Real estate has been part of my life for as long as I can remember. Growing up in the industry alongside my parents, I knew I had to give it a try--and I never looked back! After graduating from Carroll University with a degree in Marketing and a minor in Psychology, I jumped into real estate full-time and have been helping buyers and sellers navigate the market for 6.5+ years. I take pride in providing top-notch communication, expert negotiation, personalized service, and strategic marketing to help my clients achieve their goals. Whether you're selling for top dollar or finding the perfect home at the best price, I'm here to guide you every step of the way! Outside of real estate, I love traveling, paddle boarding, and spending time with my fiance, Shawn, and our dog, Sadie. Ready to make your next move? Let's connect!
OTHER LANGUAGES
English
Community Involvement
Sponsor & Run Greendale community Garage sale
HOBBIES/INTEREST
Swim, Paddle board/kayak, Walk, Travel, Be around my dog Sadie, family and friends
FAMILY
Fiance Shawn & Dog Sadie
Read More About Kaeley
Specialties
Sellers
Buyers
Residential Property
First time Home Buyers, Move up Buyers, Downsizes, Relocation, First time Home Sellers
Awards
2026
TOP AGENT
Mukwonago, WI
2026
TOP AGENT
Big Bend, WI
2026
TOP AGENT
Kansasville, WI
Other Awards
Million Dollar Producer, Top 10 Agent, Viral Video Award, Top Closer
View All Awards
FAQ
1. What advice would you give a buyer trying to purchase a home?
It's never too early to start! I meet with many people 1+ years out to make sure they are on the right path. Start finding a realtor you like & trust, I promise you, we make all the difference. Look at the agent's reviews. If they aren't asking you questions about your goals, be wary. Once you do that, we can guide you through literally all the next steps!
2. What advice would you give a seller trying to sell their home?
Hire the right realtor for YOU that has a proven strategy and plan, with over the top marketing and track record! Ask questions. If they aren't asking you questions about your goals, be wary. And lastly, if they aren't using professional photography - please run :)
3. What types of clients have you worked with?
So many! I work with a ton of first time home buyers who are so afraid/lost on where to start in the process. With teaching and guidance, by the end they are so confident!
I also work with a lot of sellers, and LOVE using my marketing skills to show off your property and get you top dollar with the least hassles. Anything creative and problem solving, that's my go to!
You'll tell when meeting me how laid back I am - My job is never to push, just to offer all the options that let's you make the best informed decisions for you & your family!
4. Describe a recent transaction you are fond of. How did it go?
So many great ones to choose from. I recently helped a friend get a home and we found the home of their DREAMS! Only problem, it had 5 offers. No problem for us, I helped them craft a super creative and appealing offer that kept them protected and comfortable, and we won! After that, negotiated everything they wanted after the home inspection. Turns out, they got the home for 45k UNDER the appraised value! That's a crazy good deal. Everything went smoothly until the great MKE flooding, right before their closing day, and the basement got some water. I explained all their options & they still wanted to close and din't want to ask for anything, but I insisted we get them a credit. got them thousands off! They were thrilled and closed happily ever after!
5. How did you get started in Real Estate?
Both my parents are in it, so I grew up watching them :) Real estate has been part of my life for as long as I can remember. Funny enough, going into college I didn't know that's what I wanted to do, but by the end near graduation, I knew I had to give it a try—and I've never looked back!
6. Do you have any special education or training that will benefit your clients?
I'm a top 10 agent in my office out of 300+, I'm experienced, have a marketing degree, and will give you the ultimate best customer service!
Contact Information
Location
2665 South Moorland Rd #104 New Berlin, WI, 53151
Social Media
Marketing Materials
More Agents Near You
Loading recent sales...
Kaeley Simek's Reviews & Ratings
5 Reviews
(5/5)
Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Communicative
Responsive
Hard working
Knowledgeable
Trustworthy
Liz B.
Review for Member: Kaeley Simek
October 1, 2025
Kaeley made our home search an incredibly smooth and comfortable experience We were on a very tight timeline to secure an accepted offer and she truly made our goals her own She was always quick to schedule showings often within hours of a listing going up and even found homes for us before they officially hit the market Her honest advice and knowledgeable opinions gave us confidence every step of the wayAs first time homebuyers we leaned on Kaeley for everything connecting us with a trustworthy lender crafting offers that protected us while standing out to sellers and guiding us through inspections with reliable recommendations and scheduling help Thanks to her dedication and expertise we found our dream home in our dream neighborhood in just three weeksWe couldnt recommend Kaeley more highly Shes exactly the kind of realtor you want in your corner
Joy P.
Review for Member: Kaeley Simek
September 25, 2025
Kaeley did amazing with selling my condo She communicated the entire time and was so easy to work with When I move again I will definitely be having Kaeley be my realtor Shes the best
Leah G.
Review for Member: Kaeley Simek
September 24, 2025
We just purchased our first home with Kaeley and that was our smartest decision We would use her a million times over again She is the best person to walk through this experience with Kaeley treated this process like it was her own home she was looking for She was super quick to respond always available for us and also was just as excited as we were Kaeley always gave us advice and tips as well as her educated opinion on different moments of home searchingclosing Even after closing she continued to check in on us
Matt B.
Review for Member: Kaeley Simek
September 23, 2025
Kaeley made our home buying experience so fun and easy As first time home buyers she walked us through every step of the process and always made us feel comfortable She was also very responsive throughout the whole process and helped us book showings and get answers to our questions very quickly I highly recommend using Kaeley as a realtor
Bob
Review for Member: Kaeley Simek
August 20, 2025
Kaeley was wonderful to work with Always quick and prompt to reply which is very important during a real estate transaction Looking forward to working with you again in the future Thank you Kaeley