Credentials
LICENSE
Real Estate - Connecticut - # REB.0756394
Specialties
Buyer's Agent
Commercial Properties
Foreclosure specialist
Investment Properties
Listing Agent
Property Management
Awards
2026
TOP 25 AGENT
Connecticut
2026
TOP AGENT
West Haven, CT
2026
TOP AGENT
New Haven, CT
Other Awards
Five Star Professional, International President's Elite
Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Professional
Knowledgeable
Responsive
Communicative
Outstanding
Trustworthy
Attentive
Sold Quickly
Excellent negotiator
Hard working
Zuser20150214111926187
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
August 19, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick went above and beyond for many months to help me find the perfect property that fit my needs. I will continue to use Nick Mastrangelo as my realtor for many years to come.
William B.
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
August 8, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
As a first time buyer I had many questions.Nick kept me well-informed regarding new listings on a daily basis. He had my best interest at heart.He was more than happy to answer any questions I had at any time. Nick was very professional and I would definitely recommend his services
Jhon J.
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
August 3, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
I am very impressed with with nicks knowledge and guidance. I done business with others in the past, but no one has given me the confidence and market knowledge to where I can make a purchase sight unseen.I thank Nick and his team team for all that they do! and I look forward to doing business with him in the future.
Gail R.
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
January 4, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick and Cindy listed and sold my aunts home in Stratford in record time. The process was time consuming, but smooth with few glitches. The one glitch was the fault of aunties attorneys office, who failed to obtain probate court approval although it was written in the contract. I would happily use Nick and Cindy again.
1gailrich
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
January 4, 2021
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick and Cindy listed and sold my aunts home in Stratford in record time. The process was time consuming, but smooth with few glitches. The one glitch was the fault of aunties attorneys office, who failed to obtain probate court approval although it was written in the contract.I would happily use Nick and Cindy again.
C J.
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
December 15, 2020
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick was an incredible real estate agent who handled every detail extremely professionally and expeditiously. Our house sold for significantly more than we had expected or asked for, because of his negotiation skills and marketing plan. We highly recommend Nick for your real estate needs!
Bvelazquez58
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
October 22, 2020
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Very Responsible,Respectful, Always there went we needed him. Always trying he?s best to help me out in my best interest.very pleasant to talk to and very understanding of all you needs. He is the best realtor that you can get. I recommend Nick to anybody that needs to buy or sale a property.
Haley R.
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
September 3, 2019
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick was fantastic to work with for the purchase of our first home. He is extremely knowledgeable about the real estate market and was a trusted advisor. Nick was beyond attentive to our needs and made our home buying experience easy. It was an absolute pleasure working with Nick. We would highly recommend him.
Villafuertefe
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
July 16, 2019
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick was very professional and took his time to explain in details the value of our property and comparing our home to other listings. He ensured that he heard our opinion and provided his feedback to ensure we had the best pricing. He is a great listener, responsive, patient, and truly showed that he cared. Selling a home can be stressful! However, Nick made it easy by addressing any concerns or issues that arose when dealing with the buyer. I will definitely continue to do business with Coldwell Banker and particularly Nick.
Drffreeman371
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
February 26, 2019
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick has handled a less than easy transaction (due to difficult selling agents) with professionalism, kindness and insight. His experience in real estate investment continues to be an invaluable asset to our property well after the purchase.
Robert M.
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
December 5, 2018
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Working with Nick was a pleasure. He is very knowledgeable regarding home sale values. Nick stuck with us for a long period of time. He initially sold us a home and then we decided not to purchase the home. He continued to maintain contact with us and we eventually found another home that we purchased. His assistant Cindy is also a pleasure to work with. Both return calls promptly and keep you informed of the closing activities. I highly recommend Nick and Cindy to work with you to purchase and/or sell your home.
Robertmillspaughjr
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
December 5, 2018
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Working with Nick was a pleasure. He is very knowledgeable regarding home sale values. Nick stuck with us for a long period of time. He initially sold us a home and then we decided not to purchase the home. He continued to maintain contact with us and we eventually found another home that we purchased. His assistant Cindy is also a pleasure to work with. Both return calls promptly and keep you informed of the closing activities. I highly recommend Nick and Cindy to work with you to purchase and/or sell your home.
AndrewVerlezza
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
November 20, 2018
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
I?ve known Nick over 20 years and this is the 1st time doing business with him. This was my 4th closing in 12 years. I should?ve called him years ago, as I?ve never had an agent give such attention to detail and a smooth escrow period. He had my home under contract in 48 hours. Nick is the ?Michael Jordan? of Real Estate.
Seth Z.
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
June 15, 2018
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick was ideal for my needs, helping me sell our house in Orange. I would recommend him. He was flexible, knew what I needed, and easy for me to work with.
Kevinb0023
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
May 25, 2018
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick was great to work with I have previously worked with other realtors and I am glad I went with nick this time around. If I ever need someone in the future The only person I would use would be nick. He answered all my questions and concerns promptly and he really went above and beyond to sell my property and get me into my dream home. Nick is a stand up person and a straight shooter I appreciate everything he did for us and would highly recommend him to anyone.
Noel L.
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
April 5, 2018
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Very professional experience - was recommended by someone else who used Nick. Was happy and wouldnt hesitate to use Nick again. Tracked down contract on other side of Hub contingency and did closing walk through in person short notice.
Ezoestetson
Review for Member: Nick Mastrangelo
March 14, 2018
Local Knowledge
Process Expertise
Responsiveness
Negotiation skills
Zillow Review
Nick located my first home, a condominium in New Haven, in 1997. When I decided to sell it in 2017, I turned to Nick. He also showed me area homes and condominiums for sale at that time, as well as over the years. My condos sale was not an easy one for several reasons. In all negotiations, Nick was always professional and knowledgeable. He returned my phone calls promptly, regardless of the time of day - or night. He was also available on weekends. I highly recommend that you contact Nick if you are selling or buying a home.