Credentials
LICENSE
Real Estate - Florida - # BK682932
Awards
Contact Information
Location
403 AnastasiaSaint Augustine, FL, 32080
Find a Top Real Estate Agent Today
ZillowVERIFIEDOne month ago, my home in Saint Augustine was sold by Karen Peil of RE/MAX MyStAugustineHome and Mackenzie Reddy of RE/MAX Market Force. The sale of your home is never an easy decision, but Karen and Mackenzie made it a smooth one by explaining each step and being an advocate for my interests and needs. The process was flawless. Both women showed deep knowledge of the current market combined with savvy experience in the best practices to bring about a quick, profitable sale. They offered real world experience with down-to-earth explanations, compassionate support, and guidance. This team is exceptional, and I highly recommend them.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren and Mackenzie, are the Mother-Daughter Duo, you will want to sell or purchase your home! FACT: the St. Augustine Market "Inventory" for condo's and town homes has been overwhelming for the seller. Our condo was on the market when we moved to NC. Very responsive to our needs. They continually updated us, successfully managed our NEST HVAC System (so we could save money). And, they took care of a problem in the building breezeway that a lesser experienced realtor wouldn't have been able to handle! We encourage you to call them today!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren is an excellent agent who helped us buy and then sell some years later. She is smart, well-organized and very down-to earth. She has extensive contacts in the home trades which we appreciated as newcomers to St. Augustine. We enjoyed working with her!
ZillowVERIFIEDWe have used Karen 3 times. Once to buy a winter home in 2020 and to sell that home this year. We also used her to buy our current home, which will now be our full time home. She is very professional and does things over and above what we have found with other realtors we have worked with. If you are looking to buy or sell a home in the St. Augustine area, we would highly recommend her and her daughter McKenzie!!!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was wonderful to work with through the entire process of purchasing our new home as well as selling our previous home. We were out of state for the majority of the process and she went above and beyond to answer our questions, send us photo updates and videos and provide recommendations as needed. Not only is she a professional, she is very responsive and a delight to work with, highly recommend! We are already having her work with our son on finding a new home!
ZillowVERIFIEDWe don't live in Florida and Karen took care of every detail, from the estate sale to the closing. Karen is the most knowledgable and hard working realtor I have ever worked with. Her negotiating skills are top notch and she guided us through the entire process with complete expertise. Highly recommended!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren has assisted our family in selling a home twice in the last several years. In both instances, my family was dealing with a health crisis at the same time. Because of this, we were not the easiest clients. Karen was and is exceptional, communicating and coordinating to keep everything moving. To say she goes above and beyond for her clients is an understatement. We absolutely recommend Karen!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren Piel is always a pleasure to work with. Her professionalism and expertise is what brought us back to her a 2nd time (bought and sold). We will be back to her very soon for another property in St. Augustine, where she is a resident expert. If your a 1st time home buyer, an 2nd home/investment buyer, or looking to sellaEUR|dont hesitate to call Karen.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren is a top notch real estate professional. She has worked diligently to sell my house. I could not be more pleased. This is the second time I have used her and both times have been a charm. Believe me, you would not go wrong choosing her to help you sell or buy your home.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was an exceptional representative throughout the sale of my home. She is responsive and thorough, and obviously has a ton of experience and local knowledge. I highly recommend Karen for all property buying/selling needs.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren Peil is a total pro who is extremely knowledgeable, responds quickly and makes it all look so easy. We have done several transactions with her since 2016 and they all went very smoothly. We plan on working with her in the future.-Camille Slade
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was a pleasure to work with during this home selling process. She was easy to reach and extremely responsive to calls/texts/emails. Karen's professionalism is unsurpassable. She was calm and remained positive thru-out our ups and downs. A true joy to work with and we would highly recommend Karen for your house hunting or house selling experience. Thank you Karen for always being our advocate.
ZillowVERIFIEDWe were extremely pleased with our home buying experience with our agent Karen Peil. Everything went very swiftly from start to closing. If you want an expert in this highly competitive market right now choose Karen to navigate this market now!!Thankyou Less & Gina Laska
ZillowVERIFIEDKAREN. IS. AMAZING. She really had her work cut out for her in this crazy low-inventory, high-price market. It took us a few months, getting outbid by cash offers, working with our must-haves, and dealing with rapidly-increasing market. Karen was excellent throughout the entire process. Whenever a home came up that we wanted to see, she was happy to jump on it to meet us there and show us. She readily answered our questions and gave advice when we needed it. SUCH a great agent, and would recommend her to everyone!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was an exceptional representative for my wife and me. She is responsive and thoroughly read through contracts, always giving us advice and answering any questions along the way. We could not have asked for a better realtor to help us through the process of building our first home.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren Peil is great with a capital G and a pleasure to work with! As an absentee owner of a condo in St. Augustine that I decided to sell, it was important to me that I work with a realtor living in the area who had a long, very successful track record and could handle everything for me. I interviewed a number of real estate professionals and decided to go with Karen. Boy, am I happy I did! Karen responded right away to my first phone call, answering my many questions, when I just wanted to explore the process. She immediately made herself available to see the condo and gave me great advice on potential pricing and marketing strategies and what improvements did and did not need to be made before putting the condo on the market. Once I started working with her, she was very prompt in responding to all my phone calls and emails, and she always reassured me to not hesitate to contact her if I had any more questions. I felt very confident having her sourcing and getting estimates from cleaners, repair people, painters and other contractors and overseeing their work. The result was a full-asking-price, no-contingency, cash offer within 24 hours of listing, with a closing 10 days later. And sold at a sale price at the highest dollar per square foot of any unit in the complex!Overall, Karen is friendly, attentive, a great communicator, always accessible, good with all the details right through the closing, and willing to go the extra mile. I highly recommend her for anyone looking to buy or sell a property!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren helped us navigate the sale of a home during a challenging time. She went above and beyond to prepare the home for sale, was understanding of our special situation, marketed and priced the home exactly right, got a quick and easy sale and closing, and communicated frequently. I highly recommend Karen for all your real estate needs!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren went above and beyond to help me with a real estate purchase in St. Augustine in an extremely competitive market. Her communication was superb, she assisted with everything from the beginning of the real estate purchase to closing, and was always available to guide and offer invaluable advice throughout the process. If you are deciding on which realtor to work with, save yourself some time and choose Karen, you will be more than glad you did!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren is a true Real Estate professional. We have worked with Karen on 2 transactions, as a buyer and a seller. She exceeded our expectations both times, making each deal as seamless as possible. We would recommend Karen to anyone who is thinking of buying or selling with complete confidence, knowing the transaction will be handled properly.Greg and Karen Di Vico
ZillowVERIFIEDOur experience with Karen was amazing! She is an expert in her market, she made the entire selling process easy, without worries, or stress whatsoever. If you are looking to buy or sell in the St Augustine area look no further! We received 2 offers within 12 hours of listing our property. She is an outstanding agent and you will be in the best hands!
ZillowVERIFIEDWe have so much enjoyed working with Karen. She is very knowledgeable in every aspect of selling a home. She is both professional and personable. We will definitely recommend her to our friends in the St. Augustine area.
ZillowVERIFIEDWe just concluded our third real estate transaction with Karen and couldn't be more pleased. Karen's professionalism, process guidance, and expertise are second to none. We truly appreciate Karen's rapid responses and execution. When you encounter issues in a sale or purchase, you want someone in your corner who you can trust to represent you and rapidly resolve issues. Karen is just that person, and we look forward to conducting our next deal with her.
ZillowVERIFIEDWe have worked with many realtors through the years but Karen is the best. She is diligent, responsive, conscientious, and she definitely looks after your interests. She is very knowledgeable about the area and the market and we could trust her input.We were very particular with what we wanted and didnt buy right away and she stuck with us throughout.. worked to find the right property for the right price. She didnt try to upsell us and only showed us properties above our price range if she felt we had a chance to get them for a better price. We really appreciated this because realtors in the past have tried to push us up and out of our comfort zone.She was on top of everything right up to and even after closing. We cannot recommend her highly enough!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren made the process of buying our home so easy. She was very responsive to any questions we have and her communication was A plus. Would recommend her and will use her again should the need arise for us.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was very friendly, helpful and professional. She helped us find a residence before it was even listed. She was there for us from beginning to end culminating with her walking Us through the closing process and answering all of our numerous questions.She was very responsive to returning our calls and emails.Shes awesome,
ZillowVERIFIEDWe found Karen to be prompt, personable & professional from start to finish. She had a buyer for our home within 4 hours after going live. This was one of the easiest home transactions weve ever made. We highly recommend Karen for buying or selling your next home. Tim & Brenda Skinner
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was instrumental in helping us obtain our perfect Oceanside condominium. She was knowledgeable and so helpful with all off the processes involved including helping connect to a lender. We did everything remotely and were overwhelmed with all she did to help us
ZillowVERIFIEDMy husband and I hit the jackpot when my colleague recommended Karen. She raved about how great she was to work with when purchasing her home. I can truly say Karens expertise, professionalism and integrity are unsurpassed. Her knowledge of current market trends, unlimited professional resources and attention to detail helped make our dream come true. The stress of purchasing a home along with trying to do it during this unprecedented time of COVID-19, is a true testament to Karens dedication. Thank you Karen...well be back!Alex and Tanisha
ZillowVERIFIEDThis is our third time working with Karen since 2016. I highly recommend her. She is extremely pleasant to work with. She makes it look so easy, and I know she works harder than anyone I know. You will not wait long for a response from Karen. If you are in the buyer's market, she will show you properties at your convenience. We have also sold with Karen and it was seamless. She is a true professional!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was a joy to work with. Our transaction was mostly from out-of-state, and Karen's ability to communicate quickly and efficiently was of paramount importance in getting our purchase completed smoothly. Every real estate purchase is a journey, with bumps in the road, and Karen helped smooth those bumps. Her knowledge of the area, and of area expertise, was invaluable. I highly recommend working with Karen!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren came highly recommended by another family member. She worked diligently to find a local property with the attributes we wanted in our new home. Karen even called after the sale to remind us to transfer bonds and warranties- above and beyond! Thank you, Karen! We are so happy with our purchase.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was always professional, knowledgeable and timely about all aspects of real estate. She was always a text or call away when any concerns came up and you were worried about any problem. She went out of her way to help even if it meant changing her plans to help when needed.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren worked with us in selling our condo and purchasing a new one. She definitely knows the community and expertly guided us in our decisions. She was very patient with us and our constant calling and answering our many questions. I think we were pretty questioning and demanding and she handled us with 'kid gloves'. She more than met our expectations and we found her to be genuine, a great communicator and negotiator, and worked tirelessly with us. You can't ask for anyone better to represent you, either with selling or buying. She is generous with her time, accessible, and understanding of one's personal needs. Simply put, she is an outstanding person to work with and a genuinely nice person.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren has been exceptional in every aspect of my real estate transaction. She provided me with excellent, timely advice and was there to help me every step of the way. I would highly recommend her to anyone looking for a realtor in St. Augustine.
ZillowVERIFIEDWorking with Karen Peil was a very good experience for me. I live in Daytona but was looking to purchase a condo in Saint Augustine Florida. Karen always answered my questions As soon as possible and was very supportive during My search and purchase. I would recommend her services to anyone. She is a professional with a heart.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren Peil was our agent for the sale of our home. She was always professional and a delight to work with. She was knowledgeable, extremely helpful, and went above and beyond our expectations. We highly recommend her to anyone needing the services of a realtor, either as a buyer or a seller. Should we decide to purchase another home, she would be the first call we made.
ZillowVERIFIEDWorking with Karen as our Realtor was a wonderful experience. Karen took the stress out of looking and buying a house. Her knowledge and expertise during this process, is a valuable asset that only someone like Karen, who truly goes out of her way for her clients can give. I highly recommend her if you are in the market for a Realtor. Thank you for everything Karen!!!
ZillowVERIFIEDShe is an excellent realtor. She is always available to answer the phone, emails or texts right away and makes the selling or buying experience easy with little stress. Paperwork is handled without visits to any office or home and she will help you with anything you need to do before or after the process. I would recommend her to any of my friends or family selling or buying a home.
ZillowVERIFIEDShe is an excellent realtor. She is always available to answer the phone, emails or texts right away and makes the selling or buying experience easy with little stress. Paperwork is handled without visits to any office or home and she will help you with anything you need to do before or after the process. I would recommend her to any of my friends or family selling or buying a home.
ZillowVERIFIEDWe started looking for a beach condo in June 2018 and with Karen's help closed on the perfect one for us in August 2018. She was very helpful in navigating the process, we had not purchased a home in over 15 years. She was well connected in the area, which also helped the process. Karen responded to all my messages the same day or next day at the latest. When she was out of town for a weekend, she made sure our progress continued and set us up with her colleague who was also stellar. If I ever had to buy or sell a property in the St. Augustine area, I would get Karen in a heartbeat.Karen was interested in finding the right place for us for the right price!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was a pleasure to work with as a seller's agent. She is very knowledgeable of the St. Augustine market, especially Oakbrook. The sale went very smoothly.
ZillowVERIFIEDWe had an excellent experience working with Karen when she sold our condo in just days!She is really knowledgeable about the local market and was very responsive, answering any questions we had immediately. Highly recommend- I wouldnt use anyone else.Thank you Karen!
ZillowVERIFIEDWe would recommend Karen so sell your home without reservation. Very professional and thorough. Pleasant personality an very personable. We would definitely use her again! Thanks Karen!
ZillowVERIFIEDWe had a great experience with Karen - we were on a tight timeline, with a fairly difficult closing - plus moving across the country - Karen got us through on time and with very few problems. We were very pleased.
ZillowVERIFIEDVery Good. Karen treated us more like friends or family members than just clients. We have worked with her before and would definitely work with her should the need arise.
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren is an excellent realtor. She was always on time, well-prepared, certainly knows the St. Augustine market, and has an extensive list of contacts in trades and services. She was a tremendous help to us as we are moving to St. Augustine from another area of Florida. In addition to her many skills, she is a darn nice person, down-to-earth and easy to chat with! Highly recommended!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren Peil immediately responded to my request to view a condomenium unit on my short visit to St. Augustine. Within an hour we had completed the walkthrough and decided on a fair counter offer. I immediately was pleased with her professionalism. I never doubted that she was looking out for my best interest instead of just being interest in making the sale. The negotiations and contracts were executed electronically making the long-distance purchase painless. Being from out of state, I encountered requirements that were somewhat different from what I had previously experienced. A couple of hurricanes intervened during the timeline but we were able to close the transaction within 6 weeks. Thanks to Karen for making it a pleasant experience.
ZillowVERIFIEDWe highly recommend Karen Peil as your realtor. We purchased a home in Florida while living in Maryland. Karen looked out for ourbest interests every step of the way and went above and beyond to help us transition to Floridians.
ZillowVERIFIEDI was facing a short sale situation, and Karen knew exactly the team to build to see that my condo was marketed, under contract, and sold! Even though the banks threw up some barriers, Karen and her team persevered and kept me in the loop through efficient, effective communication during the entire process. Thank you Karen!
ZillowVERIFIEDKaren was absolutely wonderful to work with. My family relocated to the area from out of state, and not only did she help with the home purchasing process, she also provided information to us on the local schools, businesses and things to do in the area. I feel she went above and beyond to make sure we found the house that was right for our family, in the area we wanted to live, and at our established price range. She took care of all of the details quickly and professionally. I will definitely recommend Karen to all of my friends and family!
Loading recent sales...