Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Olester175
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn was simply amazing. He worked his butt off to represent my family and I. He is a master of his craft. Not only did he sell our house, but he got us multiple offers to choose from. He professionally represented himself and my family's interests. John was also instrumental in the purchase of our new house. We were one of four officers, but the "outside the box thinking" John provided the little extra that pushed our offer through for acceptance. We will use John again! and would highly recommend him to anyone!
Atkinsnc10
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn was amazing to work with. He is very knowledgeable, friendly, trustworthy, and always responsive to calls, texts and emails. He even went out of his way to complete some repairs for us when time was of the essence. Highly recommend!!
Cara K.
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn has gone above and beyond our expectations for realtor services. He got us top dollar for our home , and he even helped sweep prior to pictures and showings. I recommend everyone to use John Natoli for the best experience in selling your home. He is a great guy!
Zuser20140527144259565
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDSelling a house you have called home for over 20 years is a very emotional experience. We contacted John Natoli to help guide us through the process. He is such a warm understanding person that we knew we were in the right hands from the minute he sat with us. John is extremely knowledgeable and professional. He listened to all our concerns and had no problem respecting our wishes. Having had a problem with some paperwork, John immediately went down to the Town Hall and had the situation taken care of. He was in constant contact with us and was always respectful of our wishes. The house sold in less than a week and the process was as stress less as possible! We highly recommend John!
Nikkitorretta
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDI cant even begin to describe how wonderful John was to work with. He helped my boyfriend and I to sell our house in Queens and purchase our dream home in Massapequa. John was very patient throughout every step in pricing our home to sell, and we found a buyer quickly. John always kept us up to date on any news and was always easy to reach and quick to find us an answer to our many many questions. John also had the patience to show us practically all of Nassau and managed to find a home that suited all of mine and my boyfriends needs and desires. John was always very professional and was a pleasure to work with. I have already recommended him to several people!
Paul S.
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDMy wife and I started our home search during the summer of 2017 with John. We were interested in the Town of Huntington and focused on identifying a good school district. John worked with us to identify a larger list of priorities and then took the time to describe how each particular town might hit the mark for those priorities. Throughout the process, he always respected that the perfect home was solely our decision and based on our opinion. He never pushed us into a home but was quick to highlight and warn about qualities that might lose value over time or wouldn't be attractive when trying to resell. After months of shopping, John helped us to find the "perfect" home and then worked to negotiate it into our budget. He was reliable, considerate and most importantly honest. At one point, I told my wife that if her and John thought it was a good purchase then make an offer. A bit extreme but it shows the level of confidence I had in John and his understanding of our needs and wants.
Paul S.
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDMy wife and I started our home search during the summer of 2017 with John. We were interested in the Town of Huntington and focused on identifying a good school district. John worked with us to identify a larger list of priorities and then took the time to describe how each particular town might hit the mark for those priorities. Throughout the process, he always respected that the perfect home was solely our decision and based on our opinion. He never pushed us into a home but was quick to highlight and warn about qualities that might lose value over time or wouldn't be attractive when trying to resell. After months of shopping, John helped us to find the "perfect" home and then worked to negotiate it into our budget. He was reliable, considerate and most importantly honest. At one point, I told my wife that if her and John thought it was a good purchase then make an offer. A bit extreme but it shows the level of confidence I had in John and his understanding of our needs and wants.
Yanksfan077
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDVery knowledgeable, attentive and professional.Found me only properties he knew i would like. I highly recommend John and his team for any real estate needs.
Bo B.
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn Natoli is a consummate professional, an extremely hardworking broker and one who followed through to every last detail until the end selflessly. In fact, even after the deal closed, he still inquired as to how he could help make my family's transition easier. To be honest, my family ran John through the gauntlet, and had to walk away from one home given a set of very poor engineering inspection results we received, forcing him to reset the search process on our behalf. John never complained, was extremely conscientious and was able to deal with a stressful situation expertly while keeping my family calm.I would highly recommend John Natoli's services to anyone looking in his coverage area. My wife and I have worked with a number of brokers over the last 20+ years across dofferent parts of NY and Connecticut, and John stands out as one of the very best.
Zuser20161231123033527
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDAs buyers, we found John to be respectful. He honored our request to see a house multiple times. He even went into his own pocket to be sure the lawn was cut before closing. He really worked for his commission from the seller!! If you use John, you won't be sorry. He will do whatever he can to sell your house!!
Jfalcone2003
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn recently helped us with the sale of our current home and the purchase of a new home. We were impressed from day one with his expertise and knowledge of the real estate market. We received multiple offers on our multi-family home which sold in one week. John is always there whenever you need him and he truly cares about all his clients. He constantly kept us updated and he responded to our calls/emails the same day. I would highly recommend John to anyone who is interested in buying or selling a home. You will not find anyone better.I would also like to give special mention to the other agent, Joe Casale, who worked along with John with both the sale/purchase of our homes. Together, they made up the most incredible team. If one of them were not able to make a showing, the other one stepped in. All our questions were answered in a timely manner. Joe knew the real estate area where we were selling our home because he had lived there. Joe is also a pleasure to work with and he has a wonderful personality. I would also highly recommend Joe to anyone who wants to sell or buy a home.
Devin A.
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn worked diligently from day 1 to produce a report of the homes in the surrounding area and correctly price my father's home for sale. He had it listed across multiple places and was able to generate multiple offers within a few short weeks that were a mix of cash and mixed funding sources. He is highly responsive over call, email, and text, and is highly technically savvy. He was thoughtful to our particular situation and we were extremely pleased with the full-service attention to detail mindset he brought to selling our home.
Tedpaf
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn was knowledgeable, creative and patient. He helped us find the perfect home. John negotitated terms and conditions that met our needs and provided us suggestions along the way which made the process easier. We highly recommend John.Ted and Barbara P.
Shows234
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn is a very hard working realtor. He is knowledgeable and very personable. He goes above and beyond the expectations of a seller. John worked very hard managing the sale of my property. He helped with being available to make sure my dog was safe during all showings. He answered all questions I had anytime I had them. He was always reassuring when I was anxious. He found me a handyman to correct some issues in the sale. I highly recommend him to anyone looking to buy or sell their home.
Magandy19846
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn Natoli is a great guy who has been very professional and helped me out with my first house. Thanks to all his efforts and efficiency I had my house no later than two months. I am very thankful for all his work.
Mheretakis
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn was very knowledgeable about the Dix hills market and exactly what I was looking for. He was extremely responsive and made my closing as smooth as possible. I am very pleased with the experience I had with John Natoli.
Patrick G.
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDAs a 51 year old father of two adult sons in the middle of a trial divorce, the last thing I had time for was to chase unwanted rentals. As a quick closing date approached on a home sale l, time certainly wasn't on my side leaving me with sub par credit and and the brink of bankruptcy..... John and I spoke briefly as far as what I was looking for and immediately had several condos and homes for me to look at within the exact area,l we wanted to live, as well as a comfortable monthly dollar amount, again achieving every "wants" me and my children asked for. The move was quick and seamless....I cannot nearly repay John for what he did for me and my family....As a man your job is to provide a roof over your family's head....without John I wouldn't have been able to do this. He honestly saved me from possibly living separately from my kids....We're currently settled into a warm cozy comfortable home. I cannot thank John enough. A real lifesaver.Thank you. Patrick.
John N.
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn was great! His knowledge of the home buying process was key for me seeing as I am a first time home buyer. He was very professional, honest and very fast to respond. I felt that I could trust his opinion and advice in this process. I would 100% recommend him.
User7027390
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn is an experienced realtor who has successfully sold four of our properties over the last 12 months. He has an impeccable attention to detail and is one of the hardest working agents on Long Island. I would recommend anyone looking to buy or sell a home here on Long Island to consider John for his services.
Tegrimm5
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn helped us find a qualified renter for our home. He was reliable, knowledgeable and courteous when it came to showing our home. I would highly recommended John Natoli if you are looking to buy, sell, rent or need to find a renter. We really appreciated the time and effort he put in to find the right person to rent our home.
Tlockwood428
Review for Member: John Natoli
ZillowVERIFIEDJohn is a real professional. He has made our dream of finding a new home come true with a very easy transition to N.C. We are more than satisfied and happy to recommend someone with his know how ,and caring skills!