About Judy Mitchell
HOBBIES/INTEREST
Credentials
LICENSE
Designation
SRES
Awards
2026
TOP AGENT
Longboat Key, FL
Other Awards
Platinum Award, Diamond Award, Gold Award

Available Listings View All

View All ListingsSRES
2026
Longboat Key, FL
Platinum Award, Diamond Award, Gold Award


View All ListingsI had a great experience with Judy Mitchell. Judy is great communicator and was very knowledgeable about the real estate market. My house sold in 30 days. All the marketing that she did definitely helped to get the house sold. I highly recommend Judy Mitchell is you need to sell your home in Longboat Key, FL.
We had a wonderful experience working with Judy as our broker when selling our Longboat Key condo. She was incredibly helpful and accommodating throughout the process, always making herself available whenever we had questions, needed help or guidance. Judy truly went above and beyondaEUR"from helping us get the condo ready for market to ensuring everything stayed on track through closing. Her dedication and attention to detail made what could have been a stressful experience smooth and manageable. We are so grateful for her hard work and would absolutely recommend Judy to anyone looking to buy or sell a home.
Judy very adeptly helped us navigate a long distance sale of my parents condo in Longboat. Her many years of experience was very important to us, but her service level and especially her living (not just working) on the Key was the difference maker. Among the long list of everything she did to market the condo, her ability to be at every showing and meet painters and handymen was such a relief to us given we were thousands of miles away. If you are looking for someone to sell your home in LBK, having the agent also be a resident makes a huge difference! I can imagine the same would be true for anyone wanting to buy there. We would also add that the deal closed as planned with no hiccups. Smooth as silk. Judy's communications were numerous and she was extremely responsive which meant a lot given the distance. Thanks Judy!!!
We had the pleasure of working with Judy over the last three months. She found us exactly what we were looking for and was great in navigating us through the purchase process. She is very knowledgeable in the Sarasota area and was able to answer all of our questions. She is very professional and honest which is so important in an agent. She is very pleasant to work with. We would not hesitate reaching out and having her help us in a future home.
We bought a place in Longboat Key, site unseen, as we live in London. We couldn't be happier with having Judy to help us through the process. With emails, texts, calls, live video, and video links, Judy made us feel comfortable making decisions from "across the pond." She was available, friendly, knowledgable, professional, and experienced. Our purchase went smoothly, thanks to Judy and those who she referred us to (e.g. her wise choices of title company, insurance carrier, inspectors, and banking). We had a greater measure of confidence in an agent who lives on the island, and she lived up to the expectation. Highly recommend Judy Mitchell!
We bought a place in Longboat Key, site unseen, as we live in London. We couldn't be happier with having Judy to help us through the process. With emails, texts, calls, live video, and video links, Judy made us feel comfortable making decisions from "across the pond." She was available, friendly, knowledgable, professional, and experienced. Our purchase went smoothly, thanks to Judy and those who she referred us to (e.g. her wise choices of title company, insurance carrier, inspectors, and banking). We had a greater measure of confidence in an agent who lives on the island, and she lived up to the expectation. Highly recommend Judy Mitchell!
Judy Mitchell is very knowledgeable. She knows the LBK area very well. We actually found her through viewing youtube. We were impressed with her constant analysis of the market in the Sarasota/Manatee County area. We listened and understood the advice given to us. Judy handled our sale with ease. From start to finish we were listed and sold within 28 days with multiple offers. We highly recommend Judy Mitchell with Premier Sothebys International Realty.
I am so pleased to write a review for Judy Mitchell. Judy was an excellent resource for real estate in Long Boat Key and the surrounding Sarasota area. We looked at many properties and Judy was well-versed in the market. My husband and I ended up purchasing a vacation condo in Long Boat Key as we are from RI. It could have been a daunting experience, but Judy made the transaction seamless. From the initial call that the property was available to after the closing, Judy kept in touch with us every step of the way. We were so impressed with how incredibly organized Judy was with reminders and updates. Judys impeccable attention to detail kept the process moving along and she answered all our questions in a timely manner. We were so happy to have such an excellent realtor who communicates effectively. There were no surprises, ever! Judy negotiated a fair deal, and we could not have been more pleased with the whole experience. I cannot speak highly enough about Judy Mitchell. If you are looking for a realtor to help you purchase a property in this area, you should definitely call Judy. She will consider your interests, guide you through the process, and advocate on your behalf all with a friendly personality.
Very glad I chose to work with Judy. She is knowledgable, responsive and efficient. There were a few hiccups with the unoccupied property but Judy helped smooth them over. Highly recommend for LBK.
I happenstance upon Judy after she sent a letter to the community I was living in whereby clients were looking to purchase Usually I shred them but I decided to email her about my property. It was a smart move on my part (pat on the back) as Judy responded immediately. Long story short, she got my place sold in two days at top dollar, cash - all I was hoping for. She was smooth, professional, easy going and easy to deal with. On top of that she found me the exact home I was looking for within a few weeks of accepting the bid on mine!She also handled both closings as I was in Europe. No snags - nothing. Perfect!Bottom line. - Judys the go to person in this area. Give her a call!
On the day I contacted Judy and told her I was interested in a home to purchase, she was in her car to check it out... that night! In addition, she made every step easy! She kept me in the loop every step of the way. She even went out of her way to contact the town and inquire about land variances regarding sheds and garages to be built on the property. She is responsive and professional! Very happy with our decision to hire Judy Mitchell!
It has been a pleasure working with Judy! She is very professional and wonderful to work with. She is very friendly and knowledgeable and makes everything easy to understand. She took the time to get to know us and what we are looking for. Her commitment to her profession is evident. You can tell she loves what she does and wants to get you into the dream home that you want!
Judy, a realtor in Longboat Key, recently sold my condo and it was the best experience. She helped me get my home ready to sell with essentially no expense. Judy just used my own furnishings and furniture to make my home look great. And the photos were amazing. I was able to sell it for more than I thought, and I had several offers to choose from. Judy negotiated a great deal for me. She is a true professional, always accessible. Highly recommend!
Loading recent sales...