Note: Reviews may include other agents on their team
What clients say about this agent....
Jeff M.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIEDThe Jim Geracie Team has been nothing short of extraordinary!! From our initial introduction to the final close, and EVERY point in between, The Jim Geracie Team was extremely responsive, completely professional, and amazingly knowledgeable! Jims extensive experience really came to the fore during the market engagement and sale negotiation activities, during which, he exercised extreme savvy and incredible creativity. I never had to worry if he and his Team had my interests at the forefront as this was made abundantly clear by the Teams daily actions! I could not have asked for a stronger advocate! Despite this being a rather unpredictable and quite aEUR~eventful sale process, Jim and his Team maintained continuous poise and unwavering focus throughout. Their persistence and diligence are unmatched! I am completely convinced that I would not have achieved the same results with any other realtor. If you are looking for the best in the business to represent you, look no further than The Jim Geracie Team!!
Lindsay B.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED WOW, just wow. From our first interactions with Jim we knew that we was the realtor for us. Welcoming, kind, honest and transparent- he made us feel comfortable from the first moment we connected. He is so knowledgeable about the business, the market, and the process. He was able to take first time home sellers like us, and walk us through the entire process step by step. Jim was there every step of the way for us, even if that meant calling him to share our concerns, excitement, and everything in between. He was also not afraid to reset our expectations and provide honest advice when we needed him to. His top notch team of professionals were there to assist us with everything that we needed. I can't imagine a real estate transaction going more smoothly than it did with Jim and team. Aside from a really talented professional, it's also just worth mentioning that Jim is just a really great human, as was everybody that we connected with during this journey from his team If you are looking to buy a home, sell a home, or just learn more about the current market - our family wholeheartedly recommends Jim and Team. Thank you Geracie team, for making this such an incredible experience for us.
Chlnrhue
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim Geracie is all we ever talk aboutaEUR|..when were not talking about JillaEUR|..! Unbelievable breadth of knowledge and skill at every point from property evaluation to suggested improvements to increase offers to multiple offers including the one we choose to accept, considerably over our asking price. His team is prompt responsive and hands onaEUR|.as if we were his only clients. Thats why we talk about Jim all the time. Hes the best!!!!
Paintnpaper0
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED I highly recommend The Jim Geracie Team to anyone looking to buy or sell a home. They understood the local market trends and displayed exceptional professionalism throughout the entire process. Colin O'Neil, who went above and beyond arranging inspections and being always available and responsive to my questions and concerns. Jill did an outstanding job staging my home beautifully. Jen who toke care of all the paperwork and helped me through the entire process listing to closing. Jim for overseeing everything. You and your entire team were a true pleasure to work with! Thank you all!
Marciajsr
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim Jill and their team are spectacular. They made a process that I feared almost painless with a wonderful result. I was not looking forward to the process of selling my long-term home to move closer to my daughter at the age of 79 after the death of my husband. They were kind, listened and respected my wishes as to when I wanted to put my home on the market. It did not go on until I left town and all of the staging occurred without me being present. The long distance negotiations went smoothly and the few hiccups that occurred during the weeks that my home was on the market were handled with ease. I am so happy I used them and can recommend them without reservation. A number of people that I interviewed were not sensitive to my needs, and some were too pushy and lacked their level of experience. Additionally, I can testify that they are extremely competent and knowledgeable in their profession.
Pianogirljuly1943
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and Jill Geracie and team are the best! Jim sold us our home in 1986 and for 38 years we built many happy memories there. In 2024, when we decided to downsize, Jim and Jill sold that same home to a very satisfied new buyer. During the 38 years in between he has helped our family and friends buy and sell their homes. In every instance they experienced total satisfaction with Jim, Jill, and their team. What a great feeling it is to have total trust in a professional group who provide their services with professionalism and integrity. Thanks Jim, Jill and team!
Donna C.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED 30K above asking! We had the pleasure of working with Jim and his team on our recent home sale and with Colin on our new home purchase. Jim did everything he said he would do and Colins knowledge of the market is outstanding. The entire process, from listing our home, closing the deal, finding a new home, and getting an accepted offer has been managed with efficiency and transparency. The guidance and proactive communication from the team ensured a stress-free experience. We highly recommend The Jim Geracie Team to anyone seeking dedicated and knowledgeable real estate partners.
Loewe F.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Working with the Jim Geracie team was a flawless experience. Our family decided to sell our home and purchase a new one through them, and everything went smoothly. We had specific requirements for our new home and needed them to accommodate our schedule with two young children. The buying, selling, and back office teams exceeded our expectations! They helped us find our dream home and ensured a seamless transition from our old house to the new one. It was money well spent, and we couldn't have done it without the Geracie team's amazing hands-on approach!
Jeff K.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Top-Notch service from the entire Geracie team! Working with Jim and his team was a pleasure. The team's commitment to client satisfaction is evident in their attention to detail and effective communication. We felt supported and confident throughout the entire marketing and sales process. Highly recommend for a positive and successful real estate journey!
Cynthia M.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED WOW! Jim and his team of professionals are AMAZING! We had to sell my brother's house FAST due to unplanned medical issues he had, which resulted in him being in assisted living at a young age. Jim and his team helped get the house on the market and sold VERY quickly so we had the money available to pay for the assisted living fees. THANK YOU! You SERIOUSLY kept my brother from homelessness. Your knowledge of the market is incredible, but also your network of various professionals who can "help with last minute details", such as getting the house emptied and cleaned, was INVALUABLE. I've seldom worked with such an incredible group of professionals; you made the process a JOY!
Sarahaklug6
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED We had the pleasure of working with the Jim Geracie team for our first home purchase. We were very impressed with the professionalism, communication, and overall support and guidance of every member of the team. They always made sure we felt comfortable and understood every step of the process. But our biggest pleasure was working with Colin! From the very beginning, he wanted to make sure he understood what we were looking for in the home buying process and he stuck to that. With also being in the middle of planning a wedding, Colin said he wanted to take as much weight off our shoulders and make the process as stress free as possible and he did just that! He was patient with all our questions and was always quick to respond, no matter what time of day it was. We truly felt like we were the only ones he was working with! He is extremely knowledgeable and was able to offer some great insights as we were looking at houses. He also helped us learn different ways to structure an offer and negotiated a great deal for us on our first home. We cannot recommend Colin enough. We hope to work with him again for our next home purchase!
Patricia F.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
The Geracie Team exceeded our wildest expectations. They worked incredibly hard on our behalf throughout the entire process. We would highly recommend consulting with Jim if you are considering selling or buying a home. We cant overstate the added value the Geracie Team provided!
Mlf711marylee
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Great experience. Constant contact, updates, sold house for much more than expected. Guidance from start to finish. Assisted me through various challenges, estate sale, contractors, finding the right buyer. Worked with title company to sort out various issues. Being the last family member to take care of my sisters passing, I had much on my plate. Jim Geracie helped the situation immensely.
Karinjeatran
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED We had the pleasure of working with the Geracie team on the sale of our Elm Grove home. We contacted Jim Geracie about one year ahead of the sale - best decision ever! We redirected our renovation efforts after talking to Jim. Jim gave us great references for contractors so we could keep the cost down while making our deadlines. But the real magic happened when Jill and her team staged the house. There were no more signs of boys growing up in the house, she turned the house into a show home, and we have pictures to prove it! The house sold in 3 days, above asking price, with a cash offer. All in all a great experience, start to finish!
Jodiboom
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim Geracie is an exceptional realtor. His professionalism, knowledge, marketing strategy, honesty, integrity and work ethic says it all! In four days, we had 62 showings and 12 genuine offers to consider. Jim's Team kept us informed every step of the way. The number of showings, the number of offers and the outstanding accepted selling price on day five was above and beyond our expectations. We will definitely recommend Jim and Jill Geracie and their Team to friends and family for years to come. Thank you Jim!
Magmillion
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED We had the pleasure of working with an agent at the Jim Geracie group named Kristen Gustafson.She was excellent! Kristen is responsive, extremely knowledgeable, willing to go the extra mile to help us find our perfect home and she represented our interests perfectly throughout the transaction as she guided the buying process seamlessly.I never worked with a more lovely professional in real estate with such a positive demeanor!Our search for our home was from a distance as we were relocating from another state. To accommodate us she created many Zoom home viewings which were so thorough that we almost felt as if we were there in person.Thanks to Kristens expertise, it was a painless experience to landing in our perfect home.We highly recommend the Jim Geracie group and in particular, Kristen Gustafson!
Ajdonley
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED The Geracie team has been AH-MAZING to work with!! We went through the process of selling and buying with them and it could not have gone smoother! We felt cared for every step of the way and the team offered great guidance to our family as we searched for (and eventually found!) our forever home!
Jjgersz
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED The Geracie Team sold my Mothers home in Menomonee Falls last year with such professionalism that we decided to have the Team back to sell our home. From Jim Geracies initial visit giving honest feedback regarding pricing to Jills expertise in staging to Brenda keeping us informed of progress. We asked Jim to come to our home to discuss putting our home on the MLS. We had thought we would wait until we came home from vacation. Jim suggested letting them show the house while we were out of town. It sounded like a good plan so we wouldnt need to leave every time someone wanted to see it. Thank goodness we listened to Jim. We had 105 showings in 3 days and needless to say, sold our home!
Claire S.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED The Geracie team was MORE than we could have hoped for when buying and selling our home. Their team came to the table with so much expertise, strategy and confidence. They were extremely hands on and transparent. They always listened to our needs and made us feel confident at every phase of the process. If you're looking for down to earth people who are true experts in the industry, the Geracie team really provides "white glove" service truly a blessing to work with them.
Amy H.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED When we were ready to purchase a larger home for our family, a friend referred us to the Geracies. Throughout the process of selling our old home and purchasing a new home, we were very impressed with the level of service we received. We found everyone we dealt with on the team knowledgeable, responsive, organized, and relatable. Weve previously purchased and sold two homes with other realtors who we liked, but in our experience the Geracie Team offered a higher level of value and service. Jims years of experience were invaluable while navigating a changing marketplace, Kristens diligence and relatability helped us find a great home, and Jills design expertise helped us make our home shine when we were ready to sell. We will definitely be recommending the Geracie Team to friends and family for years to come.
Godfreyrichard225
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and his team understood the local market very well and were aware of changes in the overall market. They also priced the home accurately and were very helpful through the selling process. The home sold for slightly above asking and the team made getting all the documentation needed for closing easier to manage.
Tkoehlerr
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Colin helped us in purchasing our first home, which included a cross-country move and buying sight unseen, and did a fantastic job. We felt comfortable throughout the entire process, had all of our questions answered, and had everything explained to us in detail. If he wasn't available the rest of the Geracie team stepped in in his place and continued where he left off. Overall a great team and great experience working with the Jim Geracie team!
Frank L.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and his superb professional team were able to get me through the home selling process unbelievably fast; in addition to quickly this was the most professional and friendly I have ever dealt with. They were in total control of all issues ensuring the fastest possible resolution. In less than a month I went under contract to sell my home, and am now in my new location closing on my new home. This team is far out front of their competition, and I give them my highest recommendation to anyone considering their services. Jim has the plan, and it works. Jim, Jill, Brenda, Brittany, and the rest of their staff are part of my family. I have a special love for them. May Christ bless them always.
Stonebank
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and his superb professional team were able to get me through the home selling process unbelievably fast; in addition to quickly this was the most professional and friendly I have ever dealt with. They were in total control of all issues ensuring the fastest possible resolution. In less than a month I went under contract to sell my home, and am now in my new location closing on my new home. This team is far out front of their competition, and I give them my highest recommendation to anyone considering their services. Jim has the plan, and it works. Jim, Jill, Brenda, Brittany, and the rest of their staff are part of my family. I have a special love for them. May Christ bless them always.
Davemackett
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED I could not be more satisfied with the help I got from The Jim Geracie Team in buying my first home. They proved a wealth of knowledge, experience, recommendations, and expertise. Further, I received excellent customer service; they responded promptly, listened authentically, and made sure I felt comfortable with every stage of the process. Indeed, they went far and above the call of duty (a member of the Geracie team negotiated on the phone until midnight to ensure my offer was the one that got accepted in a competitive "race" for the condo I now call home).This team is excellent; I strongly recommend them for anyone looking to buy or sell a home.
Fhgbwdsb5x
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED We have used Jim and his team for several home purchases and sales. They have never disappointed and always worked hard to get us the best deal. They have been very professional and accommodating.
Heather
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and Jill were wonderful to work with! Jim has a work ethic like no other. Jills attention to detail is amazing! Our house was priced competitively for the market and sold within two weeks. We had several out of state and international buyers looking at our home. The team provided staging and stunning videography/marketing services. Would highly recommend!!
Heathermers
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and Jill were wonderful to work with! Jim has a work ethic like no other. Jills attention to detail is amazing! Our house was priced competitively for the market and sold within two weeks. We had several out of state and international buyers looking at our home. The team provided staging and stunning videography/marketing services. Would highly recommend!!
Javouwp04
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED We worked with Jim to buy our second home. Both him and Colin treated us like good friends and were always in our corner to help us. If I had to do this again I would work with them.
Joeupright
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Working with the Geracie Team is always an exceptional experience! Jim and his team have been at this for years and it shows every step of the way. Jim was able to provide his insight and expertise and help me secure the best deal on selling my home. I have used them in the past and will continue to use them in the future!
Becky H.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED We've bought and sold a fair share of properties over the past five years through the Geracie team and every transaction has been a home run. Even your worst nightmare property *crack* That's the sound of Jim hitting it out of the park. Done deal. That's not just a clever slogan, that's the result Jim gets when he puts his passion, time, and talent to work for you. Also, the team he has working with him is top notch! Buying and selling properties is always a pleasure with the Geracie team!
Mariamaster
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and his team were always professional, kept in constant contact with us and guided us though the process. They posted photos that really enhanced our home. We had an accepted offer well above asking price in only two days during the week of Christmas. We sold during Coronavirus and they had many protocols in place to reduce in person visits and help us feel safe when potential buyers viewed our home. In short, they made the process Jim and his team gave us valuable advice the made the process quick and efficient. We highly recommend Jim Geraci for sellers and buyers.
Shawn K.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim, Brenda and the entire team made promises they actually kept! I trusted Jim and I am so thankful I did. He was always available and spent hours at the house making sure I understood everything. He has amazing connections. No joke in 4 days he scheduled 60+ private showings and an open house. On day 5, I recieved multiple offers above asking. Its no surprise they are number #1.
Nescobales
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED We had a home in Bayside that we needed to sell. It was just the right time for us. From the first call, Mr. Jim Geracie was able to clearly explain the process to us. Jim made several key recommendations that were very important for the sale. We recognized the house needed a little bit of more work than originally thought. We followed his advised to the tee and trusted his judgment. Jim was very honest. We committed to the sale and proceeded with the repairs. When he said, the house is ready for the MLS we said aEURoelets do thisaEUR?. The offers kept piling on over the span of two days since the first open house. It was amazing and exactly as he predicted it. On the third day, we accepted an offer. It was that simple. All the work done was well worth it. It has been a week since closing and cannot say enough how thankful we are of having our house sold. Everything went flawless through the closing which by the way was done all online. Mr. Jim Geracie and his team are very knowledgeable about the housing market in the area. They truly know what they are doing. Jim and his team did more for us than we ever expected, and we are very thankful for that. Based on the above statements, we strongly recommend Mr. Jim Geracie and his excellent team from Realty Executives.
Ram S.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Every home in my neighbourhood sold in a week or so and I had to wait 3 months after following all suggestions. Could not get a single showing on my first open house day, where I was told to plan to stay out for 3 days, expecting a huge traffic. No understanding of market and neighborhood. I was told every aspect of my home was great, but still failed to capture seller market to get the highest price for my home. High sales pitch. 19 day closing - failed. Highest price - Reduced listed price in a week, suggested to reduce further but I decided not to. Closing - Low confidence, had to wait last minute to plan my moving.
James G.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
Jim and his team were knowledgeable, experienced and exceeded our expectations from start to finish. We knew of Jim's stellar reputation before hiring him, so the bar was.set high and he cleared the bar with room to spare. Jill and Brenda helped us with the staging of the house a critical step in presenting the home in its best light. We had 3 excellent offers within 1 day of listing the house. Jim set a.realistic price, and all offers were above the asking price. Jim negotiated the best price and negotiated 1 month of occupancy after the sale with no additional cost to us. Jim and his team were pleasant and available to answer all our questions Two of our qualities we look for in a real estate agent is honesty and great communication. He was honest in telling us what needed to be done prior to listing and the communication was excellent throughout the process. His team returned all text, calls and emails promptly. The home closing went without a hitch. His assistant Dakota helped with any questions we had. This is our 3rd home sale and by far our best experience. We highly recommend Jim and his fabulous team. Jim and Diana Sussex, WI
Jimgym61
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim Geracie and his team consisting of Jill(his wife), Brenda and Dakota acted with the utmost skill and professionalism throughout the sale.of our home. This was our.3rd.home sale and by far the best experience we had. Jill and Brenda helped with the staging which was critical in presenting our home in the best light. Jim had.the experience, knowledge and communication skills to properly market our home resulting in 3 offers in one day. All above.asking price. Jim also negotiated.additional occupancy, which was a.big plus since we were buying out of.state. He also hooked us.up with a.realtor.out of state.to help us in the purchase of our next home. The team's communication was great in both their responsiveness and thoroughness in answering all our questions. We highly recommend Jim Geracie and his team for your real estate needs
Danielnoahgreen
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Despite having to do everything without meeting in person, the Geracie team was helpful and knowledgable about getting our house sold. They were able to help with staging and getting the best deal possible for us during a crazy time for everyone.
Hanaassad
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim was there to help me purchase my first home in 2015 and was so wonderful that I reached out to him to help me sell my duplex. He was amazing as he helped me through the process smoothly and the duplex only was on the market for a day. He relieved a lot of stress during a difficult time I have been going through, along with his team who have been nothing but amazing.
User3796280
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and his team have been incredible to work with. They kindly educated us along the way and worked extremely hard behind the scenes at all hours of the day to get our home sold in less than 4 days! I highly recommend him and his team!!
Frank C.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED It's been more than a year since we purchased our house through Team Jim Geracie. We are still enjoying our home. It didn't take long for us to find the house that fit what I was looking form. There were some challenging contingencies to work through with the seller and my team dealt with them to help guide us all to a close. Well done! I've bought and sold houses through Team Geracie, exclusively. They never fail to deliver.
Frank459
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED It's been more than a year since we purchased our house through Team Jim Geracie. We are still enjoying our home. It didn't take long for us to find the house that fit what I was looking form. There were some challenging contingencies to work through with the seller and my team dealt with them to help guide us all to a close. Well done!I've bought and sold houses through Team Geracie, exclusively. They never fail to deliver.
Jakubla
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED The Jim Geracie Team did an excellent job from day one to finish. The initial meeting was informative and understanding, and helped up price our home at a level that was reasonable but maximized our price. They encouraged us to get to the market at the right time, and did a wonderful job advising us on preparation and staging of the house. Throughout the showing process they were responsive and helpful. When the offers came in Jim did a great job of getting a maximum offer with very clean terms that made our decision to accept easy. Then in the process of preparing for closing they are providing great support.
Koleary46
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED I used Realty Executives (Jim Geracie) to sell my home and he was outstanding. Jim had been referred to a friend, the friend referred him to me, and I won't hesitate to recommend him to my family and friends as Jim took extra steps to address my concerns and solve my specific problems with my home. His knowledge of what it takes to sell a home is so solid, that I felt secure through the whole process. All throughout the negotiations and closing Jim and his excellent team were there to quickly handle any issues that came up.Karen O'Leary
Samuel W.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED We can't say enough about the Jim Geracie team and the way they helped us sell our home. Their experience and expertise were evident from the start. From professional staging and photography, to effective pricing, marketing, and a successful open house; we were thoroughly impressed. The difference for us was how Jim, and every person on the team, genuinely supported and cared for us throughout the process. They took care of all the details and kept us informed every step of the way, and they did so with great kindness and humility. Thanks Jim!Luz & Sam Wright, New Berlin
Lars1861
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Almost 5 years ago, Jim and Jill helped me buy my very first home. This year they helped me sell it. Their entire team was responsive and many times anticipated my questions before I even asked them. From our initial planning meeting to signing to closing documents, I felt informed, secure, and confident in the representation Jim and Jill, and the team provided to me. Choosing them for a second time was the best decision I could have made!
Melhaber
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and his whole Team were wonderful to work with! He sold our house very quickly and worked with us to find the perfect house for our family. His whole team was patient with us and had great communication through the whole process!
Jyee06
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim and his entire team make the home buying and selling experience incredibly seamless. My wife and I needed to relocate for her new job, which meant that we had to sell our current home and buy a new home in a very short amount of time. Jim responded promptly to our situation, clearly and expertly walked us through the relocation process, and had our home listed as soon as we were comfortable with listing. Within 24 hours, we had two full price offers for our home, one of which we accepted. Jim and his closing coordinator, Kelly, kept us on track through closing, and we had no issues with selling our home. Additionally, one of Jims selling agents, Heidi, generously traveled outside of their usual coverage area to help us quickly find a wonderful new home and we will be closing and moving next week; thankfully, the buying process was just as smooth as selling, which is a full credit to Jim, Heidi, and Kelly.We are so thankful to Jim and his wonderful team for easing all of our concerns and for minimizing our stress during a very hectic time. We will absolutely refer Jim to everyone we know who is in need of real estate assistance.
Nicholas H.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED Jim Geracie and his team were an excellent ally in my house sale. They helped me understand the process, set everything up, and negotiated the best possible deal for me in a very rapid manner. Highly recommend!
Karma R.
Review for Member: Jim Geracie
ZillowVERIFIED It was a pleasure working with the Jim Geracie team. They are hard-working, experienced and friendly. They kept us informed and were great hand-holders during the entire process. We recommend them highly
View All Listings
