Service Areas
Specialties
- Sellers
- Buyers
- Residential Property
- Commercial Property
Awards
-
2025
TOP AGENT
Newton, NJ
2025
TOP AGENT
Montague, NJ
2025
TOP AGENT
Branchville, NJ
Recent Sales
We only display transactions from the last 3 years. To view transactions older than 3 years, please follow these steps:
- 1. Click the "View All Sales" button below.
- 2. Use the "Year" filter to select the desired past years.
Kelsey Kistle's Reviews & Ratings
- Professional
- Communicative
- Responsive
- Knowledgeable
- Trustworthy
- Outstanding
- Attentive
- Great for new buyers
- Hard working
Alfonso Dehesa
You know when youre buying a house and everyone says, aEURoeMake sure you have aces on your teamaEUR?aEUR"and you think, aEURoeYeah, but where am I really going to find someone that good?aEUR? Well, look no further. Kelsey is that good. Shes on top of every detail, resourceful, smart, and incredibly knowledgeable. Shes available day and night, and she goes above and beyond to make sure you find the right house for you. She never pushes you toward a property just to make a sale: in fact, shell tell you flat out if a house isnt right. Kelsey is truly on your team, not just trying to close a deal. Shes one in a million.
Jesse Bambrick
Kelsey Kistle was amazing! She, and the entire kistle realty team, are the best in Sussex County for a reason! She goes above and beyond for you and remains completely transparent and accessible throughout the entire process! Would always recommend Kelsey and the Kistle Realty team for your buying and selling needs! Thank you, Kelsey!
Bman5225
Kelsey was awesome to work with! Her knowledge, advice, and guidance all helped us tremendously throughout the entire process. She is, hands down, the best realtor in the area!!
Zuser20180121062403584
I recently had the pleasure of working with Kelsey Kistle at Kistle Realty to sell my house, and I cannot recommend her highly enough! From the very beginning, Kelsey demonstrated exceptional communication skills, keeping me informed every step of the way. She was always available to answer my questions and provide valuable insights that helped ease the selling process. What impressed me the most was her tenacity as a negotiator. Kelsey fought hard to secure the best possible deal for my property, always with my best interests in mind. It was clear that she genuinely cared about achieving a positive outcome for me, and her dedication made all the difference. If youre looking for a real estate agent who will go above and beyond, look no further than Kelsey Kissel. Her professionalism, knowledge, and personal touch truly set her apart. Thank you, Kelsey, for making this experience so smooth and successful!
Pedersendana0
Kelsey was there for us every step of the way! Responsive almost immediately and she made sure everyone did their part and got things done and answers right away. I highly recommend her she has knowledge of the area, the process, and all the mechanics worling parts your house needs. I love my home and the stress free process she made for us!
Available Listings View All



