Service Areas
About Jimmy Stewart
Credentials
LICENSE
Specialties
- Buyer's Agent
- Landlord
- Listing Agent
- Relocation
- Short sale specialist
Awards
-
2026
TOP AGENT
Fort Collins, CO
2026
TOP AGENT
Windsor, CO
2026
TOP AGENT
Severance, CO
2026
Fort Collins, CO
2026
Windsor, CO
2026
Severance, CO
Jimmy was incredible in the sale of our home. He comes with decades of experience and is a market expert. He helped us sell our home surprisingly fast even when the market wasn't in our favor. He is an excellent communicator and made the process feel seamless. He was always there if we had questions. And was so fun to work with! He comes highly recommended from this family!
We have worked with Jimmy in three real estate transactions over the years. Our experience with him has always been joyful, informed and professional. Jimmy's knowledge of the market (his data driven model for home pricing is extremely accurate) as well as his expertise in general contracting helped us tremendously- both when buying and again when selling 5 years later. Thanks Jimmy for being our favorite realtor!!!
Jimmy Stewart approached me to list my FSBO home as a Sellers Agent and suggested my FSBO price was $50k too low; I signed with him because he brought data, charisma and energy. He was my Sellers Agent on my signed listing agreement, but while on a beach vacation in Portugal, Jimmy had located a buyer. Rather than follow the contract, he aEURoedecidedaEUR? to represent the Buyers as a Buyers Agent. Jimmy notified me he was a Transaction Broker, but in fact, in our contract, he needed my signature to agree to this. Jimmy Stewart represented himself as honest, but he negotiated AGAINST me when our contract said he was working FOR me. He brought a contract for my home representing himself to the Buyers as a Buyers Agent, and the signed contract with his license number shows Jimmy as a Sellers Agent AND a Buyers Agent. I did not find his marketing of aEURoetireless dedication, meticulous attention to detail and unparalleled negotiation skillsaEUR? that he raves about in his personal bio to be factual. When Jimmy wanted to list my home, it was worth $50k more than I had the home listed as FSBO, but while under a contract with me as a Sellers agent, he brought a Buyer as a Buyers agent with an offer, my home was worth $40k less than my FSBO value, just four months later. While we made a modification to the contract to correct the error Jimmy made representing himself as a Sellers Agent AND a Buyers Agent, today, Jimmy proudly markets himself as having brought the Buyer and Seller for the transaction.
Jimmy was very thoughtful in the market and valuation of our home and had great pictures taken for the listing. He made everything smooth, and our home sold quickly. It was a pleasure working with him.
Jimmy Stewart is the best real estate agent I or my husband have ever had. He spent 9 months helping us find what we wanted, with a very narrow criteria. We drove up from Aurora, CO every other weekend and looked at many properties. Believe me, we were not easy to please. We put offers in on four; one we were out bid on by $50K and the other three we withdrew after inspection. Finally we found something that met our criteria and are moved and happy in our new place. Jimmy is very knowledgeable about the real estate market as whole and specifically Northern Colorado. He is patient, kind and gives excellent advice on making offers. He is persistent, honest and genuine. He really cares about his clients and makes sure he does the best thing for them. His transaction coordinator, Chris, emulates the same attributes. Take the opportunity to work with him. You will be pleased!
Selling a home in our current market has its challenges, marketing, curb appeal, minor touches and most of all was staying positive throughput the process, Jimmy met everyone of them. His knowledge in negotiating and ability to read the market got us our top dollar, actually more than I expected. He is a proactive hands on professional with the patience of Jobe. As a retired Military service member I respect his character and dedication to his trade. Bottom line: Jimmy your the best.
Jimmy was an absolute pleasure to work with! We felt so at ease since the first time we met with him. Our house was listed during a down time and Jimmy was honest the whole step of the way. Always great communication before and after each showing with us and the buyers agent. Jimmy did sell our home and the process went as smooth as possible. We felt like we made a new friend in the process. Jimmy's expertise really shows! Would gladly recommend him friends and family.
Jimmy did an amazing job selling our house in a very difficult market. He is extremely knowledgeable of the market and the area. He took the time to listen to us, and made suggestions based off of what our needs were. We highly recommend working with Jimmy!
Jimmy did a great job. Made the process easy. Willing and able to make things happen for you. He was able to help me get into my first home and made it work in my timeframe
Jimmy has been hands down the best realtor I have worked with. He will presented data that I have not received from other agents, as well as insights from his many years of experience! Top notch professional!!
Working with Jimmy was a breeze. He is always professional and is extremely knowledgeable with the current housing market. I would recommend Jimmy without hesitation to anyone looking to buy our sell their home.
Buying a first home in a competitive market during a global pandemic could easily be a stressful experience, but with Jimmy, the process was smooth and efficient. Jimmy is very knowledgeable about the market and knows how to conduct business like a true professional. No matter how busy he was, he always took the time to answer all of our questions and referred us to a great contractor to remodel our new kitchen.
He had my back throughout the whole process. He response very quickly and made sure I didn't "settle" with a house he knew I wouldn't be happy in. Very happy about where we ended up. Thank you Jimmy and Chris!
Jimmy was a pleasure to work with on my first time buying a home. He was very knowledgeable, prompt, and willing to give his honest opinion. I appreciate everything he has helped me with in this process.
Jimmy was such a pleasure to work with! He is awesome at what he does! He is prompt, thorough, responsive, and extremely knowledgeable. I highly recommend!
We have bought and sold 7 homes in 5 states. Through that experience, we have worked with a full range of real estate professionals. Jimmy topped them all. His level of personalized service, positive personality and attention to detail was refreshing. Highly recommend him and his team to anyone looking to buy or sell in Nor CO.
Jimmy was great to work with. He was extremely responsive, hard working, and knew the Northern Colorado market better than any other agent I have worked with in the past. We have bought and sold more than 5 times and this was by far our best experience with listing, selling, and finding our new house. I would recommend Jimmy and his team without hesitation to anyone looking to list their current home or search for a new home in the future.
Working with Jimmy and his team was amazing. They made everything so simple and made sure I understood what was going on every step of the way. My house sold very quickly and I couldn't be more pleased. I definitely plan on working with Jimmy in the future and will recommend him to friends/family who are looking to buy/sell homes. Thank you Jimmy!
Our family worked with the Key Group We were unsuccessful at selling our mothers home by ourselves. We hired Jathan Trevena as our agent. He got us an offer within the first week and closed in 30 days. ...
Jimmy and his team are some of the best. He approached me when I was a for sale by owner. No pressure but very prepared and personable. I was pressured by another realtor but Jimmy was a solid voice of reason. He and his team did what they said they would do. He sold my townhome faster than the others in my complex for top dollar. Jimmy is a man of his word and lends his expertise and time even when there is no sale for him. I would use him again and recommend him and hisbteam without reservation.
Jimmy knew the Fort Collins area and market very well. He listened to what we needed and wanted and worked diligently until he found us just the right property. He was personable, very easy to work with, professional, and knowledgeable. He was readily available to answer all our questions. We will definitely use his services again and recommend him without reservation to anyone looking for a realtor.
Jimmy handled the sale of our home perfectly. He knows his business, is always calm and relaxed, and gets the job done. He has an interesting strategy on how to sell a home quickly at the best possible price - and it worked for us. I would highly recommend Jimmy.
We have had nothing but a great experience workingwith Jimmy. His easy going, upbeat, no pressure manner,along with many years of experience and sales success made the homebuying process easy.He not only finds you a home, he provides a lot of customerservice during and after you are in your home.Without a doubt, we highly recommend Jimmy.Chuck & Janine Johnson
Jimmy is very experienced and knowledgeable. His advise on alternative purchasing options, negotiation strategies/outcomes, and purchasing timing was helpful for us as we were first time buyers. His guidance allowed us to confidently negotiate from a position of strength and close on a deal satisfied with the outcome, despite a few inspection surprises.
Jimmy helped us find our home in record time! He is very knowledgeable on the area, fun to work with, and he got us in at a surprisingly low price! I would definitely recommend.
I attempted to sell my home by owner (FSBO) for a couple of weeks at 240k. It got frustrating quickly as the majority of my calls were from real estate agents, non-qualified buyers and investors trying to low ball us. Let alone trying to juggle my schedule for the showings. Thankfully, we hired Jimmy Stewart to take over the process. He presented us with a very strong marketing plan and offered a unique strategy to create a bidding war on our home. Jimmy listed our house for $250K and held an open house on a Saturday afternoon. He had 25 groups through the home in a two hour period and presented us with 3 offers by that afternoon; all the offers were well above the listing price. I would highly recommend Jimmy; he is honest, fun and has a program that works. The commission we paid him was well worth it. Jimmy is definitely a Pro!
I would not recommend using Jimmy Stewart. He did not do his job and was not a good Realtor at all. He only looks out for himself. I unfortunately used his services twice. The first time he didn't help me out at all and when I would call he would not answer and then send me a text. On my first transaction I only saw Jimmy three times. Then on my second transaction he turned the sale of my property over to another Realtor and then showed up to sign the contract on my new purchase and then was not seen again for two months. I fired him for abandonment and went with a different agent to help me finish the sale and purchase of my houses. Then 7 months later he showed up to collect his money. He has no values at all.
We are currently living in Georgia, and have a tough situation. With having to hunt up houses in Colorado while living a long way away Jimmy has been a real friend and is fighting to find us the perfect home. I don't envy him in his task, but his is very kind and patient. He is steering us thru a stressful situation, and doing a stellar job. I would highly recommend him as an agent and friend.
Loading recent sales...