Kelsey Kistle

Kistle Realty

7 Years of Experience

(57)

$12.8M

Total Sales Last Year

Years of Experience

Recent TransactionsTransactions from the last 3 years

$459K

Average Price Point

Service Areas

Andover, NJ Augusta, NJ Blairstown, NJ Branchville, NJ Franklin, NJ Hamburg, NJ Highland Lakes, NJ Lafayette, NJ Lake Hopatcong, NJ Layton, NJ Montague, NJ Newton, NJ Ogdensburg, NJ Sparta, NJ Stanhope, NJ Stillwater, NJ Stockholm, NJ Sussex, NJ Swartswood, NJ Vernon, NJ Wallpack Center, NJ

View All Service Areas

Specialties

Sellers
Buyers
Residential Property
Commercial Property

Awards

2026
TOP AGENT
Newton, NJ
2026
TOP AGENT
Montague, NJ
2026
TOP AGENT
Branchville, NJ

View All Awards

Loading recent sales...

Kelsey Kistle's Reviews & Ratings

57 Reviews

(5/5)

Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team

What clients say about this agent....

Professional
Communicative
Responsive
Knowledgeable
Trustworthy
Outstanding
Attentive
Great for new buyers
Hard working

Umit A.

Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle

March 8, 2026

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Working with Kelsey was a great experience from start to finish. She was responsive, organized, and stayed on top of every detail, which made the whole process much smoother and less stressful. A big thank you as well to attorney Marleen, inspector Ryan, and Stephanie at the title company aEUR" everyone was professional, helpful, and great to work with. Highly recommend Kelsey and her team!

Baverogary

Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle

February 12, 2026

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

I was very happy with having Kelsey as my agent. She was extremely helpful and a pleasure to work with. Kelsey always got back to me ASAP with answers to all my questions (and I had a lot)! Her knowledge and level of expertise is top notch and resulted in the purchase of my dream home. I also used Kelsey to sell my prior home and we closed in less than a month!

Tina Y.

Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle

January 13, 2026

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Kelsey was fantastic. Her knowledge about each property we visited was incredible and she pointed out the smallest details for us to pay attention to when we visited each home. She knew exactly the right questions to ask and how to set us up in the best position possible to find our house! 100% recommend her to anyone looking to purchase a new home!

Jen R.

Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle

January 11, 2026

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Kelsey is absolutely amazing. Honest, educated, personable and willing to go to bat for any of her clients. We had the pleasure of using her for multiple occasions, over a course of 2 years. We recommend Kelsey to everyone; whether it be renting, buying or selling!! She is your girl!!

Denise S.

Review for Member: Kelsey Kistle

January 10, 2026

Local Knowledge

Process Expertise

Responsiveness

Negotiation skills

ZillowVERIFIED

Kelsey Kistle is a true professional. Her knowledge, guidance, and positive support in assisting us with our search for our home made for a smooth process. Were happy to be back in Jersey and if youre searching for a home here, call Kelsey!