Service Areas
About Mariah Mills
Credentials
LICENSE
Awards
-
2026
TOP AGENT
Greenport, NY
2026
TOP AGENT
Southold, NY
2026
TOP AGENT
Cutchogue, NY
Available Listings View All
View All Listings2026
Greenport, NY
2026
Southold, NY
2026
Cutchogue, NY
View All ListingsLoading recent sales...
Working with Mariah was seamlessaEUR"she made the entire process as smooth as any homeowner could hope for. Her professionalism, deep market insight, and steady guidance stood out every step of the way. Shes not only knowledgeable but also incredibly supportive. Were grateful to have had such a thoughtful and capable partner by our side.
Mariah and her associates did a fantastic job marketing and negotiating the sale of our home. A seamless experience from shooting the marketing photos and social media, listing, negotiating the offer from the sellers, working with our lawyer and the sellers team, to the final closing. We highly recommend her and the entire Daniel Gale team on the North Fork of Long Island.
Mariah represented the sellers for the summer home we recently purchased in Greenport. We aren't local, and she went out of her way to assist us throughout the process and transaction. I would happily recommend her to anyone looking for an agent on the North Fork.
Mariah did a great job for us throughout the process. She was very responsive and had the pulse of the market. Was sensitive to this being a second home regarding schedules as well.
Mariah was an absolute dream to work with. She stuck with us for nearly two years as we hemmed and hawed about whether or not to sell or rent our beautiful North Fork home, providing excellent advice and market expertise. She advised us on how big capital improvement projects like adding a pool or a finished basement would impact our eventual listing price, which gave us the confidence to make those investments in the home. When we were finally ready to sell, she gave us excellent guidance on the list price and handled the open house like a true pro. Mariah also guided us through every buyer's dream - multiple offers over the asking price within the first 10 days of being on the market. She knew exactly how to play the negotiation game and put us at ease - we knew we had a professional in control, and we knew she would get us the very best price, which she did... 15% above our asking price, which was already at market! The entire time the house was on the market, we were at our permanent home... 1500 miles away. That's how much we trusted Mariah with the sale of our home. In terms of Mariah's communication and responsiveness, all I can say is that it both are outstanding! She never made us feel like our questions were dumb or our texts were bothersome - she answered every question thoroughly and immediately. She gave us clarity and transparency in the process of selling our home, and she anticipated issues and planned for them before they arose. As a result, we had a smooth closing with no surprises. The only issue that did come up was OUR fault, not hers, when the moving company we hired turned out to be bogus. Mariah again showed up for us, no questions asked, and helped us ensure the move happened smoothly with a different mover after we had already left the state. She went above and beyond to make sure we had a positive experience, and we are so grateful for her!
When it came to selling our family home of 60+ years in Bklyn NY we sought the advice of a valued family friend and experienced/successful realtor Mariah Mills. My sister and I no longer had ties to the Bklyn neighborhood we grew up in and were at a loss as to whom to trust to market our property. Mariah came through with no hesitation connecting us with an excellent team (Angie & Irene/Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty) with vast knowledge and experience in this highly competitive urban market. Mariah's invaluable connection/referral enabled us to close within 2 months of listing at above asking price!
Mariah is an outstanding agent. 8 years ago she went above and beyond in helping us buy the North Fork house of our dreams despite the sellers getting a higher bid just before the contract was signed. We would have lost that deal if not for her perseverance and creativity. In 2022, we decided to sell when the market was peaking but by the time we listed the market had slowed significantly as interest rates soared. We worried we had missed our opportunity but Mariah put together an outstanding marketing plan and got us multiple offers at our asking price within a month. Mariah's knowledge of the North Fork is only out matched by her creativity, social media expertise and a tireless work ethic. And she's a wonderful person as well! She's simply the best.
Mariah Mills was an absolute pleasure to work with. She is extremely knowledgeable, and a top-notch communicator. Since it was an estate sale, and we lived a distance away, Mariah was always readily available if we needed her. Within a short amount of time, Mariah was able to secure a wonderful buyer for my parent's home. I highly recommend Mariah Mills.
It was a real pleasure working with Mariah. She helped us sell our home and went above and beyond ensuring that it was a seamless process, especially since we were selling from a distance.
Working with Mariah was a pleasure. Her knowledge of the North Fork is second to none. She was extremely professional and prompt during or home search. Always quick to respond and accommodate schedule changes. We looked at quite a few properties with Mariah and she helped us weigh the pros and cons of each earnestly. I would HIGHLY recommend using her.
There's nobody on the north fork who knows as much about the real estate market, area, things to do or places to go as Mariah. In a very tough market she helped my partner and I find a house, in our budget, that met both of our very different needs. Highly recommend using Mariah!
Mariah was wonderful to work with. She has impressive knowledge of the NOFO area, is honest, has excellent judgment and made the buying process in a very competitive market much easier. Being responsive to questions both during and after the sale was much appreciated. We "highly" recommend working with her.
Mariah was professional, understanding, offered honest advice and was the best fit for us! Cant say enough great things about her! Sold our house at lightning speed for a great price!
We knew as soon as we met Mariah she was for us! Smart, honest, laid back and got our house sold quick as lightning for a great price. Highly recommend her!
We worked with Mariah to find and buy a new house and also sell our existing house. She was responsive, knowledgeable and we really felt like we could trust her throughout the entire process. She was amazing to work with and we have already recommended her to several people locally.
Mariah was the agent selling the house we bought. She was a pleasure to work with and was super helpful to us since we didn't have our own agent. Her local knowledge is apparent and she was quick to make great recommendations for everything from restaurants to other service providers.
We had a wonderful experience with Mariah when we decided to sell our home! She carried a positive energy and vast knowledge about our local community. Communication was always available and Mariah kept us informed from beginning to closing! She gave professional advice and guidance while supporting us to make our own decisions. It was a huge success!
My wife and I had a great experience working with Mariah when we were looking to purchase a home on the North Fork. We were pretty particular, and had a number of items on our 'wish list', and Mariah was extremely knowledgeable, offering insight, and suggestions throughout, and even after the process. She is hardworking, always responsive, very professional and upbeat. I highly recommend using her for whichever side of the real estate transaction you are on.
My wife and I had a great experience working with Mariah when we were looking to purchase a home on the North Fork. We were pretty particular, and had a number of items on our 'wish list', and Mariah was extremely knowledgeable, offering insight, and suggestions throughout, and even after the process. She is hardworking, always responsive, very professional and upbeat. I highly recommend using her for whichever side of the real estate transaction you are on.
Mariah was the listing agent on a house I just sold. From the very start it was clear that Mariah was going to be an excellent agent. She was highly responsive, engaged and very customer focused. She ensured the house was priced right for the market and exceeded our expectations with regard to how she priced it - we received several offers. She is also very personable, which is important when showing a house. The house sold quickly at asking price and the transaction went very smoothly.
Mariah was the listing agent on a house I just sold. From the very start it was clear that Mariah was going to be an excellent agent. She was highly responsive, engaged and very customer focused. She ensured the house was priced right for the market and exceeded our expectations with regard to how she priced it - we received several offers. She is also very personable, which is important when showing a house. The house sold quickly at asking price and the transaction went very smoothly.
Even before my husband and I met Mariah, we knew she would be the right agent for us just from her carefully curated social media presence. Once we did meet her, it solidified our instincts. She was professional, honest and laid out a game plan as to how she would sell our house. From pricing to closing, Mariah always made herself available via email and text, maintained Covid-19 protocols and made what can sometimes be a harrowing experience, an absolute pleasure. Thrilled to say we accepted a full-ask offer and went into contract within three days thanks to her hustle. If youre looking for an amazing real estate agent on the North Fork, look no further than Mariah Mills. You can thank me later!
It's no wonder Mariah is absolutely farming 5 stars on this platformaEUR"she's a consummate professional containing all the qualities everyone hopes to find in their agent. Knowledgeable, friendly, down-to-earth, and highly responsive. Any question I had throughout the process of buying was answered quickly, be it by email, phone or text, day or night.
It's no wonder Mariah is absolutely farming 5 stars on this platformaEUR"she's a consummate professional containing all the qualities everyone hopes to find in their agent. Knowledgeable, friendly, down-to-earth, and highly responsive. Any question I had throughout the process of buying was answered quickly, be it by email, phone or text, day or night.
Mariah sold my Mom's house, and I've been recommending her to everybody since then. She is very organized and responsive and provided us with extensive backup supporting the price she recommended. The property sold within a week of being listed in an all cash deal above the asking price. I couldn't have asked for a better experience.
Mariah was a fantastic guide throughout our experience looking for properties out on the North Fork. She has an insider's understanding of the area and spent the time and effort to get a real sense of what we were looking for. When we found the right place she was very effective in guiding the process.
We highly recommend Mariah Mills after recently working with her on the sale of our beloved Orient Point home. She was incredibly knowledgeable about the market (both the North Fork and Orient specifically), kindly guided us through the process and advised us of other very helpful local resources who were invaluable to getting us across the finish line.In addition, we found Mariahs smart strategy around the use of social media and other marketing channels to be very beneficial to driving traffic to our home during open houses and beyond.
I was impressed with Mariah from the beginning, for clearly she is smart and efficient and responsive. She provided good information throughout the process and when needed, she was a good problem-solver. I was very lucky, for my house sold in 4 days, and this was, in part, because she and Carol got my house on the market on very short notice after I went to contract on a home I was buying. I certainly recommend her without reservations and with enthusiasm.
Mariah was extremely helpful with our recent new home purchase. She showed us many homes until we found the one we really loved. She was very agreeable to show us this house on many occasions until we were ready to pull the trigger. When we were negotiating with the seller she was very knowledgeable and experienced and was able to close the deal. Mariah has been very friendly and responsive. she passed along information about how to get set up and familiar with the new town and community. I would highly recommend Mariah to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.
Mariah Mills is very professional in her dealing with people and quite knowledgeable in the Real Estate business. Mariah sold our house quickly and efficiently. Any questions we had Mariah would always get back to us immediately. I would highly recommend Mariah to anyone wanting to sell their house, or interested in buying one.
Working with Mariah was one of the best experiences we have ever had working with a broker. From her knowledge of the market and the what it would take to sell our home, to the superlative personal attention she provides, Mariah is in a class by herself. She is not only supremely good at what she does she is incredibly warm and human.
Mariah was amazing during the entire buying / selling process. She is full of energy, very proactive, and very honest in her dealings. She was extremely accommodating, always available, and always positive. We couldn't have had a better experience. Mariah knows the ins and outs of the North Fork market like no one else. We are truly grateful for her help and expertise. Whether you are looking to buy and/or sell on the North Fork, we would recommend Mariah over anyone else!! We will be using Mariah for all of our future real estate needs.
We needed an apartment, not a house. Mariah treated us with the same respect, professionalism, expertise, and care as if we were buying a million dollar home! She followed up more than once with questions on our behalf and her responses were immediate. We highly recommend Mariah Mills.
Mariah was a pleasure to work with. Her professionalism was noted right from the start. She was efficient in responding to our inquiries, as well as keeping us apprised throughout the entire process. She made every effort to make our home buying experience on the North Fork a positive one. We would highly recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.
Maria is one of the most dedicated, knowledgeable realtors on the entire north fork. I have done several buys with her and highly recommend her.Scott E
Having worked with numerous brokers over many years, we can say unequivocally that Mariah Mills is thoughtful, knowledgeable, respectful and unintrusive. She listens well and presents appropriate properties. We are extremely happy to have worked with Mariah.
Mariah was fantastic to work with. Insightful, responsive, aggressive - and really had her finger on the pulse of the market. She got us to market faster than we thought, and then to a deal faster than we could have imagined - in 10 days! Incredibly hard worker, instinctual feel for the market and delivers great results - would recommend her to anyone.
Mariah is a dedicated to providing excellent customer service. During the time we worked with her she was always available to answer questions and investigate concerns. She demonstrated a firm grasp of the process of home buying here on the North Fork. We would recommend her in a heartbeat.
Mariah was very responsive and knowledgeable to our questions and concerns pertaining to the real estate market as it affected our situation.She also has great "people" skills. She has a bright future in real estate if that's her long term ambition.
Mariah recently facilitated the sale of our home and I could not be more pleased with her professionalism and diligence throughout the process. She impressed me with her market knowledge, her insight and resourcefulness. I highly recommend her to anyone who wants avoid the potential stress that can come with the sale of a home.
Mariah is professional and caring in her style of selling / buying real estate. She is young but has excellent knowledge in her field . She always gets the facts before she makes any moves or comments . Mariah worked above and beyond for the sale of my home to take place in a respectful and timely manner. I would highly recommend her as she is truly one of the BEST ! Thank you Mariah for all of your hard work and friendship. You are successful for many ,many reasons!Best wishes for continued success !
Mariah Mills was nothing but professional and experienced as well as being friendly, outgoing, sympathetic and optimistic. I highly recommend her as a real estate professional.
We couldn't be more thrilled with Mariah! She both sold our home, and assisted us in purchasing our new home. She is incredibly knowledgable, approachable, friendly and professional. Her work ethic is really admirable; she truly goes above and beyond for her clients. We couldn't have asked for a better experience with both the sale of our home and purchase of our new home. We highly recommend her to both buyers and sellers. Her real estate agency is truly lucky to have her.
Mariah is a true professional. She was always available to us throughout a difficult buying process. She was aggressive when she needed to be on our behalf, an never pushed us in a direction that didn't truly meet our needs. She made us feel like she always had our best interest in mind. Also, Mariah knows the North Fork very well - a real plus. We would recommend her to anyone that is seeking a knowledgable go-getter.
Mariah was a pleasure to work with. I thoroughly enjoyed her professionalism and advice. She was a great help to me on many occasions. I would recommend her to anyone wanting to sell property or home. Thank you so much!
Mariah was a pleasure to work with. I thoroughly enjoyed her professionalism and advice. She was a great help to me on many occasions. I would recommend her to anyone wanting to sell property or home. Thank you so much!
the sale of this property had many obstacles and delays. Ms. Mills professionalism and stick to it attitude really held our family together through the hardship of selling a life estate. Mariah really put all of her resources on the line and went above and beyond no matter what the obstacles were.
the sale of this property had many obstacles and delays.Ms. Mills professionalism and stick to it attitude really held our family together through the hardship of selling a life estate.Mariah really put all of her resources on the line and went above and beyond no matter what the obstacles were.