Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Allison M.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIEDSelling a home can be an emotional roller coaster, especially when it involved family properties. The process gets even more complex when multiple people are involved, like in a Estate situation. When my husband and I set out to sell my parents cherished 1957 home we knew it would be a challenge, given our background in land development and custom home builders. Fortunately we had Michael Scarito, his talent in managing different personalities was nothing short of amazing. In situations with multiple decision makers, it easy for deals to slip away - timing is everything. Many dont realize the first offer is often the best. Michael was always there, pushing us forward, even when things seemed impossible. Hes a true go-getter and closer ready to do whatever it takes to make things happens. Michael consistently kept the momentum going, dedicated to achieving results no matter the circumstances. We feel incredibly blessed to have Michael on our side during this most difficult journey. My parents can rest in peace knowing a beautiful young family is in their cherished home, thanks Michael. Caryn F Owner
Alyssad529
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED We recently worked with Michael Scarito to sell my fathers home, who passed away this past year, and I cant thank him enough for making the entire process so smooth and stress-free. He handled everything with professionalism, compassion, and efficiency. The house sold quickly and without any headaches. This was actually our second time working with Michael, he also helped us sell our first home in Port Jeff Station about five years ago. Just like then, he proved to be honest, trustworthy, and an absolute pleasure to work with. Well continue to turn to Michael for any future real estate needs and will happily recommend him to anyone looking for a reliable and knowledgeable agent.
Zuser20200222094152909
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED It was a pleasure working with Michael, a true professional. He is very knowledgeable about the community and local market. He was in constant contact with us thru the whole process of showing and selling our home. We were very comfortable working with him. He comes highly recommended.
SusanMcSweeeney
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED This was our second time using Michael for the sale of our home. We couldnt have been happier both times. He constantly communicates with you from when you list your home until closing. We never had to think about anything pertaining to our sale once we listed with Michael. He made the entire process very easy. He is very professional, personable, keeps you informed, negotiates well, answers all questions honestly and just made the whole deal go smoothly. He took all the stress out of a stressful situation. We couldnt thank him enough!
Zuser20140504173403497
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael was our agent for the sale of our Commack, NY home. From our first meeting with Michael we were impressed with his experience and knowledge of the local market. He was professional, accessible and personable throughout the entire process. His advice and expertise yielded multiple offers and resulted our accepting a sound offer well above the asking price. We could not have asked for a better real estate agent. Due to Michaels guidance, the entire process went seamlessly from beginning to end.
Abrel01
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Highly recomended! Michael was extremely knowledgable about both the Smithtown real estate market as well as the actual comp units available in our area. Michael was extremely hands on in helping us price our listing, as well as address any questions or concerns we had throughout the selling process. Lastly Michael worked with the buyer's realtor to resolve any issues and ultimate we closed for a price that both ourselves and the buyers were happy with.
Ladybug9815
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael is a very knowledgeable and professional. He is extremely educated about the market. Michael keeps in constant contact with you through out the whole process with updates concerning the sale. He is honest and caring and such a pleasure to work with. This is the second time, I have used Michael and will continue to do so again. I highly recommend Michael to anyone looking for an honest, trustworthy and professional realtor.
Claudiademauro
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Being a 51 year old woman in a wheelchair with extensive medical challenges, my husband and I have very unique needs when it comes to finding a home in this next stage in our lives as he continues to steps into the role of my caretaker. So when it came time to make the difficult decision to sell our beautiful home and move into a townhome, we knew we needed someone with a lot of patience & compassion. To say we were overwhelmed with the task at hand would be putting it lightly. As a matter of fact, we sat on the decision for 3 years. It is for all those reasons and more that we knew we needed a realtor who truly had our best interest at heart, had extensive knowledge of the market and the current inventory, someone who could set realistic expectations for us, and someone who could be our compass when we got off course in our search. Reaching out to Michael this year, just as we did 15 years ago for our first home, was a decision we did NOT hesitate to act on now that were ready to sell once again as we seek to downsize. I dont know about you, but if I'm going to work with a professional to assist me in finding a place to call home, especially when a long list of unique needs are involved, not only do we have to trust them and their expertise professionally, but we also have to trust them personally. I can assure you that Michael is not only our go to real estate expert with extensive knowledge, but hes also been our voice of reason, our compass and our sounding board as we make decisions every step of this journey. We could not imagine navigating such a profound transition in our lives with anyone else. Michael has always had our best interest at heart. His gentle reminders of our objectives when we stray (shiny object syndrome lol), are kind and yet done in a way that reflects his extensive knowledge of all the things wed never even thought to consider before taking the next step. We also want to speak a bit more to whom it is that Michael is as a person and how wonderful his wife has also been through this process. Have you ever met people who you just knew were good people through and through, people who genuinely cared about and were invested in the well-being of others? Thats Michael & Gail (his wife). Gail is a realtor as well but not currently active as an agent. Gail assisted Michael throughout our entire journey. This has included taking part in the showings of our home where WE required everyone who entered to wear gloves & masks bc I'm immunocompromised. While Michael navigated the scheduled showings, Gail stood out in the heat on our driveway with a table where we provided all the necessary precautionary materials. She made sure nobody entered our home without respecting our wishes for all precautions to be taken. Gail also took time out of her day to stay with us when we needed more time at a particular home and Michael had to step out for a bit. She gave of herself just as he has. They both have tremendous patience and compassion! So, if you or your loved one are looking to age in place, have unique needs and are looking for a knowledgeable, highly experienced professional to guide you every step of the way, Michael Scarito is the realtor for you. I truly hope that this review helps you, the reader, the person on the other end overwhelmed by taking this next step, to see that youve found the person for the job. Michael had his work cut out for him with the laundry list of needs we came to us with and yet he has stuck by us with unwavering commitment every step of the way. We wish you all the best on your home search and hope you are as blessed as we were/are to have Michael by your side every step of the way.
Rbtower1
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael is a true professional. He is very knowledgeable of the real estate market and was extremely responsive to our needs. He really cares about his clients!
John S.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael Scarito is a true professional, well-respected, knowledgeable realtor who is your single source in buying or selling a property. Mike helped us in finding a house some years ago and when the time came to sell our house this year, he took care of our property and got it sold in a record time and at a price beyond our expectation. With Mike on your side, you feel assured since he will get you the best deal. He is a top-class realtor in Long Island !
RichRudolph8
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael is a professional realtor who is extremely knowledgeable about the market and our community. He is not pushy but is all business. I truly felt at ease with Michael and felt that I had made right decision to put the sale of my home in his hands. This proved to be true when Michael got multiple offers on the first day, in fact he sold my house in six hours at asking price! Throughout the process, Michael kept in constant contact with me about the progress and updates concerning the sale. Dealing with Michael was stress-free and a pleasure! I highly recommend Michael to anyone looking for an honest, trustworthy and professional realtor. You will not be disappointed!
Dsternb66
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED 30 years ago, we purchased a lovely home in Commack with the assistance of the Team Scarito - Douglas Elliman agency.Time marched on and as my wife and I are now retired and were ready to move out of state to be closer to our daughter. Our first thought was to go back to Team Scarito to facilitate the sale. We wanted to do this because of the quality and professional service we initially experienced many years ago with Team Scarito.We were not disappointed, and Team Scarito were as supportive and helpful as they were years ago. Mike Scarito is knowledgeable, transparent, answered our questions honestly, understands the Long Island market and developed a highly effective plan of how to sell our home. Mike is not pushy but respects our timing and needs. He stood by our side during the entire process. It was a pleasure working with him.My wife and I cannot praise Mike and Team Scarito highly enough.
Aabbccdddavezg
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Just closed today can't thank you enough! You made everything from beginning to the end just so effortless smooth. I knew it was the right choice to go with the Scarito team. You are a true professional!
Allenbraun36
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael is extremely professional and personable. He will be attentive to your real estate needs to accomplish your goals. I highly recommend Michael, I'm sure you will agree when you work with him.
Stephanie E.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael was an absolute pleasure to work with. His expertise and experience that he brings to the table is impeccable. He made the whole process for us so easy and we would recommend Michael for anyone looking to buy or sell their home.
Tommiboy217
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED I would highly recommend Michael Scarito! From the time we saw our new home to the time we closed he was absolutely always ready to help and was very knowledgeable on any questions we had! He is an asset to any buyer or seller!!!! He made the whole entire process easy and ensured that it went smoothly!!! Excellent real estate professional and caring person!!
Kimmedat
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael helped us to sell my Mothers home and buy a co-op for my Step-Brother. He guided us through the entire process and was always available to answer any questions we had. His knowledge of the area was impressive and at times fascinating, providing insight that kept us out of areas that we would not have liked. He also knows many local people and has a great deal of contacts for local services if needed. Over the course of our dealings with Michael he always maintained a cheerful positive outlook and never ceased to encourage us that we would eventually find a property that would work for us. I would highly recommend Michael to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate and will gladly use his services again.
Fallonvisotzky
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael Scarito was very knowledgeable about the homes and neighborhoods that he showed us. He was helpful throughout the whole process of buying our first home. He was always available and quick to respond about properties we were interested in. He listened closely to what we were looking for and we were able to find our dream home because of him. We recommend him to any prospective home buyer.
Kristenl M.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED As first time home buyers, we are forever grateful for Michaels guidance, kindness and patience! He quickly found our dream home in our top location/school district and we couldnt be happier! He was there with us every step of the way and genuinely cared about our experience! Thank you, Michael!
Nicksnest5
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Our experience with Michael Scarito was terrific whien selling our home. As our listing agent His knowledge and experience was thorough and thru out the process his suggestions, guidance and insight proved to be spot on. My wife and I strongly recommend using Michael and would not hestitate to use him again.
Zuser20190623122653276
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED My wife and I recently bought our first house, and used Michael as our agent. He walked us through everything and tailored our searches based on our school district needs ans certain characteristics we wanted in a house. Michael will work hard to find you the right house, and will steer you away from houses that won't be a good fit even if it means delaying making a sale. He came highly recommended to us, and I couldn't recommend him enough to anyone else looking to buy or sell a house.
Vgambler
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael was a pleasure to work with during the selling of our home in Nesconset. He knows the area and the market and provides an honest assessment and feedback during the entire process. He works hard for his clients and is committed to the best interest of his clients. I would highly recommend Michael if you are selling your home on Long Island.
Deana S.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Working with Michael was the easiest decision I have ever made. My family has worked with him before and couldnt say enough great things about him. I was a first time seller and he made it all so easy for me. He was quick to respond to any question big or small. He was extremely knowledgeable and everything went smoothly. I would recommend Michael to everyone. In the future I wont hesitate calling Michael.
Woods M.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED It was a pleasure working with Michael Scarito and his team. He was very quick to respond to my inquiry when I decided to sell my home (he was also my agent when I purchased the home in 2009). Michael provided valuable insight to help select the right price point and to prepare my home for viewing by potential buyers. He always took time to answer any questions I had throughout the process. I completely trusted that Michael always had my best interests in mind; I will contact him again if I decide to buy or sell a home within his area of service.
Jaime I.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael Scarito made our first home buying experience quite a pleasure. He is possibly one of the kindest, most stand up guys I know. If he could assist us in anyway possible, he did, without hesitation. That says a lot to people who are new and need someone they can trust in one of the biggest financial investments so far in their life. Mike was there with us every step of the way, he was honest, and kept our best interest the top priority. I have already recommended him to others because he is someone who cares about his clients, and that does not come around that often these days. I thank you Mike from the bottom of our hearts for your patience, your knowledge and most of all just for making this experience an enjoyable process.
Apersons16
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael was phenomenal throughout our whole process. He was the agent for both our sale and purchase and we couldn't have asked for better. He made each step of the process easy and stress free. He was insightful and very knowledgeable about many aspects we wouldn't have thought of , as well as being honest and reasonable. He looked out for us and made sure we thought through any decisions and didn't miss out on what was best for our family. I would recommend Michael to anyone looking to buy or sell their home and will utilize his expertise in the future.
Zuser20170714121505584
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Our experience with Michael was great! He is very knowledgeable, patient, efficient and very helpful! Found potential buyer in 3 weeks after listing our house with Douglas Elliman. He was very quick at emails, phone calls, and messages. He is all around amazing. I would highly recommend Michael to anyone. Thank you so much for everything!
Zuser20170426151328079
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED If you are looking for a reliable, honest, and professional experience --- Micheal is the way to go. He is easy to get into contact with, timely, flexible, and efficient. Michael knows Long Island, he knows homes, and he knows quality. He takes the time to get to know his buyers and has an knack for connecting his clients with what they are searching for. For a pleasant, organized, and truly enjoyable home buying experience --- choose Michael!! --- Alex and Tim
Young H.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael sold my house about two years ago and this year 2017, he helped me finding my home. He has been so professional(courteous, knowlegable, patient, sophisticated, thoughtful). I want to give him a score of ??.
Young H.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael sold my house about two years ago and this year 2017, he helped me finding my home. He has been so professional(courteous, knowlegable, patient, sophisticated, thoughtful). I want to give him a score of ??.
Isabella S.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED I had the pleasure of working with Michael. He was a consummate professional through our entire transaction. He is definitely committed to exceptional service, friendly, & knowledgeable. He was totally available and responded immediately to phone and email questions. I am grateful to have worked with him, and highly recommend this realtor!
I
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED I had the pleasure of working with Michael. He was a consummate professional through our entire transaction. He is definitely committed to exceptional service, friendly, & knowledgeable. He was totally available and responded immediately to phone and email questions. I am grateful to have worked with him, and highly recommend this realtor!
Arrielle M.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED I hired Michael to sell my home after it had been on the market for four months. He sold it within six days. He got to work right away, having new photos taken and listed, an open house immediately, and I'm sure doing many things I'm not aware of. He is extremely professional and a complete gentleman. His calm manor and friendly smile cannot be overlooked. I thank Michael and his company for selling my home and bringing the process to a quick conclusion.
Sharon R.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED I hired Michael to sell my home after it had been on the market for four months. He sold it within six days. He got to work right away, having new photos taken and listed, an open house immediately, and I'm sure doing many things I'm not aware of. He is extremely professional and a complete gentleman. His calm manor and friendly smile cannot be overlooked. I thank Michael and his company for selling my home and bringing the process to a quick conclusion.
Info3055
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael was a pleasure to deal with from the start. He is calm, knows his business, a straight shooter, and a nice guy. He sold our house quickly and efficiently, showed great patience with our elderly mom, and gave us information and help in preparing for the move. I highly recommend him.
Patricia P.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Michael was a pleasure to deal with from the start. He is calm, knows his business, a straight shooter, and a nice guy. He sold our house quickly and efficiently, showed great patience with our elderly mom, and gave us information and help in preparing for the move. I highly recommend him.
Kzamanpour
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Anyone looking for a real estate agent needs to reach out to Michael Scarito. He is extremely knowledgeable in every aspect of buying and selling. My husband and I were looking for a long period of time and once we reached out to Michael we found a house within weeks. He knew all the neighborhoods inside and out and asked all the right questions. Its scary to think we were looking for 2 years without asking some of the things he brought up. He is a true professional in every sense. Hell get back to you anytime of the day (and night)! We were lucky to have him as an agent. Thanks to him our search is finally over and we can enjoy the summer in our new house!!
Michele W.
Review for Member: Michael Scarito
ZillowVERIFIED Anyone looking for a real estate agent needs to reach out to Michael Scarito. He is extremely knowledgeable in every aspect of buying and selling. My husband and I were looking for a long period of time and once we reached out to Michael we found a house within weeks. He knew all the neighborhoods inside and out and asked all the right questions. Its scary to think we were looking for 2 years without asking some of the things he brought up. He is a true professional in every sense. Hell get back to you anytime of the day (and night)! We were lucky to have him as an agent. Thanks to him our search is finally over and we can enjoy the summer in our new house!!
