Service Areas
About Natalie Affenita
Credentials
LICENSE
Specialties
- Buyer's Agent
- Listing Agent
Awards
2026
TOP AGENT
Sayville, NY
Other Awards
LIRP Top 40 Under 40
Available Listings View All


View All Listings2026
Sayville, NY
LIRP Top 40 Under 40


View All ListingsNatalie jumped right into our home search and faced the many challenges of finding a home for us in Sayville while we were still living in Charleston, SC with a positive attitude and professionalism. She coordinated showings so my family/friends could attend as our proxies and provided realistic guidance and feedback throughout the entire process. Its evident Natalie truly puts her all into helping her clients and we were never left wondering where offers, etc. stood. If youre looking to buy or sell a home, get Natalie on the case and shell get it done!!
Natalie was amazing to work with! She was available for us 24/7 for any questions we had. She walked us through each step of the way with ease, it felt effortless. We at no point felt any pressure from her throughout the process. Without her I dont think we would have found our home!
Natalie helped us find our first home. She was amazing to work with during every step of the process. We never felt pressured at any point. She answered all of our questions and continues to provide us with great advice.
Working with Natalie was an absolute pleasure. From our very first meeting, her kindness and genuine desire to help were evident. She took the time to understand my needs, guiding me through every step of the process with patience and honesty. Natalies expertise and unwavering support made what could have been a very stressful experience feel seamless and even enjoyable! I couldn't have asked for a better partner in my real estate journeyaEUR"she truly goes above and beyond for her clients!!!!
Natalie is the best realtor weve worked with!!! My wife and I had a great experience working with her. Natalies communication, honesty, integrity and willingness to listen allowed us to purchase our property with ease. She really made our buying experience so wonderful. It was a roller coaster ride looking for our perfect home over the years until we met Natalie who went above and beyond to give us advice and allow our family to make a fresh start in our first home. We will be forever grateful to her. With Natalie it was never about the sale but more about securing a family home that we can create new memories and live happily in. We highly recommended her.
I cannot give Natalie enough praise for the job she did with helping us buy our home in Patchogue! Natalie always showed up with a smile and a positive demeanor. She was honest, punctual, incredibly communicative and responsive, and very knowledgeable. Her hard work on a daily basis was undeniable, and I had the utmost confidence with her as our Realtor that we would be successful in our plan to buy a house. She helped us to navigate the tricky waters of submitting an offer in a volatile market, understanding what it takes for an offer to look appealing and get accepted. Anytime we had a question, we either got a direct answer or a promise that she would find out for us, and she never failed to come through. Working with Natalie was a blessing, and I know for a fact that my home-buying experience was made to be much easier by her efforts. Work with Natalie, it will be the best decision you ever made!
You cannot go wrong with Natalie. In this wild housing market you need someone who will listen, fight for you and your family, guide you and explain all the nuances that you may not completely understand. Natalie not only has all of these qualities; she goes above and beyond to help make sure the house youre buying is truly the house you can make your home. After years of buying our first time with Natalie, my husband and I highly recommend her to all our friends and colleagues who have all been successful in buying homes with her. We cannot thank and recommend Natalie enough!
Natalie was an amazing broker, she was very responsive and answered all my questions about the property including giving me an licensed inspection report. She understood that the house needed work and understood my position on my offer and respected everyone's time by explaining the sellers situation and next steps. She didn't play the usual back and forth and I didn't feel pressured on my offer, overall it was refreshing to experience a rather straight forward negotiation.
Natalie is a great person. She has a bubbly personality. She talked to me everyday and let me know what was going on. She listened to what I wanted and I landed in a new home that I love. I would use her again for myself and anyone else who wants to move.
The stress of attempting to become a first-time homeowner cannot be overstated. After several unpleasant experiences with agents, my wifes mutual friend recommended Natalie. From our very first meeting, Natalie was at the house she proposed with a shovel actively paving the driveway for us. I knew we had found the person who would find us our dream home. Fast forward two and a half years and Natalie continues to help our friends and colleagues find their homes. I cannot recommend Natalie enough for all of her patience, experience, effort, effectiveness and reassurance.
Loading recent sales...